3 out of 5
The Humidor is very attractive and fits a lot of cigars. The magnetic tacks at the bottom fall out very easily and need to be super glued in so they stay in place. This is a design flaw that could be easily fixed with a little quality control from the manufacturer. Additionally, the humidifier pack easily falls off of the magnetic strips that hold it on. I just use the gel canister and it seems to hold the cigars at the right humidity.
Overall, I would say that after some work on my own part, I am satisfied with my purchase.