Your web browser is no longer supported.
Cigars International is commited to providing you with the best web experience possible. Please upgrade to a modern web browser.

Ave Maria Reconquista Reviews

Shop Now
Showing 1-0 of 19 Reviews
Customer Reviews of “Ave Maria Reconquista”
I got the Ave Maria Reconquistas as a gift to my brother for Father's Day. Highly recommended!
UB of Linden, VA
My NEW favorites have just arrived.........a father's day gift....can't ask for more than this!
JS of West Deptford, NJ
I was worried that the price would just be for the production value of having the individual coffins inside of the tobacco graveyard and, of course, the intricate oversized Ave Maria label, but I was wrong... This cigar was incredible! Unbelievable smoothness from the start down to the nub, with a sweet tabacco aftertaste that pleasantly lingers long after the last puff. That said, the Reconquista is by no means easy to tame. I usually smoke fairly quickly, yet this took me an over an hour to conquer. It is a full bodied giant and definately not an everday smoke IMO (obvious by the price point), but any Ave Maria or AJ Fernandez fan owes it to themself to stash a couple of these in their top shelf for that special occasion. To further put it into perspective, my favorite cigar is Morro Castle, based soley on the fact I "could" smoke those daily, but I recognize Reconquista as a more complex and superior offering.
RS of Valhalla, NY
Absolutely phenominal cigar! Everything about this one was perfect. The presentation with the cedar coffin and the beauty of the construction just added to the overall experience. I was pleasantly surprised upon first light to find that it has kind of a sweetness in the finish. Definitely one of the most flavorful and pleasant full bodied cigars I have smoked. I honestly can't find anything wrong with this cigar. Definitely not an everyday cigar but well worth the price for a once in a while or special occasion stick.
ST of Fpo, AP
Just got my box in yesterday, I couldn't leave it shrinkwraped! I had to see those coffins for myself. I intended to age them for a year at least, but, have convinced myself that I can allow myself to smoke one on the next BIG occasion. The other 2 I plan on saving. At the price I feel I will be getting a couple more boxes to leave sealed... I want to say DON'T BUY but that would be over sheer greed for not wanting CI to run out before my next order.
JG of Santa Maria, CA
I just ordered these cigars and from the time the order started processing, my legs started to tap the floor with the excitment of getting them to my front door. Being in Afghanistan on my 3rd deployment, I am sure these will be the highlight of this trip. Just the presentation of the box and the description I have read on them makes it so much sweeter. In one week when they arrive I will plan my two hours of quiet time in a nice spot to enjoy life as good as it gets.
JC of Apo, AE
This was a very nice cigar! Smooth and tastey to the end.
JK of Pomona, CA
All I can say is Holy S***. Bought a box of three to save for a special occasion here in afghanistan. Two of my fellow coworkers were departing and we have become quite good friends. I wanted to sent them off in style for their last night. We broke the box open and smoked them. I was apprehensive having never smoked these before and not knowing anyone who had. Just read reviews. I was promising my friends a quality smoke on the electronic words of others. I have smoked several premium cigars with a price tag that was no where near close to the quality you would expect. In fact in today's new cigar wars there are many that just do not deliver for the price you pay. God of Fires come to mind. Well, I rolled the dice and came up a winner. What an awesome smoke. Every bit worth the $20 price tag. Starting off you think it is a mild smoke but you can actually taste the rich creamy boldness increase as you work down the cigar. In fact the roll is so perfect and the burn so smooth that you will be looking for a clip or pliers to smoke it to the absolute end. Flavor does not diminish. Also, it is a cigar that that leaves you with a contact high at the end. The only thing that would have made it better would have been a glass of bourbon or scotch. I also bought a box of crusaders with the deal of 10 lion hearts thrown in. Ranking the three I would say 3rd place went to the crusaders, 2nd to the lion hearts, and the winner in a blowout was the Reconquista. I am definitely buying the bigger box and Reconquistas will become a permanent member of my personal stock and lineup. Thank you CI for stocking these beautys and having such a great price deal.
MC of WILLIAMSBURG, VA
When I smoked my first Reconquista I didn't quite know what to think. Was it a good cigar? Was it a bad cigar? Was it a great cigar? After flame met the Reconquista and caused the combustion of its contents, which caused heat and smoke (which I then inhaled), I was overwhelmed by the peculiarity of all the different and complex flavors contacting my palate. It was like a symphony of different sounds billowing from different instruments that were trying to come together with the help of a conductor to form this beautiful experience (at least one would hope). However, were these instruments and sounds, orchestrated by this conductor, shaped in a way to form that melodic experience? After smoking my second Reconquista I came to my final conclusion. After being hit with the smooth, earthy, and banana like flavors all at the same time I realized that this is a great cigar. The conductor (Ave Maria) performed an excellent and beautiful symphony (Reconquista). At no point was there a bad taste. The cigar burned evenly and the flavors were rich, smooth, and robust throughout the whole cigar. Although, admittance into this performance is pricey, but it is totally worth the fare. Save this cigar for a special occasion and enjoy a magnum opus.
DT of Fort Drum, NY
Amazing cigar. Wish we could by without fancy packaging!!
KG of Auburn, NY
Wonderful, spicy full-bodied smoke… But am I the only one that has trouble keeping it lit?
RS of Zionsville, IN
One of the best cigars of ALL time in my opinion! if there was ever a cigar that every cigar lover should try it's this one!
AD of Pickens, SC
Real nice smoke! This is a special occasion cigar for me. I bought several grab bag specials that included this cigar in individual coffins. Well packaged and a very good smoke. Overall I like the Ave Maria brands and the Reconquista is top of the line. In conclusion you can't go wrong with this smoke.
ML of PINSON, AL
What an awesome stick! This thing is a work of art. From the beautiful packaging to the gorgeous band to the magnificent wrapper. This cigar is a winner all around. Very smooth & very flavorful. Mostly a sweet hay/tea leaf flavor throughout with a toasty coffee finish drifitng in & out. Nice even burn. Beautiful solid white ash. It went all the way to the first band! Probably would've gone longer but I knocked it off to remove the band. Moderate smoke output. Wonderful aroma. No flaking or flowering on the ash. Just an all around pleasant smoking experience. Wars could be ended by this cigar alone. If world leaders would only sit down with one of these, two fingers of scotch & some Loius Armstrong/Ella Fitzgerald in the background, no more wars! Not a quick smoke by any means. It took me an hour to hit the first band. Then another 20 to hit the second.Another hour to the nub. Flavor intensifying all the while. They're a bit pricey but dont let that turn you off. When you smoke one you'll feel like a king. HIGHLY RECOMENDED! Pick some up today. What are you waiting for? Go....NOW!
JR of ennis, TX
Absolutely THE best cigar I've ever had. PERIOD.
SC of Purvis, MS
Excellent. As complex as the Liga T52 but not as subtle. Very much worth the price. Mine sat in the back of the humi for a year at 67.5% and came out as a celebration cigar. Will buy more.
RB of WATERLOO, IA
I love Ave Maria cigars Im relatively new to cigars about two years now and Ave Maria was and still is in my top two. At about $7 a piece I feel they are well worth it but I was worried I couldn't afford the Reconquista until now. CI you have out done yourself with the weekly special you mean I get a 5 Pack of Reconquistas plus 10 other 90+ rated sticks for $40? The Reconquistas alone are worth more then $40. My order came today and I can't wait to light up a Ave Maria when the time is right I can only imagine based on these reviews thanks CI
TM of Rosedale, MD
I wasn't overly impressed considering their price point. It's definitely full, and very fermented. Reminded me of the cask strength fermentation-wise. I smoked it after the MOW Armada and the combination gave me a buzz. I smoke a lot of cigars and that rarely happens. Discounted I'd consider them, full price I wouldn't think twice about moving on.
CE of Milford, PA
I have ordered some pretty high priced cigars in my time but they have always contained at least 20 cigars in the box. Every time I see a box of 10 cigars going for more than ones with twice the amount I get really angry. After smoking the AVA Reconquista I had a whole change of mind, and said I will buy these regardless of how many come in a box. One of the best if not the best cigars I have ever smoked. I used a stop watch and this stick lasted more than an hour and a half. The smooth rich flavor remained from beginning to end, and I hated to see this cigar come to an end. This is a must try cigar for every lover of a fantastic smoke.
DM of Hixson, TN