Reviews by Steve R

Back To Staff Reviews

Hoyo Excalibur

Steve R

As I drove to the office yesterday, I thought about two things....

First, it’s great to be a sports fan in the Philadelphia area. Penn State is 8-0 and a hopeful for the national championship - curse the corrupt BCS system. The Phillies play in game one of the World Series this week in a very winnable series against the Rays (otherwise known to Mike Ditka as the Tampa Ray Bays). And Tony Romo is injured, while the NFC East is managing to keep my Eagles in the hunt. What more could a Philly fanatic ask for? Oh season started, did you know folks still play hockey?

Second, I received another request to review a cigar. Hoyo de Monterrey Excalibur in the 5” x 50 Epicure size. An old, long-toothed giant in the cigar industry that still maintains an insanely loyal customer base despite the bountiful array of new releases that hit our shelves weekly. In fact, this very vitola received a ‘92’ rating in April of 2007 and a celebrated position among the ‘Top 25 Cigars’ of the year.

Knowing Excalibur is a pillar in quality, I selected four cigars from four different boxes – one cigar from each box. Each cigar looks exactly the same. The true Connecticut shade wrapper is shiny and smooth with no large veins or blemishes. The pre-light aroma is sweet and doughy, reminding me of the inside of a curing barn. The roll is solid from head to toe and, once lit, the draw is perfect.

Note: I am on my third of four samples.

The cigar smacks of wood and toast. The aftertaste is almost refreshing....crisp and clean, like drinking a Corona on a hot summer day. There’s some sweet nutty undertones that linger a tad after each puff. I’ve read reviews that note leather, coffee, and earth....yeah, I get none of that. According to my palate, Hoyo Excalibur offers a rich, but not overwhelming, core of oak and toast. Roll it around in your palate for a little while before releasing the smoke, you’ll see what I mean. And this core is velvety, almost as if it leaves a film on the bottom of your palate. Through the nose, nothing but pepper. Black pepper. I’ve also read reviews that consider this to be a medium to full-bodied cigar. I find it to be medium at best. But a pleasant, easy-going medium.

Hoyo Excalibur can easily fool the unsuspecting enthusiast. While both flavor and strength remain consistent from start to finish, the blend is quite complex. Long-fillers from Honduras, Nicaragua, and the Dominican are used. However, the use of two aged Connecticut shade leaves – one as binder, one as wrapper – likely mellows this mixture to create a smooth and balanced bouquet.

How would I rate this cigar? It’s damn near perfect when construction, consistency, and aesthetics are considered. However, I lean towards cigars that evolve as they burn, so the Excalibur loses a couple of points in my (often overly critical and usually high maintenence) book. Either way, it’s a winner that should not be overlooked.

All Reviews
All Reviews
  1. Ave Maria
  2. Diesel Heart of Darkness
  3. Relic
  4. Metrokane Rabbit Electronic Corkscrew
  5. CAO Brazilia Amazon Basin
  6. CAO Extreme
  7. Davidoff Maduro Series
  8. Casa Magna Dominican
  9. Don Pepin Garcia Legado de Pepin
  10. Oliva Saison
  11. Ramon Bueso Odyssey
  12. Punch Bareknuckle
  13. Ramon Bueso Genesis The Project
  14. Obsidian
  15. Cohiba Red Dot
  16. Morro Castle
  17. Blue Label B2 Cuban Wheels
  18. Cuba Libre One
  19. Alec Bradley Tempus Maduro
  20. Joya de Nicaragua Antano Dark Corojo
  21. Gran Habano Vintage Corojo 2002
  22. La Aroma de Cuba Mi Amor
  23. 5 Vegas Gold Maduro
  24. La Perla Habana Black Pearl Original
  25. Diesel Unlimited
  26. Graycliff G2
  27. Cuba Libre
  28. La Estrella Cubana Oscuro
  29. Diesel
  30. CAO VR
  31. Rocky Patel Sun Grown
  32. 5 Vegas Classic
  33. John Bull
  34. Perdomo Tierra del Sol Maduro
  35. 5 Vegas Classic
  36. Excalibur
  37. La Herencia Cubana
  38. Nub Habano by Oliva
  39. CI Anniversary
  40. Nub Habano by Oliva
  41. Nub Habano by Oliva
  42. Arturo Fuente Gran Reserva
  43. Drew Estate Larutan Ltd. Pimp Sticks
  44. Victor Sinclair Triple Corojo
  45. Hoyo de Tradicion
  46. San Cristobal
  47. 601 Blue Label Maduro
  48. Gispert
  49. Alec Bradley MAXX
  50. Montecristo Media Noche
  51. Ashton Aged Maduro
  52. CAO VR
  53. Romeo y Julieta Viejo
  54. Perdomo Lot 23
  55. Zino Platinum Scepter Series
  56. 601 Red Habano
  57. Saint Luis Rey
  58. Arturo Fuente Hemingway
  59. Pueblo Dominicano II
  60. 5 Vegas Gold
  61. Oliva Serie O
  62. Fonseca Habana Selección
  63. Punch Rare Corojo
  64. Romeo y Julieta 1875
  65. Xikar Envoy 3-Finger Cigar Case
  66. Torano Exodus Gold 1959
  67. Gurkha Centurian Double Perfecto
  68. Cu-Avana Maduro
  69. 5 Vegas Series A
  70. Drew Estate Larutan Ltd. Pimp Sticks
  71. Montecristo White Label
  72. Bolivar
  73. Gurkha Symphony
  74. Partagas Cifuentes
  75. CAO Brazilia
  76. Drew Estate Natural
  77. Perdomo Mistakes
  78. Macanudo Gold
  79. Gurkha Doble Maduro
  80. Don Diego
  81. Onyx Reserve
  82. Triple Ligero
  83. La Aurora
  84. Rocky Patel Connecticut
  85. Victor Sinclair Vintage Select
  86. Rocky Patel Sun Grown
  87. Pueblo Dominicano
  88. Puros Indios
  89. Ashton
  90. Perdomo Slow-Aged Lot 826 Natural
  91. Joya de Nicaragua Antano 1970
  92. Arturo Fuente Gran Reserva
  93. Fonseca