Click the icons below for product information.

Caldwell Blind Man's Bluff

This ain’t no bluff, you must try this cigar

Robert Caldwell has burst onto the boutique cigar scene like some sorta supernova, and it seems like there’s no stopping his meteoric rise. You see, he makes cigars his way…he scours farms across the globe for the best tobacco leaves, tests and retests his blends until he gets the exact flavors he’s looking for, and keeps production limited in an effort to deliver a superior product. My word is bond, son, and I’m telling you once you try a Caldwell cigar you will count yourself among his growing legion of fans.

Blind Man’s Bluff comes wrapped in an enticing Ecuadorian Habano leaf atop a refined Honduran Criollo binder, long-fillers from the Dominican and Honduras ramp up the intensity. Tasty notes of cedar, bread, and sweet spice all enter the fray with a long and cool finish topping off the experience. Do yourself a favor and pick this sucker up before everyone else beats you to it.

PackIn StockMSRPPriceQtyCart
Box of 20 + 5 CigarsBackordered$272.00
save $101.0137% off
Magnum (Gordo) (6.0"x60)
Pack of 5In Stock$45.00
Box of 20 + 5 CigarsBackordered$232.00
save $97.0142% off
Robusto (5.0"x50)
Pack of 5Backordered$37.50
save $2.005% off
Box of 20 + 5 CigarsBackordered$252.00
save $99.0139% off
Toro (6.0"x52)
Pack of 5Only 2 Left$40.00
Overall Rating4.58 out of 5 Based on 26 Ratings

Customer Reviews of “Caldwell Blind Man's Bluff”

Write A Review
5 out of 5
5 Star
4 out of 5
4 Star
3 out of 5
3 Star
2 out of 5
2 Star
1 out of 5
1 Star
Showing 1-26 of 26 Reviews
4 out of 5
Visitor’s Cigar
I got these in cigar fest. Very smooth, same flavor throughout, I would say it’s a beginner cigar. If you’re looking for different flavors along the way, if you want enjoy more in the middle and thickness of the smoke, that’s not for you. Good for the price that you pay and well worth the value of the cigar.
4 out of 5
Very nice
What a nice smooth cigar. Burns well and even. Nice draw,not too loose or too tight. Ordered 2 boxes
5 out of 5
Never heard of it, so I tried it.
Smooth, easy draw. Nice, slight hints of spice. Nothing too crazy, but there. Worth giving a try.
4 out of 5
Cigar Lover
Received one of these at cigar fest and enjoyed very much so I bought a box. I find this cigar very flavorful and a pleasure to smoke.
5 out of 5
Blind Man's Bluff
This is my favorite non-cuban cigar. Very complex in flavor. Sweet, mild and almost creamy at times.
5 out of 5
Just a consistent draw and great flavor
Very Consistent draw, tastes good to the end. Burns evenly
5 out of 5
Great smoke !
This cigar is a medium to full bodied and has flavors of coco and is not to spicy, A great smoke when you just want to relax.
5 out of 5
My new favorite!
Wow! Great cigar. Tried one of these in a CO sampler and fell in love with it. Excellent construction. Very thick, creamy smoke. Notes of creamy coffee, cocoa and caramel, yes caramel after the halfway mark My new favorite stick. You don't even have to retrohale to taste it. Retrohale it to get all the delicious flavors.
5 out of 5
Great Smoke
Great smoke. My go to all the time. Def buying again.
4 out of 5
Great smoke
Smooth and great body.
5 out of 5
One of my favorites
One of my favorites
5 out of 5
smokin good
The per-light so nice. Floral old world notes. The draw was effortless beautiful. And the leather and some chocolate and spicy hit the my pallet in waves for smokey delight. A very nice involving cigar. Construction was excellent :-)
5 out of 5
Blind Man's Bluff
Great smoke at an awesome price.
5 out of 5
Great stick!
Great taste, even burn and overall fantastic cigar for the price. would definitely recommend it to anyone !
3 out of 5
Just Ok!
Not what I was expecting from this cigar, very bland no transitions, not worth all the hype it was built up to be in my opinion!
5 out of 5
Caldwell continues to impress!
This is a very enjoyable cigar. Caldwell continues to impress. They are making waves and deservingly so!
5 out of 5
Nice draw burns great taste awesome!
5 out of 5
Consistent to the end
The reason I reordered this cigar is that it stays with you to the end no harshness towards the end like other I have had Nice draw
3 out of 5
I'm not impressed.
Nice construction, beautiful cigar, even burn, but I was not impressed. I've tasted much better cigars from Caldwell, Co. This one left me scratching my head. It was just a flat smoke and very one dimensional. There were no transitions in flavors, which I'm use to receiving from this company. I'll let the others sit for a couple of months in my humidor and see what develops, but I don't think there's much to work with flavors wise for a better profile later.
4 out of 5
Caldwell Blind Man’s Bluff
Great Smoke! Subtle flavor that sneaks up on you. Might be hard for a newer smoker to appreciate the subtle flavors, but a seasoned puffer will really enjoy it.
5 out of 5
Blind mans bluff
Always a great cigar
5 out of 5
a great smoke
One of the best non-rated cigars I've smoked lately.
3 out of 5
Uninspiring and lifeless
I wanted to love this cigar, I really did. I had heard so many good things. Ultimately, it wasn't a bad cigar by any means. The cigar is was medium bodied, but flat and lifeless. I was hoping for some flavor profile to emerge, but it never did. Just an average cigar that left me unimpressed.
5 out of 5
Great cigar
It was a smooth, satisfying smoke.
5 out of 5
Very good smoke well balanced
Very good smoke well balanced
5 out of 5
Blind Man's Gold
This is a very unique cigar. Very enjoyable! Excellent construction, as well as flawless draw. You get a salted Carmel, spice, cedar, and pretzel flavors on the palette. I would recommend this to anyone looking for a great botique cigar.
Caldwell 5-Star Sampler and Triple Torch Combo  5 Cigars Deal

FREE Caldwell 5-Star & Triple Torch Combo!

For a limited time, receive a FREE Caldwell 5-Star Sampler and Triple Torch Lighter Combo (worth $82.00) with select Caldwell box purchase!

Caldwell has been working hard to build a strong fan base and bring you phenomenal cigars since their inception a relatively short time ago. It seems like every release they put out has been a hit, destined for greatness. The Caldwell 5-Star sampler is the perfect way to sample some of their very best blends, and the included triple-torch lighter is the perfect accessory to have on hand to help get you burnin' em down. 

The Caldwell 5-Star Sampler & Triple Torch Combo includes:
1 – Caldwell E.S. Midnight Express Robusto (5” x 50) - 90-rated
1 – Caldwell Dos Firmas Robusto (4.7” x 52)
1 – Caldwell The King is Dead Robusto (5.5” x 50) – 93-rated
1 – Caldwell Eastern Standard Robusto (5” x 50) – 91-rated
1 – Caldwell Long Live the King Corona Gorda (5.7” x 46) – 91-rated
1 - Caldwell Triple-Torch Lighter

Shop Now