Your web browser is no longer supported.
Cigars International is commited to providing you with the best web experience possible. Please upgrade to a modern web browser.

Obsidian Reviews

Shop Now
Showing 1-0 of 66 Reviews
Customer Reviews of “Obsidian”
Always liked the flavor of Brazilian tobacco, and these are loaded with the sweet, nutty Brazil tobacco, moderated by several well chosen others in the mix. Well constructed, feels firm in the hand, with even burn. Great aroma, even before lighting! Definitely full flavor, but does not taste acrid or leave any trace of throat irritation. Smoke them down to the last inch. I don't inhale, so others may get a stronger sensation. Excellent cigar and serious competition to the pricier CAO Brazilia.
AV of Paoli, PA
I have been forced as of late to get more bang for the buck with samplers. I received one of the Obsidians, via Belisoco, in one...was really intrigued at the ligero factor. I'll tell you this; very nice draw, oomps of smoke, very clean but with a clinging of a Flor Dominico Ligero aftertaste (FDL, my fave) but a helluva less expensive. Now, unfortunately, I'll have to at least order a fiver or 10 pack, hopefully on Joes Daily...really pairs nice with a decent bourbon like Jim Beam or Evan Williams (of course, Black Jack would be fine, too:) if you are up to the high priced grades that empty your pocketbook.
JH of Crowley, TX
I'm a fan of AJ Fernandez's Man O' War which this really reminds me of. This cigar has a darker and mysterious quality to it. It's less sweet but with intense blasts of pepper and spice. It has the same sensual full-bodied character and strength. Definitely a must try.
PS of Silver Spring, MD
This cigar is excellent! particularly for the price. I spoke about 5 cigars per week and have been looking for a nice alternative to Padron which has become a bit expensive. This cigar has a nice aroma, and smokes smooth as advertised. Definitely worth the price given the quality.
EK of Reston, VA
I get high hopes every time I hear of a new cigar that is full bodied and has "deep tobacco flavour". Such was my reaction to the announcement of the Obsidian cigar. Unfortunately, IMHO it did not live up to the billing, as it is very low on earthiness, otherwise known as "barnyard", and higher in wood tones and leather notes. Maybe after 25 years of smoking many types of cigars (many of them from CI), my taste buds have had it, but I know what I like "barnyard earthiness", and this cigar ain't it. So far, the best bang for the buck seems to be Rocky Patel's Edge Counterfeits. Sorry Obsidian.
MF of Cocoa, FL
Several years ago, Obsidian was one of my faves. But then it disappeared for a while. When it returned a year later, it was not the same cigar and I was mad. This new Obsidian brings back the memories of excellence and may even surpass what we smoked back then.
PK of Milwaukee, WI
I smoked the Obsidian Box-Pressed Toro and for a sub $3 dollar stogie it was great. I struggled with an uneven burn and was forced to re-light several times. I did enjoy the cool burn all the way to nub. It wasn’t super complex, but the flavor was a very nice sweet/spicy M/F body mix. I would smoke it again.
LL of Round Rock, TX
I don't normally stick with just one cigar as my favorite. I bounce around from one to another so my taste buds don't get bored. But that's changed. If I were stranded on an island and had a crate full of Obsidian, I would be perfectly happy to smoke these day after day. I've smoked several sizes and they're all good. You just can't go wrong with this cigar. Clouds of smoke, rich, but not overpowering, smooth as silk. Great with coffee.
DS of Casey, IL
At this price point (or double) this is a really nice, dependable medium-full cigar. It does compare well to the La Flor Dominicana Ligero but at a fraction of the cost. Not obnoxious or in your face (ala The Punisher) but rich with a full flavor profile with very little pepper. Gorgeous to look at, firm in the hand and on the draw, with a nice gray ash that needs to be pounded off. A six inch cigar with a three ash burn, I'll be keeping these in my box at all times, and they've actually been aging well. Can't go wrong!
DV of Middle Village, NY
After reading reviews about this cigar I finally tried one. I am not as impressed with this smoke as some but I think it is still a cigar worth keeping around. Pretty simple smoke without a lot of changes. Once you fire it up what you get is what you get. If it burned better and didn't have to re-light over and over I'd give it higher praise, but for now it's what you would expect for a $3 cigar.
HB of Edgewood, MD
Picked up a couple of these during my last trip to the CI Superstore. Smoked one a couple days later and was blown away! Needless to say, I will be ordering a box very soon!
MM of Clayton, NJ
the obsidian for me is the best new cigar Ive ever tried since being with CI. Every thing about it is near perfect. of course it leaves one to wonder who is the man behind Pinar Del Ray, the company that makes them????
DE of Arcadia, IN
Today I smoked an Obsidian Double Perfecto. This is supposed to be a 6x60 cigar. I'd guess it's more like a 6x56. The wrapper is a nice dark very oily looking leaf. The cigar is constructed well with no soft spots. The draw is good. The burn started off sort of funky. It self corrected in a matter of a few minutes. This cigar is medium bodied and smooth. Nice flavor profile with a variety of pleasant spicy flavors. Starts off witha bang, but quickly subsides into a really smooth, well balanced cigar. For me, this will be a great first cigar of the day. I liked it, and yes, it's great to see a good cigar available at a great price.
JW of Plainfield, IL
I'll admit, I'm spoiled when it comes to my favorite pastime. My humi is populated by some of the best cigars this side of Havana (ok fine, most are from Havana). Obsidian's unique presentation and blend led my paycheck astray of the Liga Privada No.9's and Partagas D4's. I violated my 5 day hold on all freshly shipped cigars in anticipation of lighting one of these bad boys up. The reviews are right on! Tantilizing aroma, balanced, solid construction and dynamic flavor profile. Upon reaching the 2/3 mark of the Obsidian I was pleasantly surprised. The unique taste that makes the Cohiba Maduro 5 (one of my favorites) so amazing was billowing from this oily robusto. If you enjoy rich, earthy, dark full-flavored blends, Obsidian will definitely compliment your portfolio. Enjoy!
DS of North Prairie, WI
A clean burn with absolutely fantastic flavor. Would buy again!
PM of Seattle, WA
All I can say is,"Winner Winner Chicken Dinner" Getting ready to order my 2nd box. What a great smoke. Once again THANK YOU CI!!!!
BW of Hamilton, OH
Received one from a sampler, and I didn't care for the cigar. That being said, I've received the same cigars in a second sampler and they were great. I could have received one not up to par, and may need to try a second one.
DM of Taylor, MI
Received one of these in a sampler and I found like I was smoking two cigars. One end being high dollar (lit end), while the cap was from a much less value cigar. The good news; it is a full flavored, huge amount of smoke, and burned even all the way down. On the other end (cap), seemed like it was from a buck cigar. Meaning; the 54 ring size would slide out of your mouth, while making a cut around the cigar. As a result, the cigar had to go further in your mounth than desired, due to is sliding unless you bit down hard with your teeth. Because of this, half way down it became chewy more than I desired. In addition, the cap just gave away to smasked up slick tobaco increasing with every draw. My teeth made a circle around the cigar due to trying to hold it so tightly. It was a full bodied cigar, enough to satisfy any smoker but the cigar wanting to slide out of your mouth made the cigar less enjoyable. Half way down the outer leaf broke on me, but I have discovered a way to fix this problems most of the time. After finding out that a substance much like an ingredeint in jellow bonds cigars. I took a box of jellow, poured it in an empty water bottle, then filled in with hot water. After shaking it up to disolve the powder, I keep the liquid on a shelf where I smoke. When a leaf begans to crack on me, I use my finger and spread a small amount of this on the leaf that is cracking. I know it sounds crazy, but most of the time it will stop the cigar from cracking any further without changing the flavor. Try it for yourself, since it doesn't cost much money. They make a cigar clue that I have asked CI to offer, since everyone of us have had good cigars have a leaf open up on us. It is not going to fix a huge gap, but it will stop a broken leaf turning into bad cigar. As far as this cigar, I'm glad I got to try it and suggest others to do the same. For me, it is not one that I would make a purchase of in a large amount. You may feel much different since others who wrote felt better about the cigar than I did. Good cigar with even burn, just not my cup of tea.
DM of Taylor, MI
Power and flavor are the two things that I need my cigar to be and I am happy to say that Obsidian Double Perfecto (My favorite shape) delivers! Thick clouds of smoke, fantastic aroma, chocolate, coco, leather, touch of pepper and spice. Enjoy this one on a full stomach as this is truely a full bodied gar. It is sure to be a regular in my rotation.
MD of Philadelphia, PA
I kept seeing these while browsing through the catalogs smoking my favorite romeo y julietas, I was kind of curious about them, I just recieved my motherlode sampler today, didnt relize there was one of these with them so I pretty ecstatic that I'd get to take this fella for a test drive, very smoky right after lighting, very tasteful and aromatic, in other words, not bad at all my friends, I think my next cigar purchase will be a box of them, definitely a must try if you like full bodied cigars.
DP of Aliquippa, PA
Good smoke, draw was great, burned very even with a touch up after lighting. Beautiful thick smoke, but I found the aftertaste a little too earthy for my taste. Flavor profile was great except the imbalance from the earthiness. Nice and spicy, if you want something with a strong flavor and less kick than a Padron.
BL of Columbus, OH
This one has become one of my favorite smokes. Starts off with a punch, develops into several enjoyable flavors, becoming smoother at the end. The total package for an extremely enjoyable smoke.
DE of San Angelo, TX
Possibly the steal of this whole website, incredible cigar that offers everything. The only mistake is you not buying this full bodied animal.
KN of Amityville, NY
I've only had one of these, but it will make it into the rotation again for further scrutiny. It was unusual in a positive way. Need more burn time...with a few more to get to an accurate review.
MS of Bethlehem, PA
Great cigar at a fantastic price! I liked everything about these. Will definitely order more. Get on these before the price increases.
ST of Fpo, AP
Nice medium bodied cigar. Well aged tobacco and aroma.
JM of Aguada, PR
I have been seeing these come up for awhile and have been hesitant on pulling the trigger trying them. A few guys at work are hard core cigar smokers too and haven't tried one yet either. Bought a box of box pressed toro's.....they are $$$$$$. Don't even bother buying a 5 pack...Buy a box of your favorite size and shape. If you don't like them you must be crazy.
TH of Plain City, OH
Wow what a great smoke! I got the Joe's cigar deal for the Belicoso. Wrapper is dark brown, nice and matte.. Dry draw is tight. At first draw is tight with medium smoke. Flavor is quite good. Medium body with hints of chocolate and coffee. Great cigar. Halfway through its getting hot because of the draw. I might have a tight stick. I'm hoping it's just my humidor. It needs more work, I've been having issues keeping it at the proper %. I can't wait to spark up another one. Great buy getting a box next time.
RP of Saint Cloud, FL
All around a great smoke. Comes in a near seamless dark espresso wrapper. Burns very steady and consistent, but does not lose flavor. Very enjoyable from the tip to the nub. This is a cigar you can count on whenever you want a nice medium to full flavor on your pallet. I personally have purchased 3 boxes within a month time period and intend to keep doing so. Obsidian, a timeless piece for the modern age.
BV of Stockbridge, GA
I bought a box of these in Double Perfecto last fall. No doubt the best $4 cigar I have ever smoked. I love a dark oily wrapper with rich flavor and these are par for the course. You will not be disappointed if that is your desire. I will be buying more of these in the future.
KB of SOUTHPORT, NC
I really like this Obsidian, the aroma , lots of smoke and the taste is GREAT!! However I have had a lot of burn problems, uneven burn , tunnel burn they are a lot of work I'm not sure they are worth the price perhaps at half the price they might not seem to be so much work.
RH of WASHINGTON, IL
Not impressed so far! The taste is good but not as rich or complex as Diesel Unholy Cocktail or La Herencia Oscuro Fuerte at a comparable price and it is not as well constructed. Small pieces of tobacco fell out when I cut the end indicating it is not long filler, and the uneven burn and need to keep relighting it seems related to the same problem. I bought a box so I will try more, but so far I regret the purchase.
WD of MIAMI, FL
I ordered the 10-pack sampler and sucked the box dry within a matter of days. I immediately ordered 5 boxes of assorted sizes. These things are absolutely delicious. There are plenty of reviews describing the details of the tastes, so I won't belabor the point. Don't feel bad that the "experiment" cigars in the sampler are not available except for in the sampler: the sizes are interesting and cute, but some of them do not smoke as well (probably due to the small sizes) and they seem to have a bit of a different flavor. I only mention this to advise that the label should be judged based on the regular sizes. I would compare the taste and power to La Flors as many have, but they Obisidians are more chocolatey and smoky.
EW of Coral Springs, FL
To make a long story as short as possible, it's an extremely well constructed smoke. As for the taste, I liked it, and recommend that you at least give it a try. Especially for the price !!! ALOHA !!!
GK of Kahului, HI
All that I have tried have a great flavor but all have an uneven burn. 15 of 20 to go. I hope the remaining will burn more evenly.
TY of PLANTATION, FL
Awesome smoke. Burning one now to kick off the start of my vacation. Can't wait to try "white noise".
SJ of Louisville, KY
Not what I expected, did not develop flavor into the half way point, good smoke out put, slightly creamy, hints of pepper and earth. Not my type of cigar....
CY of APO, AE
Got these on a Joe's Daily Deal, two packs of five each. Very nice cigar. Draw is quite good. Taste/aroma is real good too. Somewhat less full flavored than I had envisioned but overall it was a good purchase. Will consider these again when offered at "special" price in the future.
VT of BLUE SPRINGS, MO
Had a robusto in the humi for a few months. Finally gave it a shot. Really good smoke! Creamy, sweet, with a nice dry wood note. Burn was good and lots of thick smoke. Not a stick for in the car; she puts off a lot of resting smoke. Overall, for the price ya can't beat these with a bat. I'll be picking up a 5 pack real soon. Last 3rd has really picked up. A nice spice upfront and still creamy, but the sweetness has dropped off a bit. It's a good time.
TB of RICHMOND, OH
WOW! I absolutely loved this cigar. I'm a fairly new cigar lover and I enjoy a good mild to medium cigar. These ciagrs have tons of flavor and burn great. I was extremely pleased with these cigars and I will definitely be buying more!
JH of Rochester, NY
I had this cigar sitting in my humidor for about 6 months and never smoked it. It came in a sampler and I thought it would be a bad cigar. Didn't want to smoke my premiums. To my surprise I lit it up and from the first draw noticed a quality cigar. Rich smoke, great flavor.... Got about two inches until it dropped off. Rich, full flavor with woodsy tones. Earth tones and a little barn yard at the mid point. I only had one, now I have to order at least a 5 pack to enjoy this again. To my surprise a great smoke. Give it a try and you won't be disappointed.
KM of Phoenix, AZ
The toro is quite a good cigar...good flavor...good burn...winner.
ND of Nooksack, WA
In general, I prefer Nicaraguan and Honduran over Dominican, but Obsidian is one of the exceptions. This is fast becoming one of my favorite smokes. Well construction, flavorful, all around great cigar.
SG of BEL AIR, MD
Very nice cigar. Feels well in the mouth and burns well. I was quite impressed. I wish they had a 6 X60 Gordo. I will order again.
TD of Henderson, NV
I haven't smoked a good cigar since last year, and I finally got myself to get back into cigars. So I tried these out, alot of review say Obsidian isn't a good smoke. But IMO it was great!!! Very creamy, chocolate, heavy smoke filled my mouth and im hooked on these. i bought the "experiment" sampler and a 5 pack of the White Noise as well. I'm going to be saving these for a while, I don't want to smoke all these in a week. But it's so hard not to, haha. I will be buying more, no doubt! THANK YOU CI!
SM of Lenexa, KS
Just finished smoking this cigar on a cold winter night in Afghanistan. This cigar is beautiful. Oily, dark, and solid. The flavors are chocolate, coffee, and a touch of spice. This cigar has tons of thick white smoke. I have never seen a cigar smoke this much. This is one of the best cigars I have ever smoked. Its aroma is unmatched. It smells wonderful. A solid 93 rating. Will purchase more in the future.
JL of JBLM, WA
"THIS IS MY CIGAR"
JP of APO, AP
Im a brazilian guy for the most part and fresh these guys are a fantastic value. With some age they are so good for the price. These are without a doubt the best bang for the buck cigar I've had the pleasure of smoking.
DT of Bridgewater, VA
I received this cigar in a sampler pack and compared to it's counterparts, this was the "dog" of the bunch. Average flavor smoke, good tobacco taste to the lips, average burn. Of course, when you mix CAO Brazilia in the lot, it has a lot to live up to. I rate the smoke OK, but nothing to write home about.
JN of Johnson City, TX
This cigar really ages well. They are pretty good with great construction out of the box. They are really great after 2 years in the humi. If you can wait that long
RM of Pcb, FL
Received a 5 pack as a gift....flavor is great, with depth and complexity. Had difficulty keeping them lit, however, each prompted 3-5 relights. Still, a great stick.
JR of Fulton, AR
Loose wrapper, uneven burn even after kept in the humidor at proper humidity for several months. Guess I got a bad lot.
TY of PLANTATION, FL
I read the reviews and cant find anything wrong with the burn.I smoked my first one today and no issues at all .Loads of smoke,3" of ash with a easy draw.The taste is awesome a lot of spice and pepper but not over powering .I will be ordering more and the samplers with them keep prices in range!Thanks again CI !!
AD of Callensburg, PA
I'm not a big fan of the Good Cigar For The Price phrase. I believe it's either good or it's not. Obsidian is a really good cigar period. Well constructed, billows of beautiful aromatic smoke, nice medium to m/full body.
DM of LEVITTOWN, PA
This maduro has great potential but unfortunately I don't ever see myself ordering them again. My cigars came off the delivery truck and right away I wanted to smoke one. Maybe 5-6 six minutes into the cigar...the cap separated. I've had plenty cigars in my life and NEVER had the cap just come off. I thought maybe this was just a bad one. I let these cigars sit in my humidor for about week and decided to smoke another one. Once again the cap came off. I can only think of this happening because of poor construction.
RA of Raeford, NC
GOOD: It smelled of a hint of a roasted element but a smell that had a hint of sweetness like caramel and tobacco mixed. Really enjoy the unique cigar band and the cigar is beautiful with an oily dark wrapper and very well constructed. The burn was great and produced a boat load of nice smoke and the cigar is medium to a full bodied. Overall flavor was very very nice after 10 months in the humi. NOT SO GOOD: I tried one with a buddy shortly after purchase 2 to 3 weeks and was not impressed. After 10 months of rest this is now on the ATF List ! ! !
TK of Rouses point, NY
Just smoked the Obsidian this evening as it was a gift from my wife. This smoke was smooth and burned evenly. As far as taste I was very let down; I love a full flavored cigar and this was not it. It was in no way memorable and will be remembered more for its packaging than its taste.
SB of Oak Ridge, TN
My first order from CI. My first taste of Obsidian (actually my second stick), so far better then the first. By which I didn't think would be possible. These are going to be my favorite part of many days to come. Thank You CI!
TD of Las Vegas, NV
Just love it. Great taste. Great, smooth burn. Just love it.
JP of APO, AP
THESE BABIES ARE FANTASTIC
LR of dwight, IL
Buy this cigar. You cannot beat this price for this quality. Dark oily maduro wrapper, full flavored, better sit down smoke. I'm a budget smoker and this is a high quality smoke. It's my everyday now.
BC of torrance, CA
Well wrapped stick, great flavor and arrived in great shape. Devote some time to this one, but well worth the time taken.
SA of SNEADS FERRY, NC
Great cigar. One of my new favorites.
MJ of Paxton, MA
FAN-FREAKIN-TASTIC! Great Cigar. It was smooth to the point I didn't even know it was gone until it was. I recommend for everybody!
WO of Colorado Springs, CO
Great all around cigar, full bodied, but not too strong, will buy again!
SW of Grand Portage, MN
Packs a punch!
EW of Virginia Beach, VA