Your web browser is no longer supported.
Cigars International is committed to providing you with the best web experience possible.
Close

Don Smith Reviews

Shop Now
Overall Rating 3.82 out of 5 Based on 28 Ratings

Customer Reviews of “Don Smith”

Write A Review
5 out of 5
5 Star
9
4 out of 5
4 Star
12
3 out of 5
3 Star
3
2 out of 5
2 Star
1
1 out of 5
1 Star
3
Showing 1-42 of 42 Reviews
3 out of 5
Good every day cigar.
Seen them on the wed site not. a bad price. Lets face it not a bad cigar you get what you pay for bottom line..
5 out of 5
Not bad
I have only smoked a couple of them, and they are not to bad
5 out of 5
Smooth
Very good taste and light đź‘Ť
4 out of 5
Consistent and Mild, at any price, worth it!
These are consistent, mild smokes. They are very good
5 out of 5
Gotta luv 'em
They really are a great smoke for the price. I enjoy a good everyday cigar at the end of a day with a tasty beverage. Great taste down to the end. You'll definitely will be hearing from me again
3 out of 5
DON SMITH CHURCHILLS
NOT A PERFECT CIGAR BUT NOT BAD. THEY BURN A LITTLE UNEVENLY BUT TASTE GOOD AND A GREAT PRICE.
4 out of 5
Sam Boardman
They are fine
4 out of 5
Good for the $$
They are OK for the price. You were out of my number 1 brand, so I had to settle for second best.
5 out of 5
Another winner from CI!!!
Great cigar!! Nice ,slow burn, easy draw. A good cigar for the buck!!!
1 out of 5
I'm not a fan.
I'm not a fan. Almost every cigar required relighting, if I could even manage to get a decent initial draw.
4 out of 5
Don Smith Churchill
To coin a phrase, "a good 5 cent cigar". I wouldn't pass them around at my daughters wedding but would share them on the fairway.
5 out of 5
Great cigars
Always enjoy don smith cigars! I'm waiting for po boy sampler.
2 out of 5
Not impressed
Wish I could give a glowing review but I cannot. While they are low cost I found them to be hard to draw and too strong for me. Perhaps others have had better results but I can only provide my viewpoint. I did expect them to be a good choice for me but in this case it just did not work out.
1 out of 5
Terrible smoke!!!
Very loosely wrapped the cigar is tough to draw. Not favorable at all. Extremely disappointing
4 out of 5
ok but nothing special
Ok for every day. For me the flavor profile was more of a medium than mild cigar. Overall they smoked ok though some needed to be relit a couple of times. A couple in each bundle tunneled, or canoe'd, OR hard draw. Most were good but a bit hot close to the nub. In reality I'd give them a 3.75
5 out of 5
Inexpensive but not Cheap
These are some of the best, mild smokes around and can hold their own compared to some more pricey cigars!
1 out of 5
worst cigar ever
Worst cigar I've ever smoked. I mean the worst, nice looking cigar in a maduro wrapper, I tried smoking 30 of these and they're as hard as a rock. It's not that they're not moist, they're wrapped so tight you cant draw on them. I even put an icepick down the middle of the cigar to try & draw smoke, no go. nothing works. I had them in my humidor. If you buy this cigar YOU'LL BE DISAPPOINTED!
5 out of 5
Bruce McIntyre
I am very pleased with the Don Smith Churchill smokes I purchased.They are a very good smoke and well worth the time to sit down and enjoy.Nice rich flavor,easy draw,and even burn.Damb good cigar.
4 out of 5
Don Smith Churchill
Good smooth and mild to medium cigar. Also very affordable. Enjoyed them.
4 out of 5
Just slightly bitter.
Just slightly bitter.
5 out of 5
Good smokes for the price
They are well made and stay lit. Although a bit stronger than I like they are not bad for the price.
4 out of 5
Nice, consistent smoke.
Very good for the price. Consistent, made well, no canoeing, no falling apart. I see a lot of folks describe these as mild, but to me, they are more of a medium or medium plus. Only bad thing for me is that they tend to burn quickly. But for the low price, I can smoke two. No problem.
3 out of 5
Don Smith Churchill
A good rich taste, smokes well when the wrapper does not come loose. Still, a decent cigar for the money.
4 out of 5
Good for the price .
It's a good buck cigar . Mild , good flavor , easy draw . I wonder about the filler . A lot of it ends up in my mouth and once in a while I pull out some things . Would I buy more . Yes .
5 out of 5
GOOD CIGAR
I like the don smith. It is a mild cigar,easy draw,even through the smoke. A good evening smoke.
4 out of 5
a great smoke
smooth, mild, easy draw, very appealing smoke. Good price point, worth a try.
4 out of 5
Don Smith Churchill
A great value for the price. I smoked them all and enjoyed every one of them!
4 out of 5
Good cigar, thanks
I like a smooth cigar and this was it. I don't like to spend an arm and a leg on my cigars so these fit the ticket. Thanks for the deal.
Customer Testimonials
Great value, very fast shipping and a good smoke for the dollar. Plus the cigars were fresh; another reason to deal with CI!!
The ones I've smoked, probably 5, burned evenly, produced a reasonably good flavor and smoke. I've paid a lot more for a cigar and was really dissapointed. A deal for the PRICE!
Of all the cigars in the Po' Boy III Sampler, I enjoyed this one. Needed frequent re-lighting, but the taste was actually good.
An overall good smoke for a cheap stick.
real good smoke. nice and long good flavor. Definitely a good choice
I'm surprised at the bad reviews. First off, what do you expect for a $1 cigar? Actually, I've tried quite a few of the $1 cigars here, and they are pretty bad.....except this one. It is a GOOD $1 cigar. If you want a better cigar than this, spend more than a buck. Otherwise, if you want some smokable single ducat sticks, here you go.
Okay not a top brand but didn't expect it to be. However I like the woody tones and it is a smooth smoke. The cap isn't well done so be careful if you bite it off. It is still better than machine made cheap nasties by far.
I am surprised by all the bad reviews. While not the best I ever smoked, I found this to be a pleasant smoke. At the current price of $1 a stick I think it's a bargain.
I will save these for when I have an emergency like running out of the good stuff. Don't have a novice try these, they won't want to smoke cigars again if they do.
Ah, the Don Smith Series Dee. My advice: Buy a bundle and give them out to your friends who always try to mooch a good cigar. It does produce a lot of smoke. Unfortunately, it's not good smoke. It certainly belongs on the UNSMOKEABLE list. If nothing else, it helps you to really appreciate the cigars you do enjoy.
This is a beautiful presentation but the overall cigar was a bit to be desired. At the beginning, the taste was "right on" for a sumatra wrapper. The burn was uneven and hard to keep lit. Then the entire stick became soft and mushy.
A mild bodied cigar with strong woody overtones. Smooth, no spice. Kept its character to the very end. Loosely rolled, it became very mushy next to the heat of the cherry, but otherwise well constructed with no runs. This is a cheap cigar, but with none of the harshness associated with cheap tobacco. Good for golfing or mowing the lawn. If you are in the store, get the Bag O' Dung so you can add the band to your collection. Hey, Joe! Hows about sending me a real cigar for this real review. :-)
Yeah, a cheap Dominican (there’s a million of those!) cigar. Blugh!
Wow, I finally made it in this world. I have my own cigar. If you guys are interested I could send you some photos of me smoking the cigar and you could use them in your ads. Or maybe me on the deck of a big yacht or other similar activities. This could be HUGE.
Adroit