Maker's Choice

The taste is nice. It is a good smoke and will give you enjoyment.

Hard to beat at this price point. nice flavor with an easy draw

Tasty, nice burn stays lit even smoke all the way through. Nice smoke.

Good cigar for the money

Great little smoke. Have a 45-60 minute burn. Mild in flavor with hint of vanilla.

GREAT LITTLE CIGAR FOR MORNING COFFEE!

Not a bad little smoke, better than what I thought they would be. Will buy again.

A nice cigar, very good flavor, good for having a smoke while watering the lawn. A little bourbon, a cigar, what more do you want. Good stuff

the natural's have a flavored tip . noticed thru time the cigars are now being rolled "very loose" , but still draw and burn good. a great quick smoke for the price

They are good but they are lose

Nice for the price

nice and mild.

Very good. Nice draw.

the quality issues have improved, they previously had construction issues

I HAVE ENJOYED THE MAKERS CIGARS BEFORE AND WITH THIS PURCHASE THE ENJOYMENT CONTINUES. THANK YOU.

They were all right in a pinch I prefer countryman cigars Churchill size this was affordable some of them weren't rolled tight but all in all a decent cigar.

These are good. They also appear to be flavored which was not expected. My primary complaint is the are a much quicker smoke than i expected both due to size and the way they are packed the burn much quicker.

Great little cigar when you don’t have time for the bigger ones taste good also

One of my favorite, when I need a quick smoke. Smoke and flavor is great..

Best priced at 5” with 46 ring. Aroma and flavor is good.

Good stuff here for a decent price. Will be back for more.

Good burning smoke

Just right for a good casual cigar, very good value, slightly sweet, just right

Mild flavor. Good smoke for doing chores or out on the golf course. Great price per stick.

taste, draw and smell wonderful

Best little cheap cigar I have smoked. Some of them are even a little toothy. I buy them 50 at a time and smoke 2 or 3 a day. Nice medium body for such a cheap little cigar.

Works for a nice smoke, will buy more.

Good everyday smoke

These are fair to midland for a quick small cigar smoke. They smoke evenly and have a fair taste. They are loosely rolled and some fall apart, but they are on my reorder list for small cigars. the sweetness is faint.

Burns a little uneven and needs to be re lite often after the 3/4 mark

Best Value! Out of all the budget coronas these take the top spot on my list! I'm not a flavored cigar person but I decided to give these a go in vanilla. Enjoyable smoke and lasts longer than the general grant's. In these times when you're looking for a good budget smoke, these are a winner! I haven't had them in my tupperdore for more than a couple days and they smoke fine. The ash is pretty good too for a budget stick. I didn't make a mess because I forgot to ash it.

Nice daily smoke

Great cigar for the price.

Very easy to smoke. Will buy again.

I believe that I was sent the wrong one because it was sweet, and I don't like sweet. Almost sent them back but decided to keep them. I would like to try the natural ones sometime.

Great little burn. Will purchase again

Great short smoke

I received the package ok.

Great little smoke

I enjoyed them will order them again

For flavored cigars, one of my favorites. Easy to smoke. Good draw. Great backyard chill cigar. I gave one to my buddy who doesn’t smoke cigars and he really liked it. I like the self rolled feel. Good relaxing cigar

Nice 15-20 min smoke, mild.

Great bargain excellent flavor for small cigar.

A good flavor and quick smoke when working outside.

Great size, smoke, and flavor. Product is perfect for the price.

Good price for this little treat.

Descent everyday smoke, like to smoke them at work. Worth the price, remember you get what you pay for.

I like this cigar! It's draw is easy, the size is perfect for me,and the quality is first rate. I don't have to fight to keep it lit; which makes it even better!

Good size, I don’t like a heavily flavored cigar, but these are just right.

Size is fine so are flavor and burn

Not a bad little cigar but for the extra 2 in ring size I'll go back to the less expensive Bandidos

Very good 30 cigar. Tasty... I ordered 100 for the 3rd time...

Wonderful choice for an everyday cigar! I enjoy a Maker’s Choice while working outside and working. Smooth smoke experience with tinge of sweet flavor.

This the first time I ordered these, I usually order Bandidos. I like that they are have a bigger ring size and the slight longer length. The taste is fine I will most likely order again

It has a nice mild flavor, but was lacking some on the flavor of vanilla I was expecting. But overall, I would buy it again though.

Good value, smooth draw , good aroma

It would have been a 5 star rating if they were a bit thicker

A good default smoke for a short time period.

great taste nice aroma will buy again

A good smoke, not too harsh not too mild and it burns even. I have to let mine dry a little more for it to smoke easier.

Bought it for a party favors but ended up enjoying it. It's just a simple cigar for a simple day.

Great little smoke nice price

good tasty, even burn

good burning and tasty

If these were all vanilla I'd give them 5 stars. Problem is, I ordered 50 (comes in 2 packs of 25) and I it is very evident that one pack was mislabeled. I double checked the labels. They are correct, the cigars aren't. As for the ones that I did order that are vanilla, I am very happy. I don't care that they are an ugly stick, they burn evenly, and last a good 45 minutes +/-. Flavor is there throughout, and is good. Nothing better that at this price point. Great if you are cost conscious, but don't want to sacrifice quality. Plus it's purely handmade! Sometimes, even when I'm not worried about cost, I'm just in the mood for one of these instead of my Isla Del Sol, Legend, or Tabak. Not saying it's better than those, but it is in the game. As long as you get the actual ones you ordered, you'll be very happy.

Good smoke for the price.

I liked these, smoked them for many years, but then about 6 to 8 years ago their quality went to pot. Poor covers leaked air and made them hard to light and along with skimpy fillers, they had such low density they would not stay lit. I decided to give them another try, as they are larger and last a bit longer than the Banditos. They seem to have fixed their short-comings and are a good smoke again. We will see if they can maintain quality.

Great taste smooth love them

Perfect price strong flavor smells great, ugly but just like a good work truck get the job done.

Great taste and good value.

Great medium size cigar.

Smoke flavor draw

Could be rolled a little bit tighter

They were good for short smokes but I wanted something for a little longer smoke

I saw a great deal for these cigars in the CI monthly catalogue and decided to go for it when I was ordering some more expensive cigars and I am so glad I did! They're very smooth and tasty and I'll be keeping these around as regular smokes.

Best smoke I had for a while

Very mellow and sweet, nice shorty.

very nice, perfect, nice short smoke.

I needed a cigar that was a quick smoke and this one fits the bill.

Ok for the price

Good quick morning smoke

Perfect size for a short smoke. Quality burn and taste for the price.

Proper size sweet draw and a good smoke I have enjoyed them.

OK for a quick flavored small cigar, I will continue buying these for a quick smoke.

Great bang for the buck. You can’t go wrong with these sticks.

Great a little cigar for the cost; quick smoke when you need it.

They’re pretty good value for your $.

Great smokes when you only have a short amount of time. Nice and smooth.

It’s a bargain ,nice sweet full flavor! Very enjoyable!

Ok for a quickie

Great bargain, low cost, and a nice size for a standard, light smoke.

Good quick smoke. Nice flavor.

LOVE THEM

LOVE THEM

Well, when you first open the package and put them in the humidor, the things smell like chemicals. But, if you let them breathe for about a week, they're pretty good little 'gars.

Great, mild tasting smoke at an amazing price. I'm not a fan of flavored sticks, but these are damn fine.

I think it has subtle vanilla flavor that adds a nice touch to the smoke. The burn is pretty consistent and makes a nice short smoke if you enjoy a flavored cigar.

Excellent cigar good smoke. Wrapper is nice. It stays together through your smoke. Great taste. Great price.

Good favor for a fast smoke.

Great price fresh product

Very good smoke good flavor and they draw well

Awesome smoke!

Love ‘em

Nice flavored short smoke..... highly reccommend

Cost was good good taste and a little bit of sweetness

Cost great, size good, smoke easy draw, good tasteful

Smooth taste

A little larger, a little longer smoke, than my Bandidos, and that is exactly what I wanted. They are good daily "yard cigarillos" and satisfy.

As spoken of in the description, they are nothing to brag about although the quality is maybe not jumping off the page but for a cheap little smoke they are pretty good and I really can't find anything to knock them for, I like them. The only thing that I was surprised by was that they had a sweet tip which I was surprised to find and so that as they say is that!

Not bad for the price but they seem to not burn evenly

I like these. They are better than Bandidos.

Exactly what I was looking for. Great taste and the price fantastic. I will buy more.

For a cheap little cigar they have good smooth taste. I enjoy the aroma and the cost is not prohibited. Ordering is easy and fast.

They were a great smoke but some were a little hard packed and loose fillers. Over all,a nice smoke.

Always good for a quick cigar

Nice everyday smoke Great while fly fishing.

For the size of these cigars they are very smooth and tasty!

Not bad for the price

A nice enjoyable smoke

A nice smoke that is tasty and medium in strength. Some may be a little loose but they still burn well and when you don't have time for bigger cigar this can fill the bill.

Price is right. Aroma is great.

I buy these all the time. Tasty short smoke slightly sweet, however due to the short clipping that are used, sometimes the cigar breaks up at the end of the smoke leaving a little debris in my mouth. I chalk it up to part of the overall experience. Great for golf or the condo parking lot with a bourbon

Pleasant smoke easy draw.

Good everyday choice. Right size at the right price.

Both of these selections were okay. I've only smoked one of each of them so far. Hopefully, the next ones are better.

Lower cost, decent draw good flavor. Perfect size for a quick Enjoyable smoke

Good bargin....

Mild and Sweet Just the way I like them.

Construction leaves a little to be desired, as the burn is typically uneven, and the binder often comes unrolled during the smoke. However, the flavor is smooth and on point, and these have become a favorite for the times when I only have 10-15 minutes for a quick smoke. For the price, these are really hard to beat.

Good simple smoke

Smooth, Very nice everyday cigar

Good smoking easy draw nice flavor.

Nice flavor. Very enjoyable

Smooth, nice flavor.

Great little cigar for a everyday smoke! They don’t break the bank

I would buy again

Enjoyed these. Gonna order more.

Good 👍

Love them always have I wish u guys would get swisher sweets outlaws but not the three packs I want the old school 8 packs they where my favorite but can find a place that sales them anymore

All three are just right.

Good taste, lots of smoke

Good smoke,buy again

Very tasty, good draw and construction.

Not a bad smoke. Plenty of flavor and smoke. Draw is good. The flavor has a fake vanilla flavor. It’s not bad. The wrapper is very rough but what do you expect for a cheap stick. Will buy again.

Good smoke

A decent cigar for when you don't have an hour to kill. A quick smoke but not too quick. Decent flavor. Ugly but who cares.

Enjoyable cigar with a mild vanilla aroma that folks comment that smells good for a cigar.

Decent taste and burns even. Good Cost and fair size.

These were good but not wrapped well

draw is not always good. Aroma is good. decent smoke

Smooth & Mild. Burns well. Love them

its a pretty good smoke--the only i had was that they were rolled a little too loose--the flavor and size were decent and the price was affordable

My 4 star rating is relative to what these are, a quick smoke for when you don't have the hour or so for a nice premium. They're good, really good for that. I was doing the Banditos for a couple of years but I was growing tired of them and they could be a little on the harsh side at times. These are nice and mellow with just a touch of sweetness and nice thick smoke. I like 'em!

great everyday, quick smoke

Great cigar for under a buck!!!

Good everyday cigar.

Great taste and smooth...great price...

What I’ve been looking for. The right size, smooth, rich flavor. Great for the golf course or hunting.

Rolled a little different from a year ago but still a great smoke for the price

Good flavor and perfect size

excellent

Love these, a great end of the day smoke.

Good deal

Great

Good flavor they are a good fill in during the day. And the quality is pretty good to

Good bargain for the money. Some are rolled to loose

Good inexpensive small cigar with excellent mouth taste and a great aroma

light weight, smooth

Wife liked the aroma(first time i heard that) actually had more flavor then most flavored cigars well made not a cigar expert by any means but good even burn and draw. will be buying more of these

Smooth cigar . Ordered natural and was not expecting the sweet flavored tip . Overall, it’s a great little cigar . burns even and longer than expected . I will order these again

Nice easy burn, light flavor, a perfect kick around cigarillo

Since Pirata Pesquenos, the very best small, inexpensive flavored cigars in the world, are now unavailable, these Maker’s Choice Corona Naturals were recommended as an alternative. For the very small cost they are very good cigars. I personally find the quality to vary somewhat from stick to stick. They are somewhat stronger than Pesquenos mentioned above and do have an understated sweetness. These Maker’s Choice are a fair alternative to the Peasqenos, but come no where close as a true replacement.

A good smoke and easy draw with a nice taste and aroma. these are a very comfortable, leisure smoke

On the harsh side. Not something to leave hanging in your mouth while you do yard work. Maybe the loose roll makes it burn hotter. With this smoke, less is more. Pace yourself.

Giving these a 5 because the whole is greater than the sum. They are inconsistent and dubiously made - kinda like life. They taste of straight, mild tobacco, which is a welcome change when you just want to light up and relax for a bit. Much better than many "premiums" that I've purchased of similar size and much higher prices - mainly because of the good draw they have; they are not over-packed. Nothing worse than paying $5 a stick only to get a draw that turns your mouth inside out. Buying again.

I’m not big on sweetness but I smoked them and they weren’t bad

Price Not bad good bargin

I didn't realize they were sweet but besides that they were a good smoke. A couple were hard to draw but the rest so far have been good.

After sampling numerous cigars these are by far my favorite. Smooth taste and draw. Just right for a relaxing after dinner smoke. My wife and family even like the smell.

These are my favorite work smoke.

Great little smoke . Everyday cheap delicious a smoke the size is great.

Great smoke..

Like😊

Nice and mild smoke and it to me had a wonderful flavor of coffee notes and you can taste the sweetness of the tobacco i will definitly buy more of these every humidor should have a roll or two handy

nice short smoke the construction has a few flaws but it is only once in awhile

Good size and flavor.

Has been a favorite of mine for a long time. Unfortunately, with my last order, a lot of them canoe and you have to cut it and start again, but they're worth it.

flavor is OK, thinner than I thought they'd be though

I love these little guys

a good smoke if you like the taste of vanilla!

These are mangy as described and more of a chewing cigar in my opinion but I LOVE THEM. Great flavor, they burn well and with the looser wrap they get good air flow. I like the burn and smoke them a bit but I tend to burn them up quickly. I like them for working around the property as a good flavored smoke.

Not bad, but a bit too sweet for me

Good tastes

A really nice easy smoke in between breaks of the day. Very soft and smoothe.

I don't smoke often. But when I'm in the mood and I want something mild, with a bit of flavoring, I find these to be very pleasant.

Great price. Thought I was buying cigarillo's. Too big for my preference. Great taste though. Love the sweet vanilla flavor. A little dry. Needed to humidify for a little bit.

Great little smoke for those times you just need a quick one. Wish you would keep them in stock!

After burning around 80 of these tasty treats I must say “winner winner chicken dinner” not a dud in two separate bundles. Good flavor decent roll, small yet chunky enough and each one is just a little different as they are free hand rolled. Thanks CI, keep them coming!!

Great little smoke.. Very nice when you don't have a lot of time....

have ordered these for years.....prefer them to the banditos..order both prefer these. smooth quick easy smoke.....

I liked it

Great for the price

These are not the prettiest cigars but they deliver a great flavor and satisfying smoke. These are my go to smoke when I want a pleasing half hour smoke rich in flavor.

Excellent selection for a daily Cigar.

Awesome smoke and good for a quick smoke. Had a couple that wouldn’t stay lit due to voids in the packing.

They are good for the money

A good cigar for working around the yard, Have enjoyed these for years.

Too small too tight

A great quick smoke. Only complaint is frequently backordered.

These are a great little cigar. I buy the natural and the vanilla in the larger size. Fantastic

Smooth nice little cigar. Burns nice and even.

Great cigar, smooth, great flavor.

Every now and then you get one that burns uneven but what do you expect for what you are paying