Your web browser is no longer supported.
Cigars International is committed to providing you with the best web experience possible.

CAO Black Reviews

Shop Now
Overall Rating 4.64 out of 5 Based on 22 Ratings

Customer Reviews of “CAO Black”

Write A Review
5 out of 5
5 Star
4 out of 5
4 Star
3 out of 5
3 Star
2 out of 5
2 Star
1 out of 5
1 Star
Showing 1-50 of 95 Reviews
5 out of 5
Once you go Black, you won’t go back
Flawless construction. Consistent draw. One of my favorites.
5 out of 5
This is my go to cigar. I also like 5 Vegas gold, Gran Habano Vintage 2002, and Padron 3000, but if I had to pick one cigar for the rest of my life this would be it.
4 out of 5
Nice budget stick
Great morning smoke with coffee!
5 out of 5
Best cigar ever
Have tried all samplers, 5 packs and others over several years. These are the absolute best for a med - full cigar. Try them.
5 out of 5
My go-to cigar
Far and away the best cigar I smoke! Good anytime of day.
5 out of 5
Excellent cigar
My go to cigar. This is one that's never let me down. I also like Hoyo Excalibur, 5 Vegas Gold and Gran Habano Vintage 2002's, but if I could only smoke one cigar for the rest of my life this would be it.
5 out of 5
CAO Order
Thank you to Cigars International for working through a misplaced delivery. Unfortunately the package did not arrive in time for the party, but I appreciate the effort to try and track it down and then resend. The reshipped package arrived quickly and the cigars are fantastic. Thanks.
5 out of 5
Medium greatness
Great medium smoke
4 out of 5
CAO Black Bengal
Great tasting cigar for the money, but it was dry upon arrival and the wrapper crumbled as I smoked them...
5 out of 5
Perfect in every way.
This stick is just about perfect. Smooth from the start, it delivers aroma, smoke and taste with every puff. I would compare it with other much more expensive cigars costing nearly three times the price as these. Enjoying one as I type this very moment. Must be gone now, this Cao black calls my name.
5 out of 5
Great cigars along with terrific service!
5 out of 5
Nice smooth cigar
Nice medium flavor cigar from CAO; fairly consistent smoke.
5 out of 5
CAO Black
Always a favorite.
5 out of 5
Thanx C.I.
Say Heah Guys and Ladies, As you were. Yeah, I really like some of the Black Pearl offerings, But this C A O Frontier, If I couldn't get my Fav's, I wouldn't be disappointed. Grouchy Marx nailed it, "A Woman is just a Woman, But a Cigar is a Smoke" Yeah, It's a good smoke. ,, ,, Paul'ie
5 out of 5
Simply the best !
I agree with everything good said about this cigar and disagree with all the naysayers. one of my all time favorites and tremendous value when Joe unties the purse strings.If you like a Connecticut with a little oomph and flavor you can't do better than this.
5 out of 5
CAO Storm is Excellent
The CAO Black Storm is an outstanding cigar. From the moment you light this beauty, the flavor, smoke, draw and burn is excellent. I am always looking to buy these and keep a stock of a couple boxes. They are great morning, noon and night! CAO hit the bullseye on this one.
4 out of 5
Flavorful and balanced
As advertised, a medium strength cigar in a good quality roll. No bitterness, plenty of flavor.
4 out of 5
CAO- Nice!!
This is a very nice smoke at a very reasonable price! My new favorite on the Golf Course....
2 out of 5
Flavor is a no go for me
Flavor is a no go for me. I guess I have moved away from this flavor profile. Also experienced tight draw with a straight cut. Rh was 67% for the month they sat. Now I still have 8 of 10 left. Need to decide whether set aside in secondary storage or add to the donation pile.
5 out of 5
fast and consistent shipping
My orders are on time every time. Customer service is great.
5 out of 5
Very good smoke
For me, as a novice smoker, was an exceptional smoke
4 out of 5
Arrived perfect! Smooth smoking cigar. mellow, very flavorful and nice aroma!
Customer Testimonials
DELICIOUS. The only issue I have with this stick is trying to keep them in my humidor.
Well the first one of these I had was horrible. Comparable to chewing up a Marlboro. I have since had another and determined that there was just something wrong with the 1st stick as the 2nd was much much better, but still I believe there are better options for the money.
Got one of these in the Backyard Boogie sampler, perhaps I just had a bad one, but I was very disappointed. Hoping the other CAOs in the sampler are better.
Even when I was an avid cigar smoker I knew these were a special cigar. Now, many years later, the CAO Black is my go to cigar. This is a medium cigar, not full strength like some have quoted. These cigars age very well, too, if you can keep your hands off of them that long\. Very complex flavor profile and I just absolutely love these cigars.
Decent, not great. The wrapper is delicious; the wrapper was just delicious to wrap around the mouth! Took about to the half way mark to even create a flavor profile. The flavor profile (thank god) went from zero to hero the more and more you smoked it. Smoked it all the way to the nub; creamy as all heck, yet still missing the complexity to be a GREAT smoke. I give this cigar an 87.
I've tried a lot of cigars. Gurkha, Vegas, Rocky Patel, and I always come back to CAO and far and away my favorite is the black. I've tried all the different rolls and no matter what the black in any roll is my favorite. What a wonderful experience it would make anyone a cigar lover.
I just tried my first CAO Black, and it was wonderful! I smoked it down to almost nothing! I paired it with some Crown Royal Black (didn't plan that haha. I'll most certainly buy more of these! A great cigar that doesn't hurt the wallet. What's not to love! Awesome job CAO!
These were about the best I ever had! Great value, smooth smoke with rich flavors. Well worth the money!
Well made, perhaps a bit hard. Smokes evenly with pleasantly spicy taste. Would recommend it and I will order again.
Bought a sampler that had CAO Black...this cigar is extremely well made, and burns evenly from start to finish. Copious amount of smoke with each draw, but never harsh....Very, very enjoyable smoke, regardless of the price....a "10"!
Bought a sampler that had CAO black. This cigar is extremely well made, and burns evenly from start to finish. Copious amounts of smoke with each draw, but never harsh....Very, very enjoyable smoke, regardless of the price....a "10"!
Yesterday I had the CAO MX2, and thoroughly enjoyed it. I had a couple CAO Black's sitting in the humidor and decided to try it today. This is an amazing cigar. Very pleasant throughout with nice fulfilling smoke. The taste stayed immersive and left me with that warm fuzzy feeling afterwards!
very good, nice flavor profile, great burn good medium body cigar ... best bang for your buck nice aroma
It's all true! CAO's Black is the kind of blend that should be reserved for special moments. It's the most delicious mild bodied smoke anywhere near my rotation & that says a lot for a roto that includes Camacho, Joya DeNic, Obso & Core. The toro is a smooth, slim thing of beauty measuring 6.2" X 50. I love the cedar wrap & carefully remove it & place it on another of my 50 ring gauge vitolas, for a long cedar nap. Notes of vanilla, wood, light white pepper with a sweet undertone, intermingle on the tongue & cling pleasantly to the palate. CAO makes excellent cigars & the Black blend is their best, IMHO. I give the CAO Black toro a robust 4.5 out of 5 vitola rating. Highly recommended. Works well with a snoot of scotch or a pint of English ale.
After reading the great reviews, I'm left wondering if I smoked the same cigar. Not bad, but far from great. They seem rather bland to me....
One of my favorite cigars of all. A genuinely good tasting smoke. I was a novice so I ordered a sampler with a humidor to get started and this was one of the most pleasant smoking experiences I had found. The corona size seems to provide less of the exorbitant smoke plumes that I enjoyed so much in the chunkier version I had in my sampler, though I can't remember what that size was....I'll be keeping my eyes open for CI's next CAO Black deal--and I will be buying some. Thanks CI!
Best cigar to date! I just received a 5 pack of these last night and tried one right out of the package. Smooth and flavorful. I definitely will stock these. I can't wait and try one after its been in the humi for awhile.
The first draw on this made me smile. It is simply perfection. The wrapper and construction are flawless. This cigar came in a sampler and, boy, am I glad it did. I would say it is more on the full bodied side. I have smoked many a nice cigar, but this truly takes the cake. I highly recommend it.
Novice smoker here. Have tried CAO Gold, Gold Maduro (both nice), LFD Sauve (very mild & enjoyable), 5 Vegas Classic, and Macanudo Cafe Hyde Park (need to try another; the first stick burned horribly). With two fingers of Laphroaig Cask Strength accompanying me this CAO Black is easily the best, most enjoyable, creamy, delicious tobacco I've tasted thus far. The light is effortless, the burn is consistent, the draw is perfect, the flavour can only be described as "gorgeous"; not the least bit overpowering to even the novice palette. The smoke billows out more than the other sticks I've mentioned and I'm smiling ear to ear.
Great cigar, smoked one last night last over an hour wonderful
Unfortunately this is the one that didn't do it for me. I got the Dream Team sampler and I have THOROUGHLY enjoyed all but this particular one. The rest have absolutely blown me away. That being said I have one more Black Bengal and will give it another try later on, but for now this is the only one I won't be buying again. If you haven't already you owe it to yourself to try the Dream Team sampler.
While I enjoy a CAO Black when it is a good cigar, too often for me it is rolled too tight and with the delicious, but fragile wrapper it gets damaged much of the time. Out of a box I would say that half are a delightful mellow smoke and the other half are a job to smoke.
I just smoked one last night and I was amazed on how great this cigar was. The flavor was out of this world. I will be filling my humidor with this cigar.
Don't judge a cigar by one stick (any more than all women by one lousy relationship). If I toss 2-3 sticks from any box, I'm not happy, but it sometimes happens (four, however, is a return). Many problems are attributable to what happens between the cigar leaving the factory and arriving at your home e.g. handling, storage, temperature and moisture variations. All that being said, I'm with the 50 or so fans that find this cigar distinctive and flavorful. Plus, I've smoked plenty, and can't recall any construction problems. One of my desert island picks.
Very disappointed in these cigars. Miserably weak as I was expecting medium-full. Maybe I got a bad box, but I'll pass from now on these. Only time I have ever been disappointed in CAO.
Wow, 49 out of 50 positive comments; sorry to have to add the second negative one. I received a Black Bengal as part of a sampler, and the wrapper was cracked/split from the cap to the band. After a little thought, I removed the cracked part of the wrapper, and smoked the cigar backwards! Lit the end that is supposed to go in your mouth, and put the foot in my mouth. Once I got past the construction problem, it WAS a pretty tasty cigar! I posted my experience on a cigar forum, and one of the other posters had gotten one in a sampler that was cracked as well. Maybe we both got one out of one bad batch, but the construction problem outweighed the nice taste for me.
CAO .. Does. Not. Disappoint. The Black (Bengal) is just another example of an excellent cigar from CAO. What impresses me most about each CAO is the build. Perfect burn, consistent draw, and then at the core of CAO Black is an assortment of flavors, mild enough to enjoy in the background, but rich enough to not go unnoticed.
Well, I got this cigar as a single to try, since I have seen soooo many good reviews on this one. I have to say she's a beautiful one. It is well constructed with great amounts of smoke. Burns well. The only thing is, besides being slightly smoother, the taste is just like these John Bulls I have. If you gave me a blind taste test I would barely tell the difference. If you want a excellent top shelf Connecticut go with Olivia. Can't go wrong.
CAO BLACK Is my favorite by far and I have smoked many top self labels
CAO Black is a fantastic cigar. The burn is razor sharp the whole way through, if you muck up the lighting it'll correct itself within the first third. The draw, for me, is perfect, not to loose. The taste, like cedar, very little pepper, not harsh on finish, smooth. Smell that even non-smokers enjoy. After several boxes, they ALL were consistent. Can't go wrong buying these delicious sticks.
CAO Black is one of the most complex cigars you will ever smoke. Upon first lighting the cigar you will instantly recognize cedar and mild spice. The spice is a pleasant addition and not an over powering pepper taste. This flavor note mellows VERY quickly into the character of the cigar enjoyed throughout the rest of the burn which offers strong notes of cherry, dark chocolate, and a touch of brandy. Not until you get to the nub does the spice reappear and meld with the other delicious aspects to create a fond farewell for your palate. A welcome addition to any cigar lover's humidor.
BY far one of the best cigars I have ever smoked. Very good flavor. Very good draw, an even burn. Not much to say here, just an all around excellent cigar!!
This is definitely the best cigar i have had in a long time. The taste is incredibly smooth and consistent. The construction and burn were perfect. I both a box of these and once I had one I odered another box to set in the humidor. This is not for the full bodied smoke lovers out there, but the medium to mild guys like me should not pass this up. The best part may have been the aroma. I smoked one at a local outdoor bar and many people commented on how good it smelled. DO YOURSELF A FAVOR AND GET A FEW OF THESE. A FEW BOXES THAT IS.
If you want the best cigar around, this is it consistently! They may cost more than what you'd spend on a everyday smoke, but when you want a smoke that NEVER lets you down, this is it.
Do yourself a favor and try a CAO Black. The rave reviews is no lie - they are excellent - everything about them for a medium smoke.
A great smoke (CAO Black), but best with a meal. I normally prefer a milder smoke but picked up some of these on the recommendation from a friend. It is creamy and smooth, and went very well with a red wine and steak! I got a bit of a rush as I started it while dinner was still cooking, but once I started eating it rounded out nicely, and complements robustly flavored foods.
The (CAO Black) has made my top 5 list. I think it's the best cigar that comes from CAO. Awesome flavor and aroma.
Cant get any better than (CAO Black).!!!!! Nuff Said
Just as advertised, one of the best cigars (CAO Black) I ever smoked.
CAO Black is everything a regular cigar smoker could ask for. I have been enjoying CAO Black for about 5 years and they never fail to satisfy. Outstanding consistency in construction, draw and most importantly flavor. Smooth, cool and creamy, but with plenty of complexity and medium bodied spice to keep it interesting. This is a cigar that I always keep in rotation and one that can be enjoyed any time of the day. I am certain they age well, but I can not keep them long enough to find out. I wonder why CAO does not open this fine line of cigars to all retailers? That being said, it is an big advantage for CI to be one of a few retailers who carry CAO Black. And thank you CI for your great prices and specials offers on this cigar.
Holy smokes.....this is one delicious cigar (CAO Black)!! No need to beat a dead horse here, since others have quite accurately described the flavor nuances of this smoke, but it was SO good that I felt compelled to throw in my two cents. A definite medium bodied smoke with a fantastic combination of flavors all the way down to the nub. Quite honestly it reminded a lot of the CI Anniversary which is a compliment of the highest order. I grabbed these on a Joe's Daily Deal and I wish I'd grabbed more, as they are just a tad out of my price range for an 'everyday' smoke at their regular price. But this one certainly lived up to the hype!!
After reading CI's reviews, along with some of the others from recent buyers, I decided to try a box of CAO Black Bengals. All I can say is that I will never doubt a CI recommendation. This cigar is undoubtably the finest smoke I have evered tried. Medium bodied with a wonderful flavor throughout. My wife will even kiss me after I smoke this baby! I will definately make room in the Elie Bleu for these! Thanks CI for keeping these great smokes so afforadable.
What can be said that has not already been said. (Okay, no has said "I like potatoes!" ) A nearly flawless cigar. Every time I smoke one of these CAO Black (I prefer the Storm or Bengal) I enjoy it as much as any cigar I have smoked. As with all of the CAOs I have smoked, the draw is perfect. Some of the staff reviews mentioned that there is aging potential, and I can attest to that. The Bengals that I have set aside for merely a year have mellowed, but the "creamy spice" that the CI gents refer to has become broader. Not necessarily stronger, but seems to coat the palate more evenly... very cool! Great smoke!
This cigar ( CAO Black) smacked me down like a pacifist at Genghis Kahn's birthday party. Deep, dark, and delicious, I was savoring its fullness of body and thickness of smoke, when it punched me in the head like a Mike Tyson uppercut. (Pre-Prison Iron Mike). Needless to say, I had to sit back down, and let my head clear before I could finish this incredible smoke. Definitely should be labeled "Do not attempt to operate heavy machinery or speak in coherent sentences for up to 15 minutes after smoking this cigar." I strongly recommend the CAO Black, but only if you are not a wimp.
This is quite a nice cigar. (CAO Black) Beautifully made with an excellent flavour and aroma. Excellent draw and even burn. I'll smoke this one regularly.
I never did get to the taste (CAO Black). Vanilla through out, pepper on the after taste, creamy and buttery smooth. Last time something tasted sooooooo good on my lips, it was my first kiss. HAPPY NEW YEAR!
I'm a loyal Gurkha lover.....having said that, i now have a new favorite cigar, the "CAO BLACK" is quite simply the most delicious cigar that Ive ever smoked. I will be ordering these relentlesly. Move over Gurkha (in the humi), i need some room.
Tried my first "'C.A.O. Black VR", and was TOTALLY blown away. Sooooooo, I thought I'd try the "C.A.O. Black", well you know the rest. The order is on the, i can't better overnight it. High and dry in S.F....later.
Gentlemen (and Ladies) there is only one phrase that fits: Once you go Black, you NEVER go back. Simply put, this cigar is awesome (CAO Black).
Best Cigar Ever (CAO Black)! I can't really think of a better way to put it. Well, how about this way, this is the one cigar whose price is actually justified. TONS of flavor, the first time I smoked one I couldn't put it down, I felt like I wanted to take a bite out of it. Perfectly medium bodied, excellent construction, producing big bellowing clouds of smoke. Take my advice because I have tried them all, from Graycliff to Partagas to real Cuban Cohibas. If you truly enjoy cigars you must to try the Black.
Wow! Creamy vanilla with a hint of pepper. Smooth yet just enough punch to make me perky. I love it, I love it, I love it! This is the first cigar I have EVER considered putting on automatic re-order status with CI so that a fresh box arrives on my porch every month like clockwork. Hmmmm....I think I'll end this message now and go put CAO Black on auto re-order status right now.
With all the well deserved hoopla about the CAO Black VR, CI is performing a little sleight-of-hand by literally giving away the CAO Black Man O'War at 40 bucks for a box of ten. No, it's not advertised, and you have to look very close to find the deal, but it's there. All I can say is WOW. I reviewed the Man O'War awhile back, so I won't go on raving about it again. All you need to know is this cigar should be in the cigar hall of fame and CI is absolutely taken the price to the realm of bargain-of-the-year. As always, thanks CI!!!
I got some free CAO Blacks when I bought a box of Man O Wars. I put them away in a humidor for a couple of months and just recently "discovered them". Pretty darn good cigar. I don't like going on about nuttines or earthiness or hints of leather and cinnamon or the like but this is a complex smoke with changing taste as you smoke your way through it. Strong enough to get your attention without overpowering you. The one complaint I have is (I have smoked two now) they tend to get hot about half way down. Maybe if I smoke them a little slower they won't burn as hot..I don't know I only know they get hotter than I like. Other than that they are better than average.
Wow, did I say Wow? I meant WOW! This smoke (CAO Black) is now officially in my starting lineup!
I ordered a box of the Man-O-War (CAO Black) after reading the reviews by your staff and the comments from customers. I have smoked some good cigars in my lifetime including some real Cubans. CAO Black has to be one of the best cigars I have ever smoked. It has all the flavor and pleasantness I expect in a quality smoke and I have shared them with a few of my good friends who also agreed on their quality. I only have a few left so it is time to order another box or two. Thanks CI for the great reviews, great prices, great selection and great customer service. I hope to be nearby Pennsylvania in May so I can attend Cigar Fest 2007. Keep up the great work!
AMAZING, SIMPLY AMAZING! Such an awesome taste to this medium-full bodied cigar (CAO Black). It smokes so smoothly and the aroma is so nice! The best made cigar I have ever smoked. A+ Cigar! If they could give a 100 rating, this would get it!
Fantastic medium to full cigar (CAO Black). Like the other CAO lines, the construction, burn, and draw of the Black is superb.
My first 2 CAO Black were at Cigar Fest 2005. Smoke one and bring the butt back and get a second. What a cigar! I definitely recommend this smoke.
So-- I had to see what all the hype was about. Thus, I ponied up and bought a 5er of CAO Black Frontiers. My order came in (Pretty quick, too. Thanks, CI!) and I threw them in the humi for a couple weeks. I finally busted one out about 5:15 in the morning (Ya, I'm a third-shifter). As soon as it lit up, I could tell I was going to love it. Peppery and powerful at the start- creamy and smooth in the middle-- crisp and clean at the end (just as many of the reviews have said). Thick gray smoke billowed out nearly the entire length of the cigar. The ash was a very nice white to off-white gray that fell off in logs that you could literally pick up without it falling apart. As the sun rose, I smoked it right down to the nub on my porch. Verdict? Excellent "casual" smoke for a great price. However, the CAO Black also has unlimited potential to be a top-shelf smoke reserved for special occasions if you can't get ahold of them. CAO Black-- welcome to a permanent spot in my humidor! What a smoke!
WOW! The CAO Black Man O War has to be one of the largest cigars I have ever smoked. I pulled one out of the beautiful box and was stunned at the heft and size of this monster. All I can say about the taste is "YUUUUUM"! This cigar left the same creamy taste in my mouth that I get from eating a piece of caramel candy. Thanks CI and CAO for such a great cigar.
I just received my order of CAO Black and have found them to be a terrific and great tasting cigar. I was told they would be too strong but that is not the case.
Just when you think CAO has done it all, they release the Man O' War. This is by far the CAO crowning achievement. Think of it as a CAO Black with the volume turned WAY up. Tons of creamy smoke. Vanilla and spice....cigar heaven. When you light this one up, make sure your schedule is clear for a solid two hours. Great job CAO. Great prices CI!
One of the best around (CAO Black). Medium to full body with a slight hint of pepper as well as some cocoa and earth tones. Beautiful draw and a very relaxing, satisfying smoke. Not as chocolaty as a MX2 but a wonderful blend in and of itself. Very, very nice.
The CAO black: Smoked only the churchill (so far). This is a superbly rolled cigar with even draw & burn. Set aside about an hour to relax & enjoy this one. Smooth & nutty with enough bite to smoke late in the day. Recommended on all fronts.
This the best CAO (CAO Black) cigar I have smoked and I have smoked them all (except the Sopranos edition). This is a cigar you want to smoke till you burn your fingertips! Smooth from start to finish. If you like medium body cigars this one is worthy of your time.
One of my all time favorites (CAO Black). Creamy, tasty, cool burning and effortless draw. A real gem that I can't get enough of. CI's great prices are the icing on the cake.
This is the best CAO cigar(CAO Black)out there period. Absolutley stunning in both construction and balance. Better than CAO maduro and the Palms.
Just received my first order of CAO Black cigars, terrific tasting smoke, hints of vanilla, wood and that mild peppery taste.WOW!! I will be ordering more of these for sure. As a bonus, the limited numbered hand painted box is real cool looking too! THANKS CI
I bought some CAO Black cigars to share with my old friends this Christmas, and they will all be delighted. I could write an essay on the levels of pleasure I experienced when I sampled my first one. That was a special smoke, and I'm using all restraint to save the rest for my trip home for the holidays. Merry Christmas.
WOW, I cannot say enough about the quality and great taste of the CAO Black. It has the perfect draw and thick delicious smoke that make cigars so enjoyable. The deal you have on these (with the 6 freebies and limited edition box) was just too much to pass on. Thank you for another great deal and accurate review of this cigar.
You guys continue to outdo yourselves. I'm sitting here, smoking a CAO Black and savoring every puff, and reading your latest catalog. Aside from the fact that you have the most entertaining catalog in the industry, your prices and specials just can't be beat anywhere. You offer such a tremendous array of cigars and accessories at the best prices. Plus, your intro deals are an incredible way to sample some of the best cigars, it's how I discovered the CAO Black. I've always been a huge fan of CAO's but the "Blacks" are my favorite and you guys are the only ones who sell them (at very fair prices for the quality, I might add!) Plus, your descriptions of each cigar, such as construction, taste, and smoking characteristics, are spot on. You run a "no BS" organization and it shows. From your catalog and website, to your excellent retail store (just the nicest, most straight shooting guys I've ever met in a cigar store), you're a class act.