Your web browser is no longer supported.
Cigars International is committed to providing you with the best web experience possible.

1876 Reserve Maduro Reviews

Shop Now
Overall Rating 3.77 out of 5 Based on 26 Ratings

Customer Reviews of “1876 Reserve Maduro”

Write A Review
5 out of 5
5 Star
4 out of 5
4 Star
3 out of 5
3 Star
2 out of 5
2 Star
1 out of 5
1 Star
Showing 1-43 of 43 Reviews
5 out of 5
I have been smoking these for a long time, and have never been disapointed with them.
5 out of 5
1876 Reserve Maduro Robusto
Great cigar for the price. A nice daily smoke.
3 out of 5
John Snowden
These are the best "buck-a-stick" cigars I found. Good size ans smoke for the price. Not the best cigar, but good for all the driving I do.
2 out of 5
like smoking a paper-bag
4 out of 5
Smooth taste
A nice smooth cigar with your beverage of choice. Smokes better when it's fresh out the Humidor.
3 out of 5
1876Reserve Maduro
Burns unevenly, some sticks packed very loose and others to tight. Lit end tends to burn very unevenly. Would not purchase again.
5 out of 5
Golf course smoke
Consistent and flavorful smoke. Inexpensive and great for sharing on the golf course
4 out of 5
Good all day smoke for th re price.
4 out of 5
Everday Smoke
Good everyday smoke, good quality, even burn good value for the price
3 out of 5
Robert Thompson
Some good some bad . Leaves come un wrapped on about half of these. Beside that it is a good smoke . My humidor is at right temp and humidity.
5 out of 5
Very good smokes at great price
The 1876 Maduro Torpedo is my go-to everyday smoke. Good flavor, well made and the price is right. What’s not to like.
5 out of 5
Keep up the good work
Keep up the good work
5 out of 5
Great Smoke for the price
Great Smoke for the price
1 out of 5
Nothing good to say. Wrapped terrible, doesnt stay lit, burns awful, and draws hard. Please CI keep thhem out of your store. People dont need this junk!
5 out of 5
1876 Reserve Maduro Churchill 2-fer
excellent taste flavor and quality for a cheap cigar
2 out of 5
They taste fine, but are
They taste fine, but are way too dry. The wrapper is still flaking off of them even after being in my humidor for 3 weeks now.
1 out of 5
Poor even for the low price
Inconsistent burn and often a poor taste.
4 out of 5
My Yard Cigar
I've tried other "economy" cigars but come back to this cigar time after time. It's smooth with a little bite. I smoke 'em most often while cutting the grass or working in the yard. They last about 45 minutes and I smoke them a numb. What more can you ask for, a solid smoke at a great price!
3 out of 5
Had a few that came
Had a few that came unwrapped
5 out of 5
Good Smoke
I greatly enjoyed the flavor of these cigars.
4 out of 5
Biggest bang for your dollar
A great cigar for the price. These sticks are so affordable I keep a bunch just in case I have to give out a few to my friends. Great draw and they burn evenly.
2 out of 5
1876 maduro
I have been smoking the 1876's for years and always found them to be mild, easy draw and even burning. But this last order was anything but mild, easy draw, or even burning. I went through all 50 and found very few that were what I expected DC
5 out of 5
Great Everyday Smoke
I have smoked over 200 of these cigars over the last two years, and have found them to be a very consistant everyday smoke. Everytime I pull one out to smoke I know what I will be getting.
5 out of 5
1876 Reserve
A good mild cigar for the money!
4 out of 5
1876 Reserve Maduro Churchill
Love this cigar for a everdayday cigar. Just waiting for the backorder so I can order more. The chuchhill is my favorite.
4 out of 5
1876 Reserve Maduro Bang for Your Buck
I am a big fan of the Nicaraguan cigars. I smoke the 1876's for my work 'gars. I can have a couple a day at $1.20 a piece without breaking the bank. Lots of flavorful smoke with an easy draw. I can hand them out to people regularly without wincing. Most folks like them. I save my higher end cigars for relaxing times with an adult beverage. Please don't stop offering up this 2fer deal. I will have to find another economical smoke.
Customer Testimonials
These are GREAT. Please do not let anyone else in on this bargain smoke. I have switched from my usual "mild" cigar to the 1876. It would be perfect if there was a Corona size available.
Excellent cigar in all aspects!
Another GREAT every day work cigar. It helps immensely when cleaning the barn. I always keep a few handy.
These are a great cigar...took them out on the golf course and all my buddies including one wife loved them. Taste great, burn great and smell great. Also not a horrible smelly mouth after. I recomment these for any cigar smoker or newcomer.
Calling all "been smoking premiums 10 plus years" crowd. Truly, this cigar will disappoint you in all the right ways. First off- massive plumes of smoke and a good draw. I've smoked 40 out of my 50 (Torpedoes) now and not a one has canoed. And secondly...well, there really isn't much else to say. If you don't "power-smoke" it, it won't run hot or go bitter. Flavor wise the wrapper hints at a much costlier stick while the cheapo Dominican filler puts you back in your place until you reach the 2nd half then the cigar is acceptable. Wish this company made a Nicaraguan blend as I imagine I could make it that "yardgar" I've been hunting for. However, if you like Dominican and want a "knock around" cigar by all means pull the trigger and just give em' at least a week in the humidor. I will order again solely because the volume of smoke is way out of the price class. Anything more than an "I need a Cigar" cigar? No...But they're also not anything less.
I agree with JB that this a more medium-full smoke, rather than a mild-medium. I found the wrap to burn a little uneven, but what the heck! At this price what's to complain about?
This is the first time I've been compelled to write a review, but I've found these to be an exceptional value. I'd classify these as a medium to full, with good flavor and construction. Definitely a great "go to" cigar that won't break the bank. I'll be ordering these again and again.
1876 Reserve Maduro is a good cigar, at this price it's a great cigar. I will buy more!
Only 3 sticks in so far, but so far, SO good! This has got to be the best kept secret on CI. So far, I've had good draws, great taste, and one of the best mild-medium experiences I've had since those black pearls I burned through a few months back. This cigar smells and tastes like a good $6 cigar, but in defense of my glowing review, I do love mild cigars. This maduro version adds a sweetness that actually contributes to the mildness rather than ruin it with a bump in strength. I'll keep ordering these as long as the deal persists. I don't know about the other sizes, but the torpedo is a home run in value.
SOOOOOOOOOOO much better then the the regular ones. Very very nice smoke.
Someone made a mistake pricing a $4.00 for only a little over a buck. This is one cigar that I will defiantly keep in my box a great everyday stick!
Good burn, construction and price. I've given several away and the comments have all been the same. This is not a mild-medium cigar. More medium-full.
I've been on the lookout for a "go-to" bundle stick for several years now. I've never found a bundle worth reordering and, believe me, I've left some pretty crappy reviews on otherwise top-rated bundles. Enter the 1876 Reserve Maduro. I enjoy this stick so much that I'll smoke two in a row. I can't speak for the other 1876.... but the Reserve Maduro is a better smoke than most $5 sticks I've had. It truly is the best stick for "a lousy buck."
These 1876 Reserve maduro cigars have to be the greatest bargain I have run across yet. This is my first order here and will be far from my last. Great draw and burn along with an excellent aroma to go with a slightly sweet and a bit chocolaty flavor. My only complaint is that I wish they came in a corona size. I am a rather small fellow and prefer a bit smaller ring gauge. Still though, when I make up the next order these will be included. GOOD SHOW! You have a new loyal customer!
I need to buy a truck load of these, because when all the reviews get posted they'll be hard for CI to keep in stock! We smoke a LOT of cigars, & are always on the lookout for something enjoyable in the value line for an everyday smoke. My search may well be over. Got a 2-fer of Robusto Maduros last week. Right off the truck on a chilly winter's day these were really not bad. Unwrapped them & loaded a humidor. Two days later I actually had 2 in one night. Yes, they were that good. Nice burn, nice ash. This stick looks & smokes unbelievably well for a $1 stick. Lots of smoke. Never got hot. Not really complex, but certainly not boring by any means. Slightly veiny, but truly consistent throughout the 2 bundles. If these settle in like I think they will, I'll vow to never run out of them. An hour of enjoyment for a buck makes me a happy guy! Thanks CI, keep up the good work!!!
At last!!! Been looking forward to these. Will be top of my next purchase priority. Been thinking for a long time that CI needed to get ahold of 1876 maduro. More to follow.
I bought 50 of them and they arrived the other day. I found them quite good and I am thus far pleased with my purchase. OK, so it is not a super premium cigar but the construction was good, smoke was just fine and ash was good and the flavor was very good. I enjoyed it more than the regular 1876 Reserve...the Maduro is not so mild without being overpowering. Heck, for a buck a stick (I purchased the Robustos) I will be sure to be buying more in the near future. Next time either the Toro or Churchill.