Your web browser is no longer supported.
Cigars International is committed to providing you with the best web experience possible.
Close

Casa Magna Corojo Reviews

Shop Now
Overall Rating 3.76 out of 5 Based on 33 Ratings

Customer Reviews of “Casa Magna Corojo”

Write A Review
5 out of 5
5 Star
14
4 out of 5
4 Star
7
3 out of 5
3 Star
7
2 out of 5
2 Star
0
1 out of 5
1 Star
5
Showing 1-42 of 42 Reviews
5 out of 5
Wow
Can't imagine buying my cigars anywhere else.
4 out of 5
Not bad
Smooth
5 out of 5
Great stick!
I have enjoyed very much and for the discounted price, shouldn't pass up
5 out of 5
great taste but most do
great taste but most do not burn well...will go out half way through and do not light back up easily...same thing on all sizes!
1 out of 5
A bit tastless
Order these for price only. Golf course cigar pricing but after smoking these so many times, I will pass in the future. Casta Magna Colorado much better and costly.
5 out of 5
Casa Magna
This was a highly rated cigar a few years ago - Cigar Aficionado. It still is a great cigar and CI makes it affordable.
5 out of 5
Great smoke
Excellent for the price
5 out of 5
2 tight
of these were real good but the rest of them had me looking for a wire coat hanger to get them to draw nicely.
3 out of 5
Cash magna
I say middle of the road decent smoke
3 out of 5
Good cigar
Good cigar
4 out of 5
Casa Magna licey
Overall the cigars were solid as I ordered them twice. The cigars were a little hard and a few wrappers peeled. I just had to keep,them in my humidor longer than usual.
1 out of 5
Big disappointment
The cigar was bitter, lacked flavor and didn't draw well. I won't purchase them again.
5 out of 5
Powerful yet smooth.
I love Casa Magna for their flavorful but smooth taste. I have been smoking these since they made their first appearance, they have never disappointed me. I recently gave these to a few friends at a big get together, these guys weren't regular cigar smokers, but they all liked the full yet smooth body of these. Get these while they're hot!!!!!
3 out of 5
Not too bad
They are a litter bitter.
5 out of 5
Enjoyable
Enjoyable
5 out of 5
Good Value
Good cigar at a good price point. One in the box burned a little inconsistently, but not enough of an issue to prevent me from buying in the future.
4 out of 5
Great smoke for the money!!!
Great smoke for the money!!!
3 out of 5
Bold smoke
expected more from it being the brand it is
3 out of 5
Casa Magna Corojo Gran Toro
Recent order seemed to be of more consistent quality. Great cigar but previously had one out of five cigars not burn evenly and wrapper came apart
1 out of 5
Lousy after the first 1/4th of every stick.
Bought 5 5 packs with a promo and was I ever disappointed!! The flavor and smoke quality in the first 1/4 of each cigar is delightful--- until it goes oit!!! And it did with every one I've smoked. CAN'T keep one lit for anything. After 3 sticks I decided to tear one apart and it was FULL of huge sticks and stems that should have been used in a fireplace!!!. Taste went harsh and every stick was a jekyll and hyde!!! Not a cheap stick by any means and even more costly as only 1/4 is smokable!!!....Can't recommend and I wont buy these again--- EVER!!!
4 out of 5
Magna
Good smoke
5 out of 5
Heaven
This is now my favorite smoke!
5 out of 5
Satisfied customer
Best service I have experience
4 out of 5
good pairing with a nice bourbon or scotch.
beautiful construction. veining was almost not even there, the cap is the thickest I have seen, I don't see anyone having any cap issues with these, its the thickest cap I have seen. the burn I found a bit difficult to keep in check even with rolling the stick as I smoked it, yet the smoke was very nice and rich. the flavor was very oaky with some toast and a very slight sweetness I couldn't fully place but I will say is a berry. I really dint see how anyone could have had issues with these falling apart unless they didn't have a humidor to keep them in. I would easily buy them again if they were on a good deal. nothing against this stick at all but I always wait for deals to buy, that's just me.
5 out of 5
one of my go to cigars
good price and good service
1 out of 5
Save your money
I would give it a zero star if I could. Good construction until you light it. runs like a rabbit. inconsistent burn. fell apart about half way and the flavor to beat is mediocre at best. Save for a better stick. Tried a second one just to be sure but ultimately had to return for refund. At lease that was painless thanks to CI customer service!!!
4 out of 5
I appreciate the swift and timely deliverery
ups is really a magnificent dilivery service, your company offers a giant selection of wonderful cigars. I appreciate the polite and amassing service I receive from your agents.keep up the great offers each week it really helps me choose the product I order. Just keep up the excellent service, and thank you very much.
5 out of 5
Always great
Everytime on time, the cigars in great condition,
4 out of 5
Let go of my Casa Magna!
Very good quality and flavor, have purchased several times and will do so again . . . love to grab them on sale . . . in fact, there are some in my cart waiting for check out! I have tried many of the Casa Magna's and enjoy all the lines, sizes and shapes I have tried.
5 out of 5
Casa Magnanimous
I great smoke all the way through...nice, heavy gray smoke. Perfect for a night time "deck" smoke or just as comfortable on the golf course.
3 out of 5
Not as good as other Casa Magna cigars.
casa Magna makes some very good cigars. The Colorado and the Oscuro are very nice. The Dominican "Licey" is not as good. But OK if the price is right.
1 out of 5
Not a fan of this one
Had 2 of these and threw the second one away after the first inch. Harsh but did have a good burn. Good construction but that's about it.
3 out of 5
ok cigar
not as fresh as i expected
Customer Testimonials
Back in 2008 Manuel Quesada won "Cigar of The Year" honors with his blend of Casa Magna "Colorado", and it was/is a superb cigar. It has been a regular in my rotation ever since. He may have outdone himself with his latest creation Casa Magna "Dominican". I was fortunate enough to grab five 5.5x52 robusto grandes from CI about two months ago. I put 'em in the humi to rest and "uncorked" this one Saturday night 9/13/14. This is a very firm, well constructed stogie with a slightly veiny Corojo wrapper, triple cap, and a smooth easy draw. It is a medium-bodied smoke that burns cool and slow all the way; a slow-flavor starter in the early burn with just a trace of vanilla and cinnamon. Once you get into it about 1 1/2 inches the flavors start to come on subtly with notes to my palate of spice and cocoa - not harsh, more on the creamy side. A very pleasant mix. (Some of the other reviews talk of a peppery start that lingers throughout the smoking experience. Perhaps that part of my taste buds has died but I didn't even detect a hint of pepper in this stick.) I sent the one inch nub to it's grave after about 45+ blissful minutes and three Long Island Iced Tea's, and look forward to the remaining four siblings that are quietly aging in the humi.
Rich in flavor and a very lovely cigar in presentation.
This cigar got rave reviews and I bought five in a sampler deal. It burns fairly well, has a bit of a spicey taste and over all is a good smoke, not the super smoke I thought it might be. Good stick with a stiff night cap perhaps, would not recommend for beginners or a casual round on the links.
I do like these medium to full strength cigars. The Flight Sampler is the way to go at around $4 a pop.
Bought a box of these cigars after reading several positive reviews. I thought the first one I smoked may have been an abberation but after the third I can honestly say this is one bad smoke. In summation, I found the Casa Magna Dominican cigar having the following characteristics: 1) Soft and spongy 2) Irregular burn throughout with "touch-ups" necessary and an ugly ash 3) Most dissapointing an acrid flavor existed during of the entire cigar with no subtle hints of anything else. I smoked all to the last third of the Casa Magna Dominican in hopes of a better ending.....but, no......a bad experience to the last puff. There are much better cigars for the money and I wouldn't recommend this one brand to anyone.......even to your ex-brother-in-law or golfing buddies who generally smoke anything available.
Finally got a chance to smoke one of these last night, despite already stocking a box and some fivers at work. Putting the cart before the horse, but the original CM is quite tasty, and a relative bargain these days. The CMD is also a relative bargain, and as it turns out, a good one. Got a blast of pepper and some other heavy flavors to start, but the cigar smoothed out after about the first inch. Not tremendously complex, but a good cigar, and a solid medium-bodied smoke to my tastes. No regrets about having already stocked a bunch, and I will certainly recommend them to customers. Other than the CI description pegging these as medium-full (most cigars run about a half to full step in body as described here and (gasp) other retailers, so not taking issue with CI on this), I'd say the CI description is pretty equal to my experience. A good smoke, and one I recommend trying.
This is an excellent cigar!Very earthy, nutty,light spice,creamy-everything Steve said!Oh yeah, almost forgot,delicious aroma as well. Home run again for Sr.Quesada,thank you, C.I.!
After reading that this blend was designed to compete on the international market ie. Cubans, I am gladI ordered a Robusto 5 pack. These are hearty full flavored cigars. The wrapper is so dark my first thought was maduro, but it didn't have that kind of sweetness. With the moderate price these will go into my rotation.
As a cigar lover, I normally don't write bad reviews, as they are purely subjective; but this is one awful cigar. The flavor isn't bad, but you can tell that the various ages of the leaves is off because of the uneven burn and constant re-lights. I bought a five pack and can't wait to be done with it....
Adroit