Click the icons below for product information.

1876 Reserve

Description

Even gramps would be proud.

On a trip to factories in the Dominican Republic some time ago, I was offered a boatload of a really nice, smooth handmade called 1876 Reserve. I’m guessing the manufacturer either drank too much Dominican rum or his abacus was busted. Don’t get me wrong, I certainly ain’t complaining because I think under normal circumstances it would’ve cost me twice as much to buy what I bought (I better remove his name from the mailing list so he doesn’t see this later).

What I do know is that this is an incredibly mellow Dominican cigar that’s well worth our ridiculous 2-fer price. In fact, the buy-in here starts under two bucks apiece! Is that too cheap? Maybe it’s me that’s getting soft in the head. Oh well, if you like easy going cigars, you’ll love this deal.

Click the icons below for product information.
Size
Pack
In Stock
MSRPMSRP stands for "manufacturer's suggested retail price," which is the price recommended by the manufacturer or exclusive distributor for retail sale. This suggested retail price, also referred to as the "list price," serves as a guideline for pricing the product.
Price
Qty
Cart
Profile
Shape
Churchill
Wrapper
Connecticut
Origin
Dominican Republic
Flavored
False
Pressed
False
Has Tip
False
Binder
Sumatra
Filler
Dominican
Sweet
False
Churchill (7.2"x50)
Sale
Pack of 25
In Stock
$104.50
| save $59.51 57% off
$44.99
Profile
Shape
Churchill
Wrapper
Connecticut
Origin
Dominican Republic
Flavored
False
Pressed
False
Has Tip
False
Binder
Sumatra
Filler
Dominican
Sweet
False
Profile
Shape
Robusto
Wrapper
Connecticut
Origin
Dominican Republic
Flavored
False
Pressed
False
Has Tip
False
Binder
Sumatra
Filler
Dominican
Sweet
False
Robusto (5.0"x50)
Pack of 25
In Stock
$89.00
| save $44.01 49% off
$44.99
Profile
Shape
Robusto
Wrapper
Connecticut
Origin
Dominican Republic
Flavored
False
Pressed
False
Has Tip
False
Binder
Sumatra
Filler
Dominican
Sweet
False
Profile
Shape
Toro
Wrapper
Connecticut
Origin
Dominican Republic
Flavored
False
Pressed
False
Has Tip
False
Binder
Sumatra
Filler
Dominican
Sweet
False
Toro (6.0"x50)
Pack of 25
In Stock
$94.50
| save $44.51 47% off
$49.99
Profile
Shape
Toro
Wrapper
Connecticut
Origin
Dominican Republic
Flavored
False
Pressed
False
Has Tip
False
Binder
Sumatra
Filler
Dominican
Sweet
False
Profile
Shape
Torpedo
Wrapper
Connecticut
Origin
Dominican Republic
Flavored
False
Pressed
False
Has Tip
False
Binder
Sumatra
Filler
Dominican
Sweet
False
Torpedo (6.5"x52)
Pack of 25
In Stock
$104.50
| save $49.51 47% off
$54.99
Profile
Shape
Torpedo
Wrapper
Connecticut
Origin
Dominican Republic
Flavored
False
Pressed
False
Has Tip
False
Binder
Sumatra
Filler
Dominican
Sweet
False
Profile
Shape
Robusto
Wrapper
Connecticut
Origin
Dominican Republic
Flavored
False
Pressed
False
Has Tip
False
Binder
Sumatra
Filler
Dominican
Sweet
False
Robusto 2-fer (5.0"x50)
Pack of 50
In Stock
$178.00
| save $98.01 55% off
$79.99
Profile
Shape
Robusto
Wrapper
Connecticut
Origin
Dominican Republic
Flavored
False
Pressed
False
Has Tip
False
Binder
Sumatra
Filler
Dominican
Sweet
False
Profile
Shape
Toro
Wrapper
Connecticut
Origin
Dominican Republic
Flavored
False
Pressed
False
Has Tip
False
Binder
Sumatra
Filler
Dominican
Sweet
False
Toro 2-fer (6.0"x50)
Pack of 50
In Stock
$189.00
| save $104.01 55% off
$84.99
Profile
Shape
Toro
Wrapper
Connecticut
Origin
Dominican Republic
Flavored
False
Pressed
False
Has Tip
False
Binder
Sumatra
Filler
Dominican
Sweet
False
Profile
Shape
Churchill
Wrapper
Connecticut
Origin
Dominican Republic
Flavored
False
Pressed
False
Has Tip
False
Binder
Sumatra
Filler
Dominican
Sweet
False
Churchill 2-fer (7.2"x50)
Pack of 50
In Stock
$209.00
| save $115.01 55% off
$93.99
Profile
Shape
Churchill
Wrapper
Connecticut
Origin
Dominican Republic
Flavored
False
Pressed
False
Has Tip
False
Binder
Sumatra
Filler
Dominican
Sweet
False
Profile
Shape
Torpedo
Wrapper
Connecticut
Origin
Dominican Republic
Flavored
False
Pressed
False
Has Tip
False
Binder
Sumatra
Filler
Dominican
Sweet
False
Torpedo 2-fer (6.5"x52)
Pack of 50
In Stock
$209.00
| save $115.01 55% off
$93.99
Profile
Shape
Torpedo
Wrapper
Connecticut
Origin
Dominican Republic
Flavored
False
Pressed
False
Has Tip
False
Binder
Sumatra
Filler
Dominican
Sweet
False
overall rating 4.3 out of 5 True { } True { } True { } Based on 1123 Ratings
Customer Reviews of "1876 Reserve"
5 out of 5
5 Star
557
4 out of 5
4 Star
392
3 out of 5
3 Star
138
2 out of 5
2 Star
22
1 out of 5
1 Star
14
Showing 1-50 of1216 Reviews
4 out of 5
Mild and smooth down to the nub. Easy smoking and easy draw.
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
3 out of 5
Good cigar at this price point.
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
Have been looking for this for a long time. Mild but flavorful. Smooth draw, good burn. Very enjoyable. A good cigar at any price.
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
Good draw, mild and Consistently good smoke
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
4 out of 5
Smells good, burn good love it
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
4 out of 5
Although it's no ONYX, it's a really nice everyday cigar. I puff 2 or 3 pretty much every day. I've probably burned well over 300 of them since they've been available at CI.
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
4 out of 5
Nice Cigar
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
Great value!!
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
Nice smooth smoke.
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
Mild, good burn to the end. A wise choice I made having never smoked that brand. Offer more deals on this
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
low cost. a little harsh at the end.
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
Being new to the cigar world, I wanted something friendly to my wallet, friendly to my tongue, friendly to my taste, friendly to draw, and friendly to manner. I have tried a few different brands, wrappers, fillers, and dollar range cigars and keep coming back to 1886 Reserve. Eventually, I may find something I prefer over the 1886 but I haven't found anything to date, I'm not the type who can detect the fine hints of the different aromas, nor taste the faint glimpses of nuts, bark or dirt, I just prefer a smooth smoke that doesn't burn my tongue or wallet.
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
I have enjoyed these cigars for years. The Dominicans are mild and smooth.
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
Quality, draw, and size are all just right - And I like a cigar that doesn't knock me out. I like to enjoy a cigar, or 2-3, and get on with my day, OR - I like that one good cigar before "Lights out!" I don't need to feel nauseous with a cigar that's just too strong. Now, if you can only come down in price a bit for Retired American Veterans that didn't grow up fighting Wars on Wall Street! 😎
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes1
No0
5 out of 5
Good for an everyday smoke
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes1
No0
3 out of 5
Ok
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
It's good
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes1
No0
5 out of 5
Great taste and burn!
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes1
No0
5 out of 5
A favorite cigar. Good all around
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes1
No0
5 out of 5
Great every day cigar, ash holds and smooth burn. Tight roll quality! My go to for a light and smooth! Great cigar for the price!
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes1
No0
5 out of 5
My go to smoke everyday
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
Great cigar
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
Great cigar for the money
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes1
No0
4 out of 5
Smooth draw and a great price.
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes1
No0
4 out of 5
These are my daily go to. Burn great and draw good. For a second hand long filler you can’t go wrong. Occasionally get a tight one but the price is right.
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
Great smoke
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
3 out of 5
draw very good. burn-sometimes uneven. flavor-average,kind of dry
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
3 out of 5
there allright. i would prefer a little tighter roll so they would last a little longer .
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
4 out of 5
A very nice smoke for the price.
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
4 out of 5
Pretty good cigar
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
A very good Cigar. Nice earthy tone. Nice even burn.
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
Mellow, smooth smoke!
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
3 out of 5
They were a good inexpensive cigar. not great but good.
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
Smooth and light!
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
Just. Wow. These were absolutely wonderful. They have a beautiful flavor that's a little better than I expected and slightly more pronounced. They have a perfectly even burn and the draw is spot on. I'm reordering these as a staple in my humidor. Highly recommended.
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
4 out of 5
Great putz around the garage cigar. Decent to good flavor, mild to mid strength. Burned well mostly even. Ash frequently. Will never win the long ash competition. Especially riding a zero turn mower. I've got more on order rite now.
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
Great product, very smooth and nice smell!
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
3 out of 5
the ones without a tunnel smoke very well, great flavor, tunnelling on about 25% was not enjoyable.
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
4 out of 5
A terrific cigar for everyday puffing.
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
The 1876 is a really good cigar. I never tried these before and thought I would take the risk with such a great deal on them. Well it paid off! They are really smooth with just the right amount of flavor and strength for me as an evening cigar. I got a 25 pack and I have had about 6 so far. No problems, great construction, even burn. Thanks guys!
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
This is my everyday smoke and has been for three years. Great flavor, easy draw and great to smoke on the golf course. I recommend to anyone.
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
good smoke
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
4 out of 5
my everyday smoke
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
Love, Love, Love! Will Be a must have in the humidor at all times. Reminds me of the Dominican such a smooth relaxing cigar!
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
Excellent alternative to a Churchill. Same mellow flavor, even burn. A great choice!
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
Mild and mellow, burns evenly, long ash.
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
Great smooth cigars. Good value.
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
4 out of 5
Burns even and holds the ash
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
4 out of 5
Great smoke for a great price. Smoke taste as well. Well worth the price.
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
4 out of 5
no box good good
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
Hide Reviews