Your web browser is no longer supported.
Cigars International is committed to providing you with the best web experience possible.

Nat Sherman Metropolitan Reviews

Shop Now
Overall Rating 3.69 out of 5 Based on 16 Ratings

Customer Reviews of “Nat Sherman Metropolitan”

Write A Review
5 out of 5
5 Star
4 out of 5
4 Star
3 out of 5
3 Star
2 out of 5
2 Star
1 out of 5
1 Star
Showing 1-24 of 24 Reviews
5 out of 5
Top Quality Smoke
Been smoking cigars for 25 years and had never smoked a Nat. Smoked a natural union today and found out that I have been missing out on a top quality smoke. I'll be buying more.
4 out of 5
Great Morning Smoke
Creamy, slightly sweet, and solid flavor make this a go-to for me in the morning.
5 out of 5
New favorite, stays lit, clouds of smoke.
This is one of my new favorites. Good flavor, copious amounts of smoke. Stayed lit very well, few relights despite some interruptions. Smooth flavor all the way down till I worried I might singe my beard.
2 out of 5
Nat Sherman Metropolitan Review
Not one of my favorite cigars. I also ordered the Nat Sherman Hampton and Sterling and really enjoyed those, but the Metropolitan lacked in flavor and complexity.
3 out of 5
Not 70 ring
I ordered the Bankers because I was looking for a very large ring gauge. The cigars I received were definitely no larger than the 60 ring cigars in my humidor, and much smaller than the 70 ring Asylums I have. However, the cigar was an enjoyable smoke, very creamy. If it had been the size advertised I would have given 5 stars.
2 out of 5
Can't recommend
Very big and very well made, but dull, expensive and with a slightly hard pull.
2 out of 5
The Banker may have taken me to the bank?!
Received a really bad taste in my mouth upon lighting this oversized maduro which I have never tasted in any other of my stogies, ofcourse I was concerned, it didn't get much better. I've heard mixed reviews but always wanted to try a Nat Sherman thinking they were a better cigar but I may have been mistaken? I will let the other bankers sit in my humi for a few months to see if they improve.
5 out of 5
seal team 6 grade cigar
picked up a fat nat p.sherman 72 wallaby way Sydney cigar down in Biloxi MI a little while back when I was there visiting and they are simply the straightest C-gars ive had since. I won't drop a Benjamin on a box of seagars unless it's a box of p.shermans metropolitan. delicious, scrumptious, gorgeous cigar
5 out of 5
i appreciate the consistent quality
i appreciate the consistent quality of both nat sherman and davidoff. my cigars arrived in very good condition.
5 out of 5
Great bang for the buck
This is a complex little devil with great flavor. I have smoked this cigar in both natural and Maduro, and in Churchill and robusto sizes. It has never disappointed. I am new to smoking, and have tried a lot of cigars. This is my go to smoke. It's the first non-sampler smoke I bought, because eI knew I loved 'em....
5 out of 5
Great cigar and value
Nat Sherman cigars are always uniformly excellent smokes. Mild to medium in strength
5 out of 5
Harry Bailey
My recent purchase of Nat Sherman (Halmilton's were delivered on time and we're in very good condition I smoked one and it was awesome, smooth and relaxing. Thanks CI.
3 out of 5
sticks not up to standards I expect from Nat....
4 out of 5
John NY
Great medium body smoke for the money
1 out of 5
Not my kind of stogie
It was a one dimensional amok it really didn't do anything for me
3 out of 5
It's a Nat Sherman
I gave this a cigar a three not for the taste, I prefer a multidimensional smoke. This ain't it. However, construction and a razor tight burn tells me it's a first rate cigar.
Customer Testimonials
I will be purchasing many more of these! Great cigar.
Nat Sherman Metropolitan - Natural (Union) - Cold draw of sweet nutmeg, caramel and citrus. Very easy to light. Excellent construction, draw and burn. Heavy smoke output that is slightly oily on the palate. Light to medium strength with medium flavors. Crisp citrus and caramel flavors with sweet brown sugar, leather and cedar on the finish. Very refreshing blend with no spice or bitterness.
Nat Sherman Metropolitan Maduro (Banker) Very easy light despite the very large ring gauge. Very good construction, draw and burn. Above average smoke output. Thick and oily on palate. Mild-medium strength and medium flavors. Flavors of deep leather, mild dark spices, aged tobacco and caramel. Deep leather and sweet cedar on a medium finish. Slight bitterness set in past half way, likely due to the large ring gauge of this example.
The Nat Sherman Churchill is my 99.9, what a cigar. The taste, the draw is the leader of a fine cigar.
I just had to post. I never thought I enjoy a cigar this much, the taste, the draw, I cannot put into words. In my life I have very few enjoyable moments but having a Metropolitan Churchill makes my day.
I'll never know why I waited so long to try this wonderful cigar. This is simply the finest rolled cigar I've ever held in my hand. The neatness of this hand made cigar is artistic. The cap is round and clean. The draw is perfect. The smoke is like butter, real butter not some whipped spread with 27 ingredients with names we can't pronounce. This is butter cream, with hints of light spice in the mix. The pepper is faint while the new leather is up there with the butter. I would not label this as a Mild cigar, but just a small pinch above mild. To me, this cigar sits right in that just right area of flavour. Please do yourself a favor and try one of these. You'll see why Nat Sherman has been around so long and has some of the very best cigars money can buy.
I greatly enjoyed the Metropolitan Maduro 5-pack so much that I went to order a box and accidentally ordered the Natural instead. It turns out the Natural is just as good. Unlike most mild cigars it had a great deal of flavor to it. Both the Metropolitan Maduro & Natural will become a permanent staple in my humidors from now on.