Your web browser is no longer supported.
Cigars International is committed to providing you with the best web experience possible.

Casa de Garcia Reviews

Shop Now
Overall Rating 4.21 out of 5 Based on 70 Ratings

Customer Reviews of “Casa de Garcia”

Write A Review
5 out of 5
5 Star
4 out of 5
4 Star
3 out of 5
3 Star
2 out of 5
2 Star
1 out of 5
1 Star
Showing 1-50 of 132 Reviews
5 out of 5
Great every day smoke!
Smooth,mild to medium body, decent burning and a all around great cigar for the money.
4 out of 5
Work around-the-yard cigars
I enjoy a nice cigar to pass the time I spend working in my yard. Obviously, I don't want to spend an inordinate amount on a cigar for this, and these are perfect for casual enjoyment. They are mild and burn very nice and even. They provide a very enjoyable smoke, but not at a price that makes them too much of a guilty pleasure.
5 out of 5
Excellent Value
Enjoy the sampler deals - able to sample cigars I would not usually try.
5 out of 5
R. Michael
Excellent taste ... Outstanding value.
5 out of 5
5 out of 5
Great inexpensive cigars
I like to smoke Casa de Garcia cigars while playing golf because they are smooth and stay lit thru the whole smoke. Thanks
5 out of 5
very good
everything has been very good thank you
5 out of 5
Good job guys. Always fresh
Good job guys. Always fresh cigars.
5 out of 5
Casa de Garcia
Very good Cigar at a good price
5 out of 5
Fantastic cigar!
Fantastic cigar!
2 out of 5
Not first choice
Often too tightly rolled and difficult to draw. Not bad for daily use if you don't mind working at it a bit.
5 out of 5
Great Value
cigars are a great value and are half the price if I went to the smoke shop to purchase.
5 out of 5
Perfect for golf.
Slow burning,easy draw. Good golf cigar. Each one lasts 6 holes. Great value!
5 out of 5
Best value for the money
One in 15 has a hard draw. Other than that, consistent, mild flavor. My favorite cigar. I smoke 3 or 4 a day and I can afford it with this brand. I am not afraid to hand them out to neighbors. No one would know it is not a 3 to 5 dollar cigar. Sincerely, Joe
5 out of 5
Great Cigar!!
I've smoked cigars that have cost 4 times as much as the Casa de Garcia's but few that are alot better smoke!!
5 out of 5
my everyday go to
a great tasting everyday cigar.. why pay more?
1 out of 5
"Late Delivery"
My order was scheduled for delivery on 10 October 2015. I received a notice saying the delivery had been changed to 13 October 2015 owing to weather. I called Cigars International to cancel the order as I was departing town on 12 October 2015. They could not or would not do anything for me. They said I would have to refuse the shipment. If I'm not home how do I 'refuse shipment'! As it turns out the package was at the FEDEX office on Friday morning (9 October 2015). Yet it was not delivered as originally scheduled.
2 out of 5
Lip gloss to the rescue!
Class de Garcia Colossal is a nice size with an even burn and nice amount of smoke. I just had to get past the bitter wrapper! Yikes! After I made a modification(I put on a heavy coat of lipgloss! Handy!)so I wouldn't taste the wrapper on my lips the smoke tasted very good creamy and smooth. Will I smoke them all...well yes, I love all cigars for their suttle and not so suttle nuances. Will I purchase them again? No.
2 out of 5
OK for the price.
Simple, inoffensive stick. Mine smoked just fine, but I wasn't left wanting more.
5 out of 5
Great everyday smoke
Great everyday smoke
5 out of 5
Great service nice professional staff
1 out of 5
Set Fire Your Cash... It'll Be Over Quicker
Save your cash. Wrappers fell apart, burn was uneven, and I ended cutting them up to use for patches on ciagrs with minor issues or a cigar that I might have dropped and cracked.
5 out of 5
Great service and products. Have
Great service and products. Have and will continue to recommend clients.
3 out of 5
tight draw good roll just fair
5 out of 5
Great cigar, easy draw, and CI makes the price right
Have been getting my cigars from CI for 3 years now the selection in good, the prices are good and the delivery is very good.
5 out of 5
Fair Smoke
Decent taste, 2 of first 3 burnt uneven.
5 out of 5
Great service and great buys
Great service and great buys
5 out of 5
Great smoke for the price!
Great smoke for the price!
5 out of 5
Smooth even burning smoke at a great price. Mild but full of flavor.
I've been smoking these for two years now. Unbeatable value for such a smooth even burning cigar. Plenty of flavor. It's a home run for flavor, quality and price.
5 out of 5
I liked it.
Ihave placed several orders ofCasa de Garcia Churchill Conneticut cigars and have been mostly pleased with each order.(one order was short but CI made it up Immediately.) The cigars are ready to smoke and are a good mild inexpensive stick. I even save money by ordering online rather thanshopping at a local smoke shop.
5 out of 5
Great stick
These are a great everyday stick. I've never had one with a bad draw or taste.
4 out of 5
Solid Smoke
Good mild every day cigar
3 out of 5
longtime Casa smoker
This is the first time I bought the shorter and thinner version of what I think is a really good everyday smoke. These 44 ring smokes, I'm sorry to say, are not as nice as their big brothers. I'll finish these up, but never go back to these skinny wanna be's.
5 out of 5
excellent. Thanks
4 out of 5
My Casa de Garcia Churchill Ct. review
Excellent cigar for the buck. I generally only smoke one cigar a day and alternate between the Churchill Connecticut and the Reds. I find it a complimentary pair.
5 out of 5
Great cigar for the price Tasty!
5 out of 5
For those of you who
For those of you who like a lighter mild cigar I highly recommend the Casa de Garcia Churchill. cant beat the quality and price
4 out of 5
Cheap and tasty
excellent value, consistent roll, great daily smoke to keep in your truck or on the back deck.
4 out of 5
Not too bad of an everyday cigar.
Tasty, fairly well constructed, better to punch with these, though, if you don't like little bits of tobacco in your mouth.
5 out of 5
The Best!
It kills me to walk into a Cigar Store and pay double the price
5 out of 5
Everyday smoker
I' ve never had a Casa de Garcia I didnt like. So smooth, so mild. Would be an everyday smoker if i smoked that much.
5 out of 5
free cuba
That is a wonderful smoke!
5 out of 5
what is this?
Always an even burn. I enjoy everything Casa de Garcia makes. The Connecticut is always smooth and creamy. It has become one of my favorite cigars.
2 out of 5
Good and bad
Some were good some were not!!
5 out of 5
love thie variety and the prices is awesome
3 out of 5
Good flavor, Mild cigar
I liked the flavor and aroma. They are a good cigar for that price. Some were wrapped a little tighter that others and didn't draw as well as others and some had an uneven ash. I would probably buy them again.
5 out of 5
Casa de Garcia Churchill Maduro
Have purchased these cigars a few times from CI. Always fresh,unbelievable taste for the price. Great Golfing cigar. Will order again. Fast shipment a plus.
5 out of 5
Cass Dr Garcia Maduro
Even burn, smooth draw, good construction.Win,Win,Win.
5 out of 5
Love the CASA
Nice small smooth cigar very satisfying
5 out of 5
cigars from CI are always great, love those casa de garcias as well as those great rockey patels
5 out of 5
great cigars at a great price
Easy order quick ship unbeatable prices
4 out of 5
Great everyday smoke
They are flavorful everyday smokes. Constructed very well. Best cigar in its price range.
4 out of 5
Inexpensive Relaxation
A decent, long lasting smoke. Hard to find a better cigar for the price!
4 out of 5
Great smoke for the price!
4 out of 5
Definitely a Bang 4 Ur $$$
The flavor and consistency of the burn is what you would expect from Garcia. Dark chocolate , vanilla and slight pepper finish. Long burn with bright white ash. Positively the best everyday cigar I've smoked.
1 out of 5
Not a good tasting cigar. Outer wrapper leaf had large veins.
5 out of 5
1 out of 5
The smokes came in the package well enough. The cigars in whole have gone to production way to soon. Condition: leaves had greeny vains to them as if it needed more time to stay in the sun, Cigars were very hard to the touch, smoking one the draw was very hard but the taste and nuances were trying to come through. In comparison with other bundles these were rushed to market to soon. This is the only bundle I have purchased with this issue in the future I will purchase this brand from a "B&M" instead of online. Would not recommend this brand to anyone. Rob.
5 out of 5
MG from TX
Great cheap smokes. Good flavor, burn even and not too fast or too slow
4 out of 5
Good Everyday Cigar
Good cigar for the everyday ride home from work when you're sitting in traffic. It's inexpensive, medium body, and a medium burn with a relaxing effect. Very satisfying until my evening after dinner cigar. Gino
4 out of 5
get every day cigar at a great price
5 out of 5
mmmmmmmmmmmm mmmmmmmmm good
great cigar nice ash lots of smoke nice creamy taste bought 3 bundles a few here have tight draw but have draw poker that fixes that problem smoked about 15 of the first bundle will order again when my stash gets low lol under 20 cigars
1 out of 5
Not a good experience
I am a little surprised with all the great reviews. I thought these would be a great value smoke. Maybe it was just the coronas, that is the only size I tried. I found these cigars rolled way too tight. Very difficult to draw. I wasn't crazy about the flavor either. Maybe I will try these again in the future, but there are too many good value cigars to recommend these.
4 out of 5
great cigar
This is a great cigar for the price, nice even burn. The perfect cigar for sharing with friends and making new friends.
5 out of 5
Casa De Garcia Order
my order came in early and in perfect condition. Not to mention a great stick for a daily inexpensive smoke as well.
4 out of 5
Getting better, more consistent, and at an unbeatable price
Casa de Garcia Connecticut is as good as it comes at this price level. I have been smoking it since the "early" days and it has improved greatly, both in looks and flavor. It is now a well constructed cigar and most of its early flavor fluctuations have disappeared. It is very mild; to me, is an everyday any moment cigar that behaves good with any kind of drink. You won't get fancy flavors out of it, but a simple tasty smoke, sometimes close to an ice cream sugar cone, but only at the first half. Then it starts building to a not unpleasant sharp finish, which varies sometimes from stick to stick. The Toro is my favorite, since it provides plenty of smoke, cool, and lasts enough for a good conversation. It is woody sometimes (balsa?) and pleasant, the ash is white-greyish on layers, not specially firm, and the construction has improved greatly. It has been a long time since I've had a run on one cigar. I very much enjoy it and the price is great.
1 out of 5
Not able to smoke this cigar
these cigars were absolutely rolled to tight. I was so thoroughly disgusted after the eighth cigar in a row that was non-smokable I threw the rest away.
5 out of 5
My Golf Course Cigar
Great cigar for the price. Syuper when playing golg... good to relax to a nice mild cigar. Consistenlty rolled and smomkes nice under the most-trying drives and putts.
5 out of 5
Casa de Garcia Toro Connecticut
Great mild everyday smoke...quality constructed and reasonably priced!
5 out of 5
Casa de Garcia Magnum Connecticut
Great everyday cigar, reasonably priced, mild and an easy smoke
Customer Testimonials
Tried many cigars from CI and this is now a favorite. Mild but moist and flavorful. Great value. I will be buying more of these. It doesn't hurt that the logo on the label matches the first letters of my two kid's names.
Have been a cigar smoker for years and also review cigars. I have smoked the maduro in Churchill and it is by far one of the top worst cigars I have ever had. Cuban sandwich with a lot of stems that can be considered sticks, ugly, very tight draw and the first two parts of the cigar have a horrible taste that would spoil maduro cigars for a new smoker. Horrible. Gave them all away. A shame that this cigar comes out of one of the best factories out there which rolls my favorite cigar Montecristo.
No complaints about the price or the taste. Seems like every 3rd one is difficult to get a good draw. Maduro has a rich espresso taste and Sumatra is very earthy and nutty. Not sure if I will buy again but not dissapointed either. Your call.
Nice mild smoke. Good for the first cigar of the day. Certainly worth a $1.15 per stick.
Not bad at all, especially for the price. Very mild flavor, good for an early morning smoke or a companion for yard work or tending the grill.
Mmmmmmmmm I have found another low cost go to cigar when I get low on cash and need a stick. This piece tasted great. I, too, cannot fully describe the taste, but yeah, it was smooth, and really velvety. On the wishlist for more, especially at that bargain price.
Amazing really. I am on my first one and if the rest of the bundle is equal to this I will have found my new everyday-go to cigar. Let me quantify my remarks by saying that I had the fortune to smoke much more expensive and often very famous cigars fairly regularly in my youth... my idea of a cheap cigar was a $5 stick at the local cigar shops on a weekend night in the late 90s. Now that I'm grown and have no money and lots of responsibilities, words like Montecristo and Cohiba are just that....words (and memories.) Last summer and fall I had some terrible luck trying a few different value=brand smokes to try and find a great deal that also smoked great and I kept getting skunked. These bad boys are like a revelation! Casa de Garcia are made by Altadis, one of the best cigar houses in the business. Take a look at their brands, AMONG OTHERS, Montecristo (my be all end all favorite), Romeo y Julieta (another favorite), Don Diego, Butera Royal Vintage, H. Uppmann, Onyx Reserve, and many others. The story I got on these bad boys is that they use leftover (often times premium or super premium) tobaccos from the brands they make, have their senior rollers train new and/or less experienced guys in rolling long-filler cigars with the extra tobaccos, and the result gets labelled as Casa de Garcia. This Connecticut Shade wrapped, Dominican-binder, Dominican and Honduran long filler cigar is just the essence of easy smoking and good, mild taste. A winner no matter how snobby you are, I'm very happy with these. I would imagine 3-6months in the humidor will result in a seriously smooth cigar for less than $1.50 a piece.
Incredible cigar for price! Time for my next bundle.
One of the best "daily" cigars I've found. Even burn, good taste, and great price! I live in Europe half-time and can get cheaper in the open-air markets, but I take these with me instead.
I received five Connecticut robustos from a friend. In my humble opinion they were all about as "middle of the road" as they come. Almost no flavor, but mild and well constructed. Wouldn't buy myself, as I think there are better options in the value category. If you're gonna try a Casa de Garcia, I recommend the Honduras, which is still pretty mild, but has some pleasant flavor for a value cigar.
A great smoke, very mild with a wonderful flavor!
I'm a newbie cigar smoker (since Oct. 2014) and this is the best cigar I've found. It's not overwhelming and mild enough for the beginning cigar smoker. For the price it has clearly become my everyday smoke. From the ones I've smoked, they burn better and more evenly than the $5-$10 cigars. I can see myself with a 200 count humidor packed with Connecticut Churchills. (I'm working on it right now.)
Nice tasty cigar.
Wow! I was a bit hesitant about a cigar of this size, but it was really great.
Great cigar for the price...I have purchased these cigars a couple of times and have not been disappointed.
Not a bad cigar. Burn was even enough and flavor profile was ok. It gets a little stronger as you smoke, but not as bad as cheaper cigars. Overall, This one is a great value. I tried the connecticut, but I think I might prefer the maduro- I'll order those next time.
Didn't expect much from this stick...BUT Boy was I surprised. The ashes did flake on me but thats alright with me. Would def smoke one again.
Great cigar. The Corona Connecticut is my fav! Thanks.
In a blind taste test held by 5 seasoned cigar smokers age 47-68 this baby beat four 90 plus rated cigars. I had to see it to believe it.
I've been happy with my purchase of the Robusto Connecticut version of this product. I've smoked four of the twenty so far and have had great, even burns. I have not had to relight once and the draw is quite nice. Tonight's stick produced about two inches of ash before it fell off. I'm new to cigars so I wanted to start off with ones that are mild-bodied and cheap, but still have quality to them. These are just that.
Solid, well constructed cigar with even burn and smooth taste. Best cigar for price I have ever smoked. Highly recommend.
Holy Crap! What a hidden treasure this cigar is! If you love mild inexpensive cigars this is for you. Mild flavor, well constructed. Regularly get 2" ash that winds up on me! Been smoking them for 2 years. Get for the first time cigar smoker.
To my liking I found the Maduro the best of the two between that and the Connecticut (but I do prefer Maduro's). Both burned evenly, drew well and were very mild to my palate. If you don't want to pay much and have a light smoke while hanging out on the deck or riding around in the sun on your mower...these could fit the bill.
Pretty much what you would expect for the price. Good, but not great. A good choice on the golf course or mowing the lawn where, if you run over it, you're not too devastated.
Bought a Casa de Garcia Maduro at my local shop today opened it up looks are not impressive but one of the best smokes I have had in a long time. I can not believe there $1.00 per cigar. Right now I have a 3 inch ash and have not had to touch up. Razor sharp burn and the flavors are unbelievable. Buy this you won't be sorry WOW.
Great cigars for the price just ordered 20 more if I had a bigger humidor I would order 100 of them.
This is my 2nd review: After trying these...the Connecticut, the Maduro and the Nicaraguan in a variety of sizes, Iv'e come to the conclusion that the Corona size is the best construction wise. The thicker ring sizes seem to have burn problems, but the Coronas burn almost razor sharp almost all the time. I get nearly an hour with the stick and no frustration with tunneling or canoeing. great for those times when I feel like smoking one after another and I don't want to burn through half a box of more expensive sticks.
great everyday cigar.....highly recomend
If you are looking for an inexpensive Good cigar, this is it. Very nice in every way. Burn well, although I sometime have problems with the draw. The flavor is great. Nutty and spicy Cameroon flavor.
For the price you can't go wrong. Easy draw, lots of smoke, beautifully constucted, smokes like a $5.00 cigar!!!
A friend of mine have me a few of these a while back and I really enjoyed them. For the price this is the best cigar going. They are like a monte Cristo second. Great smoke!
Disappointed in the Toro CT, been through about 3 so far just too difficult to smoke, gave away 5 put the rest up for awhile to see if aging helps. The only cigar that I have purchased that I did not enjoy.
So far I've tried the Red... no taste....and the Casa de Garcia original?? in Sumatra and Maduro. The Sumatra has a very thin wrapper that tended to crack in the smoking....also a very dry uneventful taste. The maduro is a bit more zesty and tastes better. Haven't tried the Nicaragua variety yet, but will in the near future. For a cheap every day gar the Maduro might fill the bill.
Sumatra belicoso. 3 deep into a bundle purchase. Great flavor, draw, and construction. Im not a professional reviewer, but these meet all my requirements to be an enjoyable, mild smoke. Could be the best bang for your buck.... Good stuff !!
Great everyday, morning smoke, as it compliments coffee very well. And for $1.30 per belicoso, Im not gonna bash this cigar. It is well constructed, good flavor, very nice burn, and delivers what it promises. What else can you ask for at this price point? Will definitely purchase again.
These are really good. Can't beat this for the price.
Average cigar at a great CI price.
I love these cigars. Mild smooth taste, burns well and very affordable. Great for an every day smoke.
Nice smoke...but what happened to my favorite, the Churchill Red? Loved the flavor and value. Will miss it if it's gone.
I am new to cigars, but for my liking the CDG was absolutely tasteless. It burned well and even though. Maybe I just don't dig "mild". I smoked so far about 10 cigars and all were medium or medium full.
This is one of those you get what you pay off. In my experience these were bitter, difficult to stay lit and had a hard draw. I am all for a good cheap smoke, this just isn't it.
Recently purchased 20 individual cigars from a local vendor. Was very disappointed that four of the cigars were a complete waste. Two had absolutely no draw through the tobacco (a punch was not available) and two other basically fell apart while trying to light. Have been smoking these for the past few years and found this recent purchase very unsatisfying.
Try the Red guys! It is now my ride home cigar. Spark it up n relax, and let the idiots fly in rush hour. The 4.5 robo is very smooooth, lasts about 35 to 45 minutes. Just long enough to get home. The draw is good. Once in a while you will have one with a tight draw. It is truly a very good inexpensive cigar. Give them a try, you will not be disappointed.
Good $1.00 smoke. That about says it all. If you are looking for a cheap (but palatable) cigar then this is for you. Rough veiny wrapper, flaky ash, no finish and a few spongy spots.
Real smooth...mild, I was searching for something that a beginner like me could enjoy. These fit the bill perfectly. I know if I went into local "cigar shops" around town that I would have to pay about 7-10 dollars per stick. These are right on the money!
The cigars are truly awesome. Very smooth and very good stick for the price. Reds are very sweet on the start and remain sweet throughout. Maduros are very good and come with a typical Maduro flavor. My first Maduro that I sparked up was composed of all scraps which was actually very disappointing for me. It was plugged as a result. Unsmokable. Went back to my humidor grab another; fired it up and had absolutely no problems. It seems like the sticks will be hit and miss, but the good ones are definitely good. Must buy.
I was looking for a decent, cheap smoke for golfing and yardwork. This really blew me away far and away better than a lot of $4-5 sticks I've tried. I prefer the Sumatra's.
I was waiting on an order, but got a bit of a weekend jones. I went to the local smoke store and asked for a decent, cheap cigar. The owner said he had never smoked one, but told me he had heard good things about Casa de Garcia, so I bought a couple coronas and to make a long story short, I was blown away. I'll say that the burn didn't start out well, but everything else was a pleasure. So I just ordered a bundle of Churchills and they arrive Monday. Personally, I feel like I've found a hidden treasure.
I am an apprentice to the cigar world so I tend to enjoy the mild smokes. This cigar has an easy draw and an abundance of smoke. It's smooth, burns well, and has a nice ash. The price alone should steer anyone in its direction. If you are like me and enjoy the milder type of cigar, with a price that fits anyone's budget; you'll enjoy this one.
I bought a bundle at my local cigar shop in the dark days before I discovered CI. I needed a handmade to give out at a party and didn't want to break the bank. Got these for 3 bucks a stick and thought that was a great value for the smoke. Had favorable comments from the crowd. Now I see they are around a buck a stick at CI. Definitely keeping a place for them in my humidor.
A friend of mine gave me the connecticut churchill and I instantly fell in love so I had to buy a bundle of 20 from CI!
I sit here in my man cave enjoying a Belicoso Connecticut. The price alone should drive anyone in its direction, it is mild with a nice ash and no bite if ya smoke it too fast like I tend to. I ordered a bundle of 20 in the middle of February and I will be ordering some again soon. Trust me YOU WILL ENJOY THESE.
It's always nice to get something that you would be willing to pay more for. Cdg is one
Tried a stick of the connecticut churchill and absolutely loved it so I had to buy a bundle of 20. it has smooth creamy flavors with a great draw and and okay burn, nothing too bad though. I recommend buying them for a nice everyday cheap smoke!
Had to try one right away. It does have a certain flavor I couldn't identify, but it was NOT unpleasant. These are a good cigar for the price. They'll be in my rotation if the price remains stable.
Received this stick as a sample & had it sitting for about a week. Decided to open my last bottle of Westmalle Trappist and smoke this stick right before dinner. From the 1st draw I had a weird taste, couldn't put my finger on it. As I entered the 2nd third the weird taste started slowly going away but this cigar didn't get any better. Ended up putting the cigar out....I have have a theory on never classifying a cigar as crap until I've smoked at least 2 of them. With that being said, the last stick I have will sit for awhile before I even consider to smoke it.
Really nice cigar for around a buck. Smooth, nice flavor, good burn, did not burn to hot. Will buy again.
CDG is the gar everyone is looking for, a cheap smoke that tastes like a real quality tasting treat.
The king of inexpensive gars! Easily tastes like a 5 or 6 dollar smoke.
Casa De Garcia is a well hidden dream smoke. IMHO, maybe a 90+ for just over a buck. Like everything else cigars have come down to pretty packaging and PR (advertising) and PRICE... CDG is just a damn good smoke at a great price, a buck and change. If it has a flaw it would be the draw, a bit stiff, though there are many of us in the smoking community who find a firm pull a sign of quality. It gives you the feeling of , Hell Yeah, I'm smoking a great cigar. The ash? well keep an eye on her or you'll be wearing it. That baby will hold on for well over 2 inches not looking. If your laying down??? You'll have the whole ash 45 min later. Ah, a second flaw. Hey, I have to be fair. The Churchill on the regular CDG is a bit mild so your first inch or two will leave you longing for more. Then boom, there it is... So maybe not a flaw after all. Go ahead, give em a try. If you are not satisfied or can honestly say this is not one of the BEST cigars for the price, leave your name, I'll refund your purchase price as well...
Wow, great treat for the price. Has a terrific aroma and burns nice and even. Can't beat this one for the price!
Acceptable mild cigar for the price. Construction and burn were okay, flavor wasn't my favorite, aroma is nothing to brag about.