Your web browser is no longer supported.
Cigars International is committed to providing you with the best web experience possible.

Brocatus Reviews

Shop Now
Overall Rating 4.58 out of 5 Based on 40 Ratings

Customer Reviews of “Brocatus”

Write A Review
5 out of 5
5 Star
4 out of 5
4 Star
3 out of 5
3 Star
2 out of 5
2 Star
1 out of 5
1 Star
Showing 1-50 of 101 Reviews
4 out of 5
Great Cigar!
Excellent Cigar, and going to place my next order. My new favorite every day cigar.
2 out of 5
It's worth the price but not a quality cigar
I purchased the Brocatus Torpedo 2-fer because of some encouraging words printed in the monthly sale catalog description. I was expecting something better than what I received. These cigars are only slightly better than the CI Fresh-Rolleds. The smoothness is on the mild side to start, but by mid-way, the effect is more of a medium-full cigar. The firmness is “spongy” and my mouth tends to make indentations into the cigar. I prefer a firmer, more tightly packed cigar, but some may like the softer feel. This might be what is causing it to burn a little hot. The burn is fairly even for a cheap cigar, but drop the ash more often than on your Olivia. On the positive side, this is a good sized cigar for a low price, so I am not disappointed because I got what I paid for. Don’t get me wrong, this is not a horrible cigar to smoke. It’s a great every day cigar and a good value. I just think it fell a little short of the build-up it received in the catalog.
5 out of 5
No comment
No comment
5 out of 5
Great cigars at a great price!!
I tried the Brocatus Cigars last year and found them to be a great cigar. Very mild, and after ordering these three times, I still never had a bad cigar yet. All burn evenly & have a great mild taste.
5 out of 5
Brocatus Torpedo
Great cigar smoooth
5 out of 5
My daily smokes
These are the best hand made I have ever smoked at such a low price. Very smooth and mellow and consistent with each lot. Y'all stay away from these so I can always count on them being available.
5 out of 5
Brocatus is a fine, inexpensive smoke. More on the medium side.
Brocatus is a nice, easy smoking cigar. I consider it a mild to medium cigar (More on the medium side) but a great value at any rate. My personal taste leans more on a more milder Connecticut leaf, but Brocatus is a fine smoke. Keep stocking it!
5 out of 5
Reall good chewing cigar
5 out of 5
Brocatus Churchill 2-fer
Great everyday cigar.
5 out of 5
20% discount on Brocatus
I have bought the Brocatus cigars for over 10 years and found them to be the perfect everyday cigar.
5 out of 5
Great taste at a good price
I find these to be a delight. The flavor, the burn, it is all good. For someone like me who enjoys sharing my cigars with others, it make a good entre into cigars for those who do not smoke alotl
3 out of 5
Smoked several so far ,
Smoked several so far , they need time in humidifier to mellow some. The draw changed during the smoke. In spots packed to tight.
5 out of 5
brocatus churchill 2-fer
cigars were very good value for the money
5 out of 5
Very Satisfied
Good product, great service! Thanks!
3 out of 5
Good gar for the price
4 out of 5
Brocatus Torpedo 2-fer
This is an inexpensive quality cigar. I use it as my everyday cigar and on the golf course. The 2-fer makes is a great deal.
5 out of 5
Bro taus Torpedo
Great value, my daily cigar and Golf cigar. Great value.
5 out of 5
Great Smoke
Great Smoke
5 out of 5
On time
CI is always fast in filling orders and if not in stock they help you choose another cigar that you prefer. They are the best cigar co. I have dealt with
5 out of 5
For the money its a
For the money its a great smoke and made well with great care
3 out of 5
My order of Brocatus Torpedo was an received without any problems. I recently purchased order of 5 Vagas and that order was never received. I'm currently waiting for a replacement of these cigars.
4 out of 5
This is the first time I have tried these smokes and I have been pleasantly surprised. I assumed that at this price, they would be harsh and perhaps would not draw well. They not only smoked and drew well, they tasted good and smooth. No harsh bite and were good right to the end. A great value!!
5 out of 5
Great Cigar
I have ordered these little gems several times, this is the best bang for the buck, smooth, mild taste and they burn great. give them a try you won't be dissappointed.....
5 out of 5
5 out of 5
Good for taking a break during yard work
I like this stoogie and fire one up on yard work break and then a relight after more work it's still decent. Not a $8 soogie but good enough to get you through the day til you can fire up a good stoogie.
5 out of 5
Brocatus Torpedo
Great cigar for everyday. Love your web site and ease of ordering
4 out of 5
Great Cigar for a Great price.
I have made several purchases of Brocatus Churchill 2-fer and have never been disappointed. I spend a lot of time in my shop on woodworking projects and brewing up by favorite homebrew. Don’t worry, not at the same time. The Brocatus Churchill is a decent every day smoke that I always keep in my humidor. Best of all, the price CI has placed on this cigar takes away the guilt of lighting one up and then laying it down for a couple of hours before you get back to it.
4 out of 5
Nice daytime smoke
I smoke usually two sticks a day, and Brocatus is usually one of them with a higher end,( think la Gloria R, Undercrown etc) at night. I'd like to be able to smoke two top shelf cigars daily, and with this cigar I feel like I am. Great flavor, draw and finish. And the two for one steal cannot be beat...unless the maniacs at CI start doing a three for one.
5 out of 5
great choice and a great price consistently .
5 out of 5
Love this cigar!! Smooth down to the nub. Great aroma and no "bite". Great value and I will be ordering again!!
5 out of 5
Fred Sullivan
Very well pleased with all aspects of your company, except for your feedback procedure
5 out of 5
ordering cigars
Don't have to get them yet, always easy to order they come on time
4 out of 5
Nearly all good
Good value, although sometimes a mixed bag. I burned about a dozen boxes so far. Some of the cigars were excellent with a good taste and a great burn - a real pleasure. Most are very good. A few burn on one side until about half-way down and then straighten out if you knock off about an inch of un-burned cigar. About one in 10 burns like a twisted canoe. The bad ones increase the cost per cigar. Over all though, I like them, particularly when they are good.
5 out of 5
Great Cigar
This cigar is the best for the money I have found, and I've tried lots of them.
5 out of 5
I'm almost afraid to write this review in fear of causing the prices to jump. This is a smooth light cigar which has very good taste. The price cannot be beat for a full leaf filler. This is my new daily go to cigar.
5 out of 5
Just As I Expected.Mild,Frsh And
Just As I Expected.Mild,Frsh And Good Draw.As You Had Described In The catalog......Excellent Price Also..... Thank You.
5 out of 5
Good service and nice smoke
CI is my go to cigar supplier now. Fast shipping, decent prices and selection. Those Brocatus cigars are a really good value as well. They're a little mild for my tastes, but just right on quality and price.
5 out of 5
great smoke
This is a real good deal for inexpensive smokes, they do not run when they burn, and stay wrapped to burn even
3 out of 5
A quickie
This cigar burns quickly and unevenly but it is a great yard cigar when mowing.
5 out of 5
Freshness and great value
the cigars are very fresh and your delivery is very very prompt great to do business with you thanks
Customer Testimonials
Good deal, and great cigar for the price. Mellow and burns good.
Great cigar for the money.
Maybe my hopes were too high, and I don't want to rain on anyone's parade, but I'm just not fond of the way these taste. If you like the taste, this is a good cigar of consistent quality. My quest for a $1 daily smoke continues.
Bought a box of expensive cigars as a gift for my father-in-law, and bought a box of cheap Brocatus for myself. We ended up smoking two of his and all of mine.
I ordered two boxes for an upcoming party give-aways and everyone enjoyed them - not very easy to do! This is a pleasant discovery for an everyday/everyman casual cigar. Great flavor, strength is truly mild-medium, rolled tight, wrapper stays in place, and burns quite well. The only downside, is that just a few had a stem in them, probably 1/5, but they where short and did not take much away from the cigar experience. A good cigar, I hope CI keeps them in their inventory and maintain the price point. Enjoy!
Nice cigar; nice flavor and a good burn. Some minor flaws, but for a little over a buck a stick who's complaining? For this price you would expect a two-puff and into the garbage dog rocket. Not the case. A good cigar to smoke to save your prize cigars for better occasions. Also a good cigar for mooches that won't get them po'd at you. No, Padron need not worry.
Have only smoked a couple so far, and while they're not the best cigar I've had; I've certainly paid a lot more for a lot worse. Like most, humidor time will improve them. What they did do right out of the box was burn evenly, stay lit, draw easily, and produce nice, thick clouds of smoke. I'd say their decent, everyday cigars.
Just got my order of Brocatus torpedos....lit one up right off the truck. To be honest, I became worried when my stick was difficult to draw, resulting in little if any smoke making it to my palate. But with a little rolling around in my fingers the roll loosened up and the creamy mild smoke filled my up to the brim. If this is the worst experience I have with these cigars then I am in good shape. I recommend these to anyone looking for a mild everyday or morning coffee cigar! Keep it up CI!!!
....every other cigar was plugged...well..guess you get what you pay for
Light but tasty. As others have said, they benefit from a month or two in the humidor. Really quite nice, reaching into the "good cigar" class.
Ordered based on others reviews. First day I recieved them I smoked one. I will tell you, it wasn't love at first sight or smoke. The next few weren't much better. I let them sit for a week or so and tried another. It was better. I have now had them in my humidor for awhile and let me tell you, they get better and better. Great burn and flavour. I recommend buying these but let them sit for a bit. You will be glad you did.
I have been searching for an everyday cigar that doesn't add up to a car payment every month.....found it!
The Best medium range cigar available ... simply great!
Very pleasantly surprised. I wanted to leave these in the humi for a month or so before I tried but, curiosity got the better of me. A nice light everyday smoke. First one had good flavor and solid construction. I was worried it would be a real quick burner but, it was not. I will buy more!
For a daily cigar I generally order cigars on the cheap side so I was very surprised at how good these were for the price. After smoking 2 of them I shared one with a friend today and he couldn't believe it was a $1.10 cigar. I bought another 2 boxes before Cigarintl runs out of them!!
Returned these cigars--don't burn well--awful taste
I needed a mild cigar to smoke at night (so I could sleep) and wanted a cheapo for yard work, hunting, etc., so I tried Brocatus. It's cheap enough and mild enough and, on top of that, a nice well made smoke, good enough for any time you don't want the big kick from a strong cigar. I'll contnue to keep them on hand.
Starts out okay. But after long, about half way, turns somewhat bitter. To me finish was dry tasting. I am a fan of cheap cigars for every day craving satisfaction, but I recommend John Bull way above these.
I ordered this cigar based on the numerous positive reviews. Sadly my experience was anything but positive. I received my two boxes of Brocatus Churchills a day earlier than expected. Excited to break into them, I lit one up after dinner that night. As I opened the packaging I realized that the boxes were made of a Masonite material. I was expecting some sort of wood, but for a buck a cigar I just shook it off and moved forward. Upon opening the box there was an overwhelming smell of wood glue. I couldn't catch a whiff of the actual cigars aroma. I took out a cigar, cut it and checked the draw. Excellent, however upon smelling the cigar all I could get was the same smell of wood glue. Finally I lit the cigar and hoped for the best. After toasting the end and getting an even light I had my first puff. Hmmmmmm...wood glue. I had just bought 50 cigars that smelled and tasted like wood glue. Hoping that being a mild cigar it just needed to develop a bit I stuck it out through the whole Churchill. Eventually some vague oaky notes came through, but the overwhelming taste of the box seemed to saturate the cigar and made these subtle notes worthless. Sadly not the experience I had envisioned.... I love CI, and this is the first bad experience I've had with them.
I like these smokes. Good construction, fairly even burn, ok flavor. This is a good everyday cigar.
I just got my shipment of the 2fer of Brocatus, 30 minutes ago. Could not wait, had to light one up. Nicely filled cigar, with a heavy premium feel. The draw was a bit tight, construction was very good. Mild taste, and a mild buzz. This cigar has a spicy leaf in it that gives a non cigar fragrant aftertaste, which I love. I don't know what it is, but it tastes and smells great. The aroma is sweet and very pleasant. I read some bad reviews on this brand, however they were old reviews, and I suspect either the blend, or the blender has changed since. This is a super everyday cigar, I am ordering another 2fer now. It's cheap, so even if you get a few with bad draws, it's absolutely worth it.
Overall this the best everyday cigar. I have tried a lot of cigars looking for a good cheap smoke. Look no more, this is it. And in comes in a box for $1.20 a stick. Mild and great with coffee in the morning.
Great cheap cigar! I've purchased 4 boxes of the robusto's so far. Some had a green spot here or there but ALL smoked great and tasted great, and most burned evenly. There's nothing to complain about. Definitely worth the $. Definitely worth trying.
I picked up a box of these on a special...they came in today and put all in the humi cept the one I'm smoking now...very tasty and mild with a fragrance my wife cannot complain canoeing or relights on this one...I'm impressed with how well they were not dried up, broken or otherwise in the box...speaking of...the only thing I'm hesitant about is using the Bracatus Box for storing other cigs. I can smell wood glue...possibly airing out will help..closing, just a good cigar!
CI. Do you take request? If so, could you please have these great cigars in at least a 52 ban Churchill, since the 50 are smaller than I like? If not, this is still a great change of pace cigar,for those who are a med to full body person such as I. After smoking a few cigars such as the Triple Play, Diesel, Alec Bradley, and other brands in this category. There are times when I want something on the mild side, but still has flavor. This cigar is the answer for those in this category, and you can't beat the price. Try to resist the temptation of smoking one as soon as you get them, (like I did) since they improve with at least a week of humidor time. There are billows of smoke, easy draw, even until the end, plenty of flavor, what more is their to say. If you enjoy this one, then you need to give the Churchill Deluxe a chance also. The Brocatus is a cigar that you could smoke with your morning coffee, and all day long.
usually you get what you pay for but this was a surprise. great cigar. great price.....just had a third kid so i need a bargin
Shhh, no more kudos for this cigar. The next thing you know it will have "out of stock" next to the size I buy. Yes it's a nice mild smoke, lasts around 9 holes of golf, and seldom have to relight like some of the dogs that cost 4 times the price. Yes, I have had a couple that draw a little tight. Not enough to give you a hernia, but for the price tag I can live with it. I just chalk the occasional tighty up to a "rookie" roller.
I just bought a box of torpedos and let all of them rest in the humidor except for one. I decided to go against my better judgement and smoke one out of the box. Surprisingly even without any of my humidor time the smoke was rather pleasing for a mild cigar. I tend to smoke stronger more med-full flavored cigars but this was a nice change of pace. Pre-light smell was pleasant, construction was rather good for the price range and the only issue I had was that some of the wrappers were a little splotchy here and there.....but hey, what do you expect for $1 plus change per cigar. These would be amazing in the morning with a nice cup of coffee. The flavor kind of reminded me of the makers choice cigars that CI sells. I bet a month in the humidor will make these even more amazing.
Outstanding price and value. It is a mild smoke and you can't go wrong in buying this cigar. I take them to our tailgating group for every home game and they are loved by all.
I normally smoke maduros or various corojos cigars, yet was looking for something mild for morning coffee. This Brocatus, as I will not give it a 'wow", it is a very mild, very pleasant cigar. It ain't pretty as it has considerable veins and a blotchy-uneven colored wrapper, but this is a budget cigar. It smokes very smoothly, milldly and has a pleasant sweet nutty finish. Make no mistake, this is a very mild cigar yet has a nice flavor and perfect burn. I enjoyed this mild cigar and will keep some in my humi for mornings and cuttin" the lawn.
Just finished smoking my first Brocatus 5.0 x 50 and I think it was a wonderful cigar for the price. I immediately thought it was a poorman's Graycliff "G2"; nutty/oaky flavors and a great overall taste. It burned evenly and had no construction issues. I'm so happy I bought these; it's not a G2, but for the value conscious buyer it's heaven.
The Brocktus Torpedo is a pleasant suprise. Yes it's mild for one who generally smokes Maduro's but it"s a nice change of pace, well constructed, very nice steady burn and draw. I am well pleased with them.
I've tried most of the sub $2.50 cigars that have decent customer ratings on this and other sites. The Brocadus is the least expensive of them all and probably the best. As stated by others, it is a mild cigar but it is also tasty. I've almost finished my first box and have had no real burn or draw issues. These aren't the prettiest sticks in the world but they aren't poorly constructed either.
Brocatus is a good, well balanced everyday smoke. Mild but flavorful. I got two of the Churchills in a Po' Boy Sampler and truly enjoyed same! Nice even burn with an easy draw.
This cigar, Brocatus is great. It is a bit mild, but only paying $35.00 box it's worth it. I do wish they came in a larger ring gauge due to my draw. These cigars are one of my daily smokes. They are great in the morning with coffee or just relaxing with a bourbon. I have had only a couple of duds. Bad draw, wouldn't stay lit. That is minor in the grand scheme of things. Enjoy Brocatus!! Thanks CI for your great prices and availibility.
Just got the Brocatus cigars today (Robusto size) and I like them a lot. They are very good and they smell awesome. Thanks CI
After reading all the positive reviews I finally broke down and bought a box of these 'cheap' cigars. While I don't think they compare to a 5 Vegas Gold or a Macanudo, I was surprised when I tried one. The Brocatus burned very even with a nice light ash. The smoke was thick with a nice draw. The taste was not very complex, but was a nice enjoyable tasting smoke. For around 30 bucks a box I don't think you will find a better tasting or constructed cigar.
Not bad for the price, but not great. The construction and burn is good and the flavor is okay, but very mild. I have one in the morning when I don't want to burn through my higher end stuff. I good give away cigar for newbies or the ocassional cigar smoker that won't make you any enemies.
I bought these cigars (Brocatus) because I was looking for an altenative to my Oliveros Classic as an everyday cigar. They were inexpensive and all the reviews were positive. Great cigar...great cigar. I've been smoking stoges for about 15 years and consider myself experienced. I've smoked about everything from Cuban Cohibas and Montecristos to Partagas, Rocky Patel, and Ashtons (I have my collection of butts to prove it)...these cigars rate (to my taste buds) right up there with them. The construction is expertise, the flavor is superb, the price is absolutely a nice bonus. My only problem is...i wish I could find them in maduro. Do they manufacture them? Nonetheless, my next purchase will be 50 torpedoes to go in the humi with my Rocky Patel Vintage 99's. Thanks CI, your site is better than porn...uh...thanks anyways.
Finally- a well made, mild cigar, that doesn't taste like a paper bag! It doesn't hurt that these can be had for about a dollar per stick either! This is a cigar that I am not the least bit ashamed to hand out to all of my buddies on the golf course. Seasoned smokers and newbies alike all love this cigar, and it doesn't empty my wallet to spread the joy! The best value out there!
I've had a box of these aging in the cooler-dor, so I handed them out to the guys at the latest neigborhood bonfire. The guys were blown away that I was handing these out for free, they're so good. Thanks, CI!
These babies are AWSOME ! Not only a great smoke for the price but just plain a great smoke, price not withstanding. I've given several to friends and the all agree. A great cigar, the price is just frosting on the cigar cake !
This cigar is an outstanding buy. It has an easy draw and burns slow. I was shocked and amazed at the flavor for a mild cigar at this price. It been appoited to the position of my favorite every day cigar. Thanks CI.
Wife got me 50 of the churchills. They really aren't bad and i'm thinking they will get better with age.
I normally dont comment on anything but felt it was necessary in this case. I broke down and ordered the(Brocatus) 2fer of torpedos not really expecting much for $50. I recieved them today and put them all in the humidor and for the heck of it I kept one out and hauled it to work with me this afternoon. After dinner I went outside and lit it up.........absolutely amazing taste for a so called "mild" cigar! It held on to almost 2 full inches of ash! I hardly ever smoke a cigar that hasnt sat in the humi for a few weeks but this just blew me away. Im glad I brought it to work. Cant wait to taste em after a few months in the humi. Will definetly buy more!
Good smoke right out of the box (Brocatus), but Really good after about 2 months in the huimdor. the wrapper gets a oily look and the taste will somewhat compare to that of a vegas gold if not better in some cases, very tasty and mild. Something you don't come across everyday. So buy them and let them sit if you can!
When I first bought these cigars (Brocatus) I was a little skeptical about how good they were being such a cheap cigar, despite the reviews I read. After letting them sit in the humidor for about a week I decided to smoke one whilst having a cup of coffee on the back porch and boy was I surprised. The cigar had a very nice draw many small intricate flavors that initially caught me by surprise. I have only been smoking cigars for about two years but I have had my fair share of top of the line cigars and this one despite its cheap cost ranks high up on my list. It started out with a few uneven burns but once I got into the cigar it burned nicely and really came out in flavors. It is a great casual morning smoke and I highly recommend it to fans of light cigars. This cigar has secured its spot in my humidor!
When I first got these (Brocatus) I fired one up right away and was a little dissapointed....I put them all in my humidor for a couple of months and afterwards tried one and really enjoyed a whole a good cigar with a little humidor time.
nice mild smoke right out of the box, good construction and consistent burn.(Brocatus
I was a little concerned buying these only because the price was so damn good. I had been looking for a good cigar that I could enjoy anytime and that wouldn't break the bank if I wanted to hand 'em out on the golf course or when friends come over. So I bought a box and now I'm hooked! (Brocatus) Very mild but packed with lots of flavor; a delicious cigar. Good construction, even burn and an all around winner in my opinion. I always get great reviews from people I've given these too as well. The ash tends to fall off prematurely but I hardly call that a big problem. This is a great cigar that you won't regret buying. These will always be in my humidor!
Like just about everyone else, I wasn't expecting much from these but the price was just too right. Now these are my morning cigars. They are just great. (Brocatus) To be 100% honest I like these better than the more expensive milds that I have in my humi. Buy them and you will see what I mean. Just great!!
I am a fan of Dominican cigars, and Brocatus, regardless of the price is one of the best! The prelight aroma is mellow, the draw is excellant, the nutty, oakey, flavor is quite pleasant. It produces copious amounts of smoke, with a nice finish. I highly recommend this cigar. (Hurry, before they realize at CI that this is a great value, and raise the price!)
What a nice suprise.............. (Brocatus) the burn, the draw, the taste.........excellent...never mind the price. I love a cigar that doesn't tarnish my tongue. Compare equally for any 25/$120n cigar on the market....and I have tried many........Beware Romeo y Juliette kv
o.k. i ordered the special (Brocatus).two bundles for (can`t remember the price)but it was a deal(hey we aint all bill gates).after smoking them,this is a decent cigar for the money! i like big cigars,and this ones big(7x50).it has a good taste and burned even,and i swear to you,the ash hung on past the two inch mark! every time. if your looking for a decent smoke for a good price.this ones it brotha!
WOW! and that's an understatement. When I first read about these cigars (Brocatus) I thought what the heck, I'll give them a try. From the first draw to the last it was great. A well made cigar. I got them yesterday and I've had four so far and each one is a delight. This will be my cigar until C.I. comes up with a better one but that will take some doing. Well I'm goning out on the deck and enjoy another one.
What a tasty smoke (Brocatus), and the price makes it all the better! I usually don't care for smokes from the DR..just to mild for me, but this one's a winner!!
My wife bought me these cigars (Brocatus) and told me she paid about $1.00 a piece. I was expecting I would have to flush it instead of smoke it, I was wrong. It is mild, draws as easy as any Arturo brand and I know the price has to go up once the word gets out. My advice Buy NOW!!!
Got these (Brocatus) in today and had to give 'em a try right away. I got the Robusto's and immediatly was impressed with the silky smooth Connecticut Shade wrapper and the excellent construction. Taste-wise I was equally impressed. A mild cigar for sure but has plenty of flavor, great draw and an even burn. I've had 5 dollar cigars that weren't near this good. Buck a stick and all I can say is get 'em while ya can!
One of the best values when it comes to a cigar ever found (Brocatus). I have had 5 and 6 dollar cigars that haven't come close to how tasty these are.
This is Corona-Chris and I've gotta say that the guy's at CI finally did it, they've gotta smoke (Brocatus Churchill) that'll tickle your tastebuds senseless. No point in even describin' the taste o' these beauties, cause they're so DAMN good. If Churchills are your thing, as they are mine, do yourself a favor and the folks at CI too, buy a bundle, you'll not be disappointed, I PROMISE!
I didn’t expect to much when I ordered this cigar (Brocatus), i was just looking for a bargain. I must say the cigars look pretty. A deep brown colored smooth connecticut type wrapper with a nice classic cigarband. The cigars are pretty firm build, the draw is great. I bought the Robusto’s and i am very pleased with the experience, it's difficult for me to decribe cigar flavors but this is very ok, kind of toasty taste and very smooth, I think i found my all day smoke for less then a dollar a stick, thank you guys