1876 Reserve

This one is a FAVORITE of mine. Mellow, smooth & easy draw.

Very good and mild smoke at a decent price.

Great taste and mild.

Good quality have been smoking them for years long fillers

Great golf cigar. Give em to your buddies, they’ll thank you

3rd purchase. Love them.

Would buy again

Favorite every day smoke

good value for the money

Great for the money

Nice draw, good flavor, can't beat the price!

This cigar smokes easily and smoothly, and is mild with an even, pleasant taste, but not much in the way of flavor complexity. In sum; a nice, mild, simple cigar.

I always get these as a favorite cigar. However; I was terribly unhappy with the last bundles I received last month. They were reallly dry and the wrapper on the ones opened from the cellopane were cracked and brittle. I have attempted to use 10-15 and they were all the same!! Maybe the second bundle will be better. I keep them in my electronic humidor at 70 degrees and 69% humidity. We'll see; but for now I'm just happy I got my CAO Brazilia at the same time. Not too sure if I'll order the 1876's again. Not Happy!!!!

These are pretty consistent with a light flavor that is great for a morning dog walk. They burn a little quick and sometimes uneven. But for the price they are a very good every day smoke, I have and will purchase again.

Great everyday cigar. Good construction. Smooth flavor throughout.

Great everyday cigar to sit and chill out with.

These have a good enough flavor, but my problem is the warp. Something about the stems left in and right up the side, I have had numerable blowouts. Either the stem burns quick up the middle seriously affecting the raw, or it is wrapped near the wrapper and it created a hole a couple inches above the plug. Either one affects the draw negatively. Based strictly on successful smokes, the taste is mild and great for a middle of the week stogie, but for a weekend with friends, it's a real bear having to cut 2 inches off, or bail on a third of the cigar because of a bad burn.

Good cigars for at work

These are a good cigar for the price. I will buy them again for sure. Smooth with a good burn.

liked them so much....I bought 20 more. very smooth, great draw, even burn......smoke down till you burn your fingers......last draw as good as the first.

Good cheap cigar quick smoke.

See above

Good everyday cigar.

Great for the price!!!!!!!

Bought these as a part of my husband's Christmas presents due to the fact he had been introduced to these prior to the holidays. They did not fail....my husband is as happy when he smokes one now as when he first tried them!!!

Decent smoke for the price.

Great cigar for the price. I will order more.

That is my Favorite Cigars Price is good and Reasonable .

mild

Great everyday smoke for the price.

A great cigar when you feel a need to relax and enjoy a drink along with the cigar.

Excellent cigar for an every dayer.

Very smooth stick

good cigar for the money

Good cigar at a very good price!

Price vs quality is very good

SMOOTH, MILD ALWAYS CONSISTENT CIGAR.

Smooth, draws well and nice aroma. Solid Cigar for the price!

Good smoke for a great price

good

a long lasting cigar for everyday pleasure Alan

For the price it was good.

Smooth draw nice every day cigar

I gave theses affordable beauties a try as I could hardly ignore the price. From my first draw, the flavor was great and the cigar has a really great finish. It hold up to any of the "high priced" stogies I've had. I will definitely use this as my go to for just about anything...

This is a good everyday cigar

Very happy with this cigar and I am buying more today

Smoke this if you want an acceptable inexpensive cigar

Tried the 1876 for the first time. For the price, this is a good everyday cigar, Slow, even-burning cigar with a mild flavor. Will order again.

decent every day smaoke

Great cigar at a good price

Great cigar for sitting on the patio with a cup of coffee watching the sunrise. Also a fantastic cigar while playing golf.

Delivered on time, great smoke!!!!

It’s inexpensive but a great everyday cigar. Can’t go wrong.

Excellent as always!

Good stick good price thanks

Good mild smoke can't beat the price.

Decent smoke, good value. Burns slightly hot. I will reorder.

I have enjoyed this cigar since you bought the first boat load of them. The old originals had some good age and were delicious. Today’s 1876 needs to age a while. Good cigar with wine and whiskey. Have given many bundles to our troops and they enjoy them.

This is my everyday smoke. I have been buying them for years. They are an outstanding value.

For the price very good.

Burns smooth and even. Great "golf course" cigar !

The cigar is well constructed and burns well. The wrapper is a bit darker than I expected, and thus a bit stronger than my go-to, Free Cuba, which has been on backorder for some time now.

Excellent golf course cigar.

Great everyday smoke.

Very enjoyable smoke!

I've been smoking 1876 Reserve Robustos for several years now and i think they're great! Very well made, very smooth and mild smoke and the price fits my wallet nicely.

A disappointment. Mild but bitter. Gratefully inexpensive.

Good smooth smoke!

Good value

This batch has a 40 percent waste due to center burn hole about an 1/8th inch in diameter. No, it is not my humidor. I constantly have to re-cut the burn end of and re-light. What a waste and nusience.! If it wasn't such a hassle, I'd return the entire box.

These cigars are very good, but combine that with the price, and I rate them excellent. Appearance, shape, taste, and smooth draw are all first rate. Mild strength and firmly wrapped.

Great cigar for the price.

Good cigar but getting too expensive

Great smoke for the price

Great cigar

Nice

Good cigar but not the best

Great cigar at a great price

nice cigar

good everyday mild smoke good taste and good even burn

Good smoke and well made. Will buy again.

The 1876 Reserve has been my standby cigar for years. I like a mild cigar, and these are perfect. They burn well, have a good taste, and last long. The Churchill lasts about an hour for me. For the price, what more could you ask for?

excellent burn and draw; a great value

Good mild all day cigar.

I love them they’re great

Burns nice, tastes mild & long enough for a nice long enjoyable smoke.

My everyday

Good smoke, I usually like a larger ring size

Great every day cigar

Mediocre and uneven burn

A great cigar for the money. A mild smoke for your smoking pleasure.

A very relaxing smoke !!!!!

I ordered the Connecticut wrapper as pictured above and received a much darker wrapper, so I can't rate what I ordered

This cigar has a very good flavor. It has a nice, slow burn that lasts long enough for me to finish my crossword puzzle. I feel like I stole it from CI (it was a two-fer).

Bought two bundles and I smoke two each day. Good flavor and I like the fact that they have full leaf Tabasco.

Good smoke. Mild, easy draw, good price.

This is the perfect cigar for working around the house. Always draws well

Enjoy this everyday cigar, however, I do prefer the Toro size which you are always out of stock.

Nice smoke representing a very good value when purchased as a 2-fer. Hard to find a mild long filler cigar for an everyday dollar smoke.

The star says it all not a good flavor

Good smoke for everyday. Reasonable pricing. Recommend

Consistently smooth smoking mild cigar. Always my "go to" cigar when relaxing.

After looking for a good smoke I found these 1776 sticks a few years back and now just reorder time after time. I would hold these cigars up against other more expansive cigars with no problem. A smooth draw that can't be beat for the price. True you may have a uneven burn or a plug 1 or 2 out of the 50+ sticks but I have had worst with the top more expensive brands. I have taken the band off and given them to others only to get great complements on the smoke. .

great smoke

A good daily driver! Smooth draw on a mild Connecticut Torpedo. A well made, low-cost smoke.

Great value.

I'm very happy with this brand of cigar.

Great everyday smoke and the price is right!

Not as mild as I would have liked but nonetheless an enjoyable cigar for the price. I will continue buying as long as available.

I've bought many bundles of the 1876 cigars and I find they are consistent in flavor and quality in every one I smoke. They are mild and taste excellent. There are cigars out there that cost much more than these and don't have the same smooth flavor. I like them a lot.

Fairly smoove. Inconsistant roll. To tight on the draw.

Great value. Nice burning smoke wonderful flavor. Can’t go wrong with this purchase.

This my second order of this great burning mold tasting stick. Could be my every day cigar.

Does not draw smoothly. Disappointed.

Not a bad smoke. Has a little more bite than I would like but still a good smoke.

like these---smoked them for a long time

Very mild. My favorite smoke

Good cigar. Consistent smoke, good draw and a good tasteful blend of tobacco. Good price as well

I bought the 1876 again, they are a great every day stick.

Always good, always fresh.. Good value for an everyday cigar

Even smoking, consistant packing, good wrap, ok taste. Good cigar for golf course or yard work. Will order again!

I like it!

Good everyday smoke. Stay lit, easy draw, lots of smoke. Doesn’t bite, mild, good cigar for walking the dog, or playing around in the garage.

Love these cigars. Just wish they kept them in stock more.

great value

Great every day cigar to bad I can’t get any more backorder

😄

Not bad for the price

Very good smoke with no burn out, at a great price. Thank you

The 1876 cigar is a nice no hassle cigar. It is an easy smoking cigar with very little stems and pieces. They hold their shape to the end of the smoke. I haven’t had to use a stiff wire to clear to get smoke. The price was right for me at your two for price. These are the reasons I have bought them for years.

Great light cigar !

Great cigar for price

Love them

My new favorite and my Rabbi likes it too

A mild, smooth cigar, great as an everyday smoke.

Good

mild cigars for daily smoke

speaks for it self 3 stars

A really good cigar for the money. I smoke them while doing things around the house. Good quality and value. Good taste as well.

I prefer the 1876 Maduro. Both options are the best bargain cigars I have so far found. Quality, consistent cigars.

A great smoke for the money. An excellent 9-hole cigar

Great taste, good burn, great deal.

I always mix bargain cigars along with my favorites. They're perfect for golf or in front of a grill. 1876 Reserves are great for this and quality is up there with cigars twice the price. I put them in the same category as the La Auroras as far as consistency and smoke-ability...maybe higher. I go through around 150 of these sticks a year in between my upper shelf choices and am never disappointed.

The 1876 burns nicly, long ash, good melloe flavors. Unlike many Gurkas I have had, these do not unroll on you. I've paid more for less.

very nice mold smoke

Great cigar for the price. Smokes smoothly and stands up to the rigors of being in the wind on a golf course.

Bought a box of Macanudos. Pricey. So I back-to-back did a comparo 1876 v the Mac. Now remember that I make my living tasting as a restauranteur. And here’s the outcome. The Mac was absolutely NO better than the 1876. No, seriously. I can’t believe it either as the price difference is 5x. At least.

This could be one of the best kept secrets. For a little over a buck a stick this is an exceptional smoke. On the mild side the way I like them and smokes nice and even. The quality is good with only the occasional cigar that is not made perfect. This is my daily smoke and I enjoy them all.

Light. Mellow. Mild. Smooth. Amazing price. Great draw.

Very good cigar, excellent draw and burn, quite mild. Fabulous value.

Mild cigar, even burning, very enjoyable

Will definitely keep my humidor supplied with 1876 Reserve cigars. This is my 2nd time buying them and they are good mild everyday cigars. I truly like the flavor better than some of the more expensive mild cigars. You will not be disappointed.

Barely a 48 ring size, not a 50 as advertised. Will not stay lit, loosely rolled. Had to relight at least 10 times with reasonably frequent puffs. Smells like straw under the nose, before being lit up. Smoke aroma and taste is fair.

Fast shipping and very reliable company.

I've been smoking these cigars for years. An excellent everyday cigar.

Dry burned uneven

Very good every day smoke. It has a nice taste to it. Has a good draw and burn. I will be ordering g these cigars again.

A very good cigar taste for the price. Depending on the type you order will depend on the quality. Recommend a torpedo type.

When I ordered the 1876 Reserve Churchills, I thought I was getting a nice mild Connecticut wrapped smoke. Instead it tasted bitter, dark wrapper instead of lite Connecticut…….not pleased compared to all the other Connecticut cigars I’ve ordered in the past. Sorry!

Wonderful cigars for the money. I have smoked them for years with great enjoyment. Thank you for a great smoke !

Great cigar for the money and great for an everyday smoke. Very mild for the first 2/3 of the stick, then turns a little peppery, but not harsh, for the last 1/3. Stays lit if you leave alone for a few minutes. Burns pretty even, but not perfect. Will buy this one again.

Very good smoke for the price.

Very good cigar.

Good mild smoke, great value!

Good taste, burns well and good price.

Nice, mild smoke. Stays lit, burns evenly, Tastes decent. Would purchase again.

My favorite daily cigar.

I keep trying other brands. But still go back to the 1876 reserve. Love the flavor and they burn very well.

Love them

Much improvement of quality than in the past! I'll keep buying them again if quality is good!

Not real consistent on the draw. But other than that okay.

good cigar but not as mild as I expected. Ill buy more.

I wouldn't buy again. Almost all of the cigars had canoeing.

Better than I thought they would be. Great after dinner smoke or a lunch time break.

They did smoke very nice

The 1876 Reserve Toro is a great cigar. The 1876 Reserve Toro cigar is a nice mild cigar and is priced very cheap. I can also smoke the cigar halfway, then smoke the other half without losing the mild taste.

Satisfied with the knockoffs

Ordered 25 1876 Reserve cigars from name your price. It was great cigar and a great value.

Good, mild everyday smoke

good cigar for the price

Good

Smoke was good for the first half of burn. Smooth at first. Wrapper didn't hold last quarter of smoke. Had to relight a few times.

Excellent mild smoke at a great price!

Smooth draw nice aroma. Very pleased with this purchase

Great cigar for the price.

I always buy these cigars when they come up for sale cheaper then my usual low price cigars. They are my favorite discount cigar.

Great bargain good cigar for the price. Good cigar while working outside.

The cigars were burning crooked and some had large leaf veins in the center

I have been enjoying these cigars for over a year now. i have tried many varieties over the years and I smoke several cigars a day. the 1876 is a consistently good smoking cigar at a reasonable cost per stick. it is a mild cigar which works for me. the price is good for the amount I smoke.

Good smoke nice draw plenty of smoke burnef a little hot at the end but very enjoyable

Good

Perfect for the golf course. Mild and consistent!

great everyday smoke, draws great stays lit on the golf course

Cons: Uneven burn & many were semi plugged Pros: Nice looking cigar I may never buy these again as there are many other inexpensive cigars that are much better.

NICE SMOOTH CIGAR,A LITTLE TOO PRICEY-THAT'S WHY I GAVE IT 3 STARS INSTEAD OF 4

Good smoke when the price is right

They are my Husbands favorite.

I never thought I'd be writing a review for the 1876 Reserve. I started smoking cigars about a year ago. I smoke several a day and have purchased a LOT of cigars! A couple of things have happened over that period of time. 1) My taste has evolved toward Medium to Full bodied sticks, and 2) I tend now to stay away from "value" and "budget" cigars in favor of those that I are higher quality in taste and construction. When I first started smoking, I bought a bundle of the 1876 Reserve in torpedo. I smoked a few early on and thought....awwwww, just ok. After a year in my humi, I pulled one out today just for fun to see what I'd think. Low and behold, I'm pleasantly surprised! While it's no Padron or Davidoff, it's a damn fine stick. A little soft/spongy but is super mellow, smooth, and burns like a champ. I'm now thinking I might have to try the maduro.

Been buying 1876’s for years. Mild easy draw and won’t make your head spin. Guys on the golf course love the smell. Other cigars I’d put in the same class are cost much more.

There are other low cost mild cigars that are much better in my opinion.

Fair at best. Decent for the price.

Not bad, price was great!

Excellent service

A fair everyday cigar. Mild and slow burning. However, the consistency from one cigar to the next is not always there. Some burn hot, others burn uneven, and others very even.

Great cigars for the price.

Haint bad fer a low cost cigar. Just right when you slop the hogs.

A cigar while golfing is my favorite pastime. The value and flavor of the 1876 makes it that much more enjoyable.

Not really a good smoke sorry

For an inexpensive they're OK. Several burn uneven and come unraveled. Some have a hollow middle which causes them to be harsh.

I've had them before and while I already knew that they weren't great cigars, they weren't too bad. This time, they were just awful; barely smokable even in a pinch... Sorry, maybe this was a bad batch.

its not what you can afford but rather what delivers constant satisfying smoke. Having smoked and enjoyed 1876 Reserve in all shapes and sizes, all I can say it will be a sad day if you stop selling them. Should you decide to stop selling them, reserve me 1000 bundles.

Priced right for a mild every day cigar.

Good smokes Other companies have different sizes. Stick with CI and enjoy a bundle of 50

Nice every day cigar for the price. So far every cigar has had a nice draw and has stayed lit. I would purchase again.

Good burn for the money, nice even flavor Easy everyday cigar

A great bargain! Great for fishing or golf. Not too heavy, not too light...

Great for sitting on the deck and just watching life pass by. no hash backbite, mild flavor, a few are rolled to tight and have no draw but not often. Have bought these numerous times and will do so again

They burn good, but their wrappers are bitter; they other box I ordered tasted better. I am giving 5 stars because I'm not sure if i made a mistake when ordering or not; they have a good draw and burn easily and that is really what counts when smoking low-priced cigars.

If you are a mild cigar lover this is the best bang for the buck i've found.Been smokin these for years

Good everyday stick.

Great everyday cigar!!!

I've bought many shipments of the 1876 Reserve over the past years and was very happy with the mild mellow taste. However, this shipment was certainly not Mild but was a very dark shipment. I can't enjoy these and am very disappointed.

Nice everyday cigar

Can't get much better for the price.

I bought these for my husband because he loves the mild taste and even burn. I love the great price. A winner!

Not the most consistent smokes, but very mild & overall good value. I never go to the course without them.

Yuk. I'll smoke almost anything but these are nasty. The reviews had me thinking I was going to have a bundle of mild smokes for cheap. These are not mild and are bitter and raunchy.

It's a good everyday cigars starts off nice and smooth it doesn't have a harsh flavor nice and smooth right up to the end would suggest them to anyone I would purchase them again myself for that price how can you beat that a cigar you can share with lots and lots of friends you get 50 can't wait to get them again.

worth the money, an almost daily cigar for me

Good cigar. Will buy again

very satisfied, thank you