4 out of 5
I just finished my first #1. Overall, a fabulous smoke. As I burned through it (evenly)I kept trying to isolate differing flavors and couldn't. It was probably the most "homogenous" cigar i've ever smoked. That being said, to me there is absolutely nothing wrong with that. I enjoyed this extremely smooth and mature cigar very much and will no doubt make room for this one as a permanent resident in my humidor.
The rating is spot on but to call it a full? Med/full - is more acurate in my opinion.
Scott M Seattle