Your web browser is no longer supported.
Cigars International is committed to providing you with the best web experience possible.

Arturo Fuente Hemingway Reviews

Shop Now
Overall Rating 4.81 out of 5 Based on 37 Ratings

Customer Reviews of “Arturo Fuente Hemingway”

Write A Review
5 out of 5
5 Star
4 out of 5
4 Star
3 out of 5
3 Star
2 out of 5
2 Star
1 out of 5
1 Star
Showing 1-50 of 69 Reviews
5 out of 5
Arturo Fuente Hemingway Best Seller
Very rapid service. Easy to order. Arrived in good shape. Enjoying one as I write this. Your company is my go to place to order
5 out of 5
Great smoke
Love this cigar , super smooth the burn is perfect . The flavor to me was cedar and floral with some sweetness.
5 out of 5
Great cigars
I often just want to enjoy a "quick" cigar for 10-15 minutes just after dinner outside watching a sunset or the glorious mountains in my back yard and these are perfect. Very good smoke for me balanced flavor and taste not too strong but it doesn't get lost with a good glass of after dinner scotch.
5 out of 5
Love your cigars!
As in the past they were fresh and enjoyable!
4 out of 5
quality cigar, but one dimensional
I had high hopes for these, but the Hemingway didn't appeal to me much. There's a rich, aged tobacco flavor throughout, but that's where it ends for me. I was hoping for some more complexity here, but didn't get it. I can't rate this cigar poorly because of its excellent construction and quality tobacco flavor. It just wasn't my taste. Smokers who like a woody tobacco flavor with a touch of pepper will probably love it.
5 out of 5
Phome white,ca
These are one of my go to cigars. They're always consistent very uniform cigar never disappointed.
5 out of 5
Cigar order
Fast delivery.
5 out of 5
Always a pleasure to do business with CI.
5 out of 5
Always satisfies
Truly a wonderful smoke. Quality aged tobacco and quality construction translate to a perfect cigar. Med/Full strength, full flavored, leathery, vegetal, earthy. Smooth and cool finger burner.
5 out of 5
Arturo Fuente cigars are fantastic
Consistent and smoky, draw is smooth and taste is great. One of my favorite cigars right now and the shape is great to hold. Highly recommend
5 out of 5
What a great smoke, start to finish, now we know why they call it the Best seller .
5 out of 5
Loved them
Loved these cigars. Friends liked them as well
5 out of 5
Great cigar
AAA + gonna make this my new go to.
3 out of 5
Loved the shape
Harsh taste
5 out of 5
Hemingway short story
A great cigar. Just the perfect size for a walk or quick smoke. Great tasting and always burns evenly
5 out of 5
Celebrating my wedding day
I have about 10 of my friends that are going to enjoy the Fuentes Hemingways I am offering them at my wedding. I even picked up a few Tatianas for my brides sister and niece. Thanks CI.
5 out of 5
Ahhhh Fuente
Perfect size. Great taste. Good price
5 out of 5
Fine cigar, a keeper
I've had these from both CI and from local retail stores and they are always some of the best cigars so have around. I smoke them as treats every once in a while and they are never bad or poorly constructed. I've smoked atleast twenty to forty of these and never disappointed. I aged ten for over a couple years and let's say they tasted just as good as I recommend this cigar both signature and short story as a buy.
5 out of 5
nice doing buisness with you guys
as always just what I ordered timely delivery Thanks....
5 out of 5
One of my "go to" favorites
Fuente is one of my favorite brand cigars, and this cigar has become a must have in my cigar inventory. Smooth smoke, very good flavor, this cigar does not disappoint!
5 out of 5
Excellent Service
I appreciate the packaging and quick turn-around on my orders. Prices are good and service is always top flight
5 out of 5
Very good cigars.
Very good cigars.
5 out of 5
Arturo Fuente Hemingway, Short Story
I love the Hemingway line of cigars by AF. Never a bad one in the bunch always a great smoke. I wish they weren't as pricey, but they are good. I treat myself every so often to these little gems.
5 out of 5
A friend of mine smokes the Hemingway Classic's and gave me one to try. I enjoyed the smoke and that is why I bought some.
3 out of 5
Not as good as expected
These taste OK, they burn evenly, but hey have construction issues. Out of a 5 pack, the thin heads on 3 came apart, & 1 completely unwrapped. I am glad I didn't buy a box
5 out of 5
The Hemingway
The Hemingway is the best cigar for the money
5 out of 5
Short Story
LOVE these!!
4 out of 5
Very good cigars
Very good cigars
5 out of 5
Great cigar
I bought these for a friend that was visiting that only smokes Arturo Fuentes Hemingway's. I smoked a couple also and they are a great cigar.
5 out of 5
Great Cigar!
this is a great medium bodied cigar. Very smooth, it's turned out to be my wife's favorite!
5 out of 5
A Very Nice Smoke
I admit I am a fan of Arturo Fuente cigars and the Hemingway Signature is one reason why. The cigar is put together well and stays that way through the smoke. It burns evenly and holds the ash. I am not one that can describe the flavor so all I can say is it is sweet, smooth and pleasant. IMO this is one nice cigar
5 out of 5
Always a solid smoke
This is one of those cigars that is always a treat. Consistently fantastic camaroon flavors and a great burn sum this one up pretty perfectly. Never been dissapointed!
5 out of 5
My favorites
Best Sellers and Short Stories are my favorite cigars paired with a bourbon or a scotch. They always make the night cap memorable. CI did a great job shipping out a fresh box of my favorites and I am enjoying them very much.
5 out of 5
If it's Fuente, it's a great smoke.
Not much more to say that what I put in the title. When I bought these, they were the least expensive of the Hemmingways. It doesn't matter, they are all incredible smokes.
4 out of 5
Short Story
The cap was found to be lose on several of them
5 out of 5
Short story
great mild/medium cigar. Definitely going to be a repeat buyer! Next time I'm going too have too buy a full box
5 out of 5
My Favorite Smoke
the Hemingway is one of the best smokes you offer. Always consistent. Love'em
Customer Testimonials
Nothing much to say here other than an absolute work of art. The Hemingway would satisfy ANY smoker...the standby choice if EVER in doubt of what to buy.
So smooth and wonderful. I'm new to cigars and generally like aromatics like Drew Estates. This is a must try for those that don't like a bite.
Can't be beat for a smoke when you don't have 1 hour or more to smoke one.
....My go to cigar! You'll never go wrong picking one of these up and smoking it. Great tasting cigar; nice and smooth....
The Short Story are AWESOME! This allows for a quick 20-30 min smoke, but don't be fooled cause this cigar gets better at the end of the smoke!!
The WOAM [Work of Art Maduro]is a wonderful smoke. If you haven't tried one do yourself a "flavor". My absolute favorite stick.
The best cigar on the market!
These are always one of the best, smooth, quick smokes to be found.
Smooth to the last puff! I will order a box of these next time!
Upon embarking into my cigar hobby the guy at the local Tinderbox recommended I try the Hemingway Short Story. I instantly loved it and it has become a staple of my humidor. I even brought a few to share with friends and they were all equally impressed. While I'm not advanced enough to identify flavors, I would say that these are very satisfying without a hint of harshness. They produce a nice amount of smoke, burn evenly and smoothly down to the nub. The Short Story is a great size, though every time I get to the end of one I find myself wishing I'd bought one of the bigger versions instead.
Boy do these (AF Hemingway Signature) spoil you! A super smooth smoke from the first puff to the last with wonderful caramel and cedar nuances. Never a tinge of harshness. Full taste with no cigar buzz. The aroma is the best of any stick I have ever smoked. I never want these to end.
Very easy to light. Excellent construction, draw and burn. Medium smoke output with light silky, smooth mouth feel. Mild to medium strength. Medium to full flavors. Deep earthy sweetness with hints of coffee, cocoa, dark fruit and cedar. Natural sweet tobacco flavor on lips. No bitterness and no spice with all the flavors remaining on a medium length finish after each draw. The multiple flavors are consistent and remain throughout the cigar.
I had a Hemingway Short Story last night. It was my first after a buddy highly recommended it to me. The wrapper seemed somewhat fragile initially and cracked when I used the punch on it. For the first few minutes it required a few different lightings to maintain the burn, but eventually held and burned evenly. Also, the draw was somewhat limited for the first few minutes but it eventually opened up. The taste was very good, and I noted a change in flavors from the first half to second. There was a leathery nuttiness during the first half that I didn't anticipate, after hearing all about it from my buddy. The peppery spices really came through in the second half, which I liked even more than the first half. Overall, it wound up being the perfect stick to finish off a what was a great Christmas day. I just placed a 5 pack in my cart!
An epic tale: Arturo Fuente Hemingway, Signature Perfecto. If you have never experienced a Fuente Hemmingway then you need to re-think your life and go get one. These are some of the most nuanced, nearly magical cigars out there and stack up to smokes double or even triple the price. The Fuente Hemingway series constantly receives top marks around the world-and it's still underrated if you ask me. Only Fuente's best rollers are allow to make these cigars, and each roller is only allowed to make 75 a day. This beautiful perfecto shaped cigar straight out of the cello displays a veined, chocolaty wrapper, tight construction, and a perfect triple capped head. It smells strongly of leather, chalk, and espresso. Toast the pinched figurado's foot and the first dozen firm draws reveals tones of sweet wood and bread. A quarter in, and the thick plentiful smoke develops some subtle pepper and walnut notes and shortly thereafter and the draw relaxes for the rest of the cigar. By the time you reach the half way point the cigar will evolve to exhibit salted cocoa with a mellow earth, and leather tone. At the band you will experience a further flavor twist and be sent off with a warmed cedar, allspice, and coffee profile. The cigar has a long glorious finish of cinnamon, cedar, and cocoa. Enjoy this beauty with a cup of English black tea and creme, by a roaring fire. You have to try this for yourself, and trust me fellas: this might just be your new favorite medium bodied cigar! Overall: 9/10 due to near flawless construction, firm ash, amazingly complex flavor profiles that outclass cigars far more expensive. Ready availability and satisfaction for the price.
I'm on CI right now purchasing more of these little puppies. Got a 5 pack of the short Perfectos about a month ago. I eyeballed them for about a week in the humi before trying the first one. Big mistake. Every time I opened the humidor after that it was all I could do to not reach down and grab one. Nice, consistent burn. Med-Full bodied, creamy, sweet. I'm not going to try to BS my way through describing the flavors. I'll just summarize it in one word..TASTY. It's like reading an amazing book, savoring it and hoping it never ends. Sadly it does and you're struck with that sense of loss; you just know deep down inside that you'll never find another quite as good. Anyway, sorry for the dramatics and long review. Bottom line: loved it.
I have to say this is one of my favorite sticks to smoke. It has everything you could want in a medium cigar. It's good for morning, noon, or night. I have never had a bad one. Leave it to Fuente to have a consistent cigar.... this is a refreshing cigar. Way to go Fuente.
Great smoke, particularly if you only have thirty to forty minutes!
This is the cigar that had me at hello! The reason I started smoking cigars in the first place was due to the Arturo Fuente Hemingway. Very smooth cigar with a nice cup of Joe or even a nice cognac. Very smooth and creamy with nice transitions. If this is not in your humidor then you are out of your mind!
A great smoke with a glass of beer...
AF-Hemingway, definitely one of my favs. Was given one by a co-worker to try and I immediately bought a box. I smoke the short stories a lot for the simple fact that I can't take too long of a smoke break at work. Love the creamy smoke produced and the great burn to this cigar. I'll never be without these in the humidor. Great Smoke. N.M.--US Navy
The A. Fuente Hemingway Signature is quite simply my all time favorite cigar and the Classic is right behind it. there is a reason Cigar Aficionado gave the Signature a 93 rating. Because it is simply *that* good. I've had all kinds of cigars in my adult life, some better than others, but none have ever quite equaled the Hemingway Signature. I even recently bought the Footlocker Humidor so I could by boxes of cigars and age them a bit and my first box purchased? A box of Hemingway Signatures of course!
Perhaps I got a bad box, but my masterpieces sat in my humi for approx a 3 months before I broke one out. The burn was almost perfect, great flavor all the way down 3/4 of the stick, then I got an awful stinging sensation on my lips. smoked three more since then and all the same result. anyone else have this happen?
This was the first cigars I smoked and has spoiled me rotten. A smooth and wonderful smoke from start to finish, this is on the short list of mine and my husband's favorite stogies.
Nice morning stick w/coffee, very smooth, mildly sweet and creamy. The Arturo Fuente Hemingway, now pour that cup o joe.
The AF-Hemingway 'Best Seller', paired with just a wee bit of Grand Marnier, in a sipping glass; yum-yum!
A great smoke. Flavorful and consistent. A bit of an uneven burn but worth the trouble. Great with a Brandywine style beer. Will buy more....
AF Hemingway line are exceptional smokes. You hate to smoke them every day because they spoil you. For a medium body quick smoke you can't beat them at any price. I promise.
If you think the unique balanced flavors of sweet cedar and citrus zest are for you, then grab um. Top 10, 2009 for a reason.
the classic is great and had matured well in my humidor. i love the king b's, those have to be my favorite in the AF line.
Bro, as soon as you light these gorgous gifts from the earth they are pure heaven. (Arturo Fuente Hemingway) Definitly in my top five everyday smoke. The draw and burn is very consistent and u cant mess up the light for all you rookies cause of the perfecto design. I find this cigar to be medium to full bodied with notes on ceder and leather....... a tad spicy on the finish up.. all in all a classic like the man it was named after.
This (Arturo Fuente Hemingway) is an all day smoke for me. The aroma fills my nostrils with semi-sweet earthy clouds of smoke. worth buying if you enjoy relaxing anytime of the day!
This is one of my favorite cigars (Arturo Fuente Hemingway). You can't go wrong with either the Classic or the Signature. They both have the same great flavor. These smokes are medium bodied, full flavored, smoke to the nub beauties. The finish is awesome, a hint of chocolate is how I could best describe it.