Sitewide Free Shipping! Just spend $99 or more.

Mellow to Medium Cigars

Sometimes in life, you just need a little extra pep in your step. A shot of espresso in your coffee, or, in this case, a bit more body to your favorite cigar. Enter our mellow to medium-bodied cigar category. Filled with brands that are just a hair above the mellowest of the mellow, these handmade cigars still pair up nicely with a cup of coffee, but have enough complexity to keep things interesting. Explore brands like Drew Estate Tabak Especial, 5 Vegas Gold, Hoyo de Monterrey Excalibur, Macanudo CafĂ©, Brick House Fumas, and many, many more. 

250 Cigars
Filter By
ACID Cigars by Drew Estate
ACID Cigars by Drew Estate62 Options4.72 out of 5Ratings1650 As low as $18.00 
CI Fresh-Rolled Cuban Wheels Cigars
CI Fresh-Rolled Cuban Wheels2 Options4.31 out of 5Ratings916 $69.00 
5 Vegas Gold Cigars
5 Vegas Gold18 Options4.52 out of 5Ratings1289 As low as $17.50 
CI Knock-Offs - Coffee Cigars
CI Knock-Offs - Coffee3 Options4.42 out of 5Ratings644 As low as $39.99 
CI Knock-Offs - Compare to Montecristo Cigars
CI Knock-Offs - Compare to Montecristo5 Options4.32 out of 5Ratings631 As low as $39.99 
Don Rafael Connecticut Cigars
Don Rafael Connecticut7 Options4.35 out of 5Ratings507 As low as $14.00 
Factory Throwouts Cigars
Factory Throwouts7 Options4.28 out of 5Ratings459 As low as $21.99 
HC Series White Shade Grown Cigars
HC Series White Shade Grown5 Options4.39 out of 5Ratings417 As low as $49.99 
Excalibur Cigars
Excalibur24 Options4.62 out of 5Ratings385 As low as $30.50 
Rocky Patel Vintage 2nds Cigars
Rocky Patel Vintage 2nds14 Options4.49 out of 5Ratings423 As low as $49.99 
ACID Kuba Kuba Cigars by Drew Estate
ACID Kuba Kuba Cigars by Drew Estate10 Options4.77 out of 5Ratings657 As low as $44.50 
Romeo y Julieta Reserva Real Cigars
Romeo y Julieta Reserva Real16 Options4.69 out of 5Ratings249 As low as $33.50 
Ave Maria Immaculata Cigars
Ave Maria Immaculata10 Options4.65 out of 5Ratings215 As low as $34.00 
John Bull Cigars
John Bull5 Options4.39 out of 5Ratings371 As low as $57.50 
Tatiana Flavored Cigars
Tatiana Flavored Cigars41 Options4.49 out of 5Ratings455 As low as $22.00 
Cuban Delights Cigars
Cuban Delights7 Options4.15 out of 5Ratings529 As low as $54.99 
Drew Estate Isla del Sol Cigars
Drew Estate Isla del Sol12 Options4.64 out of 5Ratings742 As low as $11.50 
ACID Cigars by Drew Estate Blondie
ACID Cigars by Drew Estate Blondie12 Options4.74 out of 5Ratings424 As low as $24.25 
Gurkha Park Avenue Cigars
Gurkha Park Avenue4 Options4.51 out of 5Ratings491 As low as $21.00 
CI Knock-Offs - Compare to Macanudo Cigars
CI Knock-Offs - Compare to Macanudo5 Options4.41 out of 5Ratings508 As low as $39.99 
Drew Estate Factory Smokes Connecticut Shade Cigars
Drew Estate Factory Smokes Connecticut Shade4 Options4.18 out of 5Ratings56 As low as $32.80 
Macanudo Ascots Cigars
Macanudo Ascots6 Options4.54 out of 5Ratings105 As low as $16.00 
Gilberto Oliva Reserva Blanc Cigars
Gilberto Oliva Reserva Blanc10 Options4.39 out of 5Ratings179 As low as $27.50 
Casa de Garcia Cigars
Casa de Garcia9 Options4.14 out of 5Ratings296 As low as $29.99 
Man O' War Virtue Cigars
Man O' War Virtue12 Options4.49 out of 5Ratings225 As low as $36.50 
Chillin' Moose Cigars
Chillin' Moose6 Options4.51 out of 5Ratings304 As low as $12.50 
Montecristo White Label Cigars
Montecristo White Label21 Options4.7 out of 5Ratings388 As low as $47.00 
Don Felix Cigars
Don Felix2 Options3.84 out of 5Ratings297 As low as $9.99 
CI Knock-offs - Coffee: Irish Cream Cigars
CI Knock-offs - Coffee: Irish Cream4 Options4.11 out of 5Ratings19 As low as $39.99 
Perdomo Reserve 10th Anniv. Champagne Cigars
Perdomo Reserve 10th Anniv. Champagne17 Options4.79 out of 5Ratings346 As low as $18.50