Your web browser is no longer supported.
Cigars International is committed to providing you with the best web experience possible.
Close

Victor Sinclair Overruns Reviews

Shop Now
Overall Rating 3.83 out of 5 Based on 115 Ratings

Customer Reviews of “Victor Sinclair Overruns”

Write A Review
5 out of 5
5 Star
46
4 out of 5
4 Star
32
3 out of 5
3 Star
16
2 out of 5
2 Star
13
1 out of 5
1 Star
8
Showing 1-50 of 133 Reviews
1 out of 5
victor sinclair overruns
1star just ok not great
4 out of 5
Victor Sinclair Torpedo Overruns
Not too bad for the price. Several had roll issues and started to come apart as I smoked them. Over all not a bad deal and I ordered again.
3 out of 5
A little dry
I like the overruns but I've gotten three times and they've been dry
4 out of 5
Good smoking when working
The cigars were just right while doing a little hard work,poking around the garage.
5 out of 5
Overruns
They were very smooth smoke.excellent price n cigar
5 out of 5
nice smoke
love them.the price is nice,lot's of smoke.they do run a little bit near the end but all and all great every day smoke.
2 out of 5
I guess you get what you pay for.
The draw is good. It burns evenly. It stays lit. The flavor is just not that good.
4 out of 5
Hey! Pretty good!
From my experience, most of these cigars were quite good, in both taste and construction. One or two had a rank flavor for the first inch of burn, but mellowed out and became quite enjoyable. If you get a crappy one, they're so cheap that you might as well just stub it out and light another.
3 out of 5
Victor Sinclair Toro Overruns
Second time I have purchased these. The first time I got these I was very impressed with the quality of the smoke for such a low price. This second purchase has done a complete 180, the quality has dropped dramatically, they are full of hard stems, can't keep them lit, and when you do they burn unevenly, taste is very woody. I think I'll pass on these next time.
4 out of 5
Great Deal
I purchased these for the first time. They did not disappoint. For the price they pass the taste test. They burn evenly and have an easy draw. The only negative I would find is the rings size is smaller then advertised. At least it seems that way to me.
5 out of 5
Very Nice
I enjoy a milder cigar and these fit the bill. Great deal.
5 out of 5
nice for the price
Well wrapped, smooth draw. I use a punch and the cap says firm. Good value for the price
5 out of 5
great
to bad u dont offer 6 stars
5 out of 5
Great Value
Bought these for the golf course and the occasional relaxing smoke on the deck. Found that these were a great value and were comparable in taste to much more expensive smokes. Great find!
5 out of 5
WILL BUY AGAIN
WILL BUY AGAIN
5 out of 5
Great cigar for the price
Excellent for the price. All of the cigars are not perfect because they are overruns but the price makes them great. I've smoked the Robusto and they were great but I like the Torpedo better.
5 out of 5
My husband loves them
Great price. All of the cigars are not perfect because they are overruns. The price is too good to pass up.
5 out of 5
International
Live in Germany and I still receive great service...Yes!
3 out of 5
some of the overruns were roadkill
This was a very difficult order to review. Some of the sticks were well made, had a nice draw, even burn and good flavor. Some of them did not. Out of the fifteen sticks I received I would put five of them in the "next time, run over to the dumpster with these overruns" category.
2 out of 5
Not enjoyable
While I have no problem with the taste of these cigars I have to mark them way down for quality. I realize these are categorized as overruns but I didn't expect that to mean they were packed way too tight, burned very unevenly, and canoed several times. With many of the batch I had to draw 4 to 5 times just to get some smoke produced and to keep them from going out. Not a very enjoyable smoke. I would never buy these again, nor would I recommend them.
1 out of 5
not good
Sent them back
4 out of 5
Good everyday cigar
Nice medium body smoke. Smooths out nicely at the half way point.
4 out of 5
Great Smoke
Only 1 of the bunch was peeling, all others were great. Smooth cigar with a great draw.
2 out of 5
Eh...
It's just OK. Good enough to give away to the free-loader friends that want a cigar after throwing back a bunch of beer during a house party. Not what I would turn to if I wanted to sip some scotch and enjoy a quality smoke.
4 out of 5
Good buy
Good buy for an everyday smoke.. Flavorful
5 out of 5
Excellent, mild stick. Hated to smoke 'em. Wanted to save them!
Great cigar. Perfect burn on each and every one. I'll be getting more on my next order.
5 out of 5
Victor Sinclair Overruns
Excellent cigar hope CI continues to have availability. Will purchase again
3 out of 5
decent smoke, decent price
minor construction issues. an occasional uneven burn seems to self-level. great yardwork smoke
3 out of 5
pretty good smoke
pretty good smoke
5 out of 5
EXCELLENT SMOKE
I love these cigars when fishing,smooth burn ,excellent taste and reasonable price
5 out of 5
Great Smoke
Easy on the draw,mild and in all a great smoke !
4 out of 5
Good Affordable Cigar
The Victor Sinclair overruns are a nice mild smoke at an attractive price. I like them more than the Bahia Blus I have smoked, but less than my favorite Brocatus Churchills.
5 out of 5
Price is right
For the price, these are very good. Burn well, light but pleasant flavor. Could not detect any blemishes.
2 out of 5
Not great
Not a very good cigar even with the low price. un-even burn, some of them had very hard draw even after using a draw poker.
5 out of 5
Handed these cigars out at
Handed these cigars out at a charity golf outing. Everyone seemed to enjoy them
5 out of 5
Great smoke
i found these Victoria Sinclaires a great smoke for the price. Flavor remained the same from start to finish.
2 out of 5
OVERRUNS OR SECONDS?
Recently purchased some Victor St. Clair overruns. I was very disappointed. They seemed like they were seconds. They were dry with very poor construction, and had many where the wrapper came right off. I know they make a great cigar, but very disappointing. Will not buy these again.
5 out of 5
Great cigar
Very good every day cigar
4 out of 5
Very nice
great mild taste. Awesome cigar
4 out of 5
Good Value
Excellent cigar for the price. Good construction, even burn and quite flavorful.
3 out of 5
Good smoke for the price
Fair flavor, no bite. Good front porch and a beer smoke.
4 out of 5
Cheap enuf 4 me
Good everyday cigar
4 out of 5
Good smoke , great price
After a few days in the humi they were mild and all had a nice square burn, Great cigar for the money
5 out of 5
its an good stick
its an good stick
4 out of 5
first half great second half
first half great second half not so good
5 out of 5
V.C
V.C
2 out of 5
THESE CIGARS WERE NOT FRESH.. DRIED OUT SO THEY DIDN'T BURN WELL OR TASTE THAT GREAT. NOT WORTH THE MONEY. TOO MANY OTHER TO PICK FROM THAT ARE MUCH BETTER FOR THE MONEY.
MOVE ON TOO A BETTER BUY..
4 out of 5
Good over-run.
I found these cigars pretty good for an "Over-run". Especially attractive was the price. I also liked the quick turn around from order to delivery )Besides price, one of the reasons I shop at CI). Several of my friends make it to "Cigar Fest" every year. It's on my "to do" list.
3 out of 5
Inconsistent
Most were very dry but the humidor is taking care of that. Some are very hard to draw. I prefer an easy draw mild smoke. Not sure I will purchase again.
5 out of 5
Good cigar
The VS over runs are well worth it for an everyday smoke.
3 out of 5
a decent 'everyday' smoke
Tough to beat for the price; nice medium flavor from first draw down to the last couple of inches where it begins to get a bit hot.
3 out of 5
victor sinclair overruns
good smoke for the money
3 out of 5
Victor Sinclair Overruns
Hard to draw, a little bitter. Not as good as I expected.
1 out of 5
Not a Fan
I purchased these cigars based on the description that they were overruns and not seconds, however I was unable to smoke any of them. Each stick was dried out and falling apart. Thankfully CI accepted them as a return and I was able to purchase something more enjoyable. It may a while before I try anything other than "firsts".
5 out of 5
Great value
My second order for these babies I generally reserved for yard work. But now I take the golfing as well. They're smooth flavorful. A great b uy.
2 out of 5
II'
I've smoked three of them and they are really badly made. all three have come unraveled while smoking them. I would not purchase any more.
2 out of 5
Not as good as I
Not as good as I thought they would be
1 out of 5
poor wrap
Harsh uneven burn, several have the outer wrap come off.
3 out of 5
Victor Sinclair Overruns Churchill,
They were not as tightly rolled as I expected, being a Victor Sinclair. That, I’m sure, contributed to the fast burn and loose filler. Being a ‘Mild” smoker they were a bit on the hearty side. I wouldn’t say the experience was worth the investment.
5 out of 5
Yummy
Yummy
4 out of 5
Great for the price
When I ordered I expected to get seconds or rejects that did not make the cut. I am pleasantly surprised to find out that they are excellent quality Victor Sinclair sticks.
2 out of 5
Disappointing
Harsh to the tongue right from the get go. Disappointing.
4 out of 5
Victor Sinclair Overruns Robusto
Purchase 60 cigars in 4 15-cigar packs. The consistency and quality (texture, taste, burn) of the smoke varied somewhat from cigar to cigar, but overall a good smoke for the price. I would buy them again.
5 out of 5
Good golf & work Smoke
Just what the title says,,,,,,
4 out of 5
Consistently good
Great value; smooth draw; a good everyday smoke
2 out of 5
Terrible
These cigars were poor quality, wrappers kept unrolling, terrible burn. Waisted most of the bundle.
4 out of 5
Just a little too light!
In my opinion the smoke was just a little too light. It has a very easy pull and the taste is good, I just wish a it was a bit more substantial.
3 out of 5
victor sinclair overruns churchill
I was disappointed. Poor burn and draw
4 out of 5
Smooth
Very smooth and not to over bearing taste, really enjoyed smoking them
1 out of 5
Save your money
Thought I'd try something different. Mine came stale and cracked when trying to plug it, burns up one side and gives you a mouth full of tobacco. A total waste of money and my last purchase from cigars International. At least they could have sent fresh cigars.
5 out of 5
VS Churchill overuns
Nice smoke, mild and smooth!
5 out of 5
Sweet deal.
These are some really nice cigars. I've ordered a few bundles and they're really nice and mellow. The draw is decent and the smoke is nice and full. Some are a bit dry but a little time in the ol' hot box'll fix that. Forget that there're overruns, these Victor Sinclair's are the way to go if your lookin for a nice cheap smoke.
3 out of 5
Good Price, Fair Smoke
Burned easy and even, light smoke. Good draw. OK wrappers and all around pretty well made cigar. Not a hot burn to be found. Not packed particularly heavy though, a little light on the leaves. Clean flavor, not harsh or sour when finishing.
4 out of 5
Nice cigar, worth the money.
This were some really fine cigars, especially for overruns. The only reason this doesn't get five stars is that about 3 out of the 15 were just too tight on the draw but otherwise these are a great smoke. Don't forget to leave'em in the humidor for a couple weeks. I've already ordered these again!
4 out of 5
Excellent price
Nice cigar for the price. They are overruns so every cigar is not perfect but for the price you can't go wrong.
1 out of 5
Not worth it, even at this price!
Okay, I get it.....These are very inexpensive, but the first three out of the package completely came apart upon clipping. Don't waste your money.
5 out of 5
Excelent cigar for the price,
Excelent cigar for the price, mild but very good flavor, burn well.
4 out of 5
Victor Sinclair Overruns Churchill
Excellent smoke for the price. Mild and of good quality. I will order these again.
5 out of 5
good cigar for the price
good cigar for the price
3 out of 5
Close; but no cigar.
Decent; not great, they burn evenly, kinda heady.... Better when v-cut vs punch. This would be a decent starter cigar for someone on a budget. They also would be decent to use for an infused cigar with your fave liquor
5 out of 5
Sinclair Overruns
These are a good mild smoke worth the cost. I keep some of these on hand.
5 out of 5
Excellent service; prompt reliable delivdry.
Victor Sinclair overruns live up to the description. A very good cigar -- especially for the price. I have ordered these cigars several times in the past and have always been completely satisfied.
4 out of 5
Economic and satisfying
Economic and satisfying
5 out of 5
Victor Sinclair
GREAT CIGARS... TERRIFIC SERVICE WITH YOUR COMPANY..
4 out of 5
Very good Cigar for the short cake!
Tasty and mild smoke for a very reasonable price. These smokes burn evenly, light well and can be enjoyed for a good 45+ minutes. I like to relax with one during my commute home every evening.
5 out of 5
Groovy
Damn fine smoke, they take a bit of getting use to but worth the money. I will order more
4 out of 5
Good price. Good value.
Worth the price. Taste good. Would recommend.
5 out of 5
Great Cigar!
Very good cigar.. Smooth and the taste is just as described. I would recommend leaving in the humidor for a few weeks as I've found that they arrived dryer than preferred to smoke without cracking or unraveled wrapping. This is a consistent cigar that is good all the way through to the nub. No heat issues. Even burn.. Just a great deal for what's offered. I recommend it!
2 out of 5
won't buy again
There is no consistency. One out of three is a good smoke. The last one I tried I threw away, in the yard, pretty quickly. The draw was so hard it was work to smoke.
5 out of 5
Great prices for great cigars
You won't find a cheaper price for wonderful cigars. Thanks Cigar International
5 out of 5
cigars
great cigars great service too.
4 out of 5
Not Fabulous/Not Rubbish
Smooth and mild, not peppery, which is good for me. A pleasant everyday cigar.
4 out of 5
CI Appreciation Season!!!
I work a lot of hours each week. I need the enjoyment that a good cigar affords. Cigars International has came through for me so many times that I just had to fill out this survey for my appreciation. I recommend CI every chance I get, and I hope CI continues to do well. I very much enjoyed the Victor Sinclair Overruns. I hate that word "Overruns" because it makes me feel like I am smoking tobacco droppings off the floor of a cigar factory, but if I closed my eyes, it was always a good smoke. I was really not thinking about how to rate its body, taste, or texture at the time. However, I left the stick always looking forward to the next one or three.
5 out of 5
Great service good smokes
My orders arrive on time and the selection is fantastic !
5 out of 5
Nice flavor
Great cigar for a quick smoke. Draws well and burns evenly. Nice mild taste. Will definitely keep them in my humidor.
3 out of 5
What I expected
Some of the cigars haven't been too bad while others have completely fallen apart, one as soon as I cut it. They are all pretty hard too, so be prepared to let them live in your humidor for a while.
1 out of 5
Keep Looking...
Cigar doesn't stay lit and the draw is poor. Taste is an issue too. Don't waste your money on this product. Other products I have ordered from C.I. have been great.
2 out of 5
Taking a chance
Victor Sinclair makes a wider variety of cigars. When you order these overruns you take the chance of getting something you don't like, The batch I got was so bad, that I never order these again.
5 out of 5
Excellence Dominican cigar
Very pleased with the recent order of Victor Sinclair that I received today. Have purchased all varieties of Victor Sinclair torpedoes but this was the best
4 out of 5
VS overruns
As a fellow who is fairly new to the world of cigars I find deals like the Victor Sinclair overruns to be perfect for me. Other than a few (3-4 in a bundle of 20) cigers that were plugged or wrapped to tight to allow for an easy draw and steady burn, the quality of this product really shined through. As a self reconized novice the visible beauty of each cigar I experience is not lost on me, but it does fall last after flavor, draw, even burn and the feel of each cigar I hold and smoke. To have the chance to really experience a taste of what Victor Sinclair has to offer was well worth the small price this overrun sample had to offer. Great work and my sincere thanks to the CI crew.
4 out of 5
Great cigar for the money
enjoyed the quality for a good everyday smoke. Even burn with nice taste
4 out of 5
it's a Victor Sinclair fer cryin out loud!
What's not to like?!? Nice price point to boot; you can't go wrong.
5 out of 5
Great cigar
loved them!
1 out of 5
terrible overruns, not recommended
i will not buy these cigars again! irregular burn, bitter, bottom of the barrel cigars. arrived so dry they crumbled when trying to cut. CI has many other options for overruns which are enjoyable.
5 out of 5
THANKS
A superb offering of an excellent cigar. If you want pleasure of favor and aroma and a well made even smoking cigar this is a bargain to seize. This is a quality mild and satisfying cigar as is the price. Thanks!
5 out of 5
pleasant surprise
Liking Victors, I was a bit hesitant on overruns. The hearty Sinclair draw was amazing.....would definitely recommend and will stock up on my next order....thanks
5 out of 5
Victor Sinclairs over runs torpedo
they are awesome great price
5 out of 5
good cigar for the money
Tasty cigar, enjoyed the smoke, shared some with friends, they said the same
2 out of 5
Not very good..............
They burned unevenly, Hard to draw and keep lite....Very dissatisfied.
5 out of 5
We need more overruns
great cigar. I ll take all the overruns I can get. Smooth even burn. Great while reading a book
5 out of 5
good value
Pretty good smoke, even better considering the value.
4 out of 5
A great smoke!
I have smoked cigars for about 15 years and don't recall ever trying Victor Sinclairs. Then my son introduced them to me and in short order they have become my primary cigar. The Overuns are just that they are not seconds. They have great flavor and a smooth easy draw. A great value!
4 out of 5
Nice medium body cigar for the price
Nice flavor. They burn evenly. A better than average everyday smoke for the price.
5 out of 5
always great
I consistently purchase from CI. The prices, variety, delivery and quality are always great. Irv
3 out of 5
Los Blancos churchills
Several of the individual cigars were made too tight and they would not draw.
Customer Testimonials
This is one true finger burner. I can't help every evening sitting down with one of these, a great stick to close out the day with. I tend to go for these every time I raise the lid on my humidor. I stock my humidor with much more expensive cigars but enjoy these better than some of them. And for the price they cannot be beat. Thanks CI for such an awesome deal this is my third round of them and will be watching for them to be back in stock. I hope to see them soon I'm getting low.
These were a great buy! My first from Victor Sinclair and I was impressed! Very smooth with a sweet creamy taste.
This is my first purchase from CI. I'm very satisfied with this stick; good burn, good flavor and great price!
I like this cigar as much as any banded Victor Sinclair I've had; more than a lot of them. Very tasty, mild stick and all I've smoked have been very well built.
Good sampler; it lets you know what is out there. All were good, but some were outstanding!!
Great smoke! Some are harder on the draw but definitely worth the price! Great cheap stick to smoke with friends that bum off of you.
A very nice smoke that tastes great and is very consistent in its quality. A solid every day stick that you can't go wrong with. It does have a tendency to burn somewhat unevenly, but will correct itself if you take a minute or two to let it do so.
Very good. They're not very strong, but they smoke well and the taste is pretty good. It's a great everyday economical smoke.
Ordered these for Christmas guests. They are great cigars, everyone enjoyed them. Very smooth with nice smoke and good aftertaste. Thanks CI, I'm developing into a raving fan!!!
What an awesome deal! At this price I have to fill the humidor. Quality smoke, good draw, with an even burn and excellent flavor! Don't let this one go without a try! Thanks again CI!
The VS Overruns may be the best "deal cigar" I've bought from CI. Very smooth, good draw, a lot of smoke. For the price, they can't be beat. I will hastily order more. Thanks again CI!
An affordable and solid evening smoke to help wind down a long day.
A daily smoke to wind down the day with.
Good everyday smoke!
I smoked 3 of the Victor Sinclair Overruns (Torpedos) this weekend and I wanted to finish the whole bundle. It ws a very smooth smoke and smooth draw as well. The price is right and I truly enjoyed each one.
Best cheap stick available. You do have to deal with a dud, but most burn as well as a full price Sinclair. I've had the robusto and toros, and the toros have been perfect so far. The robusto is still worth a try.
Nice smoke for the price but a little hard on the draw.
Great everyday cigars at a decent price...
Adroit