Your web browser is no longer supported.
Cigars International is committed to providing you with the best web experience possible.
Close

Casa de Garcia Red Reviews

Shop Now
Overall Rating 3.91 out of 5 Based on 35 Ratings

Customer Reviews of “Casa de Garcia Red”

Write A Review
5 out of 5
5 Star
14
4 out of 5
4 Star
13
3 out of 5
3 Star
2
2 out of 5
2 Star
3
1 out of 5
1 Star
3
Showing 1-50 of 50 Reviews
4 out of 5
Great Everyday Smoke
This is a great everyday smoke that will not disappoint. Construction and burn are very good. Great for working in the garage, mowing the lawn or just watching a sports game with your friends. I can’t say that I tasted anything special like cocoa, leather or any of that stuff, but there was a slight sweetness when you first fired it up and there was no harshness to it. I will certainly buy again and can honestly say that for a good everyday smoke these will not disappoint.
4 out of 5
The odd cigar is difficult
The odd cigar is difficult to draw. Otherwise satisfactory, good price & well constructed. John S.C.
4 out of 5
Decent smoke
Decent smoke
4 out of 5
Worth the wait
A very tasty smoke. Not complex,but mild. Was not impressed initially. I put them to sleep for about 3 months and the wait was well worth it. Very nice and affordable
4 out of 5
great cigar, will buy again..
great cigar, will buy again..
4 out of 5
Starts Sweet Finished Smooth
This is my second purchase of these and they are very consistent. The wrapper is a touch sweet starting out and it proves to be a nice smooth cigar. My only complaint is that they are a little tight and I occasionally have to work some hard spots out.
5 out of 5
best cigar I smoke.
Mild, even burn, sweet tip. Always enjoyed/
5 out of 5
Review grande red
very enjoyable for the right price
4 out of 5
Good everyday smoke
If you're looking for a lot of complexity,this probably isn't for you .But if you want a pleasant,enjoyable smoke with a touch of sweetness to go with your morning coffee,give this a try.
5 out of 5
First time shopper, and I'm
First time shopper, and I'm Very pleased with my purchase.
5 out of 5
Casa de Garcia red
Good cigar consistent drawn every stick would definitely recommend
5 out of 5
very good everyday cigar
very good everyday cigar
2 out of 5
Cigars were not fresh
A few of the cigars purchased were not fresh and would not burn or burned unevenly. I will not purchase that particular brand again but will possibly order from CI again. Thanks
4 out of 5
Draw issues
Initially purchased these from a local store, liked them and decided to buy a bundle from CI. The ones I got from the local store burned well and had a good draw. The bundle I got from CI seem to be inconsistent. The first couple I had were fine but the last 3 I smoked had really bad draw issues. The wrapper came apart on the last one. I keep them in a humidor at 68% along with other brands and have no issues with those so not sure if I got a bad batch or the quality is just inconsistent.
3 out of 5
Decent around the yard stogie
I found these to be a decent everyday around the yard cigar. They burn well and are mellow/mild smokes. The tips are slightly sweet (which I do not prefer) but after the first few drags it goes away. Decent everyday smoke for a decent price. I will likely order more in the future.
5 out of 5
Good smoke
This is a bargain mixed filler smoke that tastes great and has a good draw. The Dominican filler is very mild but also tasty. I could (and have) smoke(d) these all day.
5 out of 5
john b. west babylon n.y.
a great every day smoke at a price that wont stop you from getting a few super smokes to boot!
4 out of 5
CG Red Churchill
Ok draw, sweet taste on wrapper, tastes seem to last beyond label
3 out of 5
Aight
Pretty decent until you get about three quarters of the way through then it gets a little bitter... OK for the dollar amount but I wouldn't go out of my way to smoke another pretty good to give to your friends when they want to smoke when they are not really smokers
1 out of 5
casa de Garcia
This last batch I received was not very good. They didn't burn well and some were packed too tight and hard to draw.
2 out of 5
Not bad for the money
as stated in many of the reviews draw was difficult on many of the cigars. Initial lite was a bit harsh, but the remainder of the cigar was mild and tasty. Not bad for the money spent, but I don't believe I would buy them again . Somewhat disappointing coming from Altadis
2 out of 5
Not happy any more with these cigars
these have been my golf and work around the house cigar for sometime now. I even have some friends buying them and all were happy until the last couple of bundles. there are 5 or 6 or more cigars that will not draw. I checked with my friends and they are having the same problem. the last two bundles were the same I had to throw out some of the cigars.
5 out of 5
Casa de Garcia Red Toro
Nice, mild and comfortable cigar!
5 out of 5
Perfect Casual Cigar
Brought these to a Labor Day BBQ and they were an absolute hit. The added sweetness around the cap isn't overwhelming and adds a nice touch for those not usually into smoking cigars. Highly recommend!
4 out of 5
mostly nice casual smoke
Good burn ,mild cigar, occasionally too tightly warped, for the price you don't get to upset.
4 out of 5
Wonderful
The sweetness indeed. The stick I had featured a loose wrap cap, but that signature sweetness was still present. Makes the entire stick a great after dinner treat. I will definitely be visiting this stick again.
5 out of 5
Casa de Garcia Red Robusto Is a Wnner
Casa de Garcia Red Robusto is a pretty good cigar sugary tipped cigars like Swisher sweets don't have any taste when you star them and finish 'em Bu no the case with Casa de Garcia Reds. They give me a quick smoke when I don't need to spend hour or more puffing away. I like and will order again.
1 out of 5
Poorly Wrapped
I was unable to smoke more than half of these cigars because the wouldn't draw. They were wrapped too tight and I also couldn't keep them lite. A very poor product.
5 out of 5
Great smoke for the price
On my second bundle now and each one has been as advertised. Mild cigar with just a hint of sweetness.Burns well right to the end.
5 out of 5
Great Cigars with a hint
Great Cigars with a hint sweetness, great for the price. I enjoyed them.
5 out of 5
Fast & Great service
Very fast shipping and great products!
4 out of 5
well worth the money
Mild, tasty, decently constructed, I don't think you could or should ask for more in a cigar at this price.
5 out of 5
For the price, you can't beat these great cigars
Starting with their sweet tip, smooth draw and great flavor... these Casa de Garcia Red Churchill label cigars, in my opinion, compete with the best. Cigars are like wine... it's up to the palate of the individual and my palate is delighted.
1 out of 5
Disapointing
I was disapointed in this cigar. The construction was inconsistent. I will not purchase these again!
4 out of 5
Casa de Garcua Red Churchills
Pretty good buy for the money. I buy a brick about once a month. I have found a few that had stems but the vast majority draw well.
Customer Testimonials
Not considering the price, it is a very good smoke. Mild and smooth for the entire length with an easy draw and clean taste. Considering the price, this is a great cigar. I enjoy a mild cigar and this is most likely the best I've had in this price range and most I've paid 2 to 3 times as much for. My only negative - out of the 2 bundles purchased - is the 1-2 sticks per bundle that do not draw as smoothly as the rest. For that reason only I'd give this smoke a 4.5 of 5 star rating. Having said that, I will definitely buy more.
There isn't much I can say about this cigar that hasn't already been said by the other reviews. After about a week in my humidor, it was a great cigar, at a great price. I'll keep buying them; the sweetness makes them even better.
This cigar is a winner. Great burn, flavor and price!
Having purchased several cigars from CI, this is not my favorite, but hold on. Ive paid 3? 4? times as much for cigars that were not half as good as this one. Smooth front to back- no issues. Very light but in a good way, I don't like light cigars that linger on waste of time like cheap whiskey the flavors not there why bother. In that respect, you wont find much better than this cigar for the price. Slightly sweetend tip goes away after 2 puffs or use punch maybe 1/4 in, creamy, slight spice, excellent if you like lighter type cigars. You have to try these.
Was cautiously optimistic about the Red after reading the reviews. Have to say, it quickly has become my 'go-to' everyday cigar! Glad I discovered it and the previous reviews say it all about this gem. Enjoy lighting this one up!
I am a big Fuente fan; however, I found this cigar to be a diamond in the rough. A well constructed, consistently smooth cigar with sufficient spice and sweetness to make it stand out from other bundle cigars. Mild, yet flavorful, this is a great value.
I am a big Fuente fan; however, I found this cigar to be a diamond in the rough. A well constructed, consistently smooth cigar with sufficient spice and sweetness to make it stand out from other bundle cigars. Mild, yet flavorful, this is a great value.
Have tried many mild and medium cigars including 5 Vegas, Ghurka, and Victor Sinclair and keep coming back to the CG red. The sweet beginning just sets you up for a mild and tasty smoke that lasts all the way to the end. What I really like is that it never gets stronger as you get to the nub. That's a great cigar in my book.
Nice smoke for working outside, a good everyday smoke.
Definitely a great smoke. Sweetened tip that doesn't take away from the flavor of the cigar. Must use a punch to keep the sweetened tip, and it's still a great smoke without it. Great smoke for the price, with a strong spiced filler that in no way offends, but rather leaves you eager for the next puff.
This is a great cigar for the price. Pretty well made and good to the nub.
Extremely good buy. One cigar you won't regret trying, and for the price - unbelievable. Just ordered another bundle.
This by far is the best cigar for the price ! The sweet wrap and the lite draw makes it that much better .
A great smooth and light smoke for mild smokers like me.
This is an outstanding cigar for a "bundle cigar". I purchased several other bundle cigars that I wasn't pleased with but this one is a winner! A creamy mild cigar with just a hint of sweetness and burned very nice all the way to the label. Also it did not have that usual charcoal taste near the end which was very surprising. I never had the regular Case De Garcia but can't seem to imagine if that one is better. For a buck a stick, this cigar taste every bit of a $6-$8 cigar.
Adroit