Top
Click the icons below for product information.

Montecristo 1935 Anniversary Nicaragua

#2 Cigar of 2021

Description

Celebrating 85 years!

The Montecristo brand is celebrating 85 years of success in creating amazing blends. Montecristo has a portfolio filled with cigars that span the entire strength profile gamut. Tried and true favorites like Montecristo White Label and Montecristo Epic, and many of their other lines, have risen up and received well-deserved 90+ ratings. 

To celebrate their success and the milestone, Altadis brand ambassador Rafael Nodal once again reached out to cigar master blender AJ Fernandez for help in creating a tribute to the original blend of the first Montecristo cigar. In true AJ fashion, he swung hard and they knocked it out of the park once again with the Montecristo 1935 Anniversary Nicaragua. Using premium tobaccos from AJ's farms and rolled at the esteemed San Lotano factory, this Nicaraguan puro is a medium to full-bodied experience that will ensnare your palate with notes of wood, coffee, cinnamon, earth, spice, and naturally sweet tobacco from start to finish. The amazing blend coupled with the high standards for construction the company has makes this cigar one to not miss out on. Put on your party hat, grab your favorite beverage, grab a box (or two), and join in this monumental celebration! 

Great news! Montecristo 1935 Anniversary Nicaragua has received a well-deserved 95-point rating and the #2 Cigar of 2021 spot, noting: "...a spicy, earthy backbone refined by notes of leather, coconut and malted milk."

Click the icons below for product information.
Size
Pack
In Stock
MSRPMSRP stands for "manufacturer's suggested retail price," which is the price recommended by the manufacturer or exclusive distributor for retail sale. This suggested retail price, also referred to as the "list price," serves as a guideline for pricing the product.
Price
Qty
Cart
Profile
Shape
Robusto
Wrapper
Nicaraguan
Origin
Nicaragua
Flavored
False
Pressed
True
Has Tip
False
Binder
Nicaraguan
Filler
Nicaraguan
Sweet
False
Robusto (5.0"x54)
New
Box of 10
In Stock
$169.50
| save $16.51 10% off
$152.99
Profile
Shape
Robusto
Wrapper
Nicaraguan
Origin
Nicaragua
Flavored
False
Pressed
True
Has Tip
False
Binder
Nicaraguan
Filler
Nicaraguan
Sweet
False
Profile
Shape
Robusto
Wrapper
Nicaraguan
Origin
Nicaragua
Flavored
False
Pressed
True
Has Tip
False
Binder
Nicaraguan
Filler
Nicaraguan
Sweet
False
Robusto (5.0"x54)
New
Pack of 5
Backordered
$84.75
| save $2.76
$81.99
Profile
Shape
Robusto
Wrapper
Nicaraguan
Origin
Nicaragua
Flavored
False
Pressed
True
Has Tip
False
Binder
Nicaraguan
Filler
Nicaraguan
Sweet
False
Profile
Shape
Robusto Extra
Wrapper
Nicaraguan
Origin
Nicaragua
Flavored
False
Pressed
True
Has Tip
False
Binder
Nicaraguan
Filler
Nicaraguan
Sweet
False
Espeso (Robusto Extra) (5.5"x60)
Box of 10
In Stock
$180.00
| save $17.01 9% off
$162.99
Profile
Shape
Robusto Extra
Wrapper
Nicaraguan
Origin
Nicaragua
Flavored
False
Pressed
True
Has Tip
False
Binder
Nicaraguan
Filler
Nicaraguan
Sweet
False
Profile
Shape
Robusto Extra
Wrapper
Nicaraguan
Origin
Nicaragua
Flavored
False
Pressed
True
Has Tip
False
Binder
Nicaraguan
Filler
Nicaraguan
Sweet
False
Espeso (Robusto Extra) (5.5"x60)
Pack of 5
In Stock
$90.00
| save $4.01
$85.99
Profile
Shape
Robusto Extra
Wrapper
Nicaraguan
Origin
Nicaragua
Flavored
False
Pressed
True
Has Tip
False
Binder
Nicaraguan
Filler
Nicaraguan
Sweet
False
Profile
Shape
Toro
Wrapper
Nicaraguan
Origin
Nicaragua
Flavored
False
Pressed
True
Has Tip
False
Binder
Nicaraguan
Filler
Nicaraguan
Sweet
False
Toro (6.0"x54)
Box of 10
In Stock
$186.40
| save $18.41 10% off
$167.99
Profile
Shape
Toro
Wrapper
Nicaraguan
Origin
Nicaragua
Flavored
False
Pressed
True
Has Tip
False
Binder
Nicaraguan
Filler
Nicaraguan
Sweet
False
Profile
Shape
Toro
Wrapper
Nicaraguan
Origin
Nicaragua
Flavored
False
Pressed
True
Has Tip
False
Binder
Nicaraguan
Filler
Nicaraguan
Sweet
False
Toro (6.0"x54)
Pack of 5
In Stock
$93.20
| save $4.21
$88.99
Profile
Shape
Toro
Wrapper
Nicaraguan
Origin
Nicaragua
Flavored
False
Pressed
True
Has Tip
False
Binder
Nicaraguan
Filler
Nicaraguan
Sweet
False
Profile
Shape
Torpedo
Wrapper
Nicaraguan
Origin
Nicaragua
Flavored
False
Pressed
True
Has Tip
False
Binder
Nicaraguan
Filler
Nicaraguan
Sweet
False
No. 2 (Torpedo) (6.1"x52)
Box of 10
In Stock
$195.60
| save $18.61 10% off
$176.99
Profile
Shape
Torpedo
Wrapper
Nicaraguan
Origin
Nicaragua
Flavored
False
Pressed
True
Has Tip
False
Binder
Nicaraguan
Filler
Nicaraguan
Sweet
False
Profile
Shape
Torpedo
Wrapper
Nicaraguan
Origin
Nicaragua
Flavored
False
Pressed
True
Has Tip
False
Binder
Nicaraguan
Filler
Nicaraguan
Sweet
False
No. 2 (Torpedo) (6.1"x52)
Pack of 5
In Stock
$97.80
| save $4.81
$92.99
Profile
Shape
Torpedo
Wrapper
Nicaraguan
Origin
Nicaragua
Flavored
False
Pressed
True
Has Tip
False
Binder
Nicaraguan
Filler
Nicaraguan
Sweet
False
Profile
Shape
Churchill
Wrapper
Nicaraguan
Origin
Nicaragua
Flavored
False
Pressed
True
Has Tip
False
Binder
Nicaraguan
Filler
Nicaraguan
Sweet
False
Churchill (7.0"x52)
Box of 10
In Stock
$204.50
| save $19.51 10% off
$184.99
Profile
Shape
Churchill
Wrapper
Nicaraguan
Origin
Nicaragua
Flavored
False
Pressed
True
Has Tip
False
Binder
Nicaraguan
Filler
Nicaraguan
Sweet
False
Profile
Shape
Churchill
Wrapper
Nicaraguan
Origin
Nicaragua
Flavored
False
Pressed
True
Has Tip
False
Binder
Nicaraguan
Filler
Nicaraguan
Sweet
False
Churchill (7.0"x52)
Pack of 5
Only 2 Left
$102.25
| save $4.26
$97.99
Profile
Shape
Churchill
Wrapper
Nicaraguan
Origin
Nicaragua
Flavored
False
Pressed
True
Has Tip
False
Binder
Nicaraguan
Filler
Nicaraguan
Sweet
False
Profile
Shape
Corona Gorda
Wrapper
Nicaraguan
Origin
Nicaragua
Flavored
False
Pressed
True
Has Tip
False
Binder
Nicaraguan
Filler
Nicaraguan
Sweet
False
Demi (Corona Gorda) (5.5"x46)
Box of 20
In Stock
$279.80
| save $27.81 10% off
$251.99
Profile
Shape
Corona Gorda
Wrapper
Nicaraguan
Origin
Nicaragua
Flavored
False
Pressed
True
Has Tip
False
Binder
Nicaraguan
Filler
Nicaraguan
Sweet
False
Profile
Shape
Corona Gorda
Wrapper
Nicaraguan
Origin
Nicaragua
Flavored
False
Pressed
True
Has Tip
False
Binder
Nicaraguan
Filler
Nicaraguan
Sweet
False
Demi (Corona Gorda) (5.5"x46)
Pack of 5
In Stock
$69.95
| save $2.96
$66.99
Profile
Shape
Corona Gorda
Wrapper
Nicaraguan
Origin
Nicaragua
Flavored
False
Pressed
True
Has Tip
False
Binder
Nicaraguan
Filler
Nicaraguan
Sweet
False
overall rating 4.9 out of 5 True { } True { } True { } Based on 50 Ratings
Customer Reviews of "Montecristo 1935 Anniversary Nicaragua"
5 out of 5
5 Star
46
4 out of 5
4 Star
3
3 out of 5
3 Star
1
2 out of 5
2 Star
0
1 out of 5
1 Star
0
Showing 1-50 of50 Reviews
5 out of 5
Very nice smoke, smooth long burn, very satisfying.
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
One of the best tasting cigars out there love montcrisco
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
Very nice!
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
I love this cigar! Great size, taste, smell, smoke is just right, and a fantastic burn time! Love it!
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
Excellent
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
I have had a couple of the 5.5” X 60 and just ordered more of these awesome cigars. They are well made and deliver great flavors. I would recommend these to everyone who like a medium full to full cigar!
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
Great cigar and good smoke.
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
What a cigar! It never disappoints and is reserved for those moments of celebration and relaxation. From the first puff and rush of spice and earth with cinnamon flood the senses and palate. The smoke is silky smooth with copious amounts of it. I smoked this on my eleven year anniversary and followed up with purchasing a box. Truly a masterpiece.
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
I definitely had some concerns about ordering online but I can assure you that as long as you get the 1 to 5 day shipping or sooner you will be satisfied with whatever you order, all my cigars arrived in amazing condition and have smoked perfectly, now as for this cigar in particular, I'd recommend it to veterans and new comers alike, it's a great cigar to have an amazing experience without breaking the bank, and I will be making many more purchases in the future
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes1
No0
5 out of 5
thank you for making it easy to enjoy my favorite cigar. 1935 is perfect for me.
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes1
No0
5 out of 5
Good smoke with rich flavor. Needs time in the humidor to meld the flavors together. Great construction.
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
A gift! Very happy.
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
My new go to cigar!!
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
VERY GOOD SHORT SMOKE FOR LIMITED TIME. PRICED RIGHT AND AS GOOD AS SOME OF THE SMOKES I HAVE PAID DOUBLE. HOPE THEY KEEP MAKING THEM.
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
This is the perfect size cigar for me. It provides a good steady draw, medium strength and slight nutty taste. My favorite to go with sipping Blantons while sitting by the fire pit enjoying a sunset!
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
Great smoke
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
Really nice smooth to smoke
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
4 out of 5
About as expected, smoked slowly. Wraps were a bit off, but burned okay still.
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
If you like full bodied black pepper sticks, this is your gem. Probably one of the best cigars on the market today. Everything about this smoke is worthy of the price point.
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
One of the best cigars I’ve had. Get this and you won’t regret it!
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
Exceptional stick!
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
Smooth burn to the end. Great taste. This cigar is a winner.
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
They cigars was great! It is definitely a full cigar and will knock you on your butt.
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
A tasty cigar! Full-bodied flavor without being too heavy
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
Burns even, smooth draw. Used them for my golf group and all rated them high. I’ll be getting more.
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
Received and placed in humidor............a day later had to try one, so fired it up. Smooth, good even burn, great draw, good flavor and the effervescences was awesome. Such a excellent stick! I see why the CoTY award, well warranted.
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
I think this is a great cigar, although, I have the palate of a Billy goat.
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
Nice!
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
I was new to the game on this one as I usually smoke my normal go-to. It, quite simply, may be my new favorite. Flavors are amazing from dark coffee to a subtle sweetness of cinnamon and a dark chocolate. Amazing stick! Thanks to the guys at the San Antonio superstore for the suggestion. Grab a box you won’t be disappointed!
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
I tried the number #1 cigar and I didn't think it was all that. This is an exceptionally good cigar (#2 in 2021) and I think it's better that the #1. Try it for yourself.
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
I think this is my favorite cigar. Great flavor. Burns well; maybe on the quick side. But just a noticeably enjoyable cigar. Most cigars talk about all of these flavors and for many you can't notice if it's cinnamon or shoelace. This cigar has a nice, rich flavor.
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
Excellent smoke
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
The Montecristo 1935 Anniversary Nicaraguan has received Cigar Aficianado’s highest cigar rating of the last year, and came in as #2 cigar of the year 2021. The reviewers weren’t exaggerating. This is one very, very fine cigar. It had notes of cocoa and leather, and burned evenly throughout. I keep a cigar journal of some of my favorites and this cigar easily made it in. Do yourself a big favor and try a box - you won’t regret it!
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
Absolutely love these cigars
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
Dark spice and coffee bean notes with a great draw an even burn. Medium-full bodied. Goes great with a mojito.
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
Like smoking chocolate
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
They are relaxing to smoke and very smooth. The draw is easy. I enjoy these cigars so much!
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
Now I see why it was rated #2, I normally don’t like a strong Cigar but this one was A very pleasant surprise. I would highly recommend this MonteCristo. As a matter of fact I will be ordering another box
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
A friend of mine, picked one up for me and said that I had to try it. This cigar woke my taste buds up from the first to the last third. As long as the Montecristo is in stock at CI, My humidor will have them on a shelf.
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
Montecristo is a name you can trust.
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
Outstanding smoke. Easy draw and thick, THICK smoke. More complex than I assumed. Several changes throughout, and it stayed cool to the nub. Razor sharp burn and some tooth to the wrapper. I've smoked 3 out of the 5 pack and I will def be ordering a box. Held up perfectly against my Jameson Black Barrel.
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
Perfect burn, smooth drawer, enjoyable from first light to the finish.
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
4 out of 5
Very good but could’ve been better if they kept the blend for the first 2 inches the same throughout the cigar…if you’re a Montecristo fan this is a pretty damn good cigar
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
4 out of 5
A Good smoke, but not a GREAT smoke... Definitely not worthy of being the CA's #2 cigar of 2021.
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
I agree that this is the best non-Cuban Montecristo I’ve smoked. And this is with very little humi time. Can’t wait to see what they’re gonna be like after some additional TLC.
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
Great cigars and good service
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
3 out of 5
Burns evenly, but has a bitter taste. Definitely not worthy of the #2 spot on the Cigar Aficionado Top 25 list. No where near my personal Top 5 list: 1. Ave Maria Reconquista 2. Plasencia Alma Fuerte Salamon 3. Padron 80yr 4. Andalusian Bull 5. Undercrown 10 Everyone’s pallet is different though, enjoy whatever it is you smoke…
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
I’m glad I tried these on the advice of someone who loves them. Super flavorful and complex, yet very smooth. Pricey, but top quality.
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
The best
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
I don't know about anyone else but my cigar tastes wax and wane. Right now, this one hits the mark with plenty of taste, not too strong, but a lot of flavor." I have enjoyed everyone of them in the box and I cant always say that." Joel
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
Hide Reviews