Mystery 5-Pack Cigars
Click the icons below for product information.

Mystery 5-Pack

I hope you’re feeling lucky, because today is not the day for cowardice. Presenting the CigarFU Mystery 5-Pack Sale – a roll of the dice that you’re sure to never regret. Here’s the skinny: I’m overloaded on a ton of 5-packs that are clogging up the warehouse in low quantities. So rather than creating a huge category of hundreds of options, I’m giving you the opportunity of a lifetime: while supplies last, score a Mystery 5-Pack of cigars for just $9.99! 

I know what you’re thinking: what sort of junk is in this thing? That’s where the good news lies lads — this assortment is chockful of grade-A options. Here’s some brands that could be included: CAO, Diesel, 5 Vegas, Alec Bradley, La Perla Habana, Graycliff, Cohiba, Rocky Patel, Ramon Bueso, and many more. Sure, there’s a few Quorums, Seconds, and Arganese, and machine-made brands in the mix, but you have my word that those are a minority of what’s up for grabs. Here’s the only catch: I can’t guarantee what brands you’ll receive… but if I were you, I’d grab 3 or 4 of these things and head for the hills. I’d bet my reputation that you’re going to come out on top. Also, while we’ll do our absolute best to avoid it, orders of multiple 5-packs may contain identical selections.

Mystery 5-Packs from some of the industry’s biggest brands are up for grabs, at an insanely low $2 per cigar. Stock up now, and take advantage of the biggest savings opportunity you’ll find this year.

NOTE: Each 5-Pack contains 5 of the same cigar, these are not 5-cigar samplers.

Size
PackIn StockMSRPPriceQtyCart
Pack of 5Out Of Stock$19.99
save $10.0050% off
$9.99 Notify
 
Overall Rating3.95 out of 5 Based on 81 Ratings

Customer Reviews of “Mystery 5-Pack”

Write A Review
5 out of 5
5 Star
39
4 out of 5
4 Star
17
3 out of 5
3 Star
14
2 out of 5
2 Star
4
1 out of 5
1 Star
7
Showing 1-50 of 81 Reviews
5 out of 5
Great Mystery Pack
Didn’t know what I was going to get and was pleasantly surprised!!
5 out of 5
Pleasantly surprised good quality cigars
Pleasantly surprised good quality cigars
3 out of 5
Nice flavor, a little too
Nice flavor, a little too harsh.
4 out of 5
Not Bad
Not bad at all
5 out of 5
Pretty good sticks
I got 5 big ring Gurhka’s, delicious cigars, I would purchase mystery cigars again.
4 out of 5
brand ??
I did receive a 5 pack of cigars however they did not have any name or bands on them so I don't know how I should grade them.If they were 2nds then I would say very good.but if they were, lets say, acid kuba kuba's then I'd say a good everyday cigar.
5 out of 5
Excellent surprises!
Fresh and quality smokes no disappointments!
3 out of 5
Decent sticks
Thought I'd get better but got some lower class Vegas 5's. They were alright though but small ring gauge.
5 out of 5
Mystery pac
Great smokes
5 out of 5
Great Deal
Very well pleased with the cigar quality and the amount of cigar in the pack.
4 out of 5
Try different things!
Bought these to bring in some variety at good price. So far pleased with choice, thanks.
5 out of 5
Smok'n good
great deal, awesome smokes. I'll buy some more soon.
4 out of 5
Got lucky. Diesel
Got lucky. Diesel
5 out of 5
Gurkha Legend Calcutta Club are SMOOOOTTHHH!!!!
For real this cigar is very smooth was 7" long burned even all the way to end not just 1 or 2 of them but all 5 and slow burning only had to light once. Went into catalog to get more but evidently not available yet? Hope they will be soon.
5 out of 5
GOOD STUFF!
I HAVE TO ADMIT THE MYSTERY PACK DIDNT LOOK REAL EXITING BUT I WAS VERY HAPPY WITH THE CIGARS. THANKS CI..
4 out of 5
Nice cigar. Like the quote
Nice cigar. Like the quote on the ring.
5 out of 5
excellent product
it was the smoothest tasting cigar that in have smoked yet
5 out of 5
These were a good smoke,
These were a good smoke, even burn. As an add on to my order very nice.
4 out of 5
Man of War
Smooth smoking. Even burn. Mild flavor.
5 out of 5
Greycliff
G2 Greycliff 5 pack is what I received. Solid smokes. Can’t beat the price. Greycliff has consistently proven itself as a high quality smoke.
3 out of 5
Mystery 5 pack
I got 5 elixir named cigars,It’s a good smoke however when tried to find out more about it it’s not sold anywhere including the foundry website
5 out of 5
5 MOW RUINATION GORDO FREE!
Winning! I got a fiver of MOW Ruination Gordo. $50 value! Thx! Feared some off brand sticks might come. Stoked!
1 out of 5
Not even cigars
What I received were cigarillos. Furthermore, the specific cigarillos were not even available on the Cigars International site (which is good, but then why were they sold as a mystery 5-pack?). I returned the order for a refund. Never again.
2 out of 5
Good, until it wasn’t
So, a buddy and I decided to grab some of these on the cigar fu deal. We split five five packs, and it was awesome. Five nice smokes, two of which were very discontinued, but 5 great smokes. We waited a bit and did it again. Not cool. Two reapeats and two smokes that I could by for $1.99 at the local corner store. The diesel pack was cool, but the rest, not so much. First time I have been disappointed by cigars international.
5 out of 5
Mystery 5 pack
I love the cigars but I don’t know what kind it was. I’m trying to find me a favorite
1 out of 5
Expected a variety
I was hoping for a variety not just a 5 pack of gurkha cigars. Not a big fan of them at all but it was worth a shot. No more mystery packs for me
5 out of 5
Ridiculocity
I didn't expect 4 great 5 packs... but that's what I got! Not a bad one in the bunch! Thanks CI!
3 out of 5
Tiny Macanudos
They are decent cigars but quite a surpise to receive such tiny little things
5 out of 5
Mystery pack...
Well no mystery now. My pack was Gurkhas... I love Gurkha sticks! Especially for the price.
3 out of 5
Mystery
It was ok, not sure I'll do it again.
5 out of 5
Very good rich and smooth
Very good rich and smooth taste I will definitely purchase again
4 out of 5
Great Value
Easy to order snd quick delivery. Wrapped well. Nice even coloring. Asteticly pleasing. I shall fire one up this weekend.
3 out of 5
All 3 5 packs were
All 3 5 packs were good smokes
5 out of 5
Great stick
Great stick
5 out of 5
5 pack
Great cigars, great price, always fast ship
4 out of 5
Decent robustos
Decent robustos
5 out of 5
Great every day smoke
Surprise deal
5 out of 5
Amazing!!!
Amazing!!!
4 out of 5
Pleasant surprise
3 out of 4 packs were excellent, top rated cigars the 4th was ok not one I would ever really buy. Certainly do it again
5 out of 5
5 Pack Suprises
I got 3 suprise packs and they were all top notch. More than happy with the purchase.
4 out of 5
Good cigars for the price
I enjoyed all 7 packs I bought. It was A LOT of Ghurkas but they were all good. However, my brother-in-law bought the same pack and didn't have as much luck as I did. He basically got some Po' Boy packs. I think it was worth the money to try though.
3 out of 5
Too many of the same
Too many of the same cigars.
1 out of 5
Uneven burn and harsh
Most of this mystery pack had cigars that burned unevenly and were very harsh on the mouth.
4 out of 5
Nice
Nice
5 out of 5
Tasty
CI never sends dreck. All 5 cigars were great smokes. Would recommend.
5 out of 5
Mystery solved.
The mystery 5 pack was an incredible bargain. Top of the line cigars at 2 bucks a pop. Well worth taking a shot on.
4 out of 5
First time trying Diesel . Nice surprise
Excellent cigar with even burning long ash, mellow great tasting, and nice draw.
4 out of 5
Call out the Militia
All surprises, but the real surprise was the Militia cigars. I looked and you do not have these listed in your cigar brands. I am sorry I did not try these earlier. They were smooth with a slight pepper taste but as you smoked more into the cigar it got creamier. The Punch Flavor cigars I gave to my neighbors and they enjoy flavored cigars. The Gurhka Touché Connecticut was as smooth and mild as any I have smoked. The Mystery 5 pack experience was good for me.
5 out of 5
Ghurka cigars
Good cigars, priced right. Was a mystery as to what I got, turned out great.
4 out of 5
Mystery cigars
Good 5 packs
5 out of 5
Rocky Patel? - Whaaat?
You can imagine my surprise when I received 3 five packs of Rocky Patel's. Yummmm!
5 out of 5
5 pack
good smokes one brand Alec Bradley 1997 harvest selection excellent. HOW DO I ORDER MORE OF THE AC brand. They are not in the catalog or on line
3 out of 5
Mystery 5 pack.
Bought 2 just to try. 1st was a Ghurka selection, nice cigar, worth the risk. 2nd was a dang flavored cigar. Fruit punch, I believe. Threw them out. Not a flavored cigar guy.
5 out of 5
Great deal
Bought the 5 pack I got Gurkhas and I love Gurkhas
5 out of 5
Landed a jackpot
Figured I’d roll the dice.. Ave Maria Argentum in robusto, not the normal figurado. Where else can you find that?? Wife says to me “why are you jumping up n down?”
4 out of 5
Better than I thought
I actually enjoyed it. I'm not a fan of Gurkha but the cigars surprised me.
3 out of 5
Not great
Some good ones,more not so much
2 out of 5
sub-par
Would not get the mystery pack again. Ring gauge was way to big for me. Received all low end Gurka cigars which were not good. Felt like it was a waste of money.
5 out of 5
Mystery 5 pack
It was a lot of fun and cigars were of higher quality than I expected. Do it again.
5 out of 5
Great group of cigars
Couldn't have been happier with the selection.
5 out of 5
Great variety bought 4 more
Great variety bought 4 more
4 out of 5
Mystery 5 Pack
That was fun, ordered 4 sets, very happy!
5 out of 5
Very pleased
I Was Hoping for full body cigars 3 out of 5 was 👍🏼
3 out of 5
It was interesting getting the
It was interesting getting the mystery five pack. It's like a crapshoot, luckily I got a few I've never tried!
3 out of 5
Variety was lacking
I ordered 6 packs. Package came busted up with only 5. I called and they quickly sent me a replacement. However, out of the 6 packs, 4 of them were Gurkhas. I love me a good Gurkha, but a variety would have been nice..
3 out of 5
Mystery
All were in larger sizes, 6-7 " long, ! pack very good, other 2 were average at best, Ok for the money
5 out of 5
EXCELLENT
THOSE CIGARS WERE EXCELLENT!!!
5 out of 5
I have enjoyed each of
I have enjoyed each of the cigars within the mystery packs.
5 out of 5
Gurkha Mystery 5 Pack
Excellent smokes!! Was a. It hesitant due to the whole “Mystery” thing. Great choice, nice even burn. Great 45-60 minute cigars. Highly recommended!
3 out of 5
5 packs
The majority of the cigars were very good
3 out of 5
Gurkha review
The choices that were sent were a little disappointing
5 out of 5
Mystery 5 pack
Really good cigars for the price
5 out of 5
Fabulous
Delighted with the selections; got some that I've been wanting
2 out of 5
disappointed
A bit disappointed. Ordered three 5 packs and got G2, a Gurkha variety that apparently doesn't exist (Google search came up empty) and a flavored off brand that normally sells for less than it was priced in the 5 pack.
1 out of 5
Disapppinted
Same as Daniel S. ,3 5 packs-all gurkhas and not one of their better brands.
2 out of 5
?
Got Ghurka imperial dragon, and captain black tipped cigarillos. can't find them on this site to see what they are all about.. First time I have been unhappy with a purchase.I guess thats what you get for 10.00 a mystery 5 pack deal. They are still a mystery. The others were Black Pearl..I found them.
1 out of 5
Horrible
Horrible..I received 5 fruit punch cigars. I wouldn’t be upset if they were a knock off or second, but fruit punch? They are disgusting.
1 out of 5
What are the odds?
Ordered 6- 5packs and all were the same. Not bad cigars, but I was expecting a variety.
4 out of 5
Nice package
Nice selection fantastic
1 out of 5
What are the odds?
Ordered 6 "Mystery" 5 packs and all were the same (Gurkhas) Not a bad cigar but I was expecting if I ordered 6 packs there would be a variety, not all exactly the same.
5 out of 5
Good
Good