5 out of 5
The Excalibur is one of my favorite cigars (second to Partagas Spanish Rosado) and I often buy them when they're on sale. I still have not tried the 5 Vegas, but they do have good reviews so I'm sure they're solid.
4 out of 5
This sampler was on my first order from CI. I really enjoyed the Hoyo, but the 5 Vegas was a huge disappointment. I will not get the sampler again because of the 5 Vegas, instead I'm just going to order the Hoyo Excaliburs. 4 stars just because the Hoyo is that good.