Your web browser is no longer supported.
Cigars International is committed to providing you with the best web experience possible.

Punch Rare Corojo Reviews

Shop Now
Overall Rating 4.86 out of 5 Based on 42 Ratings

Customer Reviews of “Punch Rare Corojo”

Write A Review
5 out of 5
5 Star
4 out of 5
4 Star
3 out of 5
3 Star
2 out of 5
2 Star
1 out of 5
1 Star
Showing 1-50 of 67 Reviews
5 out of 5
Great Experience
Everything was good
4 out of 5
The verdict
This is a great cigar with a beautiful construction and perfect burn. It loses a star for me because it's too similar to the Punch Signature and doesn't differentiate itself enough for me. I still recommend it if you love a good full body cigar with the Corojo spice and taste. As I was enjoying mine though my mind immediately went to, wow, this is just too much like the Signature blend. Still, one fine cigar.
5 out of 5
Great cigars superior value
Hard to find cigars sent to a close friend for Christmas were a great value and arrived timely in great condition. What else can you ask?
5 out of 5
A Real Good Cigar
This may become my ‘go-to’ cigar. I enjoy several different brands, but the Champion is at the top of my list. Well made, draws nice and provides about an hour of enjoyment.
5 out of 5
Excellent Cigar
This cigar is a tried and true winner in my eyes. I have never been disappointed.
5 out of 5
Service Rating Excellent
As always, prices, service and value are exceptional
5 out of 5
You always need to keep a 5-pak around
I find these Punch Corojo's to be a great way to indulge yourself in a wonderful Cigar. Not overpowering, a lot of subtle hints of flavor. You always need to keep a 5-pak around, you'll never know when friends stop by unannounced.
4 out of 5
Solid Smoke
Good price good smoke.
3 out of 5
Westchester guy
I thought the punch pita's were a bit on the dry side when I recevied them. The shipping seems longer then usual probably due to the holidays. After letting them sit in my humidor for a week to 10 days they seemed much fresher as always a good smoke.
4 out of 5
A great Corojo
I have been smoking these for a while. A consitant medium body smoke.
5 out of 5
Great service, prompt and always
Great service, prompt and always correct.
5 out of 5
Taking Care of Business (TCB)
Cigars International is once again, taking care of Business, (TCB)! On time Shipments. Orders Correct, and if not, they Corect them immediatley and without questions. For instance,a recent Shipment was to include (two) Free Butance Lighters. While the Cigar Order was Correct, the Lighters were not included. However, with one (brief) phone call, the missing Lighters were sent and received within 5 Business Days. And THAT is (why) I love Cigars International. Consistent Service, with a Touch of Class! Merry Christmas to ALL.
5 out of 5
Ross J.
The only place to buy cigars! Best Price! Best customer service! Amazing delivery time!!!
5 out of 5
I love this cigar
this cigar is great for those half an hour walks with the dog or cleaning the car or the yard work times. The cigar is smooth and taste at the same time.
5 out of 5
Very satisfied with your service
Very satisfied with your service
5 out of 5
45 minute smoke
Very good smoke ,has plenty of flavor and we'll made I also got the same cigar in the magnum robusto and it was excellent. Can't go wrong with either of these 2 punch rare corojo is a winner.
5 out of 5
pparcel process
I enjoy your product, howeveriam displeased with the low cost, ( on your end that is ) on saving a buck to deliver parcels. Im referring to using USPS. As a delivery service after ups starts the primary shipment....
5 out of 5
My favorite Smoke for the past 5 years
A good friend of mine gave me an El Doble Punch Rare Corojo on the first fairway at the Grande Golf course about 5 years ago. I was immediately impressed. An even draw, smooth smoke, filled with rich flavor. It has been my smoke of choice since then. I have never had one that did not burn evenly. I keep a few in my bag at all times.
5 out of 5
Good quick smoke
Smoked three of the five I ordered and all three have been excellent. I have two small children and am out o town a lot so when I'm home I want to spend time with both of them and my wife but still enjoy some quiet time for a good smoke. They were a medium bodied smoke that was about 45 min. Really enjoyed and will purchase again
5 out of 5
Great, dependable smoke
I like the size of these and the fact they are a consistent fine smoke
5 out of 5
Cigar Awesomeness!
Firstly, CI is the only internet sote I would order cigars from. That said this cigar is totally first rate...smooth and easy on the draw...slow burning... fantastic flavor and awesome aroma. A little pricey , BUT I've paid more (especially Cubans...out of Switzerland ) and the fact is you get what you pay cheap get better get better ! Last word on the Punch Rare Corojo Rothschild is that it is the only cigar I'd want if I were shipwrecked ! LOL
5 out of 5
Rare Corojo ..... Tasty
I love to grab a box of the Punch Rare Corojo smokes when they are available. Good go-to Cigar while watching a Hockey or Football game. The cigar is spicy & flavorful, but doesn't hit you over the head. Great medium-bodied smoke !!
5 out of 5
As always the cigars arrived in great condition- The flavor is smooth and relaxing - it is my every day cigar, after a hard day at work, sitting on the back patio--relaxing for about an hour enjoying this fine smoke
5 out of 5
Great cigars
I am very pleased with these cigars. Nice burn and even smoke throughout. CI has done it again!
5 out of 5
The Perfect Smoke
I have been smoking Punch brand cigars for almost 30 years. They are consistently the best value smoke. The Rare Corojo is true t this statement. A fantastic cigar and an even better smoke.
5 out of 5
GR8 Smoke.
This guy has now become one of my all time favorites. Smooth burning, clean crisp flavor; just a delight to relax with and just enjoy. Great price too. if you get the opportunity and haven't tried it yet, do it! you will not be disappointed.
5 out of 5
small smoke
very good small smoke
5 out of 5
Punch Rare Corojo
A great medium body cigar Burns evenly.
4 out of 5
Cigar evaluation
Pretty good cigars, a little hard for my taste. But very acceptable.
5 out of 5
You won't be disappointed
You won't be disappointed
5 out of 5
Great cigar
No matter how much I try to try something else I always come back to the punch rare corojo they are great tasting full of flavor and burn nice even on the golf course
5 out of 5
Review of Punch Rare Corojo Rothchild - Bill Brooks
I love these cigars for the size, aroma & taste! They're the right size for a 10-15 minute break.
5 out of 5
Amazing selection!
Amazing selection!
5 out of 5
One of the best cigars
One of the best cigars I've ever smoked.
5 out of 5
Great stuff
5 out of 5
Exquisite Cigar!!
I have tried many cigars over the years, from inexpensive to extremely expensive, and have NEVER given a full 5 star or 10 rating to any of them prior to this. This cigar is truly exquisite in every way. I don't have anything negative to say about it. Do yourself a favor and get some of these. They are sure to be your new favourite. They are now my new go to cigar of choice.
5 out of 5
Smoking Punch Champion
One of my Favorites I am smoking one right now. Excellent little cigar. I always keep them on hand.
5 out of 5
Very happy customer
The cigars were very reasonably priced and arrived very quickly!
5 out of 5
Punch Rare Corojo Elites
Great daily smoke at a great price!!!!
5 out of 5
Rare Corojo
The Rare Corojo has been my daily smoke for years. Medium to full bodied but not overpowering. Limited availability "hence the rare" so enjoy whenever possible!
5 out of 5
Punch rare Corojo champion
This rare Corojo to is a very good smoke.i prefer the longer cigar but this champion is good for a weeknight cigar the el double is the size cigar I prefer. You still get the awesome taste from the smaller ones. I would and will by the se again
5 out of 5
Punch rare corojo
excellent cigar very consistent smoke is my favorite and great taste. Have been smoking this cigar for around five years.
Customer Testimonials
Great go-to, everyday smoke. Smooth, flavorful, fine draw and even burn. The box pressed adds a nice feel. I have been smoking these gems for months and I have not had a bad smoke yet.
Perfect size, great flavor! A highly underrated cigar!
My 1st real cigar was a Punch Rothschild many, many years ago. Back when all the former Cuban manufacturers were setting up shop in The Dominican Republic with smuggled Cuban seeds. Back then, they all took a turn for the milder. Except one. Punch used Honduran & Nicaraguan tobaccos to keep a Cubanesque profile, as well as most of the former strength. I was sold. Many years later Punch introduced me to the joys of the Corojo leaf. Enter Punch Rare Corojo. I was hooked. Although I have had many other Corojo cigars since then, I can tell a Rare Corojo after a few puffs. Consistency, affordability, quality. That's Punch.
There are so many cigars to try, it makes my head spin. Truth is there are some stand outs, this is one of those gems you keep in the humidor.
I've just started smoking cigars and I've been trying different brands and styles for the past several months. This cigar was by far the nicest smoke that I've tried! It started with the beautiful packaging; a red velvet lined cedar box with each cigar suspended on a platform. The cigar itself is impressive, a nice deep brown patina with a very nice shape. The cigar smokes very smooth and burns absolutely perfect. It was never harsh, even at the very end. I would buy this cigar over and over again. As a matter of fact I smoked 2 of them today while playing golf.
These mild cigars are great for a quick smoke.
Great cigar, no issues.
Without a doubt, the best cigar I have ever smoked. If I hit the lottery I am filling my new walk in humidor with boxes of these babies! I am not a fan of any other Punch smoke, but this one does it for me. I can just sit out on the deck with one of the El Doble and a great cup of coffee and just let my day melt away.
Punch makes THE BEST Cigars on Planet earth! If a flying saucer landed in my pasture and they asked for the best cigar I knew of, it would be one of these!
I really like these cigars. They burn true, have a nice draw and taste great. Buy them and you will not be disappointed.
I read in some cigar snob rag that these are not "true corojos". Don't care. They're real good, that's all I know. Great value, too. Cheap enough to be a daily smoke, good enough to share w/ friends.
Don't know if I can say I've had a bad Punch. Then I had one of the Rare Corojo Champions. Took a while to get used to the odd shape, but was loaded with flavor and the burn was perfect. Well worth a try if you're a Punch fan or just enjoy a quality smoke.
Love the flavor so I bought a box. I'm disappointed because at least one in four have a draw so tight that I have to throw it out. Maybe I got a bad box but they are too expensive for me to take a chance on another box. Love my MOW. Not a bad one in the box!
By far, one of the best cigars made outside of Cuba! Great flavor, burn and draw. Strong from the first light down to the nub. Couldn't put it down until my fingers started to burn. Great with single malt scotch, port or brandy. Not for the light-hearted. Rated a 10!
This is the best Punch cigar ever made. It is strong and complex. I have some of these aged for years and they never lose their strength and complexity. Made once a year so you must buy them.
i understand this is wrapped in a equadorion wrapper , not a corojo. no matter, it does taste like a corojo wrapped cigar. this was a fine medium to full body cigar. light spice, earthy coffee undertones and smooth to the nub. i rate it a solid 90.
The Punch Rare Corojo is a wonderful smoke. I have only been smoking the various Punch blends for about 18 months, and I like the Rare Corojo and the Gran Puro the best. Both are rich and tasty, solid middle-weights with good balance. This year, I am going to try a recommendation and let a box age for a year - that is if I can keep my hands off of them that long. Highly recommended.
Without doubt, my favourite Punch.(Punch Rare Corojo) Wonderful flavour, excellent draw and burn. Just a fine cigar.
The best description for this smoke is Velvet, as it is so smooth and rich (Punch Rare Corojo). I recently had a few at a friends house and heard someone complain about cigar smoke. I laid one of these bad boys on him and now he owns two humidors. I will always have these in my humidor alongside customs and Cubans.
I just have to say I would smoke these all the time if I could The Punch Corojo Rare has got to be one of the best I've smoked, and thanks to CI I've been able to sample top shelf more than before with that other place ( that thinks it's in competion), and my favorite little shop.
I just had my first Punch Rare Corojo. Smooth, even burning, good flavor. I enjoyed it a lot. I will smoke more for sure. I wouldn't say it is a thrilling smoke so if you are looking to have your socks knocked off this ain't it. However it is a good easy, smooth, enjoyable smoke. Sort of like eating comfort food.
The Punch Rare Corojo Magnum is as smooth a smoke that can be found. Even burn, nice draw and absolutely no bite. Mellow taste with a pleasing aroma. I don't think it can be beat for the price.
Without a doubt one of the best stogies ever (Punch Rare Corojo). The box pressed shape sits perfect in your fingers. The flavors that poured out of this stick were incredible and the burn and draw were superb. Treat yourself right now to one of these, who cares what the wife says, and you can thank me later.
The PRC (Punch Rare Corojo) Rothschild is a very nice "go to" stick. Burn, draw, appearance, taste, taste of wrapper, coolness of smoke, all those categories are very well satisfied. Notable item (in addition to a super taste) - the silver-gray ash stays on and intact very, very well. Only criticism I could offer is the smoke volume was, for me personally, just "moderate", and that could have been something applicable to just the three I smoked rather than the cigars on average. This is a cigar that will convert the occasional or "something-different-every-week" smoker to having a "favorite".
I don't normally care for Punch, but I was given a coffin El Doble and to my great surprise loved it. Had it with a glass of Weller, and the flavors that popped out of the cigar and whiskey combination were astounding. I'm a CAO fan through and through, but this was one of the tastier cigars I've had in a long time. I don't know if it was the cigar or the whiskey, or the combination but tastes of vanilla, cocoa, and almond. Surprisingly not harsh, never hot, great draw. Relit it for the last 3 inches after dinner and it got a little tough for the first inch but mellowed.