Your web browser is no longer supported.
Cigars International is committed to providing you with the best web experience possible.
Close

#5: Macanudo and Man O' War Virtue Reviews

Shop Now
Overall Rating 4.38 out of 5 Based on 64 Ratings

Customer Reviews of “#5: Macanudo and Man O' War Virtue”

Write A Review
5 out of 5
5 Star
42
4 out of 5
4 Star
12
3 out of 5
3 Star
4
2 out of 5
2 Star
4
1 out of 5
1 Star
2
Showing 1-50 of 79 Reviews
5 out of 5
Service
As usual your service was excellant. Good cigars. will reorder in the future.
5 out of 5
As
As
5 out of 5
Macanudo vs MoW Virtue. Which is the winner?
The Macanudo Cafe was good. Not a lot to say about it but mild and tasty. Would not buy again. Would not buy a box. The MoW Virtue, however, is a mild-medium with all of the bold flavor and body that the other MoW cigars have, but with a connecticut wrapper. Definitely leans towards medium. Comparing the two, the Macanudo loses to the MoW Virtue in every way.
5 out of 5
Macanudo and Man O' War
Good smoke
5 out of 5
Solid pick
Smooth as ever. Great buy
5 out of 5
Great buy
The macanudos are a great mild smoke the man o wars are a little Stronger and burn great
4 out of 5
Nice
I like both, Macanudo mild and smooth although I had two that were to tight to draw. ManoWar Virtue were great draw, great burn a bit stronger then the Mac's but still smooth and tasty. I gave it four stars only because of the draw on the Macanudo.
5 out of 5
Back for the Macs
I love the Macs but find the Virtues so-so flavor wise. However, both are well constructed and a good value in this sampler. You definitely get your money's worth with the Man O' War, it's not so much a stick as it is a log. You can have the first half of a MOW at breakfast and then finish it at lunch. Macs, on the other hand, are good for a dedicated sit.
5 out of 5
Great value for the price
Great value for the price hope there are more samplers forthcoming.
4 out of 5
Decent combo
The macanudo is what a macanudo is, a mild smooth smoke. I preferred the Virtue, was a bit tastier to me anyway.
5 out of 5
New favorite
Received these in a sampler. They are very tasty, great draw, well constructed. I'm going to try the rest of the Man O War line because of these.
4 out of 5
#5: Macanudo
An excellent mid-size cigar. Perfect for the winter months.
5 out of 5
great light smokes
Very nice smokes. Man o war is a nice long even burn
5 out of 5
Great cigars at a very
Great cigars at a very fair price. The staff is always help full if there is any need to return any product.
4 out of 5
Bang for buck
Great price, good smoke
4 out of 5
Medium Sampler
The Macanudo are the perfect smoke when you don't have a lot of time. Size is right and a nice mild smoke.
5 out of 5
Happy with service
Your prices are more than competetive
3 out of 5
Cigars are very dried out
Cigars are very dried out and beginning the unraveling process.
5 out of 5
Superb combination
Great anytime cigars. The wrappers on both are beautiful and the flavor is not too powerful. Bought these initially for the macanudos but ended up a fan of the virtues as well. These are probably the only cigars I'll smoke during daylight hours.
4 out of 5
Excellent Value
Great price on good cigars. Have re-ordered multiple times.
5 out of 5
Great deal, cigars arrived fresh
Great deal, cigars arrived fresh as always!
5 out of 5
one of the best companies
one of the best companies to do business with. ...A1
1 out of 5
very poor
poor pull.....stale and quite hard....surprising for the brand So badd I sent them back............
5 out of 5
Great!!!!
this is my favorite cigar deal I have found.
5 out of 5
NOT A BAD COMBO
Nice Combo two good smokes
5 out of 5
Happy customer
Excellent shipping
5 out of 5
My favorite's
The Macanudo and Virtue are two of my very favorite cigars. Thanks for the great bargain in your offering of these super cigars to your customers.
2 out of 5
Not thrilled
Macanudos are always good, however the Man O' War Virtues were dry and crunchy as if they had been left out a long time. I have never had an issue with ordering cigars from you folks til now. I tried to smoke one and it kept splitting and flaking. Right now they are in my humidor trying to get resurrected.
1 out of 5
bought 4 lighters,two dont work.
bought 4 lighters,two dont work.
5 out of 5
#5 macanudo and man o war virtue
Macanudo were dry not impressed with deal
3 out of 5
Half Good Half Bad
The Macanudo is a consistently good cigar; the Man of War pales in comparison
5 out of 5
great
Both cigars where great will buy again
5 out of 5
Great cigars!
Great cigars, and a good way to sample them. Let's have more samplers like these.
5 out of 5
Bargain Combo!
The macanudos alone are worth the price. Surprisingly the Man O' War Virtues are a smooth elegant smoke as well. Can't beat this combo!
2 out of 5
macanudo are not as good
macanudo are not as good as the use to be however the man o’ war virtue
5 out of 5
#5 Macanudo and Man O' War Virtue
Both are high quality cigars. Tasteful and mild. Both burn real nice, especially the Macanudo.
5 out of 5
Great Combo
I really like the Macanudos, but then you have the Man O War and realize the Macanudo is the under card.
2 out of 5
Batting 500
Macanudo, thumbs up! Man O' War, not so much.
4 out of 5
GREAT DEAL!
Great deal, got it for the Mac's. First time trying the MOW, they were okay. Again, for the price & the Mac's + MOW's, it's one of the better deals on CI.
5 out of 5
Fresh product, not out dated stale cigars
quality cigars
5 out of 5
Great Smokes
Great smokes at a great value
4 out of 5
Like them both
Both great daytime cigars. I personally smoke them while doing yard work or projects in the shop. The Virtue is "bland" in that there isn't much complexity or flavor, other than smooth smoke and cedar. The Macanudos are much more flavorful.
4 out of 5
Nice change of pace.
These are good cigars if you want a change of pace from your traditional favorites.
4 out of 5
Nice change of pace.
These are good cigars if you want a change of pace from your traditional favorites.
5 out of 5
Combo
Not too bad the man of war were a bit stronger than I like
3 out of 5
Macanudos were stale
threw away most of the macanudos but the Man of Wars were great
5 out of 5
Ten stars
Two of my favorite brands at around half the price. Enough said. Thank you CI.
5 out of 5
Great Pair
This is my favorite pairing for a morning cigar. Alternating them daily satisfy s my need for variety.
5 out of 5
Macanudo & Man O War cigars
order came in 4 business days. Everything was great. JB
5 out of 5
Excellent Smokes
Great smokes, if your in to mild smokes. Nice even burn great taste, even turned a few friends on to them.
5 out of 5
Paul D
The Macanudo are always a great smoke. The Man O War Virtue is a great cigar for the golf course. I've shared it with my group and they liked it so much they have ordered them as their go to cigar. Great value too!
5 out of 5
my review
Great cigars, great value!
5 out of 5
#5: Macanudo and Man O' War Virtue.
Great deal. Purchased for the Macanudos, not gonna lie. But the the Virtues were a pleasant surprise. Will buy again!
5 out of 5
Great deal, great cigars
You can't beat this deal on Macanudos and Man O' War. Will buy this bundle, again.
4 out of 5
gerry
macanudo is a great cigar for the price. man o war is good, very smokable, but not great.
5 out of 5
Was very please with the
Was very please with the cigars. Plan on making more orders! Very satisfied!
2 out of 5
Disappointed
I was sadly disappointed with both cigars. Two of the Macanudos unraveled while being smoked. By contrast the Man-of-Wars were perfectly wrapped. However, they were too strong and I was unable to finish them.
5 out of 5
Macanudo & Man O'War Virtue Offer
This was such a nice purchase. While I have always enjoyed Macanudos, this also gave me the chance to sample the Man O'War for the first time. I was very pleased with the taste and enjoyed them very much. I highly recommend this offer.
3 out of 5
1 bad cigar
Got package today Quick delivery Liked the humidor Tried the Macanudo & outer wrapper peeled right off Tried a second one & had no problem Good cigar Aside from the one I was pleased with my order
5 out of 5
Best deal around!
Best deal around!
5 out of 5
This is a great deal
This ia a great deal. The Man O War Virtue is worth this deal alone in my opionon.
4 out of 5
Very enjoyable selection
Thoroughly enjoy this particular combination.
5 out of 5
great deal
good cigars at a great price
5 out of 5
both cigars were very good.
both cigars were very good. i prefer a mild cigar and these both fit the bill
Customer Testimonials
This is one of the best samplers I have got from CI. Both are excellent cigars and well worth the money.
Thoroughly enjoyed this sampler. Great bargain on trying them. I ended up liking the Man O' Wars better.
First of all, what a great deal. I have a 50 cigar humidor so these Gentleman's Deuce samplers are the perfect addition to my small collection. Two varieties of high quality cigars for $2.75 apiece. I got these cigars and let them sit in the humidor overnight before smoking the Macanudo Cafe Hyde Park. This cigar blew my mind. It was smooth and refreshing, a mild smoke, but rich with flavor. The burn was perfectly even and the draw was just right. From the start you get a nice nutty taste, almost like a peanut or chestnut oil. The second third of the cigar was my favorite part. The aroma alone was satisfying, but the flavors really start to come out. I got a taste of the nutty oil, a touch of coffee, and since it's so smooth, it tastes a little sweet and creamy. The final third was great as well. You get all the same flavors of the second third, but just a bit more "toasty" and a little stronger. I would have to say this is the most satisfying cigar I've smoked so far, and it was so mild and aromatic that my wife even enjoyed the taste and smell. I never understood the term "breakfast cigar" until finding this little guy. I can honestly say I would smoke this cigar any time of the day, any day of the week. It's the perfect smoke that just won't get old. As for the Man O' War Virtue, I was not so impressed. I let this one sit for two nights in the humidor. It does have a nice mild taste and a nice spice, but it seems to be lacking in flavor. The construction was nice and neat, but the draw was a little too soft for my liking, maybe just packed a little loose. Hopefully this cigar will gain some flavor as it ages in the humidor. Overall, this is a great deal. I would buy this again just for the Macanudo's. I can't wait to try these after a few months. This is definitely getting another purchase from me.
Very surprised by the Man O' War Virtues! I'm buying this combo in multiples just for this cigar. Don't get me wrong, I like the Macanudo as well. Together, this is a smoking deal for under $3 a stick.
I've read all the reviews for these two cigars and I'll tell you they are not wrong I'll be ordering them again very smooth and a great burn. Thanks!
Simply wonderful, thank you CI!
Excellent combination. There should be a second one featuring the same brands in a medium-full selection
WINNER! One of my favorites at a price that can't be beat. Heck, the Macanudos alone are a bargain at this price!
Great cigars. Great price. A must buy.
How can you pass up getting (5) MACANUDO Cafe Hyde Park; and (5) MAN 'O WAR Virtue Toro for $2.75 a stix...the CI's "Gentelman's Deuce" Samplers are totally unreal...think about it this way, If you're a Macanudo fan...a 5'er of Macanudos from CI is $27.50, and then CI gives you a $40 5'er of MOW VIRTUE Toros to try as a FREEBIE !! This is another CI deal that I order in multiples...save even more $$$ !!!
great smoke..love em on my lanai relaxing..
I have smoked many cigars over the years, but I have just started smoking regularly since being deployed, maybe one cigar per week. I finished this batch a few days ago. The Macanudo is a really good cigar; smooth with a nice draw. The MOW is similar, except its draw is an easier one and has tons of white smoke. Both of these smokes are great smokes for almost any occasion, except maybe big occasions like winning the lottery or making that huge sale. Then you might want to go upscale. But this is a decent sampler for anyone. I will purchase the Macanudo Hyde Park in the future, but I probably won't buy the MOW Virtue because it is a pricey cigar, and I don't think it's worth the price (except in this sampler). I am pleased overall. And CI had great shipping. Cigars made it all the way to Afghanistan in 8 days. Nicely done, CI.
No brainer. Will order this one again and again. Top notch sticks for bottom of the barrel prices. Way to go, CI!
Hyde Parks are my favorite mild cigar, definitely a creamy feel, good smoke volume. ManoWar virtues are peppery in the beginning and more medium flavor. Overall great value for the price within the Gentleman's Deuce
This is one of the best combo deals around. Both Cigars offerings are superb. Great taste. I bought this combo initially for the Macanudos...but after trying the Virtues...I am back for more of these. They are awesome.
Adroit