Your web browser is no longer supported.
Cigars International is committed to providing you with the best web experience possible.
Close

Nat Sherman Reviews

Shop Now
Overall Rating 4.69 out of 5 Based on 39 Ratings

Customer Reviews of “Nat Sherman”

Write A Review
5 out of 5
5 Star
30
4 out of 5
4 Star
7
3 out of 5
3 Star
1
2 out of 5
2 Star
1
1 out of 5
1 Star
0
Showing 1-50 of 55 Reviews
4 out of 5
Nat Sherm Hobarts
These are great cigars and we liked these OK, but, as fine as they were, we still think that Baccarats are better and still our top choice. The Nat Sherms just aren't as smooth.
5 out of 5
Great service
Great cigars, service, price and shipping!!!
5 out of 5
Excellent
This is one of the best cigars I have ever smoked. Extremely smooth and enjoyable from the first draw to the last. My new favorite.
5 out of 5
Nat Sherman Hunter
Very Good Cigar
5 out of 5
Great cigar mild
Great cigar mild
4 out of 5
Very good mild cigar. Burns
Very good mild cigar. Burns smoothly to the end.
5 out of 5
Very enjoyable!
Starts out mild with a hint of sweetness but finishes with a really nice and suttle medium feel. Very complex from start to nub. Burn quality is ok.
4 out of 5
Like a $100 bottle of wine
Nice smoke but not worth the price. I am a guy who thinks a $10 bottle of wine is just as good as most $100 bottle of wine and I feel a lot better spending $10 when the bottle is empty. Little unfulfilled when the burn of the Nat Sherman was done.
5 out of 5
Oh Yeah!!
Though taste is very subjective, I have to say that for the money, I think you would be hard pressed to do any better on performance or flavor. What a stick! Great value at twice the price.
2 out of 5
Nat's Hamptons D-
Not very good ,gave them away to people I don't like..Nat should try one before he sells them.
5 out of 5
Smooth and buttery
If you enjoy a mild smoke, this is an excellent choice. Creamy butter, slightly sweet and smooth from start to finish. Easy draw, holds an ash, perfect for the golf course or with your favorite after dinner cocktail.
5 out of 5
A memorable cigar !
This is my favorite cigar, for a couple reasons. Great, mild flavor. I'm a mild kind of guy. Flavor holds all the way to the end of the smoke. The 6x60 is my favorite size. The price is reasonable. The other reason I like it is because my dear, recently departed wife bought me a box of Sherman's shortly after I started enjoying cigars in the early 70's. It was the first full box of cigars I ever owned and they were Nat Sherman's. Donna didn't know anything about cigars and I don't know how she found them, but she certainly made the right choice! Every stick brings memories of her sweet kindness. Glad I can get these from C.I.
5 out of 5
nat sherman hampton
A mild cigar that is great for the golf course or after dinner with a cocktail.
5 out of 5
nice smoke
mild nice taste my go to stick
5 out of 5
Super Value!
There may be some $12 - $15 sticks out there, but I have never had a cigar at this price-point that was so delicious! This stick burns well, holds ash great, draws perfect, and most importantly it tastes great! No ash taste, no nicotine kick, but a nice pepper and sweet taste, with notes of cream and coffee. Very light, good smoke volume. New favorite of mine.
5 out of 5
Tasty
Mild, smooth and tasty. That's what I'm looking for. A man size stick.
5 out of 5
Excellent
For me probably the best cigar I ever smoked !!!
5 out of 5
Nat is smooth
This is a really good smoke. Classic, smooth, great taste. I have ordered these more than once!
5 out of 5
Smooth NY
Easy to smoke - well worth the price with enough interest for even the most novice lungs.
5 out of 5
Phenomenal smokes
Great quality smoke. Burns smoothly and generates large clouds of thick smoke. Many different tastes throughout. Well worth the price. I'd rate it is medium
5 out of 5
A great everyday smoke
This is a mild and well made cigar. You can always count on its beautiful Connecticut wrapper.
5 out of 5
Nat Sherman Hampton
This has been my favorite! to me, they are the best!
5 out of 5
Nice cigar
It was my first cigar!!!!That was a fantastic!Very mild,creamy,smooth,tasty!!! Swetened tip is good to!
4 out of 5
Nat Sherman Hamilton
Great cigars, as expected
5 out of 5
Nat Sherman
Great mild cigar, I will be buying more.
5 out of 5
Nat Sherman
I discovered Nat Sherman Cigars about 5 months ago, what a great mild and flavorful cigar!! Morning coffee, evening cocktails or a day on the links, this cigar is just a perfect mild smoke. Great flavor, construction and aroma!
4 out of 5
Mild well rounded
Mild well rounded
5 out of 5
Paul B.
As always, Received what I wanted, when I wanted it. No hassle.
5 out of 5
Nat Sherman Harrington
Great mild and mid afternoon smoke!
5 out of 5
always consistent !!!
I enjoy the cigar its smooth not to strong and its worth the money
5 out of 5
Love the mild cigar.
These are mildest I have found. The service and price are both excellent.
3 out of 5
Hamilton Nat Sherman
This last batch of cigars was very bitter, not the traditional smoothness.
5 out of 5
Smooth very enjoyable
NS Hampton ,is an excellent smoke, never disappointed
5 out of 5
Best sticks in my box
I love these cigars! Very smooth and mild with a small hint of sweet. Nice even burn everytime. Great smoke to accompany a glass of whiskey after dinner!
5 out of 5
customer
Great cigars, timely delivery
4 out of 5
A nice flavored corona, but you have to be quick.
The cigar burns even and is well made, but the draw is a little loose, so it burns faster than I like. While it gives you a nice flavor, it could be tightened up a little bit and still have plenty of flavor to spare.
4 out of 5
Nat Sherman
This Nat is good, I would like a little sweetness on the tip like the Halmilton.
5 out of 5
Nat Sherman harringtons were great,I would order them again
your store is great,especially your quick delivery.cigars are fresh. Very happy.
5 out of 5
TC OF Los Alamitos CA
This is a very good mild smoke with a sweet tip. It is similar to Baccarats but better. I like to smoke a variety of cigars, mostly mild to medium. This a great cigar to give to a friend who doesn't smoke much. I will definitely buy these again.
Customer Testimonials
Great mild cigar, good beginner cigar or if you're just in the mood for something mellow.
After smoking my first pack of 5 - 6x60, I have to say that this is the most mild cigar I have ever smoked. I ordered a second pack of 5 in the same 6x60 size. It provides a nice change of pace to the Perdomo 10th Ann. Champagne. When you feel like something a little more mild.
Received my order today that included the Nat Sherman Hamilton Corona. Nice mild smoke with a hint of sweetness. If you like your pleasure on the mild side, can't go wrong with Nat.
Just had my first Nat Sherman Host in size Hobart (5X50). It was a very pleasant surprise. This will be going into my high rotation for sure. Very unique creamy oily film on the mouth. Leathery sweetness abounds with a very well balanced pepper that stays on the finish till the next draw. They call this a mild... the flavors were more like a med to full. If you have a chance to enjoy one of these, don't pass it up
Got the robusto version in a build your own sampler special and I do not regret it. I'm more of a fuller bodied smoker but I do like to smoke a "palate cleansing" mild cigar every now and again. Couldn't be happier with these smokes, they burn great, have tremendous smoke output, and have the most delicious hint of sweetness. Currently smoking one while writing this. Well done Nat Sherman. I will re-order in the future.
Nat Sherman Host: Very easy to light. Excellent construction, draw and burn. Voluminous smoke output that is thick and creamy on the palate. Mild to medium strength with medium to full flavor. Flavors of sweet vanilla, cream and nutmeg with a medium length finish of nuts, sweet dough and toasted cedar.
I have to follow up on the previous review I wrote concerning the Nat Sherman cigar. The first one I smoked must have been one of those bad cigars we often receive. The ones I smoked after that is more in line with what others have written. This is a great cigar in every area, & the next time I write a review it will be after I tried more than just one. Please accept my apology.
Because all of the previous reviews have been positive. I will assume I'm one of those individuals who must have receive a bad 5 pack....The Nat Sherman 7x50 5 pack I receive have been the worse cigars I've smoked In years. The words harsh, bitter, hot, lack of draw & smoke are just a small description of my experience. The taste they left in my mouth took awhile to go away. I'm so disappointed since I had wanted to try these for years. I may break down & try another size since others give great reviews....
My favorite cigars. Light taste of sweetness on the wrapper, burns evenly and is very mild. I would recommend this to everyone
This is what a cigar should be. I will go back to work just so I can enjoy a Nat Sherman.
Love these cigars...all sizes. The touch of sweetness on the tip actually works in this instance (most cigars, it wouldn't). The construction and draw is flawless. The taste is outstanding, the type that leaves you wishing for more. The only problem is that they are no longer "dirt cheap" as the ad says.
Nat Sherman and Gispert are two of the best mild and flavorful cigars to me that leave no lingering aftertaste . They will leave you satisfied and the cost and construction/burn are great. Not everyone can afford Monticristo . Macanudo Hampton court are good but leave a wet hay taste in my mouth. Don Diego has no aftertaste and is probably the best cigar to offer a newbe for the cost . However, after a while my taste has advanced...now it's Nat Sherman and Gispert for my budget.
I read the discription from CI and deceided to try a box several years ago. I was hooked, mild cigar with a slight hint of sweetness that burns evenly throughtout your smoke. Great cigar while on the golf course or after a nice meal.
I am a lover of full bodied cigars. I do like to stock my humidor with some mild cigars from time to time and the Nat Shermans are my choice. They are slighty sweet on the palate and have a nice hint of almonds as well. You cannot go wrong with this brand.. Great great cigar...
This (Nat Sherman) is a very pleasing smoke with a nutty taste, gradually building in strength. They throw off clouds of aromatic plumes. I like the Hampton size. Glad I tried these, I will order more to keep in my rotation.
I'm a beginner--at 44! This is the cigar(Nat Sherman) that has brought me into the fold of fellow tobacconauts. It starts with a hint of sweetness, and maintains a mild and balanced flavor from start to finish. I am now exploring the vast horizons of cigardom. Whatever disappointments may come in my search, I know I can always return to this cigar for satisfaction and rejuvenation!
Adroit