Stinky Car Ashtray

Love it except it could have been bigger.

This is a nice ashtray for mobile use, but it has one fatal flaw when using it as a portable ashtray. The lid is way too heavy so the minute you open it, the whole things falls over unless it is placed securely into a cup holder. I have others from Xicar, etc. that can be used for travel in a car and also on a table. For this one I would suggest the include an optional counterweight for table use. I personally stuck three magnets (2 inside and one outside) and it stays firmly upright in the steel table where we are currently. Still not able to use it on a non-steel table. Functionality: Holds cigars well if you push them securely into the binder clips. Takes ash well and is plenty deep for butts, bands, etc. The lid is quite heavy so make sure your sup holder fits it tightly and not just loosely.

Ok

Got three of them now One in each car and on in the back yard

This was a replacement for my out-of-production Xicar Ash Can and overall it does its job as advertised. Two minor complaints: 1) With the top open, it will fall over unless supported in the cup holder and 2) unlike my beloved Ash Can, it does not have a false bottom for the ashes or a nice wire loop and cone to help form the end of the lit stick. It is just a plain cup. Pluses are the top closes easily and securely, the cigar holder actually works very nicely at not damaging the leaf, and it is very shiny