Estd. 1844
| Strength: | Medium-Full |
| Wrapper: | San Andres |
| Origin: | Nicaragua |
| Shapes: | Double Perfecto, Perfecto, Salomon |
Estd 1844
Share: Email Tweet
A good year indeed.
You order a burger, but amazingly get served a big, juicy porterhouse....on the house. Dream the impossible dream friends, because Estd 1844 delivers in spades. A full-flavored, eye-catching new Nicaraguan handmade that's oh so tasty. Dressed in a dark, toothy San Andres Maduro wrapper and brimming with a healthy dose of robust Nicaraguan long-fillers, Estd 1844 unleashes a rich, complex profile that's layered with notes of espresso, earth, pepper, and cedar. But the fun don't stop there, every size option is some sort of figurado - perfectos, double torpedos, salomons, oh my! Put on the bib and feast boys, because Estd 1844 will satisfy your hunger. Oh, and every box, regardless of size, is just $49.95. Nutty.
Showing 1-30 of 30 Reviews
Customer Reviews of “Estd 1844” “Gave it a few days in the humi before I couldn't resist any longer. The 52 does not disappoint. The first third starts out on the mild side and picks up strength from there. Great notes of peper and expresso with a nice even burn. Really a medium to full bodied smoke that is a great buy at 2.50 a stick. Nothing bad to say about this one.”
CS of Burlingame, KS
“Newsflash, this is an A.J. Fernandez blended smoke (an unadvertised fact). It's a well balanced medium-bodied maduro in the $2.50-$3 range. Fans of Nica Libre, Diesel, Herencia Oscuro, and Vegas Triple A will surely like this one.”
AD of Rochester, NY
“AJ Fernandez has come up with a winner. I usually smoke Alec Bradley but decided to try 20 of the 1844. During golf the other day I lit up a 1844 on the first 9 then a Bradley on the last 9. The 1844 won the contest. Give them a try, you will be glad that you did. Time to get another 20.”
BU of Mocksville, NC
“For me personally, the 58's are the best bang for the buck on the market at this point in time. First review ever written.”
JW of Westmont, IL
“Is the 1844 the best cigar I have smoked in my life? No. Is the 1844 the best cigar I smoked this year? No. Did the 1844 surpass my expectations for a $2.5 hand made? Absolutely. The 1844 isn't a game changer but the flavor was nice and consistent adding spice and a bit of complexity with the cinnamon notes toward the end. If you are looking for a value priced Maduro packed to the gills with long fillers this is your cigar. I would smoke the 1844 again without question.”
LL of Round Rock, TX
“I see a lot of good reviews for the 1844, but....I get a mix of flavors, mostly good, but there's an after taste of hay. I tried one right off the truck, so I hope this gets better with a bit of time in the humidor. Draw, construction and ash are all great...”
DS of Casey, IL
“The 1844 is def a good smoke, hints of pepper throughout. Rates more of a medium-bodied cigar for me though. This cigar will have a place in my humi as long as they don't go on back order again.”
RG of Hudson Falls, NY
“Wow! I just got these in the other day and had to try one right off the truck. Like I said WOW! What a powerhouse. I got the #50, nice size, I can get about an hour out of it, great flavor. If you like a bold cigar, try these. You wont be disappointed. I don't know whether to stick with this size or go bigger??”
LG of Columbia City, IN
“Have smoked a ton of Est 1844 since release. Not the world's best looking wrappers, but who cares? The flavor profile is delicious. Medium to medium plus bodied. A ton of flavor and solid construction. Great draw and burn. Love the shapes too. Another great cigar from AJ Fernandez, geeze, I'm shocked, NOT!”
JW of Plainfield, IL
“I received 2 of these in the "Clown Car Corona Sampler" and smoked one right after receiving them. I was really surprised by the taste, sweetness and perfect burn; it was a nice stick. These looked to be specifically made for this sampler as they looked like a barbers pole. I would buy these again.”
TS of Corona, CA
“The burn was perfect,the draw just right,the strength in the upper medium range and the taste was spot on for me. Do us tight wads a favor and pass on these so A.J. won't raise the price. Thanks C.I.”
GR of Mobile, AL
“I tried a 5 pack based on other reviewers comments, and I found the reviews to be very accurate. This is a decent, flavorful smoke that I enjoyed to the nub. It's not a complex cigar ... it just does what it does well, and a great bargain. For those who enjoy upscale cigars at an affordable price point, this one does that very well.”
VB of Austin, TX
“Deff a bang for the buck !!! A very good tasting stick, that burned very well, awesome draw, very good taste !! AJ again hit it right on the spot !!”
BR of Williamstown, NJ
“Just received a 5 pk. of the No.50. While smoking I read some reviews on other sites. As of now I'd say they're right on point. Great flavor, and great burn. However I am getting the bitterness after the first 3rd. In the 1st third I got sweet earth notes. 2nd I'm getting the same with bitterness. While in the 2nd third I'm not sure if I would look forward to this bitterness. I will give it the Benefit, that I have not aged them. There's a real battle in the finish with the flavor & bitterness. With an inch left I'm gonna put it down. My tongue isnt enjoying the bitterness. Recommend? Yes. Buy a box? Dunno.”
CO of Monrovia, CA
“I smoked one of these with 2 weeks humi. time and am very impressed with the profile of this cigar. A fairly strong smoke with steady flavors from start to finish, ie; not complex but a good cigar nontheless. I expect better things to come with some aging of these unique cigars.”
PN of Lacey, WA
“AJ got this one dead on! This is a can't miss smoke, I will be stocking up on these and a true steal at the price.”
DP of East Orange, NJ
“The reason my 350 count humidor is always full with good cigars, is due to ordering samplers with cigars like this. Had I not have ordered the CI Sumer Vacation sampler, I would have never tried this fantastic cigar. In a respectful manner, I suggest you order the sampler mentioned due to the selection you receive. Through the years I have always read the information contained in the CI monthly catalogue, which has helped me decide on what to order. Had I just read what the description said concerning the 1844, I wouldn't have ever made a purchase. The reason; I'm among the few that really can't stand any type of black pepper taste hit my palate. It has nothing to do with the strength, since I've enjoyed the Punisher, AB Tempus, Diesel, Cohiba, San Cristobol, and many other full flavor cigars. For what ever reason the taste of black pepper destroys my palate. This 1844 is described with a black pepper taste, among others. However, when I fired this stick up with my lighter. Here was a cigar that was full in nature, but didn't go overboard with the black spice. As a result, I had the pleasure of enjoying a future box order of a better than average cigar. Again, this is why I would not be ashamed for any lover of the stick to open my humidor. Thanks to higher end samplers, I have cigars that would please most cigar smokers. The 1844 is a strong smooth flavor smoke, that satisfies every part of your smoking experience. Pull the trigger on this one, I highly doubt you will be disapointed.”
DM of Taylor, MI
“The reason my 350 count humidor is always full with good cigars, is due to ordering samplers with cigars like this. Had I not have ordered the CI Sumer Vacation sampler, I would have never tried this fantastic cigar. In a respectful manner, I suggest you order the sampler mentioned due to the selection you receive. Through the years I have always read the information contained in the CI monthly catalogue, which has helped me decide on what to order. Had I just read what the description said concerning the 1844, I wouldn't have ever made a purchase. The reason; I'm among the few that really can't stand any type of black pepper taste hit my palate. It has nothing to do with the strength, since I've enjoyed the Punisher, AB Tempus, Diesel, Cohiba, San Cristobol, and many other full flavor cigars. For what ever reason the taste of black pepper destroys my palate. This 1844 is described with a black pepper taste, among others. However, when I fired this stick up with my lighter. Here was a cigar that was full in nature, but didn't go overboard with the black spice. As a result, I had the pleasure of enjoying a future box order of a better than average cigar. Again, this is why I would not be ashamed for any lover of the stick to open my humidor. Thanks to higher end samplers, I have cigars that would please most cigar smokers. The 1844 is a strong smooth flavor smoke, that satisfies every part of your smoking experience. Pull the trigger on this one, I highly doubt you will be disappointed.”
DM of Taylor, MI
“Had to try this once I learned this is an AJ Fernandez cigar. I've had some of his others in samplers and though very good cigars, the price point on a lot of those is more than I want to spend on cigars. Then I learned of this 1844 and see I can afford them, so I snagged some and wow! Flavors somewhat similar to Man O' War, if not as full. I guess he could have called these "Man O' Skirmish" or "Man O' Fracas".”
JE of Universal City, TX
“All I can say about these is ... AWESOME! To be honest, I am mostly a smoker of milder cigars. I like to keep an open mind, and when I order singles I always try something out of my comfort zone. This baby is perfect!!! Not too intense to start, but a very heavy finish which was not TOO heavy and intense. Smoked perfectly, beautiful ash and burn all the way down to the nub. Nearly burnt my fingers because I didn't want it to end. This is going on my list of must-have-on-hand cigars, for sure. Try these bad boys- you will NOT be disappointed.”
EM of Holyoke, MA
“Had one ROTT and loved it. This is my flavor profile. I've got to work more overtime so I can buy several boxes of these. That's the only way I'll be able to smoke some and age some. May be my new go-to cigar. Yum.”
OE of Loudon, TN
“Established 1844 is a medium to full flavored gem! IF you like maduro cigars I highly suggest this stick. Had mine in the humi for about 2 months before trying and the flavor was great! Great tastes of espresso and a touch of pepper throughout the smoke. Needless to say, I smoked it to the nub and nearly burned my fingers off. IF you like Maduro cigars, this is a must try!”
RR of Pasco, WA
“Recieved a box today and had to try one right away, Damn good stick will be filling my humidor with these from now on.”
SS of Bernville, PA
“I'll keep it simple. Very happy I purchased the 1844's. Great smoke for the price. Will definitely buy again.”
JF of West Milford, NJ
“Just finished my first 1844 from the Monster Maduro sampler pack, Very nice Cigar, Smooth, burned even entire way to the nub. Very peppery in the first inch but then smooth sailing the rest of the way. Will purchase more when I get room in Humi lol.”
RP of Oswego, NY
“Great cigar, too bad they are on backorder.”
ZT of Peridot, AZ
“Got the #50 figurado in an A.J. Fernandez sampler. Tried it today and was totally impressed! Best cigar of the last two weeks, and I smoked a few highfulutin ones. Not a "powerful" cigar, but the flavors were plenty full enough to enjoy thoroughly. Burned absolutely even, and I mean ABSOLUTELY even! The perfecto shape is a cinch to light and fun to smoke, the draw was perfect, the smoke was voluminous, and there were zero distractions such as caps coming loose or burn touch ups. That's about as First Class as you can ask for. This cigar is excellent.”
SC of LAKE FOREST PARK, WA
“As I cut this cigar, the first event is the wrapper splitting, how wonderful. I go ahead and tear off the piece and mend the rest at the head of the cigar; no big deal there. I toast this little baddy and wait on the tightness of the draw to give as the cigar narrows at the foot. Cosmetic gimmicks, got to love them. The taste of this cigar is earthy and slightly woody at the first third. Hints of spice and a grassy flavor hit the back of the palette at the end of the finish (which is medium in duration). This cigar does have a little bit of strength to it already, which is quite surprising. May I note, the burn line on this cigar is perfect. A nice white ash with slow, light smoke rising from the foot. There is a lingering espresso sweetness on the lips after each draw. The retro-hale is a smooth and creamy peppery feeling, like a dessert with a little heat to it.”
NM of MAYVIEW, MO
“Fantastic smoke. I'm reordering more. That's rare for me. I normally like to try something different. ”
AC of harrisville, RI
“Draw is a little tight loosens up about a third to midway. For what you pay for not a bad smoke but can't come close to the rest of AJ's line. Not the best but not the worst. Good beginner stick. Give them ample box time and you won't be disappointed.”
HB of EDGEWOOD, MD
Posted by Brock
Estd. 1844 Anejado No. 50
During the year of 1844, several historical events had occurred: The Dominican Republic had declared their independence from Haiti and drafted their first constitution, the US ship USS Princeton exploded on the Potomac River killing numerous passengers, including two U.S. cabinet members, and Mr. Samuel Morse sent the very first electrical telegram from Washington D.C. to Baltimore. Before I continue, you’re very welcome for the invigorating history lesson.
Estd.1844 is offered in SIX (6) different sizes that all fall under the ‘figurado’ category. The vitola of my preference is the Anejado No. 50, a pocket-sized firecracker that appears similar dimensionally to the Arturo Fuente Hemingway ‘Short Story’.
This Nicaraguan-made beauty is presented in wooden boxes with a rough patch of fabric stitched to the outside of the lid proudly displaying “1844”. Box quantities vary depending on the cigar’s size, however, the size I am reviewing today, the No. 50, features a standard box quantity of 20 sticks. Furthermore, the band is traditionally located toward the cap of the cigar which boasts its name, 1844.
This handmade gem features a dark, oily San Andres (Maduro) wrapper. I’ve noticed at the CI Super-Store that Mexican tobacco has received somewhat of a bad reputation. I’m mystified as to why this is. The San Andres Maduro wrapper, which is very susceptible to plume (a crystallization of the cigars’ natural sugars and representation of impeccable aging) typically features a slight pepperiness with an underlying sweetness and a pleasant coffee or cocoa note. It’s also the same wrapper that is used on two of our most popular selling brands in the CI Super-Store, the Reposado Maduro and San Lotano Maduro.
The flavorful wrapper encompasses a fine blend of skillfully aged Nicaraguan tobaccos hailing from the Esteli growing region. The Esteli region essentially symbolizes the tobacco capital of Nicaragua, even though there are over 5 distinct growing regions within the country’s mountainous landscape.
Pre-lit, the cigar is fairly light in the hand but the tobaccos in this flawless figurado are packed nice and tight.
I fired up one of these oily treasures on New Year’s Eve in the heated garage at my brother’s house (we’ll do it again next year, Brandon). For some reason, we obtained a bottle of Black Velvet Canadian Whiskey, some of the cheapest crap on the market. With my watered down Black Velvet, tasty 1844 and lawn chair, I am ready to go.
Similar to most figurados and salomons, the first couple puffs started off a bit tight as there is very little surface on the foot of the cigar to burn. But as the cigar burned to the bulbous portion of the “1844 No. 50”, flavors opened up immensely and a heavy natural espresso overtook my palate.
As for the combination of cheap Canadian Whiskey and a Mexican maduro cigar…I must admit it wasn’t my finest pairing. However, the whiskey kept me warm and the gambling stories my brother and I constantly share with each other were in abundance.
The draw was almost perfect as billows upon billows of smoke poured from this flavorful morsel. The middle third of the 1844 produced a toasty flavor with a slight cedar undertone. The aroma of this pint-sized puro was quite pleasant and produced an attractive, white ash that hung ever-so-firmly off the end of the cigar. The finish was clean but hot due to the cigar’s size.
But overall, for the price, this is a fantastic value and I highly recommend it.
As I finished my 1844, I was in an incredibly good state of mind. As a matter of fact, I nearly forgot I was in a garage until I tripped over my nephew’s Burton snowboard onto a pile of my nieces’ Hello Kitty stuffed animals and blankies (yes, I said blankies).
I must say, if you’re a fan of the Reposado Maduro, Nica Libre, San Lotano Maduro or A. Turrent Triple Play, this is going to provide you with a coffee-break sized cigar which should take you no more than 25 minutes to burn. Also, as the weather gets a tad-bit nippy, this is one of the better smokes for Winter Time.
Expert Philosophical Thought for The Day: “Why do you drive in a parkway and park in a driveway?”
Loading....