Top
Click the icons below for product information.

CI's Premium Mystery Samplers

Get ready to brown bag it!

We’ve presented “mystery” samplers and “brown bags” before, but I don’t know that we’ve ever offered up a lineup like this. Each mystery sampler below features four unique cigars — one each in the 4-cigar sampler, and 2 each in the 8-cigar choice. And let me tell you, these are 100% certified premiums. No random brands you’ve never heard of, no “Don Bubbas”, all Grade-A beef. I’m talking the likes of Romeo y Julieta, Caldwell, Fratello, Macanudo, Gurkha, Cohiba, Alec Bradley, Rocky Patel… there’s no brand that’s safe from inclusion here! So what do you say? Step up to the wheel and win a prize, well below MSRP.

Note: Brands listed above are given as examples of the quality of product you can expect in your line-up. These brands are all eligible for inclusion, along with many others, but we can make no guarantee of what four brands you’ll receive.

Size
Pack In Stock Price Qty Cart
4 Cigars In Stock $15.99
8 Cigars In Stock $27.50
Overall Rating 4.33 out of 5 Based on 78 Ratings

Customer Reviews of “CI's Premium Mystery Samplers”

Write A Review
5 out of 5
5 Star
42
4 out of 5
4 Star
24
3 out of 5
3 Star
9
2 out of 5
2 Star
2
1 out of 5
1 Star
1
Showing 1-50 of 78 Reviews
5 out of 5
4 Cigar sampler
It’s worth the price, especially for new smokers.
3 out of 5
Wouldn't necessarily call it the
Wouldn't necessarily call it the premium...
4 out of 5
Great Deal
Great Smokes for a good Value!!
5 out of 5
CI Premium 4- Cogar Mystery Sampler
Excellent choice of cigars
4 out of 5
Never Dull.
I have bought these a few times and I will again.
5 out of 5
I tried things I would
I tried things I would have never knew about. The Fallen angel. Nica rustica
5 out of 5
Mystery sampler
Nice selection of balanced cigars. I would get it again.
4 out of 5
Black and mild,wine
Very smooth taste, &fresh
5 out of 5
Great flavors smooth smoke
Great flavors smooth smoke
5 out of 5
The price was right
The price was right
5 out of 5
Fallen Angel
Yet another great smoke from Cigars International!!!!! so mellow and tasty what more can I say but to keep up the fantastic deals and BARGAINS. Thanks for everything you do. John P. Eastly
4 out of 5
Very surprised very good
Very surprised very good
5 out of 5
Love it
Fantastic assortment in my first buy...turned me on to an incredible cigar I'd never heard of....Fratello....other picks were great too. Even had a Montecristo Platinum
5 out of 5
Boutique Sampler
Nice mix of good cigars. Fresh and in good condition. Great sampler. Will order again. CI does it again.
5 out of 5
Not bad for the price.
Great combination of cigars. Good premium cigars. Definitely worth the price.
5 out of 5
very enjoyable
I shared them and they were very good. We enjoyed them all. I'll buy them again
5 out of 5
Really enjoyed
Really enjoyed
5 out of 5
Top cigars at every day
Top cigars at every day prices
4 out of 5
Decent selection
Was pleased with what I ended up with. Worth the price
5 out of 5
Pleasantly surprised.
Nice selection of cigars. No junkers.
5 out of 5
8-cigar premium review
It was fantastic, not only were the cigars fresh and smoke great the selection allowed me to try cigars I can't find locally. Will order again soon!
5 out of 5
Great way to try various
Great way to try various sticks at a more than reasonable price.
5 out of 5
Premium Sampler
Great Buy, Great Cigar.
5 out of 5
CIGARS RECEIVED WERE IN GOOD
CIGARS RECEIVED WERE IN GOOD SHAPE AT A FAIR PRICE. I WAS VERY SATISFIED.
3 out of 5
Good for the price
The options were good for the price. I'm prefer more of a medium body smoke. 3 / 4 were med-strong.
4 out of 5
Fair enough
Fair enough
5 out of 5
excellent taste low impurity smokes
excellent taste low impurity smokes smoothly and long
4 out of 5
Great surprises.
Great surprises.
2 out of 5
Cigars not humidified good.
Cigars not humidified good.
5 out of 5
EXCELLENT
EXCELLENT
4 out of 5
Surprise sampler
Great price !
5 out of 5
Good deal
Worth every puff
5 out of 5
total steal
Amazing deal! Got some really high end stuff. Nica Rustica, Victor Sinclair, CAO Cameroon. Great great great!
4 out of 5
Good selection
4 cigars I had not smoked before -- not bad! Will definitely do another grab bag again...
5 out of 5
Great stuff!!! 😎
The best prices and taste as usual! Keep it up guys!!!
4 out of 5
fUN ASSORTMENT.
I have only tried a few as yet.
5 out of 5
Great service and product priced
Great service and product priced very affordable.
4 out of 5
Nice Mix
Good value for the price. An affordable way to get a little variety in your humidor.
4 out of 5
GreaT Choice
The sample was indeed premium. The only issue was in my own expectations; I was hoping for a God of Fire or a Kuba Kuba in the mix, but still the selection was a good buy.
4 out of 5
Good deal
I'm just starting out and feel this was a great way to try some different cigars. I bought the 8 pack, so I could have 2 of each cigar. I really liked one, liked another and thought the other two were ok. I got to try them twice just to be sure.
5 out of 5
CI's Premium 8-Cigar Mystery Sampler
I'm not really a cigar connysewer...just an old retiree on social security. I normalyy buy what a lot of cigar smokers would call cigars for the great unwashed. These Mystery Samplers give me a chance to try a few truly good cigars that I couldn't normally afford. Thanks CI.
4 out of 5
Great deal on all of my cigar needs
One can get more their money with confidence
5 out of 5
mystery sampler
great selection at a great price
5 out of 5
Great selection and quality
This isn’t the first or the last sampler pack from CI that will find its way to my humidor. Always impressed with the quality brands in every sampler I’ve bought. Also with how quick the shipping is!
5 out of 5
Excellent cigars
I’ve only smoked two cigars so far, but they have been two of the best I ever smoked. I’ll definitely buy this again.
1 out of 5
Very unsatified with selection of
Very unsatified with selection of cigars compared to what is shown in advertisements
3 out of 5
Premium 4 pack sampler
It was ok. I was expecting a little more from a premium sampler. Overall if you just want a casual smoke then this will do.
5 out of 5
Excellent quality, great price
Very good value for your money. Excellent quality
4 out of 5
Great Value
Always great value from CI.
5 out of 5
Good variety, great price
I was pleasantly surprised with the quality of cigars received in this package. all of the cigar store big brand name and all of them were in good condition and tasted amazing.
3 out of 5
Not my taste
Normally happily surprised by CI Samplers but dont care for 1/2 of this one...luck of the draw...or should I say bad luck!
3 out of 5
Expected More
Was a little disappointed in the selection that I received. But as the saying goes, you get what you pay for.
3 out of 5
Good brands, but as with
Good brands, but as with most things from CI, they come a little dry and need some time in a humidor.
5 out of 5
not disappointed at all
I was super happy with what I got. I also found a new favorite to add to my continual smoke list
4 out of 5
Worth It
Good cigars. Thanks.
5 out of 5
Navy VETERAN ORDER
Outstanding service! Cigar arrived fresh and packaged tightly to preserve integrity of package
5 out of 5
Nice sample pack
Great mixture of cigars. Might have found a new favorite.
4 out of 5
Mystery cigars
Just was not happy with the quality cigars I ordered through the catalog. Risky ordering the mystery pack I know, have ordered them in the past with great reviews from my friends and family, it’s a fun order ....but disappointed this time. More my fault I know. I will always continue to order thru your exceptional business.
4 out of 5
Premium mystery
All the cigars were very good, was hoping for a Cohiba, maybe next time
4 out of 5
Solid mystery pack
2 if the sticks I didn’t care for so overall great job on the premium mystery
4 out of 5
Sampler Pack-good idea
Nice selection
4 out of 5
Thumbs up!
Thumbs up!
2 out of 5
Mystery Sampler?
Not impressed.
5 out of 5
Ain't no mystery to me
Nice selection good quality cigars enjoyed everyone. Not to mention the price was well worth the mystery. 10 Colorado Springs.
4 out of 5
Good quality cigars Great sampler
Good quality cigars Great sampler
3 out of 5
An acquired taste
I am not particularly please. I prefer sticks no stronger than medium, three out of four of this pack are stronger than medium. I guess I have cigars for those who want an occasional stick.
5 out of 5
CI's Premium 8-Cigar Mystery Sampler
Really great cigars for the price. I love CI's samplers, they allow you to try a bunch of quality cigars for a quality price. Very happy with this sampler.
5 out of 5
Great mix
These were a great mix of cigars. will order again
3 out of 5
Duplicates
The cigars I got were good quality, don't get me wrong, but the sampler was comprised of 4 different cigars with each having a duplicate for the advertised total of 8. I would have thought it would be 8 different cigars so I was pretty disappointed.
3 out of 5
Pretty good
Pretty good
5 out of 5
Great selection in this sampler
I love the not knowing what you will get but you will get great sticks. I will add this or the double mystery sampler to every order going forward to get my mystery sticks. Well worth the price.
5 out of 5
Good site even better cigars
Good site even better cigars
4 out of 5
great sample pack
I have only smoked to of the four brands i got and both are really good smokes.I am new to cigar smoking, so im going to keep track of the ones i realy like untill i find a brand that blows me away
5 out of 5
Great, as usual
Nice selection of great cigars.....naturally, priced right, and quick shipment....think this is year 10 of business with Cigar International and see no change in my future....thanks a bunch!!!
4 out of 5
Suprised and Pleased
Great selection of premiums in this CI offer. Would purchase again
5 out of 5
Good stixs
Good stixs
5 out of 5
Fantastic Cigars
For the price. one of the cigars i received would have cost more at my local shop then the entire sampler. will throw a mystery sampler on to any order i make with CI.
5 out of 5
A great experience
A couple real solid sticks, no stinkers. A nice unexpected variety, four new to me boutique brands. Will buy again and recommend you do too. Great value.