Sitewide Free Shipping! Just spend $99 or more.

90+ Rated Cigars

The crème de la crème, this star-studded cast is in a unique class all their own. This collection is of the industry’s top manufacturers, all boasting their most prestigious blends. Each and every one of these gems is equipped with a 90-point rating or higher. All the high rollers are here – From Don ‘Pepin’ Garcia to Alec Bradley and from Rocky Patel to Padron. Now it’s easier than ever to find your favorite top rated blends.
267 Cigars
Sort By
"
"
$
$
Filter By
Macanudo Cafe Cigars
Macanudo Cafe43 Options4.53 out of 5Ratings818 As low as $11.99 
Montecristo Classic Cigars
Montecristo Classic16 Options4.52 out of 5Ratings240 As low as $13.75 
Romeo y Julieta 1875 Cigars
Romeo y Julieta 187518 Options4.5 out of 5Ratings704 As low as $11.10 
CAO Brazilia Cigars
CAO Brazilia12 Options4.78 out of 5Ratings614 As low as $24.50 
Montecristo Platinum Cigars
Montecristo Platinum11 Options4.56 out of 5Ratings392 As low as $41.50 
5 Vegas Classic Cigars
5 Vegas Classic16 Options4.45 out of 5Ratings739 As low as $17.00 
Rocky Patel Super Ligero Cigars
Rocky Patel Super Ligero3 Options4.52 out of 5Ratings123 As low as $35.50 
Excalibur Cigars
Excalibur24 Options4.62 out of 5Ratings385 As low as $30.50 
Padron Cigars
Padron67 Options4.75 out of 5Ratings447 As low as $22.50 
La Gloria Cubana Serie R Cigars
La Gloria Cubana Serie R20 Options4.66 out of 5Ratings454 As low as $29.00 
Oliva Serie O Cigars
Oliva Serie O14 Options4.6 out of 5Ratings333 As low as $31.50 
Gilberto Oliva Reserva Blanc Cigars
Gilberto Oliva Reserva Blanc10 Options4.39 out of 5Ratings179 As low as $27.50 
Alec Bradley Prensado Cigars
Alec Bradley Prensado13 Options4.72 out of 5Ratings289 As low as $45.50 
Rocky Patel Vintage 1990 Cigars
Rocky Patel Vintage 199022 Options4.52 out of 5Ratings216 As low as $40.00 
La Perla Habana Black Pearl Morado Cigars
La Perla Habana Black Pearl Morado6 Options4.34 out of 5Ratings345 As low as $21.00 
CAO Black Cigars
CAO Black10 Options4.41 out of 5Ratings429 As low as $22.00 
La Aroma de Cuba Mi Amor Cigars
La Aroma de Cuba Mi Amor12 Options4.77 out of 5Ratings161 As low as $35.50 
Rocky Patel Decade Cigars
Rocky Patel Decade Cigars15 Options4.64 out of 5Ratings363 As low as $46.80 
Torano Noventa Cigars
Torano Noventa6 Options4.19 out of 5Ratings443 As low as $16.00 
Punch Gran Puro Nicaragua Cigars
Punch Gran Puro Nicaragua8 Options4.45 out of 5Ratings44 As low as $25.00 
Arturo Fuente Gran Reserva Cigars
Arturo Fuente Gran Reserva58 Options4.7 out of 5Ratings341 As low as $19.00 
Drew Estate Undercrown Maduro Cigars
Drew Estate Undercrown Maduro20 Options4.64 out of 5Ratings397 As low as $16.50 
Alec Bradley American Sun Grown Cigars
Alec Bradley American Sun Grown12 Options4.46 out of 5Ratings158 As low as $25.00 
La Aroma de Cuba Cigars
La Aroma de Cuba18 Options4.65 out of 5Ratings144 As low as $23.50 
Punch Gran Puro Cigars
Punch Gran Puro10 Options4.46 out of 5Ratings156 As low as $26.00 
La Gloria Cubana Cigars
La Gloria Cubana36 Options4.46 out of 5Ratings201 As low as $15.99 
Rocky Patel Sun Grown Cigars
Rocky Patel Sun Grown13 Options4.44 out of 5Ratings137 As low as $17.00 
Torano Exodus 1959 '50 Years' Cigars
Torano Exodus 1959 '50 Years'6 Options4.52 out of 5Ratings364 As low as $28.00 
Partagas Black Label Cigars
Partagas Black Label17 Options4.64 out of 5Ratings195 As low as $18.69 
Torano Exodus Gold 1959 Cigars
Torano Exodus Gold 19598 Options4.57 out of 5Ratings60 As low as $27.00 

Shop all 90+ rated cigars. The highest rated cigars at the best prices, in stock and for sale at Cigars International