Your web browser is no longer supported.
Cigars International is commited to providing you with the best web experience possible. Please upgrade to a modern web browser.

Rocky Patel Vintage 2nds Reviews

Shop Now
Showing 1-0 of 72 Reviews
Customer Reviews of “Rocky Patel Vintage 2nds”
Come on....Stop advertising these (RP Vintage 2nds)! I don't want anyone else to find out about these! I would have to say that this is probably the best buy you have!
SJ of Urbandale, IA
I can't believe I only paid $2.66 each for these cigars (RP Vintage 2nds)! They are outstanding! I smoked one right when I opened the package and it is a SUPERB smoke! I've smoked way more expensive cigars than this that couldn't touch this one. It burned perfectly and evenly, with a perfect draw, too. It had a nice tight ash, too. Toward the middle, the flavor started changing, getting richer. I smoked this sucker right down to my fingers. Really, a great, great bargain. I'm gonna give one of these to my cigar smoking buddy and let him enjoy it, too, and when he's done, then I'll tell him how much it cost. He's gonna flip and I predict he'll order a batch for himself, too. Thanks CI!
KR of Albuquerque, NM
I find it hard to believe that these RP Vintage (RP Vintage 2nds) 1990 Petite Coranas are seconds. They taste every bit as good their expensive "cousins". Fantastic draw on every one. They are consistantly outstanding.
RM of Fairfax Station, VA
I have always been leary about buying seconds but you made the RP Vintage Seconds sound so good I gave them a shot. You were right! Other than the fact that they are not boxed pressed I can't tell the difference and if there is some flaw in the appearance I can't see it. Can't beat the price. Thanks CI
MM of Costa Mesa, CA
After having enjoyed the Vintage 1990 I thought I give the 1992 a try as well (RP Vintage 2nds). They were just as good a smoke as their older brother. Sometimes its hard to believe all the hype about certain cigars but these Rocky Patel's meet and exceeded all my expectations of a cigar for this price. This is a can't miss deal. I've ordered more of both.
RB of Ellington, CT
Had a chance to punch one of these (RP Vintage 2nds) and light her up this week with a buddy of mine who grabbed your bundle. It was indeed the taste I remember from Rocky. Don't be afraid to buy these because of the word "2nds" They are everything you expect from RP. It's a no brainer.
DD of Oradell, NJ
I am now on my third bundle of these wonderful cigars from Rocky Patel. I first tried the Vintage brand from a local store, and I can't believe that I can by these beauties for one third the price I paid at retail. All you have to do is try the Rocky Patel Vintage 2nds once and you will realize that they are just as good as the full price cigars.
DL of Livonia, MI
I just got my order of 1990 and I am proud to say I am a new member of the RP 2nds bandwagon. I challenged myself to let them rest in the humidor for at least a day w/o the cellophane wrappers. I was rewarded with a smoothe, creamy, almost floral at times in the first third, smoke that was so easy to draw and just got better with each puff. Loads of sweet smoke and the complex flavors that lingered on my palate made me wonder how the originals, (which I have never had), could be any better. I too was very hard pressed to find the blemishes which speaks loudly of Rocky's level of acceptable vitolas to carry his name. I have a bit more room in the humidor and I think it wise that I go ahead and put my order in, for some 1992's I think this time. Definitely in my rotation from here on for as long as they hold out. Cha-ching Badda-bing CI!!!!
CE of Jeffersonville, IN
Recently I made a couple purchases from your company and was 100% satisfied with the products I received. My first purchase was a bundle of Rocky Patel Vintage seconds (Excellent!) My next purchase was the CI-All Stars #3 and the selection was great. I thoroughly enjoy the readings in your catalog. I especially like the way each cigar is detailed by the taste, the boldness, the wrapper, the filler, etc. Your company has made my cigars smoking days very pleasurable.
GR of Wharton, NJ
I ordered my bundle on Friday, received it on Monday and finally bit into one of those beauties on Thursday! Let me tell ya, I don't know how anybody would pass up a deal like this on RP Vintage 2nds? A nice medium body, smooth with a slight bite...excellent. I will probably order myself another bundle soon just to have. Thanks CI for the deal!!!
RD of New Milford, NJ
I recently was invited to my bosses end of the year party. Upon my arrival I shared with with the rest of the group my Rocky Patel Seconds(RP Vintage 2nds). They were a huge hit. Everyone that smoked had one, people that didn't smoke tried one because they just smelled so good, and my boss who has been smoking cigars for over thirty years said that this was one of the best cigars he ever had. I told him the brand and the price and he couldn't believe his ears! Thanks CI!
PM of Manassas, VA
Incredible....absolutely incredible. I ordered the petite corona RP Vintage 2nds and let me tell you, one of the most finest cigars I have ever smoked. I have a few RP Vintage 1990's on hand, and I can't tell the difference. When I am pressed for time and I'm craving ANY cigar, the RP Vintage petite coronas are the ones I grab. I gave a few to a friend as a gift, he told me to give him the name of the company selling these. I told him CI, and to hook me up with some of HIS cigars he orders from Cigars International! You've got another client CI!
GR of Centreville, VA
New to CI I just got my RP 2nds 1990 robusto, RP must be a stickler about perfection. I could not find any blemishes at all, and best of all I put it up against my real vintage 1990s and could not tell the difference. the draw was perfect, and the burn was even will pick up some more RP 2nds before they are gone.
HH of stuart, FL
The only difference I can find between the Vintage seconds (RP Vintage 2nds) and the the actual Vintage line is the nifty band on each stick. If you're a poor college student, as I am, or just looking for a good deal BUY THIS!! What a creamy, spicy mixture of wonderfulness, mixed with a little amazingness.
CL of Cedar Rapids, IA
These are too good to smoke --- so I am hoarding them. Got six bundles now. Medium bodied, sweet, slight pepper taste,... delicious. I have yet to find a cigar other than the RP Vinage Second that I nub EVERYTIME and I have been smoking cigars for 15 years.
PP of Wheeling, WV
Where else can you get a 93 rated smoke for 3 bucks a stick? These (RP Vintage 2nds) are truly a great smoke. I keep ordering more. I've ordered the firsts as well and there really is no difference in flavor or quality.
ED of Tallahassee, FL
The RP Vintage 2nds. "Holly Crap!! smoke them with your eyes closed and you'll think your in Heaven".
MP of Loxahatchee, FL
They (RP Vintage 2nds) are a great cigar and the price is very reasonable. Why buy the first line ones when the seconds are just as good..at a much higher cost?
DS of Centennial, CO
Was extremely happy with the bundle of RP Vintage 1990's 2nds I received. It was worth the wait on back order for these beauties. Shared one with my Dad and he loved them so much he's going to order some himself. Can't miss with Rocky! Was hard pressed to find the blemishes. The taste was great as well as the aroma and they burned evenly with a nice firm ash. Ordered more before they're gone.
RB of Ellington, CT
Was hesitant at first, then went to Big Smoke and asked Rocky himself about the 2nd's (RP Vintage 2nds). He assured me they were the exact same as the regular, the only difference is they had no band and cosmetics on the wrapper. So I decided to give them a shot and now they r my staple everyday smoke. A $9 cigar for $3, there is no beating this deal.
MR of Dallas, PA
Wow! The RP Vintage 1990's have always been a favorite of mine since my first taste, but these Vintage 2nds are A STEAL! Same wonderful blend, but much cheaper. Definitely an "everyday" cigar for me. Thank you CI for introducing me to them!
JF of Atlanta, GA
WoW! I have no idea why these are called "seconds" (RP Vintage 2nds)? They are absolutely delicious! All I can say is I got a bundle of them yesterday and the day after tomorrow I am ordering 2 more... maybe 3.
WS of Waterford, MI
Do not pass these by (RP Vintage 2nds)! I was very sceptical at first, as the regular vintage cigars are extremely enjoyable. I get them in the mail and almost throw them away. They are not a consistent color, the wrap is about 90% as perfect as the original. Then I smoke a couple, as the first one was as good as the original. If you like this smoke, get these seconds. You will not notice the difference, I swear!!!
CS of Round Rock, TX
My favorite smokes have been CAO Gold for many years. I tried the robusto sampler which contained CAO Gold, Perdomo Reserve, RP Vintage 1990 and 1992. I liked the RPs so much I purchased a bundle of RP Vintage seconds. My number one smokes are now RP Vintage. I like the 1990 a little more than the 1992. The seconds are spectacular at $3/stick. I'm sold on RP.
JC of Lomita, CA
Just over $3.00 a stick (RP Vitnage 2nds)! It arrived in a triangular cellophane mazo of fifteen individually wrapped cellophane smokes without bands or any labels on the outer packaging (not as shown in CI’s advertising). The square pressed torpedos are perfectly constructed with no observable blemishes whatever, although the maduro wrapper color varied ever so slightly from stick-to-stick. With no moisturizing smoked directly from the cellophane, the pre-lite draw and aroma is superb, and it lit easily. The maduro wrapper is beautiful and adds a robust taste to the blend. However, I still prefer the 10-year Sumatra, but just by a shave! The taste is identical to its full price brothers, the opening is airy with just a hint of spice and nut, it evolves into a creamy almost juicy taste by the one-third mark and from there on it is lip smacking with tastes of chocolate and hits of charcoal toast. The draw is easy and it booms out smoke! The grayish ash holds firm for the first third and the burn is even all the way to the nub. Though medium bodied this fantastic maduro cigar creeps up on you when smoked to the nub so watch out! All the evolving mellow tastes lull you into thinking it is a candy bar so you smoke it to the end and then it kicks. This year I have smoked many of the top cigars in the industry from Perdomo to El Rey Del mundo, to Partagas and this second is right up there even when pitted against its namesake. Rocky Patel is taking blending and construction to the next level if he calls these masterpieces seconds! These seconds are exclusive to CI and on constant backorder and I shall be on that waiting list because when he stops manufacturing these blends (1990 & 1992) the seconds will disappear and only the pricy boxes of firsts will be available.
RC of Hendersonville, TN
IT'S hard to tell why these (RP Vintage 2nds) are 2nd's.i only saw one small place that probably could have been considered a defect.Rocky Patel's standards must be high if these beautiful cigars are getting rejected.But i'm glad, because these are incredible cigars at value prices.i'm wondering if i should build another "coolerdor" and stockpile these.
RA of Macon, GA
All I can say is what a value with these Rocky Patel Vintage Seconds. I picked up the Toro 1992's and wow I could not tell why they were seconds. Each of the 15 cigars had a smooth even draw and the complex flavors were fantastic. This is the best value in a cigar that I have found yet. You feel like you are smoking a $10 cigar rather than a $3 one! Thanks!!!
BL of Palatine, IL
I, along with a few of my fraternity brothers, bought 2 bundles the churchills (RP Vintage 2nds), which just came in yesterday. As soon as I took them out of the box and bundles, I right away knew that this was the best deal I had ever found. Rocky Patel must be the pickiest man in the cigar industry. I couldn't find anything really wrong with these beautiful sticks. The ONLY thing that is wrong with them, and it's not even wrong in my book, is the color of the wrapper. THAT"S IT. No blemishes on the wrappers or anything. And let me tell you, that's not the best part. My brothers and I knew what we had to do. We had to fire a few of these babies up. So we did, and they were fantastic. The smoke laid a sort of nuttiness and earthiness down on my palate, not being too heavy at all. And the fact that they were only a little over 3 bucks a stick made it just that much better. A+ deal and A+ smoke in my book.
SR of New Brunswick, NJ
Have been a Rocky fan for about 2 years now and like the Edge Lite, American Market, and Vintage 2000 & 2002s. Based on Rocky's quality, consistency, and the reviews here I couldn't resist trying a pack of the Vintage Seconds Torpedoes. I like torpedoes and, generally they are rolled by the more talented torcedores so my expectations were high. I've smoked six of them so far and 3 have been wonderful, just like the banded ones, but the other three have been complete duds. One was like trying to suck through a pinhole (despite ramming a poker through it) and had to relight it a dozen times before giving up. The other two also needed relighting and made canoes that would make the Mohicans jealous. I hope the rest are better, but right now, I can only say stay away from these! The savings are not nearly worth the real price you pay.
RG of Jamesburg, NJ
Just got my first order of RP Vintage 2nds four days ago and I am ordering more. These slow-burning sticks throw off so much flavor they seem to consume all senses at once-very unique, complex, yet surprisingly mellow. I'm thinking I might have to buy a larger humidor just to stockpile a few bundles of these. CI, when are you going to go public? I want to buy some of your stock!
RA of Escondido, CA
i received my bundle of '90 torpedoes(RP Vintage 2nds) a while back. I smoked a couple here and there and really enjoyed them. Then I forgot about them. I recently found them in the bottom of my humidor a year and 4 months later and finally smoked one. THESE ARE NOW MY FAVORITE CIGARS. Sure it took a year or so, but like i said, THESE ARE NOW MY FAVORITE CIGARS. Buy a bunch and leave them in your humi for a year or so. Believe me, it's worth it.
BW of Los Angeles, CA
The 90 is one of my top 3 smokes. I can't believe how lucky we are to have this top rate smoke at an unbelievable price of $3/stick. I received a regular 90 (not a 2nd) with a sampler pack and can't tell the difference. It will be a sad day when these 2nds are no longer made. By the way, I just tried the 92 and it now has moved into my top 3 also. Maybe even surpassing the 90. Thanks CI for the great deals.
BN of Mile High City, CO
These smokes kick butt. (RP Vintage 2nds) Best deal out there. Better than the Davidoff private label seconds. Taste as good as the firsts. Had about 10 batches with only one a bit loose on the roll. 1/3 the price of the firsts and well worth it. Everyone who's had these are convinced. Try 'em and see for yourself.
TK of Cupertino, CA
'92 Churchill (RP Vintage 2nds), I got these about two weeks ago and have smoked about 1/2 of the bundle. These might be the best stoogie I've ever smoked. My experience is just as our friend Gonz's review for back a couple of years. I hope CI carries these for life.
TB of Boston, MA
Had been hearing about RP for a while finally picked up an 'overpriced' vintage 92 second at the local shop. I'm relatively new to the world of handmade premium cigars. I've monkeyed around with some Victor Sinclairs, Fuentes, Hoyo de Monterrey etc. This supposed reject pretty much blew away anything in this price range. Burns well and in line with the audio and reviews. This was the first cigar that I actually smoked one after the other! Rock Patel is an evil genius.
EO of Milwaukee, WI
I recently purchase some RP vintage 1992's "seconds" could not tell why they were seconds!! It took everything I had to let them sit in the humidor to refresh after their transit to my house. An EXELLENT cigar! New to the cigar world I was lucky to have discover RP's stuff. Wonderful cigar, great price, thanks
SF of Houston, TX
Just got my 1990 Robustos (RP Vintage 2nds) and man I can't say enough about these cigars. I've been smoking cigars since the mid-90's and I have to say these easily are in the top 5 list of cigars I've had. These will be permanently ensconced in my favorites as long as CI has them available.
JW of Fayetteville, NC
Just got my '90 Robustos (Rocky Patel Vintage 2nds). I won't pretend to know what the real one's are like but I can tell you this is one fine smoke. From the second you yank one out of the cellophane the buttery wrapper gives you your first indication your in for a treat. The draw is smooth, the burn is even and slow, taste is complex and flavorful, and the finish is clean as a whistle. I'm no expert but I agree with CI, 2nds are a steal!!
MR of Las Vegas, NV
Ordered a bundle of the '92 Robusto and '90 Perfecto. (RP Vintage 2nds) I can't believe these are "2nds"!! Some sticks I'll be damned if I can find an imperfection. Others are very minor, perhaps a sunspot or a less than perfect cap. Each one has been pure joy to smoke, a new favorite!! Perfect burns, long white ash, great taste. I'm buying these again!!
EM of Dallas, TX
what a great cigar (RP Vintage 2nds) . i smoked one a few hours after i smoked a rp vintage 1990. i couldnt tell the difference in taste or burn. the only difference i noticed was the color. the 2nds were a little lighter in shade. still dont know why these would be called 2nds, they are a 1st in my book.
JO of Saginaw, MI
With all due respect,RP Vintage 2nds you would be a fool not to fill your humidor(s) with these tasty treats if you like the RP Vintages. Personally, I'm a '92 kind of guy. I never immagined I would be able to get this at a bundled price. Now, my standard go-to cigar is a RP '92. As for the missing band, We would just have to remove it anyway. Rocky just did it for us! Thank you, CI!!! As long as they are in stock, I'm buying them.
MR of Alexandria, VA
Just got the 1990 robusto and I have to say that these are a solid smoke. This is my first Rocky that I've had, and I'll definitely pick up another order of these! Can't beat the price and the quality...
GW of Chicago, IL
Seconds huh? HAHAHAHAHAHAHA........If not for careful inspection of the wrapper and the lack of the band one could not tell. The flavor and the smokability are there. Solid smoke by all accounts.
CB of Savannah, GA
I just bought a bundle of the 92 torpedos and the 90 petite coronas and was wondering why people say they are identical when they are not box pressed the same. The 92 torpedos look different then the regular line because they are more rounded and not box pressed. I really enjoyed the 92 seconds and would buy again but in my opnion they are not the same because of the shape. I have not received the petite coronas yet but was wondering if anyone has tried them and if they were box shaped.
JK of Saint John, IN
These are my favorite cigars for the money. Hands down can't be beat. And I have CI to thank for drawing my attention to them! I will be back for more. Considering buying a second humidor just to stock up on RP seconds!!!
DT of Bothell, WA
I got a mazo of Vintage 90s and shared with my ISAF Italian buddies here in Afghanistan. A few of them knew immediately what they were smoking. How can you give out these expensive beauties? they asked... I did admit to giving out one of the best cigars in the world, but not that they cost hardly anything. The 2nds smoked as good as the 1sts. Not a one was ugly. The quality of the roll was top notch (of course for Rocky...it's natural). I'm ordering more real soon...just have to buy a stick first to keep my new best friends back.
KC of APOLLO BEACH, FL
What a deal! What a cigar! I've been smoking the RP Vintage 1992's for about 5 years and they are my go to cigar. I was more than excited to find RP Vintage seconds and didn't hesitate on pulling the trigger based on all the reviews. All i can say is WOW! what a smokin' deal these are. I compared them to the few Toro's i had left in my humidor and i gotta say i honestly couldn't tell why they were seconds. QC at the factory must be strict for these to be considered seconds. Why would you pay retail on firsts when these seconds are every bit as good (if not better because of the price). Phenomenal cigar at an exceptional price. Needless to say i'll be ordering more the next time i head south of the 49th parallel.
AJ of New Westminster, BC
These are great for the price, but some of them have a very tight draw....
JB of Keene, TX
I can't believe these are 2nds. Wonderful flavors and price.
ML of Hollidaysburg, PA
I may be one of the few who is not pleased with this purchase...bought a bundle in early March...fell in love with the Decade so I thought I would try these on the many great reviews...finding the draw on these sticks to be really hard...seems like I have to draw way to hard and getting a real bite when I do... I have also tried trimming less..than a little more...maybe I'll try a plug....I took them out of their plastic wrap and will let them sit in my humi...even at a little less than $3.00 a pop I will not buy these again.
DE of Gibbsboro, NJ
One of the BEST CI DEALS on the site ! These babies are every bit as good as their high dollar brother “Rocky Patel Vintage 1990 Torpedo”. It has just the perfect draw & not too powerful with hints of caramel and cocoa. There is a bit of sweetness like a cherry chocolate or sweet cedar complementing its flavors. GREAT DEAL THANKS CI!
TK of Rouses point, NY
Got a pack of Robustos 1990 and they are fabulous! Very full bodied with tons of flavor and very chewy! Gobs of dark cocoa and expresso! Some sweetness and ZERO spice! No pepper zing either! Very smooooothy..... The only thing was the burn. Wonky at times and had to relight it. Annoying, but oh, GREAT flavor! Highly recommended!
VC of Brooklyn, NY
A friend had given me a couple of RP Vintage 1990 Robustos. I'm a Mild/medium kinda guy and these guys sat in the humidor cause the deep color scared me off. I shouldn't have waited! Great cigar. Well made. Even though very RICH in flavor, the smoothness allowed wimpy old me to really enjoy them. When I went cigar shopping, even at CI, these fellows ain't cheap. But, at the bundled 2nd price, they are a steal! I also picked up a bundle of perfectos for walking the dogs. They burn well and are good to the nub.
TM of Ellicott City, MD
I have enjoyed these cigars since their release and anyone I've introduced them to loves 'em as we'll. Great draw throughout with consistent, smooth flavor. My favorite in the humidor.
BK of WINTER GARDEN, FL
Unbelievable! It's now my new favorite.
BT of Novi, MI
Nice flavor, but the draw was a little tight for my liking. Good value for the money no matter what the label says or doesn't say...
OM of Staten Island, NY
Excellent cigar for an every day smoke. Excellent flavor and excellent price.
MM of JOHNSBURG, IL
The 1990 is one of my favorites. Great any time of the day stick and the seconds are absolutely the same as the firsts in construction, burn and taste.
RA of MESA, AZ
Always a favorite of mine. Love the petite corona for those times I can't sit around for an hour to enjoy a great smoke.
JP of Syracuse, NY
Love the cigars; incredibly fast delivery. Way to go CI!
JR of Strafford, NH
Thank you that humans are imperfect because these joys wouldn't be available. Secondly, lets thank Patel for their high standards because some of these 2nds I feel as though COULD have passed as regulars to my eyes, and their integrity, honesty and standards now has me as a consumer not only for 2nds, but for the first. Now, with that there were issues. ROTT the first burned super uneven the second a day later burned even but I had some wrapper issues...(wait need to take a puff :).... The Cigar itself is scary, scary good. Considering these are their seconds... they are better than most brands first, seriously. I typically don't like to smell OF smoke but I blow every puff onto my clothing so I can bathe in this wonderful blend and cherish every moment. I purchased the Robustos and only having 2 basically ROTT, I cant imagine what a few months will do. RP seconds, I applaud you for your high standards because if I spent the money for the firsts I would be upset, but thank you for staying true... I cant wait to try a first someday, but, for now I am a consumer for seconds... most companies first cant touch your seconds.. TY
EL of Cincinnati, OH
The vintage imo is the best rocky patel blend. It's smooth, creamy and full of chocolate flavor makes this one of the best smoke under $10. The 2nds just makes this tasty beauty even a better deal.
SL of Charleston, SC
Wow these are great. They have every characteristic of the Vintage line except for minor blemishes. Hardly noticeable. These are a great buy. The draw is great just like almost every Rocky Patel cigar.
IS of San Francisco, CA
Good flavor but not great. I had quality issues with the burn. I would avoid theses for the price versus the value. The Nicaraguan 2nds smoked these. Way over rated in previous reviews!
SG of Citrus Heights, CA
A friend turned me on to the Vintage 1990. I'm pleased with the seconds, but I've smoke three of them now and each one needed to be re-lit for the last third. I also detect more bitterness from these than from the firsts that I've smoked. Overall, I'd still buy these again.
NC of Waukegan, IL
I've been ordering the 1992 Toro 2nds for years. I first started purchasing the 1sts. I was told the 2nds are just as good and was happy to learn I was told right. It's just a wonderfully satisfying smoke, smoked down to the last 3/4". Can't recommend it too highly.
LA of OAK PARK, IL
My favorite smoke is the Royal Vintage and these are pretty darn good!
SP of joshua, TX
The best.
PL of EAST STROUDSBURG, PA
Great buy, excellent cigar for the golf game!
MG of WESTMINSTER, CO
These cigars are beyond amazing! Absolutely a great smoke...burns perfect, great draw, taste magnificent and cost a fraction of the price. I personally won't be purchasing regulars if the seconds are in stock...
AG of Hialeah, FL
I purchased these based on the endless, outstanding reviews on this website.... halfway through the cigar, it gets very bitter. I have smoked two with the same result and have had to end the cigar prematurely....
DC of Morgantown, WV
Bought these bad boys for a bachelor party and they did not disappoint. Couple snobs complained about the lack of bands but were put to bed after they found out how much I paid. Excellent flavor and draw!
NH of Seattle, WA