CI Knock-Offs - Compare to Macanudo

GOOD CIGAR WISH I HAD MORE

On price vs quality they are simply the best I've found. Mild, always a good draw, never a bad cigar in a bunch, ever.

The CIs exceeded my expectations they are a smooth smoke with very little aftertaste. Great Cigar for the price.

This cigar couldn't be better. Great taste yet mild. You can't go wrong with this one. Burns evenly and stays lit. Your friends will truly enjoy it.

Good deal

very good

Some of the cigars were amazing but some or blah but for the price I can't complain to much and that being said if you just looking for an everyday smoke here you go

Good! Thanks

Pretty good, pretty close to the real thing

The cigars were ok, but not at all like Macanudo cigars

Love this place. thank you!

Very good

great mild smokes at a reasonable price

I found these cigars to be very pleasing. They burn well have great taste and I thoroughly enjoyed them

you can`t go wrong with this price.

Smooth and tasty. Great with coffee in the morning, burbon in the evening.

Awesome!

I consider this smoke to be a 4 star value, primarily based on the price. Medium flavor and burns very well on the golf course. There is minor concern about the wrapper coming loose in the wind, but at this price, repurchase is assured.

Very pleased with the CI knock-offs. Unlike many knock-offs the wrapper stays strong. Be careful on wider rimmed knock-offs. Cannot beat the value versus Macanudo.

Love it! Not bad at all! wish it could last longer!

Great wanted to order more but forgot which ones I ordered. Age setting in.lol

a nice smooth cigar with a good price.

I have tried several knock offs,for the price you can't beat them always pleased with the Macanudo knock offs.

Will continue to buy these, recommended them to another guy yesterday. Very good value, my favorite lawn mowing cigar

Smooth consistent draw, good flavor.

Nice!

I was happy with product

Very good for the price will buy again

As good as it gets for a knockoff

I've tried CI's macanudo knockoffs and monte Cristo knockoffs, and love them both. These are a favorite among the guys at work, too. Every once in a while you might have to re-stick the wrapper a little after you cut it, or once in a blue moon you might get one with a tough draw. But overall these macanudo knockoffs smoke very well and have a great, mild flavor far beyond their humble price. (My co-workers and I prefer keeping them a little "soft" in the humidor.)

Very good smoke for a good price

i am no expert ,but these are really good cigars and at a good price.

Ok

Great taste and value!!

I have bought knock-offs before and have only been mildly satisfied. These CI knock-offs have all been a smooth even smoke right to the nub. I would buy these again!

These are indeed my favorites along with the Fresh Rolled Rosado Cuban Wheels. I built my own humidor and developed a very stable humidification "system". After a year in the box, these cigars are just terrific. Wait for a sale on them.

Very comparable. A great value smoke

good smoke but doesn't burn evenly after 1/2 way point

Very good. To me they taste the same.

I enjoyed the cigars and found them very satisfying.

The taste is just short of the real thing, couldn't be happier with these knockoffs.

They're as good as real macanudos for much less

Recently tried them for the first time. Very smooth mild to medium cigar at a great price.Good everyday cigar

very mild

Mild and flavorful cigar. It burns evenly and holds a decent ash. Can't beat them for the price!

My last 2 orders were the Macanudo KO's with the proper length 7.0. They draw perfectly. The previous 5 orders were the supposedly the same but the length was 7.5. To make these draw properly you had to stick an ice pick down the middle!

Loosely packed cigar. Needs way more filler. You can squish it with your index finger and thumb down to 3/8 inch as you are smoking it. Nothing like a Macanudo.

I am a beginner and I smoke a cigar a week. This is my favorite stick I have bought. My friends loved it and I did too. Would definitely buy again and would recommend to mild cigar smokers. Nice smooth flavor.

Not the best I've ever had. However, it's a great value for everyday smoke. I will buy again.

Doesn't compare to Macanudo at all. The first five out of the twenty were not good. I would feel bad giving these away. Maybe a little aging in the humidor might help the remaining 15. Save your money.

Mild, smooth burning with great aroma and taste. Knock-off but I cannot tell the difference. Just like a Macanudo without premium prices. It is my daily cigar and enjoy them very much.

Very glad I bought these cigars! Excellent value, great smoke!

Okay everyday smoke. I don't care for the start of the cigar, but the last half is good. Easy draw, stays lite most of the time and good smoke clouds

Pretty good for the price! Nothing close to the real thing!

Excellent comparison but not as tightly rolled or some loose binders give poor draw and too much heat; otherwise, worth the savings.

Very good smoke for the price. The only reason I didn't give them a five star rating is due to a slight inconsistency in draw. Even with this small flaw I have reordered these cigars several times. They are a great everyday smoke!

One knockoff was good 4 stars. Other was a little harsh.

They were good

Good value. , flavor is a little too mild

Light and tasty ,wrap unravels a little, but Bryan's that not a bad smoke.

These are smoking evenly with a smooth draw and pleasant taste

Pretty smooth, but burn a bit fast. Would definitely buy again as they are pretty good for the price.

Very good cigar. Smoked great! Mild and flavorful. They are well made and smoke evenly. Great value.

Great value. Well wrapped but a little mild for my tastes.

I enjoy the taste. They are smooth

I seldom / never spend more than $2 on a cigar so I am always looking for a decent cigar at a moderate / cheap .price . These knock offs fulfil both criteria. There as good as any $5 cigar that I've ever smoked . I buy cigars for my enjoyment and not to impress others.

Not bad tasting but burn is very uneven.

Not exactly the quality of real Macanudos but for the price they are great. A special occasion smoke at an everyday smoke price.

Not a bad smoke for the price. A few were a little harsh with a rough draw but all in all will order again for the price and value.

I have tried the other CI knockoffs, but found them mostly harsh. These are generally mild but with plenty of flavor. One of my favorites.

They are quality smokes not to be compared directly to Macanudo but generally, mild, flavorful, well constructed and a price bargain. They are fresh and worthy of sharing with your buddies and associates.

Worst quality cigar I ever bought from CI. Cigars are unraveling and some seem old. Save you money and pick something else.

Good smoke, they burn even and have a good flavor. They burn a bit quicker but for the price you can't go wrong.

Great smoke!

Nice even burn and easy draw, consistently good cigars

Let me be clear - I very seldom get a chance to actually smoke a cigar. But I do spend a lot of time chewing on them. I love the taste of Connecticut wrappers and I thought that these might be a cheap way for me to indulge my habit. The problem with these is that the filler leaf used is very short and choppy. I spend all afternoon spitting out pieces of the filler. I am 100% sure that these sticks would be just fine if I were a normal person and just smoked the damn things, but that's not what I bought these for.

For a budget cigar and a nice smoke with friends, you can't beat these cigars for price and a quality smoke.

These cigars smoke great, very much like the KO -- compare Monte cigars.

Excellent value and great taste

excellent cigars for the money. they are a constant order for me

I've been smoking the Monte Cristo knock-offs on a regular basis. Recently I ordered the Macanudo Torpedo knock-offs. These are great smokes for the price. After a few weeks in the humi, they taste great, have an even burn, and he'll I go for them quite often. Too bad for the name brands, just keep supplying me with those generics!

Smoked my first one today and thoroughly enjoyed it.

Very good!

Very smooth and flavorful

Honestly, the knock off Macs start out well then come apart like chocolate in the sun.

Not as good as the original.

I have smoked many of the CI Knock-Offs. Everyone of them was great all the way down to the snub. I recommend these cigars to everyone I talk to. For the price they can't be beat.

great value!

These are really good, and it does have a Macanudo-ish taste to it. Not bad at all.

Nice and smooth, slow and even smoke!

I have found both the Churchill and Torpedo sizes to be well constructed with a medium strength, good smoke and flavor. It has been rare toget one too tightly rolled to smoke . I prefer the Connecticut wrappers.

The CI Knock-Offs are outstanding...give them a shot and you will be surprised!

Very pleased with th draw and mild taste of the Macanudo knockoffs Thanks.

OK for the price but nothing to write home about

Everyone has there own taste so I won't say there bad but ill leave it at....not for me!

Great cigar for a good price. Smooth smoaking start to finish.

Good but like a little fatter round. My fault

Great value

These are a great cigar, for the price I don't feel guilty having one everyday.

Not bad for the price

I order my cigars the first week of every month. From now on I will be ordering a bundle of the CI Knock-Offs every time I order. I have tried the Macanudo P. Philip and the Montecristo. I loved both of them. I highly recommend these for an everyday cigar.

I buy these to hand out to my buddies on the weekend golf trips. These are nice sticks which have a great taste and a even draw. You wont be disappointed!

Almost as good as original. For the occasional cigar smoker great choice.

I expected something like a cafe. It was too strong.

Great Cigars

smooth smoke for a great price.

They are pretty good. The only thing is, sometimes I "chew" on them for a few moments while working around the place, and if I cut too much of the tip off after that, the tobacco tends to leak out. Just a personal habit but other than that, ok by me.

Bought these only because Mistakes coronal are out of stock

No brainer well built cigar from start to finish

Good taste, draw and burn

As close as you can get without spending $$$.

Was very surprised with the similarity of the 2. Will definitely order again

I like them.

Every single one is well constructed, draws well, and tastes great. Definitely recommended. I am buying more.

I tried the CI Macanudo Knock offs and thought they were great for the price.

Regardless of size, I rarely get a poorly constructed cigar. I favor Torpedo and Churchill sizes.

I am a repeat customer for the Macanudos Knock-Offs. There is no better cigar for the price.

Inconsistent burn

Try these CI Knock Offs and share them with your golf buddy's.

I have been buying these for some time now. I feel they are a great value. My only negatives are the draw can be it tough at time and requires the use of a draw poker and the wrapper is inconsistent. Overall good enough to continue to purchase.

Your Macanudo knockoffs are excellent - smooth, flavorful and the price is right!

These knock offs are as close as you can get without buying the real thing.

Very good cigar for the money!

It's a great read a smoke

Tasteful but loosely packed. After clipping end off a lot of tobacco spills out when taking a drag.

Excellent cigars for the price. The Macanudo is very mild, good wrap and burns evenly.

Smooth and light flavor at a budget price. A long time daily Smoke.

The knockout were awful take them off the market

5 Star, they were very good!!

Great smokes.

Burns great. Good draw. Def. not a Macanudo . For the price it's a good cigar. I would definitely buy again.

Great prices

Only smoked 2 so far & were great. Hope rest are the same

This stick burns even and is a very good everyday smoke. Would recommend and by again.

They weren't bad but a bit dry.

very nice mild smoke, so far every cigar has burned perfect

Good smokes, taste spot on and for the money ya can't beat them.

Great smoke for the money...excellent burn

Best smoke dollar for dollar. I enjoy the big brands to but for an awesome every day evening smoke you can't beat the CI Macanudo knock offs

very good value

Great deal.... good smoke for reasonable coin.

Not the best wrapped too loosely

The taste of these cigars is fairly consistent. Not quite the flavor of the Hyde Park but close enough for a $2 smoke.

Smooth and very mild knock off..

Very nice cigar.

What's not to like. Good construction, satisfying flavor, good draw and great value.

This is my go-to cigar for everyday cheap smoke. It's the perfect size shape and Mildness, the only problem is I have to punch it rather than clip the end off, or suffer the consequences.

Fast becoming my favorite utility cigar. Draw is great. None of the "golfball through a garden hose" mess with this stick. Kinda stuck on these for now due to the price/value component. The minute these things go on sale I'm bulking up.

very nice smoke for the price

great everyday cigar have ordered name brand but always return to these.

great cigar cant beat price shipped fast also.

Great price Great Smoke Very Happy with this cigar

These are very consistent throughout, burns evenly and well constructed. These have a permanent spot in my humidor.

great everyday smoke even burn holds together nicely

I buy all my cigars from CI because frankly you can't beat the prices. I look all the time and you can't find better deals.

Bought some for my son to give out for the arrival of his 2nd son. Decent smoke for the price. Good draw with punch cut. Even burn with lots of smoke and mild flavor.

excellent

Great smoke for the price! Worth getting

Not bad for the price! Good taste, burns OK, less tobac means shorter smoke! Stay away from the MonteCristo Knock off.

Great deal

Good solid choice.

Not even close

I LOVE THE MACANUDO'S, BUT MY WALLET DOES'NT. GLAD I TRIED THESE BECAUSE FOR THE PRICE, I CAN NOW HAVE A GOOD TASTING CIGAR EVERYDAY AND NOT HAVE TO WAIT TILL THE WEEKEND FOR THE REAL DEALS. THANKS CI, YOU GUYS MAKE IT EASY FOR ME TO ENJOY GOOD SMOKES ALL THE TIME. KEEP THE DEALS COMING.

I was skeptical at first but I'm definitely gonna start buying the knock-off's now, they are definitely a cheaper alternative to the name brand

reasonable price for a good quality mild cigar

The CI Knock Off had a draw comparable to the Macanudo and good flavor. Very close in quality. I would recommend as an alternative smoke at a great price point.

A month or so in the humidor will make this cigar a winner for the price!

Every good cigar for the price.

Excellent selection and great customer service at the store or online!!!!

This has been my go to cigar for years. I have never smoked a bad one. The price is excellent.

Nice everyday cigar

A quality cigar that compares very nice to the Hyde park line. The cigars come ready smoke with nice flavor and even burn. For the price, you really can't go wrong.

Knock offs are great

Good go to everyday

Pretty decent smoke

seems as if you always get something wrong on your orders or the cigars aren't fresh..

Good price but not a great smoke. Burns well but the taste is really bland.

Wicked good everyday smoke . Can't beat the price. This one is always in my humidor

I orderd these hopeing to find a new everyday smoke, so far I havent been disappointed, im going to try some other knockoffs before I settle but these are doing fine

I really like these cigars.

well constructed, good draw, nice smooth smoke...I will definitely buy more

Very good smoke. Not a bad one in the bunch. Will order again

As usual everything was good.

I know these are knock-offs and not the real thing. That being said, they're GOOD! Real value and very satisfying.

Great smokes for the buck. Light well, draw easily, burn evenly and the aroma is pleasing.

The last bundle i got were not as mild as the ones I got in the past. It was a stronger cigar than what I like!

Flavor 7/10, body 4/10, construction 8.5/10, score 5/10. Why the low score? This is shredded "Cuban sandwich" tobacco, not long leaf. The taste and burn are OK, but the experience leaves something lacking. Be prepared to eat jibs. I don't know how to put into words why the experience is different from a real cigar, but it is. Maybe because it lacks complexity? It kind of felt machine made, like a cigarette. I'd want to give a newby a real cigar, I want to pass out fine smokes at family reunions, and in my backyard I want to enjoy the complexity of a real long leaf hand made, and these don't really fit in those occasions. They are tasty though, I'll give them that.

Awesome cigars just wish there was more free shipping to frequent customers

In Short...it doesn't. Too many scraps, constantly spitting out pieces of tobacco. Harsher smoke. Wouldn't buy it again. Sorry.

This is my first purchase with CI. Recommended by a friend. Don't have a big budget for cigars because I have to pay the bills. Have been looking for an inexpensive cigar that I can enjoy without breaking the bank and I have found it! This cigar burns evenly; draws well and stays lit. Nice mild flavor as advertised. Slight bite in the back of the throat but no big deal. Loved it!

Not a bad cigar. It is fairly loose and tends to leave bits of tobacco in your mouth as you smoke it.

Fast shipping and delivery, usually receive my order before the estimated delivery date. Very happy with my purchase. I will be back to buy more CI Knock-Offs.

These are surprisingly good cigars. Good value.

Very nice cigar. Mild taste and uniform burn. Enjoyable plus a great price.

If you haven't tried these yet, you're missing one of the greatest deals CI offers. These little beauties are so close to the real thing that you're gonna feel like you just won the big kahuna lottery. Firm, smooth burning and great taste. If you feel uncomfortable about the rock-bottom price - buy 2 boxes and donate one to the troops!

I found the CI knock offs to be a decent value. I like a mild cigar and these are slightly more aggressive than a Macanudo, but I still enjoy them. They are well made and burn smoothly. I will probably buy them again. I gave them four stars as a stand alone rating for a bargain cigar, not as a comparison to a real Mac.

To my surprise these cigars were very dry...

Ordered the Churchills and was very pleased. Ordered the panatellas and they were more inconsistent. Will stick to the Churchills

A little to strong for me. I felt this was more a medium than mild-medium smoke. They are definitely a little stronger than a Macanudo Gold Label. If you like the stronger Macanudo (i.e. Cru Royale) you would probably enjoy this more than me.

The price is right and its a good knock off.

Good cigar for the money, but definitely not a Macanudo.

Enjoy the taste, not quite as mild as the macanudo but nonetheless very good. Ocassionally the consistency of the wrapper on the cigar is wound to tight or the cigars are a but stale. Overall I am happy with the product.

These were a little rough out-of-the-box but after a little time in "Jail" (the humidor) they emerged with a new attitude. I'm not an Upscale smoker so I'm always looking for the deals, which is also why I shop exclusively at CI. I'd do these again.

i like CI well overall. Seems like it but takes longer the. It should to process orders and actually ship them. I'm a fan of the knock-off cigars I wish more sales were run on home. Again over all great service!

Not sure it truly taste like a Macanudo but I enjoy the taste and has a good draw

i don't actually know what Hyde Parks taste\smoke like, but these are nice, mild cigars that burn evenly and pleasantly. I'll continue to buy them!

This is my everyday cigar...tasty, consistent and cheap! I treat myself to a name brand every now and then but I always come back to this reliable gem. Fellow smokers with whom I share agree that this is a great smoke. Neal

The taste was just ok, but he construction was horrible. The cigar was flimsy and spongy with an uneven burn. I won’t waste my money again on these cigars.

best cigars I've had in some years!

they were very good. I'd like to more of them in future.

Great sticks and clearly comparable as advertised!

love these cigars! Best for the price!

I couldn't get Churchill to appear which is the one I always order. Anyway, these are pretty close to the real Macanudo. In fact, on some light ups, I thought they were better! Smooth draw, stays lit, great taste. Try 'em. Don't be a scardy-cat. They're great.

Very happy with product taste and quick delivery times.

Mild flavor and mild bodied, anytime is a good time to smoke these cigars. They're a great smoke in the morning, afternoon and at night. They are perfectly constructed cigars that burn evenly and deliver a good volume of smoke. Great cigar and very reasonably priced.

A great tasting cigar (like it's doppleganger) but poorly constructed. With every breath I get a mouthful of filler pieces. Makes me wary of trying any more knock-offs.

The knock-off flavor is very simliar to the Macanudo, however the wrap & pack methods just aren't up to par. The Macanudo is tightly packed and wrapped in high quality wrapping tobacco, while the knock-off is loosley packed which allows shards of tabacco to get into your mouth. The wrapper is difficult to get a good cut on unlike the Macanudo which seems to cut perfect every time. To summarize, the flavor is there, but the packing & wrapping need work.

Been smoking CI Knock-Offs for several years. Not as tight as Macanuda but that makes draw easier. A matter of taste of course, then there's the difference in price. Wish you all would start selling Nespresso expresso pods!

Same size and shape, with a smooth, even burn. But maybe not quite as tasty.

These are very good smokes. They are one of the best cigar buys in the country. I hope that they remain available for a very long time.