5 out of 5
I've been ordering from CI for at least 5 years and the price, order fulfillment, and variety has always been first-rate. I usually get a box of the Partagas Black Gigantes - they are my favorite smoke, and no matter what else I stock the humidor with, these 60-gauge chimneys always treat me right.
I've smoked more expensive cigars, but really, none I've enjoyed more. Maybe as much, but not more. Well-made, even-burning, and with a strong aromatic taste, you'll know you've had a cigar after one of these Partagas Blacks, and you'll recall the experience fondly.