Your web browser is no longer supported.
Cigars International is commited to providing you with the best web experience possible. Please upgrade to a modern web browser.

La Estrella Cubana Oscuro Reviews

Shop Now
Showing 1-0 of 49 Reviews
Customer Reviews of “La Estrella Cubana Oscuro”
Big clouds of smoke, great taste, great burn--------Delicious nuff' said.
JT of Irvington, AL
I must admit to enjoying the fan mail that people write on their fav cigars! I am some-what new to cigars, but once I tried one of these maduro's I decided I needed to write one myself. "What a great cigar" was the first words out of my mouth after lighting this chocolate boy up! It has a very smooth draw and a super even burn! I was smoking with a buddy who also agreed that this should be in the standard rotation. Guess what, I'm ordering another bundle right away!!!
JB of Prior Lake, MN
I received a La Estrella Cubana Oscuro in the 'Honest Pour' sampler while searching for an everyday smoke (the Honest Pour is 15 cigars that appear to retail in the $1.50-$3.00/per range on CI). Of the sampler's offerings, this cigar, the Perdomo Lot 23 and the Gran Habano Connecticut #1 really stood out in my view - I really enjoyed all three of them. When looking to purchase a larger quantity the price point of the La Estrella Cubanas won handily. Just finished the first 'E' toro from my bundle and couldn't be more pleased with my purchase.
SB of Santa Rosa, CA
The Estrella Cubana Maduro Is a surprisingly tasty stick. Nice barnyard aroma, a dry chocolaty taste, woodsy, earthy and a maduro sweetness. These tasty sticks are dirt cheap, that's the surprise. A good cigar at a great price, period.
KB of San Francisco, CA
I will admit I don't know much about cigars but I know what I like. When I finished this smoke I logged into my account and added it to my favorites. The only bad thing is that the sampler I purchased only included one of these. It is a great smoke at a great price. Thanks CI.
DP of Grinnell, IA
I'm just about done with my first bundle of these (La Estrella Cubana Oscuro). Tasty. Very close to my standard, Gurkha Doble Maduro. Maybe a hair smoother, but has that rich cocoa I've fallen in love with. I will definitely be buying more of these. Please don't run out CI!!1!
WR of Williamstown, NJ
La Estrella Cubana is a very nice and rich smoking stick. It is very well made and burns perfectly. Very rich flavors, but lacks the sweet finish I look for in a maduro. At the same time this is a very fine cigar with ample flavor.
RF of Eau Claire, WI
I bought the robustos the first time out, and frankly felt, like a couple of reviewers, that these weren't really all that good. And they never got better. Then I got a sampler, if I recall, that had a Churchill in it, and I let it hang out because I didn't really feel up to that much of a not so great cigar. When I finally gave in and smoked it I was surprised at how nice it was. Hmmmm.... So, I ordered a bundle of toros, thinking that maybe, for some inexplicable reason, the blend needed a particular size to really work. I've had a couple brands like that over the years. Anyway, given some time, a few weeks, they indeed smoke quite nicely from start to finish. Now, we all know the story: Good cigar brands sometimes go bad, other times are spotty in consistency. Annoying. But the toros work for me, with some time in the 'dor. I will order them again, and may be disappointed... Or not. I wonder if they use different leaves for different sizes... presumably. So maybe size does matter, lol... ;0) My experience has been that bigger is better for L.E.C. Your mileage may vary.
PS of Shelter Island, NY
I love to be experimental but this La Estrella hit me the right way after trying several... but there was a consistent value all of them I tried, there was gentle bouquet and touch of sweetness to it, I'd have loved to have had that Dominican filler replaced by Jalapa leaf -- that would have been special. My rate on this stick: 82
CS of South Gate, CA
Well... This has got more flavor than I imagined from some of the feedback, which is good. It burns real nice, has an excellent draw and produced big plumes of smoke. I am happy, and the price is the real kicker, I whole heartedly agree with the staff reviews. Oh, and it just got delivered yesterday after a week in transit, can't wait to try it with a little age!
PM of Laurel, MT
I just smoked my first La Estrella Cubana last night that I received in the Chunktastic sampler. A hefty 6x60 vitola...what a great smoke! If you like maduros, as I do, you definately have to try this. And for the price, you just can't beat it! Another CI winner!
MM of Clayton, NJ
These should get a Best Buy award. It is mild but has plenty of dark maduro flavor, burns well, and sometimes that's enough. Gave one to a buddy who is only an occasional smoker of higher priced sticks and he was impressed. Give them a try if you like a mild maduro once in a while.
JS of Lincolnton, NC
These are smooth and very mellow, with a first rate wrapper( rich). All of which burn slow and consistant. I found it relaxing. I found myself wanting a little more flavor from the filler.All in all, a good deal.
DE of Arcadia, IN
I received one of these cigars in a CI sample pack. I was blown away by this great tasting smoke! The aroma is fantastic, I saved the band so that I could order more and I just did! What a fantastic price for this cigar! This will be my go-to cigar when I can't afford my Rocky P's!
ST of Orlando, FL
As a big fan of: 1. Mild/medium cigars 2. Maduros 3. C.I. I can easily 100% endorse the staff and fan reviews regarding the LEC's. The catalog description is dead on. These offer a wonderful smoke for perhaps $2.00 each. Try one of these and you will easily come to the conclusion that purchasing anything even close to this quality from your local smoke shop would run around $5 to $6. OUTSTANDING VALUE!
KG of Acton, ME
This cigar was not as strong as I was hoping for, but still a very good smoke. Actually an excellent smoke for the price. If you like maduro, order some and you will not be disappointed not for this price.
JA of Shoreacres, TX
I bought some of these recently and boy am I glad I did. So far these have been well worth the 1.66 a piece that I paid for them. Lets hope that the prices on these never go up!!!!! This will probably be my daily smoke from here on out.
JK of Caney, KS
Winner,Winner,Winner, I just got my shipment of the robusto size La Estrella Cubana , and let me tell you these are really good. A mild Medium, bodied smoke that is jam packed with flavor. Its a very tasty maduro with some sweetness , some coffee bean taste, and hint of dark chocalate. The robusto size I got was $29.99 That was the best $30 bucks I paid out in a while ,and in these tight money times its great to know that you can get a really great premium smoke cheap as hell! Did I metion these cigars are a Winner? I am boldly stating if you purchase a bundle of these , you will most definatley get a few more, I know I will be.
VF of Pittsburgh, PA
This is an awesome cigar. Taste is similar to Gurkha Empire III but at a better price. Plenty of smoke and nice chocolate taste. CI has plenty of great cigars at great prices but I would put this one at the top of the heap. This is one cigar that I hope to always have in my humidor.
DC of Louisville, KY
I just burned one of these last night. It had been in the box for about w months resting before getting in the queue. Talk about a surprise... it was smooth as silk. I like a strong cigar, and this one was smooth and fairly strong. I agree with the other reviews that said there is a definite cocoa flavor throughout the burn. While it doesn't change character much, it does stay consistently mellow for the entire smoke. Construction was great, and the entire cigar smoked perfectly to the nub in just two long ashes with no relights or touch ups. It was getting a little more woody (yes!) in the last third, but never harsh or bitter. These are a steal at these prices.
RW of San Antonio, TX
Nice!..near perfect burn with an easy draw and plenty of flavor. Ranks right up there with smokes I've had at 2 to 3 times the price. An excellent buy.
TK of Chico, CA
man what a smoke is about all I can say. everyone else was right what a value. Now all I need to figure out how to make room in the humi for more.
HC of Harve De Grace, MD
I don't understand how the price on these is so low. I don't expect a lot from a sub $2 smoke. These surprised me. They are great for when you want a low nicotine, smooth, well-made maduro with a nice coffee note. If anyone has a bad experience with these, age them. In my opinion they are too wet and young off the truck. The complexity and flavors come out with about 6 months of age.
SB of Madison, AL
Prelight: Lovely Barnyard, somewhat salty-chocolate aromas Upon lighting: This has a nice smooth creamy dark chocolate, rich espresso flavor. I highly recommend this cigar, Hands down the best bang for your buck!
DA of Beaverton, OR
Got this today as a gift from wife. This one I enjoy. A smoke that should cost a lot more then it does.
JM of Westwego, LA
Wow, I first smoked one in a CI sampler pack. It has quite a taste of flavors, very fresh, and finishing off the 1st bundle with another order coming. The relatively low cost does not come close to the smoking value. Highly recommend smoking one.
SS of Lakewood, CA
I got one of these in a sampler, and was not impressed with the look of this cigar at first. Then, after an especially hard day at work I lit one up in my truck for the drive home. HOLY SMOKE! It was like someone set off a smoke bomb. I had to roll down the window so I could see to drive. The draw was so easy I checked to see if the cigar was broken somewhere. Nope. Great taste, good burn, nice price. Keep up the good work CI.
OE of Loudon, TN
The saga continues...After a week in the box the cigar has become quite a bit less harsh and is just about smokable. The flavor profile is coming to that of dark chocolate with a hint of coffee. However the last half tasted markedly of wet cardboard, while not wholly unpleasant, it was not what I wanted to taste after the first half. La Estrella has moved to a 73. At a $1.75 each with shipping included...not too bad. I hope this cigar continues to improve because I am wondering why ALL the other ratings are so good and Steve O's were off the charts. It just doesn't add up. I so want La Estrella Cubana to be THE giant killer.
ER of Grosse Ile, MI
Got one in a sampler last year, tried it after a few months and was really impressed. Early this year I ordered a bundle of Belicosos. I completely agree with what some other reviewers have said; a few months in the humidor makes a big difference for these smokes. After sitting for a bit, they have a great cream, coffee and cocoa taste, and burn great. I haven't had a single one tunnel, go out, or plug. Great purchase for maduro fans!
RG of Coolidge, AZ
OMFG... Don't let the low price trick you into thinking this velvety cigar is cheaply made. Amazing flavor within clouds of creamy smoke for a very low price. Don't hesitate to try it.
GR of Hollywood, FL
Just on the WOW reviews, I purchased a bundle. I was disappointed. I tried 5 over a few weeks and they didn't get any better. Harsh and the wrappers tore easily. I left a few in the humidor to try later. I'm not holding my breath. It could be possible I guess, that I just got a bad bundle.
SM of Tuscola, TX
This is a follow up to the review I made in Oct. of 2011. I took one of these out of the humidor this past weekend. Wow!!! What a difference six months on these bad boys. I was so disappointed, ROTT. Do yourself a favor, first buy these, then store them away for three months or more. Sit back and enjoy a FANTASTIC smoke. You'll be so glad you waited!
SM of Tuscola, TX
I'll start by finishing first - One great cigar. Ok, I bought a bundle based on submitted reviews and quite frankly we all have very different opinions when it comes to a cigar but I will have to admit I love this cigar and everything about it. Lights easy, draws perfect, burns true and delivers outstanding flavor all the way through the smoke...in short "one great cigar".
TC of Waverly Hall, GA
Tried these when I first got them and was disappointed. Threw them in the cooker 3 weeks, and tried again today. What a difference. Enjoyed the smoke. I'll buy more.
DE of San Angelo, TX
This cigar takes the cake for a tasty maduro for the budget minded. I bought a bundle of these at the same time I ordered the Gurkha Cignarnivore III sampler and I like these LEC's better than any of the Gurks. Delicious chocolate taste and an absolute TON of smoke. My only word of caution: The delicious taste left in your mouth after smoking these will cause a devilish temptation to light up another.
JS of Bristol, TN
This is a superb cigar. I find this cigar to be somewhere between a black pearl and a LGC type R or at least a good 1st runner up. I would expect to pay 7 or 8 dollars for a cigar of this caliber. I must say a little time in the humi does them good.
DP of Norristown, PA
This is a well made cigar with a beautiful appearance. The dark maduro wrapper exhibited the right amount of oils and provided a very pleasant chocolate aftertaste. This one is a definite keeper. It provided an easy draw the complete length of the cigar and the ash was solid and well maintained througout the smoke. This is a great cigar to smoke with a good 15 year old Scotch. I actually ordered a bundle for my humidor and highly recommend it.
JH of Hennessey, OK
A veteran aficionado friend of mine gave me a La Estrella Cubana Oscuro Belicoso to try insisting that they were highly recommended. Of course, I was somewhat skeptical since how good could a $2.50 stick really be? Needless to say, it turned out to be one of the best smokes that I'd had in years easily comparable to the finest $10-$15 cigars. This 6"x52 torpedo had an oily jet black wrapper, smooth draw and the flavor itself was definitely more on the medium rather than mild side. The ash was white and firm and the stick evened itself out quickly despite its initial slightly uneven burn. The complex flavor instantly reminded me of the Cohiba Black with its rich notes of chocolate and coffee but without the $10+ price tag. And unlike some other premiums that develop that peculiar "skunky" taste towards the end, the LEC was nearly flawless all the way to the nub. As a result of this great discovery, I just bought my first of hopefully many bundles of this fabulous stick!
DH of St Petersburg, FL
I ordered the factory seconds that were not made to the specification CI had ordered. Great discounting from CI landed the lovley gars at .99 a stick to my APO address. My lucky day was when these gems arived in a 30 bundle and the first one had me hooked. I will always keep these fellas in the humi at this price.
RS of WINDBER, PA
I just now, ok about an hour ago, received my bundle of 20 Toro 6x50. right out of the package I was amazed at how smooth these are, or I should say "is" I am smoking one right now. I must say they have the whitest ash of any cigar I have smoked and the strongest ash too. I say this is a great medium cigar, I would put it up against some of my favorite big name high priced ones. Ya gotta try these. I will always have these in my humidor, do yourself a favor and try em you'll be surprised. (I can wait till they are in the humidor for a while)
DO of DAVENPORT, IA
What can I say, a great smoke at a price that allows me to make this my everyday cigar. Deep dark wrapper that really comes through from start to finish. If you like a note of chocolate in your smoke, this is the cigar for you. It never fails that when I give a friend one of these they end up buying a bundle and no one believes me when I tell them it is a $2.50 cigar. Buy 'em you will enjoy them.
JC of SCHAUMBURG, IL
Recently bought La Estrella Cubana Oscuro and was disappointed. They were backordered but was able to order 20 maduro and the quality of the wrapper was bad. The size of the robusto 5x50 seem oversized....
ED of NEW MARKET, MD
Pleasantly surprised by this smoke every time I buy them. I can't think of a better Maduro under $2.00 bucks. Or 3 or 4. Not a powerhouse, but a great sit and relax on the porch stick.
CH of INDIANAPOLIS, IN
Excellent smoke with rich plumes of smoke. Great taste and easy on the pocket book. This is my "go to" and I always have at least a mazo of 20 in the humidor. Can't go wrong with this stick.
DH of VANCOUVER, WA
She won't win any beauty contests but WOW does she offer a lot of flavor! Creamy, silky, and milder than I had envisioned. Has a feel and draw of a box pressed higher dollar stick. Only drawback was a little dry ....can't wait to smoke another after being in the humidor for a while. I will definitely buy these again and share with my friends for a small fee. They don't need to know how much they are.
TA of Rossville, IL
Great smoke! As a runner I limit my smoke to a once a week treat, unless I'm on vacation, which has never been dificult until I bought these bundles of joy. They burn perfect and taste even better. Nice roasty and earthy cocao flavor with the slight maduro sweetness. I have found my all time favorite especialy with the price. Fully recomend!
LR of Fort Dix, NJ
So far, unfortunately, mostly the wrapper, sometimes the cap, sometimes both, but ALWAYS the wrapper comes unglued.....rendering the stick un-smokeable.......generally around the start of the 2nd 3rd. I had this exact problem with a tin of Macanudo Maduros from CI except they came un-rolled pretty much as soon as the head was snipped. Not sure exactly what gives as all other sticks from CI are flawless. So much so that CI is my exclusive cigar supply......seriously! Well.......Their prices are like a broken drum stick, (can't be beat), as is their customer service. The deal on these & the reviews led me to give them a try as a "daily knock around"......but I have yet to get to the halfway point with a single one! Decided to give them a few weeks of humidor time & see if that fixes this issue. Hope that does the trick as they seem to be a good stick with a great price point.
LH of Williamsburg, OH
Great cigars for the money
TB of VICTOR, NY
I love these cigars from start to finish. Nice, cool, full flavored smoke. Consistent and even burning. Well worth the cost.
DG of Mount Washington, KY