Sitewide Free Shipping! Just spend $99 or more.

90+ Rated Cigars

The crème de la crème, this star-studded cast is in a unique class all their own. This collection is of the industry’s top manufacturers, all boasting their most prestigious blends. Each and every one of these gems is equipped with a 90-point rating or higher. All the high rollers are here – From Don ‘Pepin’ Garcia to Alec Bradley and from Rocky Patel to Padron. Now it’s easier than ever to find your favorite top rated blends.
267 Cigars
Sort By
Filter By
Macanudo Cafe Cigars
Macanudo Cafe43 Options4.53 out of 5Ratings818 As low as $11.99 
Montecristo Classic Cigars
Montecristo Classic16 Options4.52 out of 5Ratings240 As low as $13.75 
Romeo y Julieta 1875 Cigars
Romeo y Julieta 187518 Options4.5 out of 5Ratings704 As low as $11.10 
CAO Brazilia Cigars
CAO Brazilia12 Options4.78 out of 5Ratings614 As low as $24.50 
Montecristo Platinum Cigars
Montecristo Platinum11 Options4.56 out of 5Ratings392 As low as $41.50 
5 Vegas Classic Cigars
5 Vegas Classic16 Options4.45 out of 5Ratings739 As low as $17.00 
Rocky Patel Super Ligero Cigars
Rocky Patel Super Ligero3 Options4.52 out of 5Ratings123 As low as $35.50 
Excalibur Cigars
Excalibur24 Options4.62 out of 5Ratings385 As low as $30.50 
Padron Cigars
Padron67 Options4.75 out of 5Ratings447 As low as $22.50 
La Gloria Cubana Serie R Cigars
La Gloria Cubana Serie R20 Options4.66 out of 5Ratings454 As low as $29.00 
Oliva Serie O Cigars
Oliva Serie O14 Options4.6 out of 5Ratings333 As low as $31.50 
Gilberto Oliva Reserva Blanc Cigars
Gilberto Oliva Reserva Blanc10 Options4.39 out of 5Ratings179 As low as $27.50 
Alec Bradley Prensado Cigars
Alec Bradley Prensado13 Options4.72 out of 5Ratings289 As low as $45.50 
Rocky Patel Vintage 1990 Cigars
Rocky Patel Vintage 199022 Options4.52 out of 5Ratings216 As low as $40.00 
La Perla Habana Black Pearl Morado Cigars
La Perla Habana Black Pearl Morado6 Options4.34 out of 5Ratings345 As low as $21.00 
CAO Black Cigars
CAO Black10 Options4.41 out of 5Ratings429 As low as $22.00 
La Aroma de Cuba Mi Amor Cigars
La Aroma de Cuba Mi Amor12 Options4.77 out of 5Ratings161 As low as $35.50 
Rocky Patel Decade Cigars
Rocky Patel Decade Cigars15 Options4.64 out of 5Ratings363 As low as $46.80 
Torano Noventa Cigars
Torano Noventa6 Options4.19 out of 5Ratings443 As low as $16.00 
Punch Gran Puro Nicaragua Cigars
Punch Gran Puro Nicaragua8 Options4.45 out of 5Ratings44 As low as $25.00 
Arturo Fuente Gran Reserva Cigars
Arturo Fuente Gran Reserva58 Options4.7 out of 5Ratings341 As low as $19.00 
Drew Estate Undercrown Maduro Cigars
Drew Estate Undercrown Maduro20 Options4.64 out of 5Ratings397 As low as $16.50 
Alec Bradley American Sun Grown Cigars
Alec Bradley American Sun Grown12 Options4.46 out of 5Ratings158 As low as $25.00 
La Aroma de Cuba Cigars
La Aroma de Cuba18 Options4.65 out of 5Ratings144 As low as $23.50 
Punch Gran Puro Cigars
Punch Gran Puro10 Options4.46 out of 5Ratings156 As low as $26.00 
La Gloria Cubana Cigars
La Gloria Cubana36 Options4.46 out of 5Ratings201 As low as $15.99 
Rocky Patel Sun Grown Cigars
Rocky Patel Sun Grown13 Options4.44 out of 5Ratings137 As low as $17.00 
Torano Exodus 1959 '50 Years' Cigars
Torano Exodus 1959 '50 Years'6 Options4.52 out of 5Ratings364 As low as $28.00 
Partagas Black Label Cigars
Partagas Black Label17 Options4.64 out of 5Ratings195 As low as $18.69 
Torano Exodus Gold 1959 Cigars
Torano Exodus Gold 19598 Options4.57 out of 5Ratings60 As low as $27.00 

Shop all 90+ rated cigars. The highest rated cigars at the best prices, in stock and for sale at Cigars International