Your web browser is no longer supported.
Cigars International is commited to providing you with the best web experience possible. Please upgrade to a modern web browser.

Captain McMellow's 20-Cigar Collection Reviews

Shop Now
Showing 1-0 of 17 Reviews
Customer Reviews of “Captain McMellow's 20-Cigar Collection”
“This is a must-buy sampler for fans of mild cigars and those new to cigars! Each of these are one of my favorites, so it's convenient to have them all in one sampler at an affordable price. If you have never tried a ManOWar Virtue, this is a good way to do so while enjoying proven mild winners from Macanudo and 5Vegas, plus the unique Beauty by Gurkha. ”
JC of Anthem, AZ
“There is a little confusion on the Gurkha u get. Status or beauty? In both pics it's a status and beauty and one of the reviews says he got a beauty. I personally got the status. Anywho, this sampler is def worth double what is paid and a PERFECT combination of mild cigars. If you're new to cigars this is great. If you enjoy milds like me .. Well then this is just awesome. That's like 2.50 a cigar and each is easily worth $5- 6 and retail upwards of that. Buy it lol”
DM of Roberta, GA
“I am new to cigars and although I have not developed pallet for them in my opinion this package deal is exactly that; a good deal. The cigars were received in good shape minus one Gurkha Status that had a burst wrapper from the closed end to the top ring. Perhaps this was because I had the smokes sent regular mail instead of overnighted. The other cigars look fine and the moisture content seemed to be a little low. I recommend this package of cigars and would also recommend a faster delivery. Thank you CI for a nice introduction to cigars. ”
DH of Springdale, AR
“This sampler is great for those mild cigar lovers out there. The four that are in this sampler are mild with really great flavors behind each one. If you've never tried these 4 cigars before, don't be crazy grab this up!”
MS of Cold Spring, KY
“I am more of a med-full cigar smoker. But I got one of the Man O' War Virtues in the La Amistad Salomon sampler last month and I got to say, it was one of the better smokes in that pack.”
KB of SOUTHPORT, NC
“Good deal for the money. I received the Ghurka Status with my order, and it was my favorite in the sampler. Did not care much for the 5 Vegas gold. Grassy and papery at first, improving to a mild tobacco core with a bit of pepper after the first quarter....and not much else. For reference, my favorite mild cigar is the Romeo and Juliet Vintage.”
SM of Coppell, TX
“This is a fine sampler pack. Great sticks at a great price. This is going to become one of my regular selections!”
TH of HUDSON, WI
“excellent, love the pack. the vegas is awesome.”
JP of Colorado Springs, CO
“Nice selection of some very tasty yet not overbearing sticks!”
PG of MEDFORD, OR
“Great cigars, great deal, great customer service. Received the cigars in 3 business days, tried the Gurkha and it was absolutely wonderful. Had a small issue and the support team answered me and resolved it within a few hours. Great work CI, I look forward to further providing my business.”
RY of Spring, TX
“Item arrived just as advertised. These are some of my favorite and can't wait to enjoy them all.”
SS of APO, AP
“Great selection of top mellow cigars. I will buy it again!”
JB of Valparaiso, IN
“GREAT buy,Loved em all”
DM of omaha, NE
“Great assortment of mild premiums really enjoying all of them”
EC of FALL RIVER, MA
“Let me start off by saying THANK YOU CIGARS INTERNATIONAL!! So here's some ranting and praising for this "captain mcmellows sampler" just my opinions! I let these babies rest in the humi for over a week before I dove in head first, and I'm smoking 3-5 sticks a day... The 5vegas gold toro, is a true winner.... It's mild, tasty, burns razor sharp and requires ZERO maintenance!! Loved them!! The MACANUDO cafe Hyde park, another valiant champion!! I really just wish it came in a bigger ring gauge with this sampler because they were delicious, zero maintenance smoke, tasty, and will be a long term resident in my humi for years to come... Next, the gurkha symphony, wow, SO DISAPPOINTED!! It made me google "why does my cigar quit burning", and "what makes a cigar burn only down one side" and "what make a cigar canoe and refuse to be able to cooperate"!!! And lastly the man o war virtue, tasted horrible from start to finish, the wrapper fell apart on every one of them, and did I mention it tasted horrible? So, with this sampler, you get some good smokes, and some bad smokes, all in my opinion...”
DW of Andrews, TX
“All smokes were super smooth, especially the Gurkhas. You really can't buy a better collection of mild cigars for this price”
PJ of Ballston Spa, NY
“The best mild/ medium sampler out there. The 5 Vegas Gold gives the sampler a milder side, providing thick smoke with slight notes of cedar and spice. The Macanudo's are fantastic as usual, along with the Man O' War. The Gurkha's are really nice, great burn, great draw. This sampler is fantastic.”
RO of Ringgold, GA