Top
CI
Click the icons below for product information.

CI's Mystery box Sale

This item is no longer available for purchase.
See similar items below.

It’s back, baby! Back in December, we but together a mystery box sale, and you folks went bonkers, clearing out all my inventory that should have lasted a month, in a matter of days. So I had to run it back for anyone who missed out.

What we have here is a big assortment of premium cigar brands – from test blends to limited edition releases and specialty orders, and anything else I could find with only a few boxes left in stock. Instead of trying to sell them off one by one, I’ve loaded them all up into one product bin, and am letting you take a spin of the wheel. Boxes of 18 or more cigars for just $39.99. Here we go again!

I won't try to pull your leg. There are some options in the mix that are probably sitting around for a reason, and maybe some flavored options that won’t suit your taste. But the bulk of this inventory is all top-of-the-line, premium, boxed and banded, long-filler stuff from the big boys like Macanudo, La Gloria Cubana, CAO, Rocky Patel, Graycliff, Camacho, Torano, Montecristo, and more. All boxes of 18 or more, some of you are going to make out like bandits. If I showed you some of the boxes available here and the prices we actually paid, you wouldn’t think twice. We’re losing our shirts here! Take your shot before it’s too late.

Overall Rating4.6 out of 5 Based on 81 Ratings

Customer Reviews of “CI's Mystery box”

Write A Review
5 out of 5
5 Star
57
4 out of 5
4 Star
16
3 out of 5
3 Star
8
2 out of 5
2 Star
0
1 out of 5
1 Star
0
Showing 1-50 of 81 Reviews
4 out of 5
Surprise!
Mildly surprised but definitely happy. Thanks
5 out of 5
Great Value!
Would absolutely order the mystery box again, and wishing I'd doubled up this order! I received a box of 24 PDR Small Batch Reserve Habano Grand Toro's . New smoke for me, and I really like them - very smooth, cool draw, even burn from start to finish. I'll order these again.
5 out of 5
Great Surprise!!!
Great Surprise!!!
5 out of 5
2 boxes ordered now and
2 boxes ordered now and each has been a great experience in something new.
4 out of 5
Good surprise
Expected mediocre. Received well above that.
5 out of 5
My box
Pleasantly surprised and pleased about my mystery box purchase . I will take that chance again!
4 out of 5
Mystery Box
Liked the cigars but I thought it would be a variety of different brands.
5 out of 5
Love it
This deal is a fantastic way to try different cigars, at a helluva price, that you may otherwise never give a shot.
3 out of 5
i did not care for this particular cigar
The cigars were top quality, well worth the money i prefer a smoother,lighter cigar.
4 out of 5
Mystery
Its a mystery, wouldn't throw the box back that i was awarded. worth a shot
5 out of 5
Great value!
I order two of these ‘mystery boxes’ and received some great smokes! Thanks , CI!!
4 out of 5
Mystery Box
Got some good cigars that I probably would not have bought otherwise like the bahia gold. Look forward to this promo in the future.
5 out of 5
I want
I want you to offer it again, I loved the selections I was shipped
5 out of 5
Better than expected!
I was 50/50 on this, but at this price point, it wasn't really much of a gamble. I figured, worse case scenario, I could always gift them. I was very pleasantly surprised with a box of cigars that were worth twice what I paid. Thanks!
5 out of 5
Worth the chance
Quality was very good. Price reasonable
5 out of 5
The Mysetry Box was an excellent deal.
These were some of the better cigars I've had in a while.
5 out of 5
CI INFUSED MYSTERY BOX
Excellent selection of INFUSED boutique cigars and great selection.
5 out of 5
Really impressed with what I
Really impressed with what I received
3 out of 5
Mystery box
Cigars not bad would like to see a better quality cigars but the price was great glad to see old prices back.
5 out of 5
👍🏻👍🏻
👍🏻👍🏻
5 out of 5
I was very pleased with
I was very pleased with the mystery box deal ! I ordered 2 just to see what I'd get and was so happy I turned around and ordered two more ! I am very happy as always with CI
5 out of 5
Well worth the price
Completely unknown to me cigars...good surprise.
5 out of 5
The mystery box
I'm 2 for 2 on mystery boxes PDR 1878 and La Gloria I'm gonna start purchasing a mystery box with every order
4 out of 5
Surprised to receive not 18,
Surprised to receive not 18, but a full box of 24 Pinar del Rio sticks 5 x 50 robustos. The cigars are a pleasant medium bodied smoke. The burn is not consistent, but for the value, I can put up with it. When I’m ready, I think I’ll consider the mystery box again...it’s a bit like a Christmas morning...unsure of what your unwrapping and fun!
4 out of 5
odd drawing issue.
had a tendency to tunnel inside itself otherwise nice cigar for walking no matter what weather is
5 out of 5
Mystery Box
Received my first mystery box - PDR 1878 Legacy Capa Oscura. I was surprised, good smoke, flavor...a brand I would not have tried. I will buy the mystery box again and even try some other PDR cigars.
5 out of 5
Ho
I think it was a real good deal Car got the PDR’s love to do it again
5 out of 5
I was very pleased with
I was very pleased with the box of sticks I got as my mystery box. These sticks have a great draw, nice white ash, and a ton of smoke.
3 out of 5
Hoping for better
I know it’s the luck of the draw when you do a mystery box like this – but it was the one cigar brand that was not hoping for not bad brand- but brand that has had struggle living up to rep.
5 out of 5
Mystery Box
I am very happy with the cigars.
4 out of 5
Not a bad deal
Not a bad deal
3 out of 5
Decent deal however would have
Decent deal however would have like some variety for ordering 2 boxes. I received 2 boxes of La Aurora Palma.
3 out of 5
Mystery Box
It is my fault for rolling the dice on a mystery box. The cigars I received are ok but not what I typically smoke
5 out of 5
This Is A Definite Must Each And Every Time.
Whenever you see this offer pop up, RUN, don't walk to order at least 2 boxes. When I say 'run', I mean Usain Bolt Run. I'm not going to say what I got, but it was worth WELL OVER $40 worth. Thanks for these, CI!
5 out of 5
Solid Deal
Got a box of Quesada 40th Anniversary 6x54. Great deal.
5 out of 5
Highly recommended
Wasn’t sure what to expect when I opened the shipping box so I was very surprised and happy to see a box of H. Upmann 1844 Reserves
5 out of 5
Mystery box
Got an unbelievable deal on the mystery box! Will definitely order again.
5 out of 5
This is an amazing deal
This is an amazing deal to stuff your humidor on the cheap
5 out of 5
No mystery here!
I received my box of 25 and found them to be one of the best smokes I’ve ever put in my mouth, smooth, satisfying, even burning!
4 out of 5
Mistrey box
at first I thought you picked 20 different sticks but I realized I was wrong. So I got these 25 long thin cigars and I found them to be very enjoyable in the early evening,listening to music and watching the sun set. Very smooth and cool tastes. I like them I might just reorder them again.
4 out of 5
Quo Vadis Robusto
Received a box of 20 Dominican hand made robusto cigars. Never heard of Quo Vadis cigars, so decided to try one today. Flawless razor sharp burn to the nub, ash fall of more than half way. Taste, very light and have not reached medium body but i did get flavour changes from light grassy notes to slightly more stronger tobacco and leather. Good 4 star bbq / friends over smokes, it wont give anyone any dizziness and even my non smoking wife enjoyed few puffs. I will try few more after they sit in my humidor for couple months. Hope my next box will be something like in comments below:)
5 out of 5
2019 Las Calaveras LC50
Received these today and am so happy with the selection! Never tried these, but after a short stay in the humi I will be trying them out. Next box is getting ordered today!
4 out of 5
La Aurora Mystery Box
Five stars for the bargain, four stars for the cigar. I ordered two Mystery Boxes, and received two boxes of 25 La Aurora Palmas Extras (6 3/4 x 36) from the Dominican Republic. The cigars are very well made, and good for a long early morning smoke with a cup of coffee.
5 out of 5
MUCH better than I expected!
I ended up with a PDR small batch box of 24. Omg. Great smoke!
5 out of 5
Cubanacan Churchills
Received a 20 count box of Cubanacan Grand Reserve Connecticut Churchills. Slightly odd since Cubanacan is not listed in CI's list of available cigars. Still, a very good deal for the price.
4 out of 5
Great value
Great value
5 out of 5
Received PDR reserve 24 count
Pleasently surprised nice mystery
5 out of 5
Great Deal
Excellent buy! Received a box of PDR Habano Small Batch Reserve Grand Toro. Love these cigars and what a great value! I will look to buy more. Nice job Cigars International
5 out of 5
Amazing & Outstanding!!!
What a beautiful early Christmas surprise for me. Thank you so Much cigar International!!! For the mystery Box of 18 +, I received a Box of Aging Room Maduro + 25 La Aurora Palmas Extras box. CI's You made my day. I am Smoking Aging room now and it is Excellent by all means, can't wait to order the mystery boxes again. 🤠👏
5 out of 5
worth it!
Received a box of Vegas limited Churchill. Couldn't be happier.
5 out of 5
Fun times.
So I really enjoy the surprise of not knowing what I'll be getting. I've ordered 3 boxes separately. All 3 were different. La Aurora Cigarillos was a bit of a shock. As I though these were cigars only. But they ended up being pretty good. The other 2 boxes were from PDR. Legacy Small Batch in Churchill and the Capa Oscuro in robusto. Both are very good and new to me. I'll probably order one more box and hopefully get something cool. Cheers.
5 out of 5
Surprised!
Wow. Box of Graycliff Crystal, piccolo. Box used to sell for $240+. Can’t wait to try them!
5 out of 5
La Hoja
Received La Hoja Edicion Crema 1962 No. 6 Toro Gordo. They’ve been burning a bit uneven, but easy to fix.
5 out of 5
Take the Shot - It’s Worth It!
AMAZING! Box of PDR Small Batch Gran Reserve! Very happy with the quality of these. I will definitely be making more purchases of the mystery box 📦 if it is available in the future.
5 out of 5
Very Pleased
For this price and a new 400 count humidor to fill, I figured I would try my luck with 3 boxes. I was hoping for a variety and was a little disapointed to find they were all the same size and brand, La Aurora palma extra . After smoking one, I am very pleased with the result. I will absolutly try this deal again.
5 out of 5
Great deal, great smokes!
This was a tremendous deal! Got a box of PDR small batch reserve churchills. Got the deal of a lifetime you can't go wrong.
3 out of 5
Great Price
Great Deal! Just wish I got 2 different kinds rather then 2 of the same.....
4 out of 5
Will try my luck again
Got 2 boxes of minis, flavored. Not necessarily my cup of tea but seemed worth it. I’ll roll the dice again.
5 out of 5
Great Deal!
Ordered 2 boxes. I received 2 boxes of PDR Small Batch Reserve Habano Grand Toros. They are excellent sticks with good construction. Flavor is medium to full without being overpowering or cloying. These are not sticks that I would normally buy. But, I am very impressed. And the price! What a deal!
5 out of 5
Lots of fun
This is one of my favorite things. It's a lot of fun. First time I saw this deal, I got a box of Bahia Blu Tambor Edition. This time around, I got a box of Crowned Heads JD Howard Maduro 48s ($250 box of cigars!!!) and then a box of La Aurora Palma Reals (still a crazy good deal). Not a fan of the Bahias so much but they're good enough, but I got a crazy good deal on the other two boxes.
4 out of 5
👍🏻
Ordered 2 of these boxes this go around and got the same 2 boxes of sticks. Both were La Aurora. Not my favorite size but they seem to have good construction and burn well.
5 out of 5
Maybe a gamble, but it paid off.
I purchased this once before and got a box of so-so cigars, but this time I hit the jackpot! I won't name the brand, but I looked it up on this site and it's a $200 box! Some of you may get something you don't really like, but the ones I got are full-flavored and very tasty. As the description says, this purchase is a bit of a gamble. But you can't win if you don't play!
5 out of 5
Unbelievable value
I received a box of 24 of the PDR Cigars Small Batch Reserve Maduro Churchilll! Not typically a cigar I would choose on my own, but a wonderful smoke at an unbelievable value.
3 out of 5
never heard of it... not listed on web... truly a mystery
Received an off brand not even listed on the CI web page or on the web. I'll let the sit in the box for a bit then try them out
5 out of 5
A welcome surprise!
I love a surprise so I tried this for the first time with an order for 3 boxes and I'm happy with all three--better than I anticipated! So I just bought another 4 boxes; hopefully I will get lucky again. Well done, CI!
5 out of 5
awesome selection
Just recieved my two boxes today and all I can think is thank you CI!! These were PDR small batch maduro and habano churchills boxes of 24... I'm speechless... awesome selection and I'll be indulging again when available
5 out of 5
They treated me right!
I received a box of 20 box-pressed HC Habano2's. Outstanding! I will always buy a Mystery Box when offered.
5 out of 5
Real happy
Real happy
5 out of 5
Mystery
What a surprise to get 20 Pancho of Bahia Tambor What a great cigar they smoke great!
3 out of 5
Cigars weren't to my liking.
Cigars weren't to my liking. Off brands
4 out of 5
Good deal.
Good, every day cigar for good price.
5 out of 5
I would do it again!
For my mystery box I received Astral Maduro. Never had an Astral before but am a fan now! Looking forward to the next mystery box deal!!
5 out of 5
Nice
Scored a box of La Gloria Cubana coleccion reserva, I should've bought another box, and will definitely be looking out for this deal again!
5 out of 5
What a great way to start the year!
Wow!! What a surprise! New unopened box of Partagas 1845. Great Cigars! What a great way to start the year. Thank you! Thank you! Thank you!
5 out of 5
Great deal
I got a box of Graycliff for my box can’t wait to try my luck again
5 out of 5
Its a good year!
Couldn't be happier, received a box of twenty Partagas 1845 classics in 7x50 ring gauge. Very good value for the money and honestly for the price you cant go wrong I would've been happy no matter what box I got for this price. Everything is in good shape, the box was sealed and in new condition. Would take my chances again when this is available.
5 out of 5
Very pleased
HC Series Habano Colorado, and they taste great!
5 out of 5
Very Merry Happy...
First time purchase of the mystery box...received a box of 20 Partagas 1845 Classic Churchill's...to say I was happy with this is an understatement. Definitely will be trying again next year if offered.
5 out of 5
Unbelievable!
Bought 2, one was Sancho Panza, well worth it, 2nd box was very rare Macanudo Vintage 1984. Cant wait for the next one.
5 out of 5
Cuba Libre in my mystery box
Ended up with a box of Cuba Libre. Pretty good smoke.
4 out of 5
Small cigar
Cigars are small but tasty and my box was broken upon receipt