Your web browser is no longer supported.
Cigars International is committed to providing you with the best web experience possible.
Close
Click the icons below for product information.

Judge Wright by JC Newman - Packaging Mistake Blowout Sale

Give this cigar a fair trial.

In the 1920’s J.C. Newman’s top-selling cigar was a little brand known as “Judge Wright.” Back then, the line had a simple slogan, “A fair trial will give a verdict in favor of this cigar.” Now, I’ve got to be honest. My experience with any sort of court is limited to Judge Judy and Law and Order reruns. However, if I were a judge, I’d throw anyone who didn’t like this cigar out, as they must be insane.

This cigar is a straight up value, and I’d recommend getting in early and often. Judge Wright is a Nicaraguan puro with a Sun Grown wrapper, but unlike some similar blends, this one stays smooth and medium-bodied throughout. The ‘Cuban sandwich’ blend has great flavors of earth, leather, and slight spice. There’s nothing else I can say here, Judge Wright is a great everyday cigar. Case dismissed.

Recently, we received a shipment of these bad boys sans bands. While they may not be as ‘pretty’, they will be discounted to the bone! So that means extra savings for you on this JC Newman-made treat only for a limited time!

Size
Pack In Stock MSRP Price Qty Cart
Churchill (7.0"x48)
Box of 20 Out Of Stock $70.00
save $40.8858% off
$29.12   Notify
Double Toro (Gordo) (6.0"x60)
Box of 20 Out Of Stock $75.00
save $46.2962% off
$28.71   Notify
Overall Rating 4.38 out of 5 Based on 134 Ratings

Customer Reviews of “Judge Wright by JC Newman - Packaging Mistake Blowout”

Write A Review
5 out of 5
5 Star
77
4 out of 5
4 Star
38
3 out of 5
3 Star
14
2 out of 5
2 Star
3
1 out of 5
1 Star
2
Showing 1-50 of 134 Reviews
4 out of 5
Porch smoker
Good back porch smoke to have when you are just chilling out listening to music.
5 out of 5
Great Cigar for the Price
Excellent everyday cigar. Wish they were not out of stock.
5 out of 5
Great Deal
I ordered these along with several other types of cigars. These were by far my favorite. Had a great even burn and perfect taste. I went to order more and they were out of stock unfortunately. I gave several to friends to try and they all agreed for the price point, it would be very hard to find a better cigar.
4 out of 5
Good smoke
Good smoke
5 out of 5
The Judge is correct
The box that I got was best smoke for the price.
3 out of 5
Not bad
Decent cigar for the price. Would buy again
4 out of 5
Honest
New to cigar appreciation....working out humidity levels in humidor (since intro offer does not include hygrometer). This is an honest cigar for the price. They arrived dry, but when a little moisture was absorbed by being in the humidor, they are good cigars for the price.
3 out of 5
Just ok
These burn ok wouldn't get again
5 out of 5
Excellent
Excellent cigar.
5 out of 5
Taste great
Taste great
4 out of 5
Nice Value
Nice value ... for an inexpensive cigar, I have experienced good flavor, an even burn and a reasonable draw ... a good buy ... thx
5 out of 5
Good smoke
I liked them
4 out of 5
WOW
For the price this is a great everyday smoke. I was so surprised with the quality of this cigar
4 out of 5
Good stick for the price
Good stick for the price.
3 out of 5
Not the best flavour, didn't
Not the best flavour, didn't like the dia., probably wouldn't buy them again!
4 out of 5
Decent cigar for the price
I really enjoy the body and flavor of these cigars. However in a number of them I've had trouble with a hard piece of carbon in them while smoking. Otherwise, great cigar.
5 out of 5
The best low price cigar.
Amazed at how enjoyable this cigar is. Perfect every day smoke.
4 out of 5
Judge Wright Packaging Mistake Churchills
A very nice inexpensive "everyday" cigar.
5 out of 5
Excellent Cigar What Mistake?
This is a good mistake cigar..... I'll take these type off Mistakes anytime.
5 out of 5
The Judge was half Wright.
The taste was great on the sticks that had good draw, which so far is at 50%. Taste was different when draw was not as good, rolled tighter. Burn was nice and square however.
4 out of 5
Super
A great smoke. The best price on the market 😎
5 out of 5
good sticks
Great smokes.
5 out of 5
Judge Wright
I liked them. IK watch for good deals. My eyesight is not too good but now & then I luck out.
4 out of 5
As a former Judge, I was attracted by the name "Judge Wright". jud
As a former Judge, I was attracted by the name "Judge Wright". So far, in my judgment, it's a nice medium smoke which is well worth the price.
5 out of 5
Judge Wright Churchill
I like them, well made, tasty, burns even. Good 1.5 hour cigar.
5 out of 5
Judge Wright / JC Newman Toro
Good value cigar, well constructed, easy draw, even burn but rotate often, medium strength, a little peppery at first then smooths out until the end, out of two bundles had two cigars that were plugged solid and hard but the rest were fine. These cigars need to rest in the humidor for at least two weeks. I would buy again. Jeff M.
3 out of 5
Judge Wright Bargain
Great price for an everyday kick around cigar!
5 out of 5
Great smoke - and not just for the price
I didn't expect much when I bought these but they are a great daily smoke. The burn is fantastic with no re-lights, no canoes and no hot spots. They taste great too!
4 out of 5
mmcma
Good draw and taste, great everyday smoke
5 out of 5
Good cigar for the money
Nice price on a good cigar, smooth with a bite at the end.
5 out of 5
Judge Wright Gordo
Wished I bought more
3 out of 5
Judge Wright
leaving these sit in the humidor for a while. flavor profiles not developed initially. pretty good burn though
5 out of 5
Long tradition of a Great cigar
Judge Wright is a fine smoke with great flavors and a clean burn
4 out of 5
Great for the price
Let them sit in your humidor for a few weeks and they'll be great. Was pleasantly surprised they were this good considering the price
4 out of 5
Porch smoker
Good relaxing smoke for the back porch.
5 out of 5
Let me be the Judge
Let me summarize this cigars verdict. It's affordable, the cigar doesn't taste affordable. Let it age in some good humidity a few days/weeks or however long you wish in a well seasoned humidor. Then spark up your first one.
5 out of 5
A nice steady burning smoke
A nice steady burning smoke with great flavor. One of my favorites so far. Especially in the price range.
5 out of 5
judge wright
good smokes at a good price.......
1 out of 5
No so good....
Cigars don't burn all the way through,leaves unroll during smoking them,multi light is just the beginning...not a good buy.Very dissapointed.
5 out of 5
Great stogie for the price!
Great stogie for the price!
5 out of 5
Flavor
Mild flavor smooth smoke
4 out of 5
Best with coffee
Acid after tasting but goes good with coffee Even burning
5 out of 5
Judge Wright Come Back Soon...
I just wish I ordered more then 8 boxes.......What a great cigar...A couple of soft spots but still a great smoke....Only have 3 more sticks left......
4 out of 5
Great golfing cigar. Great value!!
Can't go wrong with this one. Great CI value!!
4 out of 5
Great value - 4 of 5 sticks were in 5-star category
4 of 5 were great in all respects - taste, draw, burn. The other 1 of 5 was still quite smokeable but with a little more TLC
5 out of 5
A great cigar!
These are incredible cigars, regardless of price. Smokes beautiful, lasts a good long time. The great price made them even better. Nice, slightly oily feel. Would definitely reorder.
5 out of 5
I made a mistake for
I made a mistake for not getting more of them. LOVE THE CIGAR
5 out of 5
The Judge deserves a unanimous verdict.
I recently purchased the Judge Wright double toro packaging mistake to give them a trial run. I am very pleased with the overall product. They are not too mild yet not too bold. I have actually been burning through them too fast, as I have been letting friends try them out as well. As far as I'm concerned, there is no split or hung jury here. Just good taste made for good times.
3 out of 5
I'm a bit disappointed
I read the reviews and they were positive. I guess they didn't live up to what I thought other reviewers were saying. I understand this is a very inexpensive cigar but the taste is grassy and a bit bitter. Some of the cigars have been under filled (spongy not very solid) and maybe I missed it in the description but they are mixed filled, so as someone who usually cuts the end off I get tobacco in my mouth.
5 out of 5
Judge Wright
Good shipping, good product, no problems
5 out of 5
Great everyday smoke.
I try to keep these stocked. Not a bad one in the bunch.
4 out of 5
All Rise!
An excellent smoke.Medium bodied with a smooth draw. Well constructed. Fine value.
5 out of 5
All Rise!
A great smoke with value far beyond the price. Great flavor, easy draw, even burn for the most part.
5 out of 5
great cigar
good burning and really decent smoke. the 60 rings are about the best i have smoked for the price. bill. thanks to ci for really good deals and quick shipping.
5 out of 5
There sure is a mistake here
these are probally the best mistake I ever made ordering these cigars. put together nicely with a slow consistent burn with plenty of flavor which keeps me wanting more. what a value!
4 out of 5
Really like this cigar!!!!
Very good smooth cigar.
5 out of 5
You Be The Judge
A great smoke for a great price. Of the cigars I have bought from CI this is the best, so far.
4 out of 5
Judge Wright Cigars
Good cigar at a cheap price!
4 out of 5
Everyday cigar
Surprised, good everyday cigar. No problems . Mild, burns fairly even . I'm finishing up on my second box. Can't beat price
3 out of 5
Pretty good for the price
These are a pretty good smoke for the price. They don't quite have the taste I like, but they're a good every day or a good hand out to friends who like a stronger cigar. They burn very even and draw great. I only gave 3 stars for the lack of that Nicaraguan flavor that doesn't seem to pop out. But they are good!
5 out of 5
Judge Wright
My everyday smoke. 35 years, best smoke for the money.
5 out of 5
Judge Wright
Taste great!
5 out of 5
A Relaxing Smoke
This cigar provides a gentleman's relaxing atmosphere at an excellent price
5 out of 5
Good Smoke
These were a great deal and a very nice smoke for the price
5 out of 5
Give The Judge A Try!
I'll Take "em" All Day Long!!!-Suits Me Just Fine-Thank You CI For Putting Us Together-Tom In North Carolina
5 out of 5
Don't let the price fool you
Great smoke for the money, you won't be dissapointed!!! High quality cigar at a cheap price.
4 out of 5
Ferget this grear cigar!
Fantastic! Great taste, burn, price...don't buy'em though - so I can get more before they sell out!
4 out of 5
Great cigar
For the price cigar is a good every day cigar!
4 out of 5
Don't pass this one up!
I bought this cigar and crossed my fingers, not knowing what to expect. Instead of crossing my fingers I should have ordered two boxes! The flavor is good and not harsh or bitter. When I lit it, it burned evenly without going out over and over again. The ash "hang time" was good and the big ring size is a plus any day. Bottom line, this is one to grab.
5 out of 5
Very good cigars
Very good cigars
4 out of 5
Here comes the Judge!!
Great Cigar for the low price. burns even, Good flavor, & Good draw
5 out of 5
great deal
Bought two more cases love em everyday smoke
5 out of 5
Delicious everyday smoke!
Delicious everyday smoke!
5 out of 5
Great cigars
Judge right are good cigars no more in stock though text me when the rain started I'll get more
5 out of 5
Nice
Nice surprise. Thought there would be just so so for the price, but I was wrong. These were nice down to my twentieth cigar. I just kept them in their box and not my humidor and stay in great shape. It not top of the line cigar, so don't expect to much, but they burned well, lasted nicely and no bad or cheap taste to them. Yes I would definately buy again. Bought a box for my brother in Florida and he said he's enjoying them too.
3 out of 5
Good cigar. I have one
Good cigar. I have one at night with a little whiskey, and it hits the spot. Also, I did not have the burn issues that I thought I might.
5 out of 5
Great cigar for price
I liked this cigar so much and it was priced so low, after smoking a few I immediately ordered another box!
5 out of 5
Nice smoke
Ready to order my fourth bundle. Nice everyday smoke,slow and even burn. I've handed a few out and gotten good reviews.
5 out of 5
Great Deal on an All Day Cigar!!!!
I really enjoy the Gordo! Slow burn, great taste and awesome construction! filling my humi with these. Perfect with morning coffee and throughout the day.
5 out of 5
Best cuban sandwich cigar I've tried.
Probably the best loose filler cigar I've had. Smokes and burns well, but not loosely packed. Vcut, and you are doing pretty good from getting any trimmings. Good medium bodied cigar, will be a good cheapy to keep on hand. I actually like getting cigars without bands, or minimal bands.
5 out of 5
Judge Wright for the win
What can I say about this cigar other than it is absolutely fantastic, especially for the price. You will be hard pressed to find a better value. It's a great everyday cigar because it is so affordable. Taste is great too, especially as a morning stick with a strong cup of coffee. I don't review many sticks, but this one deserves high praise. Most the other cigars in this price range are dog rockets. You will not be disappointed in this judge.
5 out of 5
Tasty
Great cigar for the price. Medium smooth smoke.
5 out of 5
THE VERDICT IS IN.
Got these for my husband. And his verdict is: Nice consistent even burn, and a smooth spice flavor up to the very end. Great value for the price. I would certainly re-order these again and again and again.
4 out of 5
Nice draw; mild smoke..Good Value!!!
Nice draw! Mild smoke, expecting a little more medium ++ taste! Overall; the one I just tried was agreeable. Long burn; no bitter/hot bite near the end. Good value. JC Newman smokes were excellent 40 years ago. I lived in Tampa and they had a company store where you could purchase the "seconds". Never had a issue. I will give another review after I finish the box. Again; good value on this item,
5 out of 5
Here Come da' Judge
Very nice size, shape & construction. Burns evenly, slowly & re-lites nicely. Flavor is Med-to-full for me. As added bonus, Cost is great with quick delivery. Convinced after 5 Judges and ordered 2more boxes.
5 out of 5
What a good cigar for the price
I just received these cigars today, and I was surprised of the nice smoke from such a low price point. They make a very good daily smoke and your friends will never believe what you paid. I will purchase again very soon, maybe next week!
5 out of 5
Love the fat boys
Nice easy draw, good flavor, even burn. Love the price. My new everyday smoke👍
2 out of 5
just ok
Not bad but not great
5 out of 5
Judge Wright - not wrong!
These are near to great, meaning they are right on in taste, burn, and draw. Not a 90 plus cigar, but at least an 89+ in my books. I would definitely buy these again.
4 out of 5
Fat smoke!
It was a great smoke for the money I ordered'em again. Constructed well, smoked well and ya can't beat it.
5 out of 5
Good smoke
Took a chance on these and was surprised how tasty they are with an even burn. Already ordered a second box and they cost a fraction of the sticks I usually buy
1 out of 5
Dirty Judge Wright
Dirt. Does dirt have a flavor? Yes it does. And it belongs to Judge Wright. Not underfilled, not a gorgeous wrapper. But hey, I was game. But for the price I paid for two (2) of these boxes, I don't think I can give them away quick enough. Like licking dirty rocks? Then this cigar is for you. I'd have to hate the people I offer these cigars. These smokes will probably just languish in my humidor, until I saturate them with bourbon or some other flavoring agent that might make me forget what a terrible investment I made in these smokes. I've smoked three of these already. How did I get through it, perhaps you might ask? I kept waiting for the cigar to improve. Let me save you the time- it won't.
2 out of 5
Don't judge the Judge
Mild, weak taste, but good value.
5 out of 5
Happy to have found these
These have nice flavor and an even burn all the way down. I'm ordering these for a second time. If you need a less expensive cigar that tastes good these fit the bill. I usually order cigars that are $150-$200 a box and can't beat these for the price.
4 out of 5
el Mono Borracho
Quite the bargain, an even burn and not too strong!
4 out of 5
the judge is ok
great smoke for the price
5 out of 5
Victor Sinclair
Thoroughly enjoyed the Victor Sinclair sampler. Slow burning and smooth tasting
5 out of 5
Excellent
Very good for a daily smoke good flavor easy draw
5 out of 5
Good Smoke
Smooth and satisfying smoke!
5 out of 5
Judge Wright
I normally smoke a 48 or 50 ring size cigar, but, at the sale price I decided to give these a try. It is one of my favorites now. Because of it"s size, you need to smoke it with nothing else to do but enjoy the taste of this cigar. Long and even burning, asy draw, and very tasty.
5 out of 5
Excellent
Easy draw good flavor solid daily smoke
5 out of 5
Very Nice Smoke
A really nice smoke. I would call this a medium strength cigar. The flavor is smooth through out the entire smoke. I really enjoy this cigar while playing golf. A good cigar at a great price.
4 out of 5
Big and strong
Good robust cigar. All very consistent so far.
4 out of 5
Very Goid Cigar
The folks at JC Newman clearly know how to make good cigars. Judge Wright is a well-built smoke. Flavor isn't exotic but it tastes like a cigar--and that's why I smoke 'em!
5 out of 5
Great
Passed them out at a organizational party I had. Everyone raved about them
4 out of 5
You can't smoke cigar bands
These cigars are pretty good cigars. They are well constructed and smoke easily. Not many runs or soft spots. The added bonus is the lower cost of unbanded cigars.
5 out of 5
Pleasantly surprised
I bought these mainly for a cheap smoke when I'm outside around the house. From the very first puff I was totally amazed on what a great cigar it was. It's a great cigar to have extras with you to share.
3 out of 5
O.K. for the price.
Construction is good. Burns evenly. Flavor is average, but good for the price.
5 out of 5
Judge Wright
Hubby wants me to buy more - that says it all.
5 out of 5
The verdict
Judge Wright is well worth the money. A well constructed sandwich cigar from JC Neumann&Co. A solid everyday medium bodied smoke for very little dough!
5 out of 5
The judge is always (W)right
When I compare these to some of the other short filler cigars I have paid good money for only to regret it, these are pretty good! Don't get me wrong they will never burn like or be as consistent in taste as the more expensive long filler, however they are still a good cigar. After all I personally either like a smoke or don't and I'm not particularly looking for the tastes that are described by the seller as this is my only criteria. Give it a try..
3 out of 5
They burn very uneven, too many ribs in the leaf.
They do taste good when you get one that burns evenly, which is rare.
5 out of 5
Have not smoked them yet.
Have not smoked them yet.
3 out of 5
A solid smoke.
well constructed, smokes well, ok flavor profile. Will never be my go to smoke but a great smoke for working in the yard.
5 out of 5
Judge Wright
Enjoyed them very much. Going to order them again
4 out of 5
Good
Good cigar. Definitely medium flavored and smooth. The burn is off on some cigars. Price makes it well worth it.
4 out of 5
Judge Wright Dbl Toro
Very good cigar for the cost, good flavor, good burn. Would buy again
4 out of 5
it was good for the
it was good for the price will buy again
5 out of 5
Judge Wright
I am now in my 2nd bundle and I happy with them. They are medium strength, burn well and have ample smoke, seldom do they get crocked or i need to relight. My wife hasn't tried them yet, but I believe she will like them also. At this point, I will be ordering them again.
4 out of 5
Excellent value
Is it going to be the best cigar you've ever had? No. But this has to be one of the best values you'll find. Burns slowly and evenly, good draw, and a perfectly acceptable everyday smoker. Worth way more than a buck a stick. Pretty full taste, so may not be for you if that's not your thing.
5 out of 5
The verdict is out... the Judge is IN!
Incredible smoke for the price! These puppers burn so smooth and get a nice fat ash on the end because of how well they are rolled. Don't expect a stiff flavor with the Judge, he administers justice on a very middle-of-the-road manner. This is what I would describe as a perfect middle priced, middle flavored cigar. I will definitely be a repeat offender when it comes to ordering from the Judge!
5 out of 5
Smoking one now and ordering more
Good construction and burns evenly. Matches up well to other cigars in the price range and I'm thrilled to save a few bucks on these bandless bandits.
5 out of 5
Tight Roll,But An Easy Draw,Nice
Tight Roll,But An Easy Draw,Nice White Ash.Stays Medium Bodied Down To The Nub,No Harsh Burning At The End.
5 out of 5
Awesome!!!
Love them. Phenomenal cigar from J.C. Newman. Buying more again.
5 out of 5
Great cigar
These cigars are smooth with flavor. Plus they burn evenly and did not have to be relighted while enjoying them, even for a 60 ring size cigar.
2 out of 5
James B.
I purchased a box of these, I have 6 left. I won't buy them again. Almost every one of these cigars burnt very bad. The draw was inconsistent from one cigar to the next. One cigar was fine and then the next you had to pull really hard. It seems to me that the construction is very sloppy. It's a shame because I really like the taste and flavor of the Judge Wright but you have to put up with too many downsides.
3 out of 5
no contempt in judge wrights court!
not bad for the buck, good construction,and burn. good everyday cigar. prob order again.
4 out of 5
Good Smoke - good value
Starts slow and smooth, finish is robust. Not always a clean burn, but still very enjoyable
4 out of 5
Very good smoke for the
Very good smoke for the money. Fast becoming my go to everyday choice!
4 out of 5
this is a fine inexpensive
this is a fine inexpensive smoke smooth, burns evenly and stays burning
3 out of 5
FM
Not a bad smoke. Flavor was decent, earthy, leather, and spices. The burn was uneven on most of them. I had to relight to keep burn even.
3 out of 5
BLAND & BITTER!
CONSTRUCTION IS GOOD, BUT I WOULD RATE THIS AS A GOLF COURSE OR GARDEN CIGAR, YOU KNOW, WHEN YOU'RE NOT REALLY PAYING MUCH ATTENTION TO THE SMOKE, BUT GETTING YOUR NICOTINE FIX...
5 out of 5
Absolutely Great Smoke!
This is now my everyday cigar! It is a great stogie that is budget friendly! The burn is perfect. Good construction, and the taste is very good. I am definitely going to buy more of these, I love them! Thank you CI for selling such wonderful smokes!
5 out of 5
Awesome cigars
Great smoke I would buy them again in a heartbeat great every day smoke
Learn more on how to get FREE Shipping on your entire order! Click Here Learn more on how to get FREE Shipping on your entire order! Click Here Learn more on how to get FREE Shipping on your entire order! Click Here Learn more on how to get FREE Shipping on your entire order! Click Here
Adroit