Click the icons below for product information.

My Father The Judge

No Judge-ments

What do you do when you’ve won the prestigious Cigar of the Year award on two different occasions (first in 2013 and then again in 2015)? Well, presumably, whatever the Hell you want! Luckily, in the case of My Father, that answer is to continue to produce amazing cigars. My Father The Judge is the newest offering from the Garcia family, and utilizes larger ring gauges to deliver chewy, dense cigars like only My Father can produce.

Handmade in Nicaragua, My Father The Judge utilizes an absolutely flawless Ecuadorian Sumatra wrapper over hand-picked Nicaraguan binder and long-fillers. The box-press guarantees that these high-octane tobaccos will be meticulously slow-burning, and deliciously rewarding. Cedar, nuts, leather, and a warm, bold core of earthiness mean The Judge is a cigar guaranteed to satisfy any enthusiast.

​Great news, My Father the Judge has received an impressive 93-point rating and was named the #7 Cigar of 2017! Here's what the reviewers had to say: "Pressed and blocky, this big robusto is topped with a three-seam cap. Notes of chocolate and gingersnap play off each other with hints of red pepper and almonds."

Pack In Stock MSRP Price Qty Cart
560 (Gordo) (5.0"x60)
Box of 23 Backordered $285.20
save $29.2110% off
560 (Gordo) (5.0"x60)
Pack of 5 Backordered $58.50
652 (6.0"x52)
Box of 23 Only 5 Left $269.10
save $26.1110% off
652 (6.0"x52)
Pack of 5 Backordered $55.50
Overall Rating 4.67 out of 5 Based on 9 Ratings

Customer Reviews of “My Father The Judge”

Write A Review
5 out of 5
5 Star
4 out of 5
4 Star
3 out of 5
3 Star
2 out of 5
2 Star
1 out of 5
1 Star
Showing 1-9 of 9 Reviews
5 out of 5
Great Cigar great service
My Favorite.. great smoke. Great service
4 out of 5
Just A Cigar
Nice cigar, we'll constructed, and good draw. But, pretty boring. No, notes of anything really. It's just a cigar.
5 out of 5
Awesom cigar! I just wish
Awesom cigar! I just wish they would be on sale a little more often
5 out of 5
A Great Smoke!
A lot of cigars of this ring gauge are somewhat difficult to smoke. This one lights easily, burns cool to the end, and draws like a dream. It’s never overpowering and I’ve found it to be a good smoke for any time of the day. I usually go for Toros, and I do like that size in The Judge Line. This cigar is a good change, and one that I would keep in the humidor all the time.
5 out of 5
Another Homerun For My Father
Amazingly great cigar. Lots of flavor. As others have said. It does pack a nicotine punch. So just don't go for The Judge on an empty stomach. A fine smoke.
3 out of 5
Not a great intro but will try again before final judgement
Struggled to burn even for the first third. Was expecting more nuanced flavors but just burned hot and packed a significant nicotine punch. Acclimated in my humidor for 3.5 weeks at 68%-70% RH. I will give it another try next. Not and reasses.
5 out of 5
One of the best cigars out there!! Definitely 5 stars!!
Best cigar I've had so far!! One of my friends let me try this one out of his humidor and just by the looks of it I knew it was going to be a good smoke,I'm looking forward to buying myself a box soon,I would highly recommend this to anybody who likes quality cigars.
5 out of 5
The Judge
A Great Cigar !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
5 out of 5
I will be ordering a box soon!
I did not buy this cigar from here as CI did not yet have it. This is an amazing cigar. Very sweet and woody. If I had to explain what it tasted like, it tastes like a chocolate covered raisin, wrapped in leather, sprinkled with cedar shavings and pepper. I really enjoyed this cigar, very well constructed, perfect draw, all what I've come to expect from My Father. You will not be disappointed. Also, this cigar does pack a decent punch, I took my time and still got a bit of a buzz! -RC